Jonghyun is really one in a million.

정말 이상적인 완벽한 그룹이다. 비주얼, 가창력, 퍼포먼스 모두 다 완벽한 샤이니같은 그룹이 또 있을까.....

SHINee's vocals are so good that even SHINee World gets confused whether they sing live or lipsync But this one is live and it's perfect

몇 년동안 볼 용기가 안 나다가, 너무 생각나서 너무 보고싶어서 들어와봤어 그 시절의 내가 어떤 마음으로, 어떤 생각을 하면서 이 영상을 봤는지 아직도 너무 생생하게 기억나는데, 내 학창시절을 되돌아 보면 온통 너희들인데, 야자 쉬는시간마다 콘서트 영상보고, 야자 끝나면 푸른밤 듣던게 일상이었는데, 고마워. 내 소중한 시절을 꽉 채워줘서. 이제야 돌아와서 미안해. 아직도 마음이 저리지만, 이제는 웃으며 추억할 수 있을 것 같아.

Our fandom is kinda fun xD other fandoms fight on their biases or otps but we fight on either they're lipsync or not xD

GUYS IT'S FUCKING LIVE. Taemin high notes are a bit different here, Kibum parts too. Different but PERFECT. oh god, you guys should simply accept the fact that they are THE BEST at singing live. thx

Smooth 1:25, Unexpected (but awesome) 2:57, Power 3:08, Emotion 3:17, Angelic 4:08, Velvet 4:41, Perfect 4:48 Who am I kidding...THE WHOLE SONG IS PERFECT!

This. This is what got me into kpop. I remember the first time I watched this and the moment I heard kibum sing I thought he was the most beautiful man on earth and I still do, god I still do.

어느 보이 그룹이 이렇듯 멋진 라이브를 할수 있을까여 오래전 영상이지만 지금 트렌드에 절 때 뒤처지지 않는 이 감각점 보소 ...독보적이네요ㅡ 괜히 빛나는 샤이니가 아니였군요 샤이니가 빨리 아픔 딛구 부활 하길 기도 드려요

Onew's voice is so soft and smooth Jonghyun has so great voice but most important is that five makes shinee 😍😚

정말 내가 제일 좋아하는 샤이니라이브 탑이야 당시에 음원보다 라이브가 훨씬더 좋아서 이 라이브버전만 계속들었는데... 이때 태민이 노래실력이 또 너무 더 늘어서 놀라기도 했었고, 진짜 샤이니는 최고의 그룹이야

보고싶었어, 보고싶을거야, 보고싶어, 고마웠어, 고마울거야, 고마워. 미안해, 이 한 마디 전해주지 못해서. 사랑했어, 온 힘을 다해. 나에게 영원히 28살로 남을 종현아. 나에게 영원히 9살로 남을 샤이니야.

이건 정말 미쳤다 . . . . 이걸 왜 이제 봤지 와 진짜 잘해 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 진짜 잘해 . . . 3:08은 진짜 소오름.. 태민 메인댄서인데 . . This is just so cazy it's so good. I mean, PERFECT. 3:08 chills.. well guys Taemin is main dancer in SHINee...

when i first hear this i thought it was lip sync but when i hear the cd version there's a slightly difference especially on taemin's highnote.. taemin's highnote here is longer.. indeed they're CDNee

To this day Sleepless Night is one of their most beautiful ballads. Everything, from their vocals to stage presence is breathtaking. 5HINee forever ✨

샤이니 라이브 진짜 잘 한다~ 그동안 모르고 살았네~~ ㅜㅜ 어쩜 목소리들이 이리 다 좋은지~ 시작과 끝 종헌이랑 온유 목소리가 마음을 울리고 목소리 넘 매력적이야~ 이 노래 넘 좋다

information for dummies, SHINee IS SINGING LIVE. dont get confused.

WOAH taemin BLEW ME AWAY. his part at 3:10 omggg dayummm son. all of them were amazing. i can't even compare them because they're all just THAT good. Their voices are so beautiful live

이름에게 듣다보니까 분위기나 여러가지가 비슷한 느낌인거 같아서 들으러 왔어 4명의 샤이니도 각각의 색도 하모니도 좋아 하지만 아무래도 5명의 목소리가 더 풍성하고 이쁘다 헤 보고싶네 이때 이 영상에서 우는 분 보면서 울었었는데

제 학창시절을 함께 해준 샤이니에게 감사해요..종현님도 그곳에선 편안히 행복하시길 바라요.

Taemin's part at 3:07 literally made my breath stop for a moment this is my fave part in the song, and in the audio alone there is so much raw emotion on his high note there but in the live here its even more raw emotions and desperation ..I am crying... SHINee is truly amazing and Taemin, one should not see any regret for your opportunity of going solo because it is well deserved I really don't know what to say anymore...wow..just wow

I went straight to this song. Jonghyun, you brought me back to this song. I miss you so much. You are loved.

Thank you to Shim Changmin for writing the lyrics of this song. It's so beautiful!

My heart can't stop fluttering .. Jonghyun made me realized why I fell in love with him. This my first time watching this song live and I fell in love all over again. My eyes are filled with tears . Can't I just marry him right now? Who cares if I'm 18? ☺️

I love all the members of SHINee but I could not take my eyes off Jonghyun. His vocals are truly amazing. He sings with such passion.💕💕💕

i miss you jonghyun, tonight must be a sleepless night......

I love this live performance so much. Their vocals are so on point and they look extremely handsome. Their voice touches my heart, it's so pure! I was in tears the first time I heard it and I can't stop tearing up again. I'm just so proud of my boys, they've come a long way and improved so much. Ps Taemin you really stole my heart with this. And Key your voice is SO BEAUTIFUL.

태민.... 진짜 3:09에서 소름이쫙...... 태민으 노래왜이렇게 늘었어? 진짜 다들 너무 잘한다.....

청음회 가보고싶어요ㅠㅠ 음향 빵빵한 곳에서 샤이니 라이브 들으면 심장 멎을듯

My first thought on this video is "Wow, no way.. This can't be live, it's just too good to be live." But I think this one is live. I watch really closely, watch it again and again. They're so good, even better than the CD, SHINee

Honestly I love them so much I cried my heart out because they deserve EVERYTHING. They have EVERYTHING single thing. I love them so so much. Other groups can't be compared to the because they're so special. They are all amazing. I hope they never break up. I truly hope they don't. SHINee is my favorite Kpop group in the world. It will never change.

I wish Minho's part was longer. I looooove his voice.

When I first listening to this song I cried so bad even though I doesn't know the meaning yet. It was so emotional and sentimental yet very beautiful vocals by SHINee. For me, in this song I think their live performance was soooo great compared to their recording on album. I count on the timing of Taemin high notes part and I notice Taemin high notes was a little longer here. They sing harmonically together , each of them had a very great and powerful voices. Only SHINee can sing live performance with the powerful dancing skills. It was so amazing , I love SHINee soo much, no one can replace them in the K-pop history. That's why they are the only one who deserved for the MMA 2013, BEST ARTIST OF THE YEAR 2013. congratulations SHINee.

I got goosebumps, I teared up, their voices are so angelic and precious. Taemin's big note, Onew's voice, Minhos speaking, Key's vocal riffs and Jonghyuns amazing soft yet high notes, I am so glad that I found them. They are truly amazing and so talented. My idols for life.

이건 진짜... 몇 번을 찾아 보고 싶은 노래 ㅠ

NO ONE IN THE AUDIENCE IS MAKING A NOISE SHINEE FANDOM LET ME HUG U

내 마지막스타 샤이니...

그냥 모든 것에서 완벽한 그룹

Onew's voice in these kinds of songs just gets me every time

Wow. The girl's tears fell beautifully. If I was there & I cried, it'd be a mess. Oh. & SHINee's awesome.

종현이 목소리 노래실력 작사작곡능력 얼굴 매력 성격 인성 춤 진짜 너무나 완벽해

Me every damn time I hear this song: *starts crying the second Jonghyun starts singing* *the crying dies down a little bit after Minho starts rapping* *crying starts up again as soon as Taemin hits that high note* *after a couple minutes it start to die down again* *starts back up again as soon as i see that girl crying* *doesnt stop till after the song ends* This is even worse when I have the song on repeat...

온유야 건강하자 태민아 널 응원해 종현아 너무 그리워 민호야 넌 참 멋져 기범아 고마워

다신 없을 최고의 그룹

제목처럼 정말 잠못드는 밤에 들으면 감성폭발하는 곡 짝사랑만 하는 나 너무 아픈 마음 떠나지 못해...

Onew Flawless vocals!

jonghyun's singing is just horrible. and i don't mean it in a bad way I MEAN WHO ELSE CAN OPEN HIS MOUTH AND LET OUT AN AMAZING HIGH NOTE LIKE THAT he's just inhuman. his ability to sing is just scarily amazing. taemin too..his singing sounds so sincere T____T onew ahhh..heavenly angelic falsetto.. minho with his honey soothing voice T_T and keyyyy nailed everything as usual. just one of the many reasons i stan SHINee

역시샤이니 다잘부른다

I watch this from time to time and I always remember just how much each member improved vocally, especially Minho, Key and Taemin.

3:09 SLAYS ME SO MUCH. DAMN TAEMIN.

끄아아아아 온유야아아 목소리 왜이렇게 좋아요

wow this song is beautiful. they distributed the lines beautifully. i really love keyi's voice; very distinctive. but i love ALL of their voices oh gosh. this is such a beautiful group. i love shinee so much it's absolutely crazy how much i love them

literally 4:18 - 4:30 will always be the reason Jonghyun was the most important singer in my life, I miss him so much

It is 5 years since the publishing of this video. Only in the last couple years have I become better acquainted with the depth of talent running through this body known as SHINee. Even in recent times, I have found myself surprised once more by their individual and collective gifts that leave me in awe and determined to always consider them as my supreme bias among all music fair including that which is produced here in the West. I say this even given the tragic passing of one of their members whose voice even an angel on high would long to call his own.

*done with life* They're too gorgeous. I can't deal with it... )':

Omg just chills Jonghyun's intense Emotions and Superb vocals take my breath away in this SONG 😭😭😭😭 👏🏻😭 🙌🏻 Never heard anyone Sing with these Powerful emotions Only Jonghyun 💋🔥 👏🏻💎💎

Idk why but my heart always aches when Key started to sing... I've watched this many many times but it still has the same effect as if it was the first time. Dashi dorawa... Everything about this performance is perfect... I'm not even a Shawol but I feel really proud to see these boys. The fact that these talented guys do exist in the world makes me feel glad lol

i was into Kpop becoz SHINEE is there... i really love them!

There are lots of new kpop idol now but SHINEE is still SHINEE!!! they still shine bright than the other groups!!! SO proud of them!!!

I'm back here again after 8 years. This song and this performance particularly, still one of my favorite when it comes to SHINee's ballad. It still is beautiful as ever. Heart wrenching. So much had changed since back then. And yeah, i miss you jonghyun.

I can't listen to this song without crying whenever I hear Jonghyun :( I don't even know what to say or think. I hope you're resting easy. I wish we could've done more. I wish the conversation and action around mental health could improve, not just in South Korea but around the world. I wish the life of an idol and artist wasn't that suffocating. I literally can't fathom how his family must feel, how SHINee must feel and his close friends; if we as fans are this heart broken. RIP Kim Jonghyun 🌹

Key looks beautiful! that high note 1:27 screw anyone who says he can't sing :D

go ahead Taemin. every time i see this i get chills all over again such a beautiful song that really showcases their talents.

시간이 오래 흘렀다고 생각했는데 아직도 어제 일만 같다 다섯명의 샤이니를 나는 평생 그리워하겠지

Key's voice is so beautiful. Its smooth, unique and clear. I feel his not being given enough credit, which is so unfair.

i can't believe this is live.. it's so beautiful! SHINee is always so amazing live..

2016 and I'm still watching this every now and theb

2018 and I'm can't move on from this performen so perfect......but heart breaking in the same time,SHINee and Shawol be strong we love you

어우 정말 어떻게 더 좋다고 표현을해야할지 모르겠다 ㅜㅠ 서로 만나 시너지가 폭발한 아티스트들ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

와......하늘에서 내려온 천사

its 2017 and it’s still the same feeling. you can really feel their heartfelt performance. i feel that girl who cried on the last part. i mean how can you not cry after hearing their voices. T.T my love for these boys is overflowing.

Listening to this now after what has happened to Jonghyun, I just can’t help but cry even more, this almost perfectly describes how it feels to live in a world without our Jonghyun.

I love SHINee; I love your tone of voice Jonghyun !! I miss you. You did well. Be well, I love you. 나는 SHINee를 사랑한다; 종현의 목소리가 좋아! 난 당신이 그리워요. 잘 하셨어요. 잘 지내, 나는 너를 사랑해.

라이브 장인 “샤이니”

SHINee is the best! SHINee is the standard! I'm blown away by this live singing, i love all five of them, they are amazing 🥺❤️

SHINee ballads are on another level, extremely beautiful.

Perfect perfect perfect perfect perfect. All FIVE of them.. their voices together is magic as I always say. Minho’s deep voice always .. ahh.. 💕💕💕

가끔 생각나서 들으러 옴

here again today. just can't get enough. so beautiful. shivers.

Happy 14th anniversary ♡ Forever OT5 ♡ Forever SHAWOL ♡

와 노래 핵잘한다.....

I cried right along that girl in the audience. This performance was simply beautiful

A very harmonic and pure performance without any vocal mistakes. It's just amazing how they can sing live, this Perfect!!! Fighting! I wish you all 5 the Best!

you're like taking the words out of Minho....i actually read one of his interviewswhere he said that he is like the bass of the band...it doesn't stand out but it supports the other instruments...got to love minho's humility! loved hik more after I read this...and yes I know how important his voice is in SHinee...if you are to listen to the chorus, you can actually hear a lot of his voice there..another minho lover! happy on hearing from you!

Dear Jonghyun your high note was perfection! true perfection baby !! you are so missed :(

I'm in love with this song, and there voices are in perfect harmony it's crazy. I am so glad to be apart of the fandom. Jonghyun is bias, I am in love with his voice.

i watched this 10 years ago and i cried the first time watching this performance, i'm watching it again today and the tears are still coming down

You see this is live! and shinee are the best in the industry for that

KEY

can't ever listen to this the same. rest in peace jonghyun

진짜 샤이니 실력 레전드ㅜㅜㅜㅜ

널 보내는데 조금 오랜 시간이 걸려도 이해해줘. 7년 동안 새겨온 이 감정을 보내기가 쉽지 않다. 널 탓하지 않는 내가 웃으며 보낼 수 있을 때가 오면, 그때 이 손 놓을게.

one of my fav ballad songs from them. Its already 2016 but I still listen to it every night. Shinee never disappoint me. Cant wait for their upcoming repkaged album which contains 5 ballad song.

I feel exactly how the girl who’s crying 😭 feels when I hear this song it’s just so beautiful and their vocals give me goosebumps and chills especially Jonghyung he’s one of kind for sure! Reminds of a 90s song. I miss you Jonghyung so much I wish you were still here! I would’ve been the only girl standing up at that show crying and screaming! 💎💎💎💙💙💙💙

Key is amazing

Damn Goodness... !! God bless their holy vocals.. And they are singing it freakin' LIVE. There's a reason why they call SHINee, "The Best Live Singing Group". I'm watching this in 2016 and I still find it hard to control my feels here. Jinki with that holy angelic voice of his gets me everytime. Jjong, how the hell does he hit those high notes ? Man ! He does it like its no big deal. Kibum, the feel he put in the song.... It melted me.. He is such a beautiful person. Minho's voice is so comforting. And Lee freakin' Taemin slayed it... Gosh ! I always get goosebumps when they sing ballads. They way they put all the emotions into the song is just soo extraordinary.. Go Go SHINee.. I'm stanning a group that is PERFECTION !

라이브라니....사랑스럽다 정말

Taemin: Tonight yeah~ Key: Tonight yeah yeah~ Jonghyun: TONIIIIIIIIIIIGHT~~~

This song reminds me of Jonghyun. Fly high, my angel of music 💚

I can't sleep since I knew about his death.. I really needed to rewatch this live. So emotional and made me cry back when I was a teenager. Now I'm crying like four years ago, but with more suffer.