Is anyone else gonna acknowledge how smoothly and confidently she sang those verses? So much breath control and such a steady strong sound!

I agree with you. I think I'm very peaceful when it comes to be a lamb.

:( I was very happy for her, even though I had my doubts because of the suddenly change of quality, but she lipped so well that I though it was live. Sadly.

Yes, I have already watched that video. I love your channel. Your video actually proved that I'm right. lol

Yes they had indeed. I haven't found trouble here for a while.

Just wonderful!!!her comeback!!!

it's 100 percent LIVE!!!

i repeated the last part a couple of times just to make sure she lipped the entire thing. i mean, notice the difference in volume, ambience and timbre from 2:00 onward. come on guys, be real.

She just needs to know though that fans dont care and still love her even if she messes up a bit. Usually if she just gets up there and is confident she's great.

She sang the Verses better than in 2005!

Excellent ending! Like if you repeated the last part a couple of times! ;)

I know, I know, but hopefully her next studio album will have the same quality vocals.

oh its different in Morocco, and both are live... but Can't take that away is not...

Lypsinched : of course without doubt

better than 2005!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lmfao of course, never in doubt..i expected the morocco track to be used in the future and she did...only them naive fans will always fall into her trick, believing everything is live

@ssssslam you be real she is Mariah Carey ! ! This is not lipped !

The morroco one is live....

it is live

if you watch the ending of both performance, you will see that they are exactly the same. The whole song wasn't lipped, just the ending climax. Its disappointing but. the ending of the song is not live.

Yes. I don't require anything from Mariah live now. I know she have her problems so it's okay for me. The only thing that turns me off is some of her stans claiming that it was live.

Yes, I have always know it was lipped though. But I knew that the lambily would kick my ass out of their group if I ever tell them that.

The ending is the same track from the morocco performance. Its a good track, but sadly its not live :(

It's a damn shame when a true vocalist of heroic prowess has to throw some notes or over embellish just to get haters to get off. I can hear inconsistencies in all of these performances so I'm not sure what you are talking about when you say it's not live but whatever. Even at her worst Mariah is still better than most. Much Love!

Is it just the echo or is it that the "beLIEEEVE" run sounds different from the one at Morocco concert?

Yes, that's why I knew from the beggining that it was lipped.

Go figure - the ending is close, but there are JUST enough differences to make me think that this is a live track, or at least a live track with some lipped parts.

It's NOt the same. Where the hell is the raspiness she had in her voice in that part in Morocco?? There are some little differences. Can we remember this woman has perfect pitch and can learn melodies by heart and reproduce them to perfection ?

In all honesty the ending is probably lipped and I'm more of an optimistic but imo it's just too similar to not be doubted. I wonder if this was just taken from her other live concert or originally prerecorded in the first place? Oh well either way, her voice was great this night, it just sounded much more healthy than usual and the quality and tone of her voice was beautiful and clear. I get eargasms just listening to her sing the first chorus tbh :D

WOW people get over it... Mariah's been lipping the ending to WBT for a while now.. The Verses are still live .. How long have some of you been a fan? That are still acting surprised and claiming some of us are haters cuz we think is lipped.

Cool story bro. Tell me more...

Im saying she sounds great in the recording. I dont think its disrespect as it is her being insecure and worried about hitting the notes. I dont agree with the lipping but at the same time i dont think its because she doesnt care. It means she cares too much...

LMAO Yes, they will come after me. lol But you're right, not all of us are delusional.

I don't know about her personal stuff, but I know that she has nodules on her vocal cords. That's it.

Well, to me, she did lip that part. Don't you think so?

I dont know is this lipped or not, but the voice is more flexible

I'm talking in general.. I mean it's not that serious anymore. If she was lipping the whole song then ok, complain. But the climax has been lipped for a long time. still her voice, and at least she changed it and belted higher LMBO

LOL

Though its dissapointing that the ending was lipped, at least she re-recorded it and sounded amazing. Shows what she is capable of still :) She sounds beautiful on the verses though!

LMAO Yes they will. But every singer has them delusional stans. Some Whitnet stans romanticize Whitney's vocal range, for instance. Unfourtunately, I have the say that after Christina and Madonna stans, the lambily are one of the most delusional diva stans. But I don't like to talk about that. :p

Mimi stans can be delusional, but I know better. She did great in that concert, she had no reason to lip. she was being lazy. No artist is perfect and Mariah's weakness is her lipping. *sigh*