Regenerations, CGI tweaks, and other ways Doctor Who has changed for the better! For more awesome content, check out: whatculture.co... Follow us on Instagram: / whoculture Catch us on Twitter: / whoculture #DoctorWho
Пікірлер: 292
@gundamgamer70606 ай бұрын
I mean, the sonic Screwdriver has a psychic interface, so it probably uses that connection to just beam the data into the Doctor's head.
@WebbstreMain6 ай бұрын
11's screwdriver was controlled with a psychic link. It was a major point when Rory was learning how to use it
@philmatin6 ай бұрын
"Two, dropping acid and falling down a big hole." 😂 Brilliant!
@MrOneDaOne6 ай бұрын
Sounds like growing up in the nighties 😂
@the.youtube.of.sam.gotter6 ай бұрын
Don't we all though
@littlegreensunflower35475 ай бұрын
Sounds like an average weekend to me 😂
@sheersternfeld19146 ай бұрын
"we all change, when you think about it. We're all different people, all throughout our lives, and that okay! That's good! You've GOT to keep moving, as long as you remember all the people that you used to be! I will not forget a line of this. Not one day. I will always remember when the Doctor was me. " I'm pretty sure I didn't quote it correctly, I'd appreciate it if someone helped me fix it.
@1neGuy-g2j6 ай бұрын
You did miss a small bit before he says 'I will always remember when the doctor was me' You missed 'I won't forget a line of this. Not one day."
@sheersternfeld19146 ай бұрын
@@1neGuy-g2jthanks! I edited it now. I noticed that I forgot something, but couldn't figure out what.
@1neGuy-g2j6 ай бұрын
@@sheersternfeld1914 no problem
@krishaangkohli21632 ай бұрын
you missed the "i swear"
@bazzer1246 ай бұрын
I think the best NuWho Master is Missy, and Roger Delgado, the original, is the best Classic Who Master. Selectively, or course. Cheers....
@candycover6 ай бұрын
The best part about her being the master, is that her gender was not mentioned at all.
@ftumschk6 ай бұрын
Totally agree. Remarkably, Delgado and Gomez were of Iberian descent (Spanish and Portuguese, respectively).
@just_jakey6 ай бұрын
@@candycover I've seen a clip of her talking about it lmao
@stevenedwards8353Ай бұрын
Missy was a good road map for when they ever needed to gender swap the Doctor. Too bad it wasn't followed well, so we ended up with "Hi. I've had an upgrade" crap
@chriskuta6178Ай бұрын
Once they got rid of John Sim, the Master got so good. The original is still iconic, but Michelle Gomez brought so much to the role and is now who so many think of when the Master is mentioned. And Sacha Dhawan is, in my opinion, the most unsettling and menacing of all the on-screen Masters (yes, that includes Delgado).
@LongPeter6 ай бұрын
David Bradley was so well cast.
@Roxor1286 ай бұрын
"The trend was bucked by characters like Ace" And Leela! Don't forget Leela. Paved the road for Ace around a decade earlier.
@lukedaley176 ай бұрын
Ncuti Gatwa’s appearance as well as the correction of the Tardis console positioning was a very good touch.
@Vim-Wolf6 ай бұрын
Ah, the assistants - they were just starting to get that right with Ace back in '87, really exploring her back story and origins. And she certainly was never the damsel in distress. And then it got cancelled.
@ftumschk6 ай бұрын
True, although I'd say that Romana II (Lalla Ward) was almost like a second lead and arguably carried the show, especially when Tom was in one of his moods. She was particularly effective in City of Death, State of Decay and Horns of Nimon.
@murmursmeglos6 ай бұрын
I'd say Barbara from the very first episode set the standard, she's strong, smart and rational, often putting the Doctor in his place. Infact we start things from her and Ian's perspective.
@robertantinone49026 ай бұрын
I really liked Jodie Whitaker as 13, but I still think it would've been a great call back if the first female Doctor was the one who finally got to fulfill 10's wish to be a ginger. They could've played it for laughs like she was so excited to finally have red hair that she didn't even notice that she was now a woman right away.
@jamesmapletoft45416 ай бұрын
Totally agree regarding Missy. Brilliant casting. I had to smile regarding the effects though. That was THE charm with the originals and I still love them.
@williamseneyjr.62776 ай бұрын
Whenever the doctor is looking at his screwdriver as if he's looking at some sort of display, I always thought he was looking at the emitter, which was beaming any information collected right into his brain. The thing is supposed to be psychic, isn't it?
@truebradfordean15556 ай бұрын
Yeah point and think so assuming it’s the other way round too
@JSP_11476 ай бұрын
"first romantic couple in the tardis, excluding 2 and jamie" laughing my arse off
@thomascoghlan59676 ай бұрын
I’m here for the Sonic Shades! 😎
@WhoCulture6 ай бұрын
😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
@SingularityOrbit6 ай бұрын
The only thing wrong with the sonic sunglasses is that there's no way to get a fun toy out of it, unless your idea of fun is a perfectly ordinary set of sunglasses with a hidden button that makes noises. It's much more fun to point a whirring screwdriver toy at things and put it away in your jacket pocket, as opposed to just holding a finger against the side of your sunglasses while staring. Also, do you buy a sonic sunglasses toy in child size (so the child will grow out of them) or adult size (so children can't get them to sit right on their faces)?
@SeeJay816 ай бұрын
@@SingularityOrbitapparently the shades were Capaldi's idea, and it doesn't have a toy on purpose. He wanted people (kids) who don't have much money to feel they could (cos)play doctor who without having to buy expensive toys. I hated the sonic sunglasses until I read that. Now I really respect Capaldi's choice for wanting them to be so dull and plain 🤣
@SingularityOrbit6 ай бұрын
@@SeeJay81 OH. Ignore everything I said. My objection has no weight next to Capaldi's actually good moral stance.
@SeeJay816 ай бұрын
@@SingularityOrbitlol, I felt much the same. Capaldi is such a gem.
@Beowolf1uk6 ай бұрын
Missy was deliciously evil and had character development which was also the plan for Delgados Master had the actor had lived to finish his arch.
@the.youtube.of.sam.gotter6 ай бұрын
"Sonic shades are too far" But what about the thumbnail? I CLICKED BECAUSE OF THE THUMBNAIL. I WANTED SOMEONE WHO AGREED WITH ME.
@ooooneeee6 ай бұрын
IKR, scammed.
@Wanderer23316 ай бұрын
The 1st Doctor expressed romantic affection in Cameca in the serial “The Aztecs”.
@docAvid3146 ай бұрын
"We do what the Doctor's friends always do. As we're told." "When one is in love with an ageless god who insists on the face of a twelve year old, one does ones best to hide the damage." River may have been closer to the Doctor's level than most companions, but saying their relationship "didn't involve a power imbalance" is a stretch.
@the.youtube.of.sam.gotter6 ай бұрын
She's literally the daughter of two of his companions
@BCWasbrough5 ай бұрын
At least River was aware of the imbalance from the very start, unlike Martha or Clara. Her attitude of loving the Doctor despite knowing how much disappointment and frustration comes with it made her that much more relatable to the fans.
@generalilbis5 ай бұрын
River's rant to the fishman concierge of the cruise for killers in "The Husbands of River Song" - where she openly acknowledges the issues of loving a god-like figure whose mission is to protect space, time and the Universe and who she believes can't love her back in the same way - shows that River's study of the Doctor has allowed her to see a far bigger picture of who he/she is than even his most long-lasting companions have ever gotten. Probably even more than Susan's grandmother or whichever parent was The Doctor's child, too. It's probably why they love River so deeply... and despises the reasons for why she knows them so well and believes that romantic love should be beneath them.
@petertrudelljr6 ай бұрын
never realised how much I wanted a Haley Atwell Doctor until now.
@nexy126 ай бұрын
Saaaammmmeeee
@DrFranklynAnderson6 ай бұрын
Been saying it for years. Years!
@TheWiggyStardust6 ай бұрын
Hearing your hello come out of 9 at the beginning of this confused me to high heaven
@weatherwitchandfelinefamiliars6 ай бұрын
I bloody Loved Ace! Finally a female companion who kicked arse and wasn't all screaming and pathetic or moany. But that's what the characters were written as then. I wanted to be like Ace, she was fantastic. Women were pathetically presented so it's really good to see how incredibly better the characters are written for them now. Lucie Miller would have been fabulous to see onscreen too 😊
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
Ace is not the only classic companion with way more personality than 13th's "fam". Sarah Jane and Liz beat Yaz by far!
@long4jimshort4gabriel6 ай бұрын
I personally think the doctor is greysexual. There’s only two characters in the entire show that imply he’s ever done anything more than kissing, so it could be that he’s not for that type of thing unless it’s very specific people like river or Susan’s grandmother.
@candycover6 ай бұрын
Why are you saying the doctor is anything since the doctor isn't even human?
@1988nProud6 ай бұрын
I want a torchwood cross over where captain is aversed to the female doctor😂
@just_jakey6 ай бұрын
@@candycoverbecause other humanoids (even time lords) would also have sexualities
@candycover6 ай бұрын
@@just_jakey Right, and they also think less of males. when the time lord regenerated into a balck woman, the first ting she said was how do you deal with all that ego?
@littlegreensunflower35475 ай бұрын
Exactly! This! They're absolutely still somewhere on the ace spectrum. I was leaning more towards demisexual for the same reasoning, but greysexual makes sense too 😊
@tranz2deep6 ай бұрын
I am very glad for the Sonic Shades. They helped Fallout Who Regenerated give Fallout 4 players the ability to lock/relock containers and doors! (Of course, some of us then pointed out the absurdity all all the "dead cows" in the game being identical, static containers the game placed by locking the cows. No, you did not just hallucinate. Locking... cows.
@jetfire1153red6 ай бұрын
4:33 add to that river song was conceived on board the tardis whilst it was in the time vortex.
@almyvannucci3926 ай бұрын
Joanna Lumley played a version of the Doctor in a comic relief spoof that came out in 1999 called The Curse of Fatal Death written by Stephen Moffat.
@hollymatton4746 ай бұрын
Great video, really enjoyed this one! Thanks Ellie and Who Culture! 😊😊
@slothy76404 ай бұрын
When you said “and two and jamie” I laughed
@sonicwind19016 ай бұрын
Missy might be one of the greatest villains in any franchise ever. So amazing absolutely love her
@unorthodoxbox6 ай бұрын
Personal head canon is the holographic display you see on fourteens screwdriver is what eleven and twelve see on their respective screwdrivers, in the eleventh doctor’s case it was a psychic interface, only he or the user could see it. It just so happened to active when he flicked it. The sonic shades are the same thing just this time inside a pair of specs. All fourteen did was make it an actual display he could interact with whereas eleven seemed to only view it and twelve had to have the shades on in some capacity to use it.
@thebowtie______50376 ай бұрын
I always assumed the sonic was telepethic sending the info into the mind directly
@danielgertler59766 ай бұрын
It's those aliens, freakin' aliens! - Ensign Fletcher, 2380
@kevhardwick67746 ай бұрын
I'm just wondering at the moment when we are gonna get a child Doctor? I mean. there has to at least be a spin off idea there for kids TV... An 'xxx' years old mind inside a kids body and all the problems that presents! Difficult to write but intriguing all the same.
@michaeltortorice98766 ай бұрын
Good video. Well written, very amusing and quirky, the right scenes at the right moment, and best of all the right voice to bring it to life. Well done, gang. P.S. There's at least two people on Twitter who post a photo of Alex Kingston "every day until River (the best character) returns to Doctor Who", to which I say: What can I do to help?
@WhoCulture6 ай бұрын
One of those people is probably an Ellie alt account
@grahamcann17616 ай бұрын
"River, the best character". Interesting, I hadn't considered who "the best character" in Doctor Who was… Let me think. Well first off I'm going to exclude Doctor's (sorry Jon), and companions, (sorry Elisabeth) as they'd deserve their own category, I think. So that narrows it down to… (in addition to River,) The Brigadier, his daughter, Benton, the Master (or Mistress,) Petronella, K9, Captain Jack, Davros, (*best character doesn't have to be a good-person,) Wilfred (aka Tom Campbell), Sally, Harriet… (honorable mention, Astrid). Wow. And those are just the ones I could remember. Hmm, well first let me say it's an opinion so any of these, or ones I forgot (sorry) aren't wrong. That said, for me I'd have to say Brigadier Sir Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart (Nicholas Courtney). As always thank you so very much all, for the videos. Also honorable mention Bannakaffalatta.
@judithstrachan93996 ай бұрын
Don’t forget Osgood.
@grahamcann17616 ай бұрын
@@judithstrachan9399 Thank you, I'd never forget PETRONELLA Osgood (Ingrid Oliver).
@judithstrachan93996 ай бұрын
Oops. Sorry. Forgot her first name.I’m so ashamed.
@tonyyoung39856 ай бұрын
What clip is that at 9:50 with the Sontarans? I don't recognize it.
@GillianMStarlight6 ай бұрын
Maybe The Invasion of Time from the Tom Baker era.
@hannahkarver892Ай бұрын
I get that romance sells - but I really appreciated the more Ace-seeming Doctor. It put curiosity and kindness first and made any affection for others feel more wholesome and genuine - no ulterior romantic motivations. It prevented skeevy age-gaps and awkward power imbalances. I'd much rather watch a lonely Doctor who brings someone along in his Time machine for friendship, to share the wonders of the cosmos and be inspired to grow. Not an old, lonely time traveler scoping out cute girls to potentially romance, using his position of experience and intellect and power to shape them into love-struck tag-alongs
@saenz7947Ай бұрын
I absolutely loved the sonic shades. At first I didn't because I was afraid that the Doctor wouldn't have a sonic screwdriver for a while, but the glasses lasted only one season plus the Monks arc in the 10th season which I think was a brilliant way to utilise the shades when the Doctor got blind. I still don't like the sonic remote of the 15th Doctor though, and no it's in no way a screwdriver. But I really hope that over time it might make more sense, maybe they will address all those 4th wall breakings and they might go all in on the ''the Doctor is in a TV show'' sort of plot/theory with Mrs. Flood being some sort of narrator god or something. After so many of these 4th wall breaks and the sonic being so fucking weird and so much like a TV remote I really wish it all tied in to this plot somehow.
@GTArajgaming6 ай бұрын
Sonic shades were great, it would allow the sonic to be able to actually give the doctor more info. The downside though is that the writers got lazy with it and had it be the McGuffin to make the episode finish the way it did. As for Ncuti in adventure in space and time, the could have done a little bit more color grading him to match the grading on the background he's on, his outfit and skin tone all seem brighter, like they didn't dial in the chroma key settings right.
@KnightRaymund5 ай бұрын
The sonic is probably psychic. That said, I do like the display as an option. Can be used to show the info to the audience or other people and not just the Doctor but also here it basically let him sit back and examine the data in front of him for a time, which is probably easier with a screen.
@roseyperkins10584 ай бұрын
4:54 I love that they used Clara when she was in Waterloo road I feel like this role is over looked a lot
@tenzhitihsien8886 ай бұрын
I much prefer the classic format and pacing. New Who often feels rushed, sometimes to a conclusion that's unsatisfying.
@matthewterry30276 ай бұрын
Completely agree. Many good stories rushed in the last five minutes.
@bloodarcher78416 ай бұрын
🤣 bad opinion is bad
@petertrudelljr6 ай бұрын
@@bloodarcher7841 hey now. Having 90 minute episodes would allow more of a cinematic approach to Dr. Who. Gives enough time for the standard 3-act play with enough time to actually build the story to a good climax and denoument. Often times we get to the climax and that's it, show's over... everybody off!
@Jenifer_R_Ай бұрын
15's screwdriver reminds me of a computer mouse. Which at least makes more sense than a screwdriver.
@stevenedwards8353Ай бұрын
Sorry, WhoCulture lady, but Delgado will always be the best Master, hands down. His only downside is he was so well paired with Pertwee, that I doubt he would've worked well for any other Doctor had he not had that unfortunate car accident and had decided to continue on being the Master after Pertwee would've eventually left.
@danielgertler59766 ай бұрын
I'm actually sad we never got a follow up to An Adventure in Space and Time. I feel like it would be really interesting to dramatize the run of every doctor in a tv movie
@generalilbis5 ай бұрын
Wonder if Sean Pertwee would reverse his stance on playing The Doctor if it was him dramatizing his own father's tenure as the character?
@thelegoninja36326 ай бұрын
So I not long finished Capaldi's run and I'm now on Jodie and genuinely i love the sonic specs, they're so funny and not nearly as bad as some people say. I WILL DEFEND THEM FOREVER!
@CrackmeupKyle6 ай бұрын
I’m not gonna lie I kind of dig the TV remote sonic screwdriver. It’s weird quirky and new but kind of works for me.
@Lucian_Reditus3 ай бұрын
No power inbalance with River? You mad? xD
@LibertyBridgeProductions6 ай бұрын
Hailey Atwell and Olivia Coleman would be good women doctors. Jodie Whittaker has absolutely nothing about her that I see as the doctor tbh. I don’t know why she was cast, u can blame Chibnall and it’s kinda fair however was Capaldi ever bad in a bad episode?
@charliemc2001Ай бұрын
For the next doctor I would really like it if it was Tom Ellis. I have been watching lucifer Season 6 episode 1 and he is very doctor in that episode and it was great. He also sings so they might be able to do something with that. I think he would be good as a slightly darker doctor similar but not a carbon copy of 12. He played the doctor Martha travelled with in the Season 2 finally and believe the characters were engaged to each other afterwards before her and Mickey got together. It would be cool if they brought Martha back and the doctor has her previous fiancé face
@cameronhermann94006 ай бұрын
Love the Sonic shades, so iconic and bad A**
@thomaswilliams27806 ай бұрын
The romance with The Dr in the modern series is a bit weird in my mind-a 900+ yr old time lord with a chick in their 20s/30s, bit strange to try and give them a romantic relation ship, isn't it?
@Mark-nh2hs6 ай бұрын
Seeing how many people kick off over a 10 year age gap now-a-day's.
@thomaswilliams27806 ай бұрын
@@Mark-nh2hs exactly
@littlegreensunflower35475 ай бұрын
On the point of "the Doctor is no longer asexual", I humbly disagree as an asexual myself. Asexuality is a spectrum at the end of the day. Just because they're not aromantic or romantically repulsed, does not mean they're not asexual. First off, sexual attraction and romantic attraction are two separate things. There are people like me that love the idea of a relationship, but find the idea of sex to be undesirable. Then there's some asexuals that do enjoy sex under specific circumstances. It's like, yeah you may not necessarily be craving pizza, but you won't necessarily say no to it either. Sometimes it's like that. I still think the Doctor could fall anywhere within that spectrum seeing as asexual just means "a disinterest in sex that ranges from repulsion to indifference to only under specific circumstances (such as needing to be close to someone before having that desire)"
@kieraburgess34315 ай бұрын
'Didn't include a power imbalance' Not sure about that!
@BW0805.6 ай бұрын
Yay new vid 🎉
@coyoteartist6 ай бұрын
I think they've over done the screwdriver. I think it would have done better to explore more options like the glasses or like McCoy's watch.
@toringleeson50516 ай бұрын
Disagree with 11 mk2 vortex being bad personally, I live it
@rhodrage6 ай бұрын
It brought back the Face
@forcedalek6 ай бұрын
Great video ❤
@sharphawkeye322 ай бұрын
I'm typing while watching. If I see anybody justify chibnals era I'm closing the video moving onto the next. Nothing will ever justify what happened to this show.
@geraldstiling3735Ай бұрын
After being Hogwarts caretaker 🧙🏼♂️and then being murdered by Maisie Williams' Arya in Game of thrones 🗡️.I think David Bradley should return as The Doctor...⏳
@emeraldvaught57764 күн бұрын
Dan is Yaz’s companion 😌☝️
@greendiamond26046 ай бұрын
The doctor could be asexual but from the show it seems to have been comfirmed he's not aromantic, basically asexual for romantic things, not sexual.
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
Well, you've showed us some changes, how about a second part to this video with _justifications_ to those? This video gives me the impression of brainstorming some bullet points without further considerations. For example, #5: Romance is introduced into the show, but do we need it and how is it justified? Even in #8, the deeper development of companions, I agree, but you didn't show any justification for it. Also, it isn't really true for the "fam" - they're such underdeveloped companions they drop bottom for most of the classic companions. I'd rather have you concentrate on _one_ point of this list and bring forward some arguments instead of just rushing through talking points.
@ProfArmitage2186 ай бұрын
Given that the Doctor has had a granddaughter since 1963, that kind of implies that they were sexually active at some point.
@chrisbellon37396 ай бұрын
I just wish they had more aliens companions or humans for past or far future, not just modern humans, as companions
@weatherwitchandfelinefamiliars6 ай бұрын
The trouble with those is how very badly they date. Poor Leela the Savage is dreadfully dated from the costume, attitude and what was known about the era she came from. Future is even harder, only a few decades ago we couldn't have predicted everyone would be walking around with miniature computers and mobile phones. That instead of talking to each other and hanging out chatting say as background characters in a street, people would be sitting in groups ignoring each other using hand held devices 😮 Aliens, look at the old costumes how cringeworthy they look in classic who. New Who Slitheen are fun but already dated. CGI rather than costumes date worse, you can see the CGI in the 60th and Ruby Road and it's a bit jarring and that's with super money to do it. After all that, I do agree with you, it'd be great but that ages so badly it can wreck things quickly.
@marionbaggins6 ай бұрын
Jamie was Awesome and he was from the past!!!!
@Just_a_Guy946 ай бұрын
YES! A WHOCULTURE VIDEO!!!!!
@DanBrizuela6 ай бұрын
Never diss the shades
@arcticflower72235 ай бұрын
What is a "flat team structure"?
@timidwolf4 ай бұрын
I'm firmly in the JNT camp when it comes to the sonic-get-out-of-jail-free-card-screwdriver, and that was before it got to the ridiculous levels it reached in the last decade or so. Much prefer the longer story form of the classic era, the stories just had more time to breathe and the "one-off" characters had a greater impact. I find most new episodes and their characters so forgettable now.
@bobhale73026 ай бұрын
Funny how so many of your "changes for the better" are the things I (and I suspect many other of the much older fans who watched the original DW when it was broadcast) dislike the most about modern Doctor Who. A couple are definitely worthwhile but most I'd happily do without. (For example both the Sonic Screwdriver and the Psychic paper are lazy get-out-of-jail-free macguffins.) I do like the consistent regeneration style which of course has now been shot down in flames by the last two regenerations. I can sort of get on board with the bigeneration thing though I think it was largely unnecessary nonsense but I'd love to hear an explanation of how Jodie's clothes managed to regenerate.
@vdeserisy6 ай бұрын
😊h❤h
@weatherwitchandfelinefamiliars6 ай бұрын
I'm older and watched the original series and I'm afraid I really don't agree with you.
@friendlyotaku95256 ай бұрын
Honestly it really bothers me that the clothes changing was just... not explained.
@bobhale73026 ай бұрын
I did say "many" not "all" - I am sure that there are as many different opinions as there are fans. I enjoy the modern version as much as I enjoyed it right from the Hartnell days but things like the sonic screwdriver and the psychic paper are used - in my opinion only, yours may differ - far too often. It's true that the original series often had too much padding because of its serialised format but its also true that the modern series is often rushed to the point that things like the clothes regenerating are just done with no explanation at all and not even hand-waved away in the dialogue.
@johnglielmi64286 ай бұрын
I actually enjoyed the multi-show arcs. Reminded me of the old Movie Serials, Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers movie serials. Cliff Hangers are cool! makes you want to keep tuning in to see what's going to happen next.
@TashaJaeger5 ай бұрын
Just wanted to say thank you for the 2 and Jamie comment. Yes. All the yes.
@otps80355 ай бұрын
2:27 but he needed the shades cos I he was blind!!! So they are not too far at all; they make sense!
@kali36655 ай бұрын
Still don't agree with the concept of giving the Doctor a love life. The Doctor really needs to be above all earthly concerns. He is NOT human, and we should not ascribe our human emotions onto them. Yes, the Doctor can have relationships with humans - that was established as far back as the First Doctor and Cameca in The Aztecs. But I still say it shouldn't go beyond that. Even if the Doctor's relationship with River Song was one of the series more touching love stories. And the sonic screwdriver. That so became a deus ex machina way too quickly. Can't do something? Pull out the old sonic! It couldn't do before what we want it to do now? Whatever - it does it now, don't ask questions. Even the writers during the Fifth Doctor's era realized it was being used too much to get out of a jam so they had the villain of the week destroy it. But like Superman's kryptonite, it was way too easy to bring it back the next time they needed it. Well, it's still better than pulling a gun for whatever reason. Did anyone ever realize that the Doctor used the screwdriver for its real-life function of turning a screw only ONCE? Yeah, it somehow had the ability to telekinetically do so, but we'll take it.
@goktimusprime6 ай бұрын
*fewer episodes, not "less." #english
@LRyuzaki1006 ай бұрын
OHHH yes..the explaination on the screw driver. Ive ALWAYS wondered how they get infos from the sonic screwdrivers.
@tracyroweauthor6 ай бұрын
Those ridiculous goblins are probably not the best example of better production values. I know Ellie is obsessed with them (though I can't understand why) but they actually make the Slitheen look like a serious villain. An Adventure in Space and Time is definitely Gatiss' best work, considering that almost every one of his DW episodes are horrible. His Sherlock scripts are much better, but Gatiss really had no idea how to write companions for the Doctor.
@StreetNoise6 ай бұрын
Yeah, those goblins....yikes. They keep telling us that they're spending more money than ever on special effects so I don't understand why episodes from the last ten years look so much better than that.
@friendlyotaku95256 ай бұрын
they're not supposed to be a super serious villain, I think you missed the point. The goblins look fantastic though and they were ALL done practically.
@dkSilo6 ай бұрын
"Well, that's okay then." No seriously, as someone starting with New Who, I might not have been a fan of the older seasons. Nice to see the improvements. Hoping for a awesome new season.
@garychillingworth6 ай бұрын
Ive noticed that you never seem to include Captain Jack in any of these clips. Is that deliberate?
@thelastofthetimelords90436 ай бұрын
I suspect it has a lot to do with the controversies surrounding Barrowman
@thechillindude44786 ай бұрын
Untrue they've used him a few times recently. They've even used Mickey and the actor did far worse than Barrowman
@WhoCulture6 ай бұрын
No… if a Captain Jack clip is relevant, it’ll be used.
@mattthesilent777RED6 ай бұрын
Doctors 13, 14 and 15 aren't canon, Jodie's a witch, Tennant 2 is a lazy marketing scheme and Gatwa came from an non canon process that makes him not even the prime Doctor in what is the "real" Doctor Who universe
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
Only because you don't like it, it doesn't make it non-cannon. Cannon comes always after the fact. For example, Regeneration hasn't been "cannon" before they invented it to keep the show going without its main actor.
@sarahchristine42986 ай бұрын
just because you don't like them doesn't mean they're not canon🤣🤣guess what, I don't like the timeless child but its in the show therefore sadly its canon whether I like it or not
@ooooneeee6 ай бұрын
Peak gatekeeping.
@DrWhoFanJ6 ай бұрын
They are all canon. None of them are witches; there was no "lazy marketing scheme", and bigeneration is inherently a canon process because it happened in the show itself! Do at least *try* and be intelligent!
@BlakeGamer-qy6ve5 ай бұрын
just because you don't like it doesn't mean It's not canon!
@marcusjohansson6686 ай бұрын
About visually inspecting the sonic screwdriwer. Do we know that the Doctor has the same visual spectrum as humans? Maybe it is in a light that humans can not see? I never liked the glasses, and never will. This is the hill I die on.
@Marcsharp826 ай бұрын
This is just a list to criticise the classic era of the show. Come on Who culture I thought you were better than this.
@kevin100016 ай бұрын
U also forgot the Amy narration that was placed before the title sequence for season 6 when it aired but was removed for the dvd release but was replaced for it’s release on max
@DrWhoFanJ6 ай бұрын
Amy wasn’t in Season 6. The Series* 6 narration was only for BBC America. It was never a part of the actual episodes.
@thetarvan6 ай бұрын
It does remain on streaming, though
@tardistrailers6 ай бұрын
It was only on some international broadcasts. It never aired like that in the UK.
@marionbaggins6 ай бұрын
@@DrWhoFanJ And Australia!!!
@kevin100015 ай бұрын
@@DrWhoFanJ Amy was in season 6 cause it was Matt’s second season as the doctor
@Zzazs6 ай бұрын
female doctor or black doctor would of been awesome if their entire story wasnt about their sex/skin they did her so dirty ruining the perfect girl to play the doctor
@mrdr01616 ай бұрын
It's not all about their gender or skin colour
@BlakeGamer-qy6ve5 ай бұрын
good thing it wasn't, like seriously there's no mention of skin colour in ncuti's first episode and even in the giggle when donna said "do you come in a range of colours" that was a one off gag and is far off from being all It's about.
@Staubfeder_6 ай бұрын
gonna be honest, i dont care about the gender or color or age of the actor for the doctor. its all fine, the doctor changes and maybe one day he will be a redhead as he wishes. But what i absolutely hate, ist the screwdriver from jodie und now the new one (Dont know how to pronounce, so i will call him cutie for now.) those dont feel right to me
@WalkingInEternity6 ай бұрын
“Less and less episodes” (around 4:15). Please get an editor who knows the difference between ‘less’ and ‘fewer’.
@JackRascal6 ай бұрын
Each to their own, but I was just amazed at how many of these didn't "get" original Who. The old idea that Ace - a "teenager" who swears, which means she calls people "bog brain" - was the first "real" companion is kind of amazing, really. Lots of the 70s companions WERE ciphers, but they had to be because the STORIES took precedence. In New Who you've got Daleks murdering people in London while the Doctor and Rose make gooey eyes, because the "emotional" (read: syruppy, overwritten nonsense with OTT "emotional" music) has to take priority. Having an obsessive identikit regeneration effect takes away any originality from the process. It's "difficult to argue" with stories that have a beginning, middle and end in 45 minutes as being an improvement?
@Mark-nh2hs6 ай бұрын
Sarah Jane Smith was a real companion and many others. The problem is most (not all) NuWho fans have not even watched any of the Classic Who's yet act as if they are the authority of the whole series via a NuWho lens.
@JackRascal6 ай бұрын
@@Mark-nh2hs I thought Sarah became a bit infantised with Tom, but as for the rest of your points I agree 100%. l can't get my head around someone thinking that a story wrapped up in 45m is an improvement that's "difficult to argue with".
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
This video appears to me rather as a brainstorming of bullet-points without diving into them. None of those changes are argued upon and therefore I can't accept it as a "justification" by any means. Yes, there's been some bad or padded writing in classic Doctor Who and some female companions feel like crybabies. But they only take the negatives in this regard. Sarah Jane and Liz would eat some of the modern companions for breakfast, especially Yaz and the rest rest of 13th's "fam". _Lots of the 70s companions WERE ciphers, but they had to be because the STORIES took precedence._ Well, we knew Liz was a scientist and she supported 3rd in his investigations. Sarah Jane was an investigative Journalist and we've seen her spirit in many stories, both with the third and fourth doctor. They weren't cyphers, their characters were introduced right ahead and harmonically weaved into the stories. Whilst in Martha, we meet her as a Student of medicine, a scientist in some regard, but when does this background of hers ever appear in a story? I only can think of _The Shakespeare Code,_ wherein she shortly checks this one guy about the cause of death. Even much, much worth, with Ryan - Do I need to elaborate? With Rose and the 9th Doctor it's another cup of tea, I liked how her background, friend and family, was integrated into the stories. That's never done before in Classics and was a new aspect of story telling.
@lancealot12356 ай бұрын
I disagree with almost every single point but I still respect your opinions
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
How can you disagree when no argument was made?
@lancealot12356 ай бұрын
@@Spielkalb-von-Sparta well most of the things they mentioned in the list I disagreed with
@jasonbodine60336 ай бұрын
Actually, one series of Classic Who had 17 parts. So, yes, less is better.
@joshuacurphey32426 ай бұрын
Are you referring to The Trial of a Time Lord, which was 14 episodes long and took up Season 23? Because if you are, I think a lot of people would disagree with that as it's in way three serials that are four parts long each and a two-parter at the end.
@DrWhoFanJ6 ай бұрын
Nope. Classic Who used the term "series" to mean "story" (unlike what it means now), and the longest story of 20th-century DW is _The Trial of a Time Lord_ (1986), at 14 episodes.
@DrWhoFanJ6 ай бұрын
@@joshuacurphey3242No, it’s definitely one 14-part story. It’s all given the same name, after all!
@joshuacurphey32426 ай бұрын
@@DrWhoFanJ I actually do see it as a 14-parter as opposed to four separate stories, but it did nonetheless take up a whole season. (I said people see it as four separate stories, not that I was one of them). The blu-ray release of it even gave each of the four "stories" their own titles.
@DrWhoFanJ6 ай бұрын
@@joshuacurphey3242 No, it provided the alternative titles on the discs as a way to indicate which episodes were where. It still treats it as but one single story (as you can tell from the back cover where it only lists one story title), exactly the same as the DVDs did.
@arcticflower72235 ай бұрын
Ncuti is the 14th.
@BlakeGamer-qy6ve5 ай бұрын
no david tennant is the 14th doctor and ncuti is the 15th, you can call ncuti 14 but he's not.
@joshuacurphey32426 ай бұрын
Thankfully, I'm not as fussy concerning a minor change such as the title sequence and didn't notice anything wrong with Matt Smith's appearance in An Adventure in Space and Time. I also only heard about the change in it's rerun and even that made me depressed; Smith's cameo not only showed that the show had come a long way since first airing, but also broadcast how successful it had become. Using another doctor starting with Jodie Whittaker (or maybe even Peter Capaldi whom people might agree his tenure started the show's downfall) just went against what William Hartnell (played by David Bradley in the special) said about his future being in safe hands.
@shenandoahbell4556 ай бұрын
I do love me some froth... Surely in a list about the most important changes... The season 7 reboot and season 8 soft reboot is king 👑? Most of the 60s styling is utterly jettisoned in order to keep the series on air and it's utterly fantastic. Keeping the charm of the series but with a 70s splash that the series has never abandoned.
@arcticflower72235 ай бұрын
Don't say "RTD"...
@qqq17016 ай бұрын
For regeneration, it seemed like the process became more and more energetic as you got closer to the end of your regenerations you can do. Not exactly followed but that was my general idea.
@Roxor1286 ай бұрын
Kind-of makes sense. The older you are, the harder it gets, until you eventually can't do it any more.
@leejnew6 ай бұрын
You cannot seriously say that Missy is a better incarnation of the master than Roger Delgado’s iteration. Just tell us you don’t like the classic series.
@SupaKen746 ай бұрын
She was better. She was the best. Wow. Look at that. I CAN tell you that. Guess you were wrong.
@tracyroweauthor6 ай бұрын
Ellie has never said she disliked the classic series. She has admitted to not being as familiar with them, which is understandable since she's so young and would not have been familiar with the classic episodes. She has also admitted that she is making an effort to watch them, and let's face it, compared to the modern Who, they are pretty cringeworthy. Yes, I am a classic Who fan, I grew up with the show, but they are painful to watch now. Roger Delgado was a great Master--for his time. Personally, I prefer Simms' Master mostly because Simms is a wonderfully nuanced actor who could switch seamlessly between manic, devious, emotionally wounded and out and out evilly crazy without missing a beat and still make the character actually likeable. Missy, however, took the Master (or Mistress) through a character arc that only Michelle Gomez could have handled so effectively. She took a one dimensional evil villain and made him/her someone more relatable. Everyone struggles with dark and light and Missy portrayed that struggle brilliantly while being bone crushingly funny as hell one moment, then finding depths of empathy the next. That is what makes a great villain.
@TheFiddleFaddle6 ай бұрын
Roger Delgado played the twirly mustachioed villain really well. His version was still ultimately just that, the twirly mustachioed villain. He did a very good mua ha ha ha.
@PhantomObserver6 ай бұрын
Okay: Delgado worked well because he had Pertwee to play off of. Pertwee was playing the Doctor as a super-smart paternal type; Delgado was the type of evil that also had respect for his main opponent. Basically you look at the pre-Donald Pleasance Blofeld, or David Warner’s R’as Al Ghul. Missy, on the other hand, had evolved from the Master’s previous incarnations - many of which added an over-the-top-showmanship quality to the Master, especially the John Simm and Eric Roberts versions. This results in a “notice-me-sempai” desperation to the performance that was quite fashionable in writing 21st century antagonists, and would appeal to sci-fi fans exposed to anime tropes. So the question of “better” depends on expectations. Me I prefer Delgado, but I’ll submit that Missy was much better than Sacha Dhawan’s scenery-chewing.
@BaldBasket6 ай бұрын
She’s allowed to have an opinion.
@arcticflower72235 ай бұрын
Who is fifteen?
@geoffroi-le-Hook6 ай бұрын
But why would the Doctor regenerate into Prisoner Zero?
@thomasnieswandt88056 ай бұрын
One tiny thing... Joanna Lumley wasnt just one candidate to play the Doctor.....She was the first female Doctor. In 1993 Children in need "Curse of the fatal death" by Moffatt, Joanna Lumley played the 13th Doctor. I know its not canon, but if you watch it and you compare it to the show today.... You can see that 10,11,12 and 13 all have some characteritcs or gender of their canon versions..... i wonder why ;)
@ZandrousVT6 ай бұрын
I think we're past the point where whe don't need Gallifrey anymore. Or at the very least, we're done with having pretty much NO Time Lords besides The Doctor and The Master. Either they need to bring back existing Time Lords like The Monk, Romana and Drax; OR they need to create some NEW Time Lords to be new allies or enemies. There's just a lot of narrative and lore left on the table that could be explored without needing to overdo it.
@weatherwitchandfelinefamiliars6 ай бұрын
I would Love to see The Eleven on screen, He's portrayed so well by Mark Bonner he'd be fantastic and so creepy 😮
@ooooneeee6 ай бұрын
Yeah, that's what makes Chibnall undoing the Moffat retcon of the time war really frustrating. The last of the timelords trope had been done to death by the time of the 50th anniversary special and bringing it back was a mistake.
@thomaswilliams27806 ай бұрын
The Classic regenerations were better because they were different each time, it kept things new with each incarnation...
@Mark-nh2hs6 ай бұрын
My fav has to be the 5th Doctor to 6th. Sadly Ive seen some NuWho fans shit on it by doing NuWho Regeneration effects over it and they all dribble saying it way better with NuWho effects - rolls eyes
@thomaswilliams27806 ай бұрын
@@Mark-nh2hs yea, ill never be convinced the Dr exploding into a fireball for 3 seconds is a good way to regenerate...
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
_The Classic regenerations were better because they were different each time, it kept things new with each incarnation..._ I tend to disagree in this point. They were only different due to different visual effects. The only exception was the regeneration from 4 to 5 with this white guardian. I didn't like that because it was never resolved.
@thomaswilliams27806 ай бұрын
@@Spielkalb-von-Sparta that may be, but the different visual effects each time made for a nice change each time in my view
@Spielkalb-von-Sparta6 ай бұрын
@@thomaswilliams2780 I like the consistency because it's always the Doctor undergoing the same process (bi-generation excluded). But yes, they could twist the visual effects a little more, like the energy looking more reddish or yellowish or wobbling more or less to empathise different Doctors. Meeting in the middle ground. ;-)
@heathbaum5 ай бұрын
Lol 😂 quality over quantity except both are falling