一个自称小国的新加坡有这样世界性战略家，不可思议，中国有这样的战略家吗？中国需要学的东西太多了，低调做人🎉

I am a Singaporean. I agree with almost all of Kishore's points. One exception is when he said "USA is solving lots of problems in the world" (this I disagree) while China has enough domestic problems that it doesn't want to meddle in other countries (this part I agree). USA, with its USD funding its military and NGOs,and monopolizing trade transactions, has all along been stirring troubles throughout the world, while using moral highground of "values" as its cover.

I think a very fundamental issue was not mentioned or discussed by Professor Mahbubani is that American's capitalism, once the most efficient economic system, is no longer as competitive against China's hybrid capitalism+socialism system. American government can not have a long term strategy (more than 8 years) because of its election cycle. Each new administration nullifies the efforts of the previous one. Therefore, while both Republican and Democratic parties want to stop China, they don't have consistent approaches over time because Americans are deeply divided. On the other hand, Chinese are quite united in facing their challenges and Chinese don't have the desire to bully other countries. This contest is like between an old world champion doing boxing with a young contender who actually just want to survive. The time is on the youth side, obviously.

China's Grand Strategy: 1. Develop a strong dynamic economy and a strong dynamic society. Learn from the Soviet Union's internal collapse. 2. Build strong trade relationships with ASEAN. Increase ASEAN's dependence on China. Neutralise the US containment policy. 3. Belt and Road Initiative.

The fact is bully never has any reasonable goal or grand strategy to compete with his opponents. Bully only has a grand ego.

马教授最后说了句关键话。透顶一块布应该听懂。你们不要被任何人收买。也就是尽量不选边站。保持中立和当一个旁观者。尤其是中东。

這個外交官太棒了

早前看過這個訪問的全個內容，真的相當精彩，馬先生絕對是受敬重的政治學者之一，他對中國亞洲以及整個世界的瞭解有足夠的深度，很有哲理及富有思想。當國人看見外媒對國家某個事件的抹黑造謠而內心毫無波瀾，不再辯駁，不再浮躁，或者反映實力已經允許藏不住的傲嬌。自信的最新高度是無需過份去炫耀自己！有了自嘲的本錢！無關政治民生，或者正是一個對和平世界的渴求！-個百姓對穩定發展的希望！一個對社會環境的寫實！這就是真實的生活！！相信國家的發展有足夠的智慧。。。🎉🎉

Countries can have strategies, visions, wants & determinations; but who succeeds ? China is the only one that consistently achieved their goals. The Chinese leaders are incredible !!

因為這場演講是用英語進行的，所以，我判斷底下坐著的這些白大袍們，都是受過西方教育的人，要讓他們接受中國的觀點，恐怕有些困難。但是美國在中東地區的實踐，大家都是看到了的--並沒有給中東帶來和平、穩定和發展，而是戰爭、動亂和破壞。所以他們也願意聽一聽一個印度裔的新加坡人的觀點，一個局外人、旁觀者的觀點。

Thanks for sharing this conference. The world should know this. ❤ from Malaysia

目前, 美国最大的优势是美元. 没有任意发行美债的手段, 美国财政将会崩溃, 世界最优秀的人才则不会再被一个崩溃了政府财政的美国所吸引.

更加佩服马凯硕教授了！

It's always fascinating listening to the Prof, but i'd also like to commend the interviewer. He asked good questions.

Professor Ma Kai made a very good point that if America wants to be great again, it must reconstruct and build society. But in the so-called democratic system of the United States and Western countries, power is always connected with capital. Capital has long penetrated into every aspect of the country and influences all national policies. In China, capital will never override the government, and the government can shape social consensus completely according to its own wishes.

This is indeed a very constructive dialogue where Prof Kishore has made profound and insightful comments. The moderator was professional in asking unbiased and objective topics of importance. We need more of this.

A wise man indeed

Professor KISHORE is As To Date AMONG THE BEST GEO POLITICAL ANALYST AND MINDS our world is Knowing Cheers from Mauritius 🇲🇺

Proud of you Prof, greetings from Melbourne Australia

干货满满。

All past great Empires came & went. Each average shelf life is about 250 years. Each of their fiat currency, shelf life is about 100 years. America is moving close to these 2 thresholds. But for China is still the China a few thousands years ago, and will still be into the far future, always developing, innovating & progressing - and its economical power & influence are getting wider, stronger and wealthier moving forward.

Another talk from Professor Kishore showcasing the depth and scope of his knowledge and the high level of his intelligence about world geopolitics.

What a remarkably wise statement, it's rare to see such insight in today's political climate.

这个提问者提的问题非常好和有思想，马凯硕是位太了解中国领导人大战略的外国人

❤America calls it "Liberation" instead of "Invasion". That was what US call it in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia and the list goes on... Why the double standard? Confused... Please enlighten. Genuine question... Instances of the United States "liberated" or overthrowing, or attempting to overthrow, a foreign government since the Second World War. (* indicates successful ouster of a government) China 1949 to early 1960s Albania 1949-53 East Germany 1950s Iran 1953 * Guatemala 1954 * Costa Rica mid-1950s Syria 1956-7 Egypt 1957 Indonesia 1957-8 British Guiana 1953-64 * Iraq 1963 * North Vietnam 1945-73 Cambodia 1955-70 * Laos 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 * Ecuador 1960-63 * Congo 1960 * France 1965 Brazil 1962-64 * Dominican Republic 1963 * Cuba 1959 to present Bolivia 1964 * Indonesia 1965 * Ghana 1966 * Chile 1964-73 * Greece 1967 * Costa Rica 1970-71 Bolivia 1971 * Australia 1973-75 * Angola 1975, 1980s Zaire 1975 Portugal 1974-76 * Jamaica 1976-80 * Seychelles 1979-81 Chad 1981-82 * Grenada 1983 * South Yemen 1982-84 Suriname 1982-84 Fiji 1987 * Libya 1980s Nicaragua 1981-90 * Panama 1989 * Bulgaria 1990 * Albania 1991 * Iraq 1991 Afghanistan 1980s * Somalia 1993 Yugoslavia 1999-2000 * Ecuador 2000 * Afghanistan 2001 * Venezuela 2002 * Iraq 2003 * Haiti 2004 * Somalia 2007 to present Honduras 2009 * Libya 2011 * Syria 2012 Ukraine 2014 * 2014 - 2022 - 9 countries yet to verify. Pakistan 2022 * Haiti 2022 * Niger 2023

受益匪淺，為教授點讃！👍👍👏👏

新加坡国家这么小，但真的是人才辈出。那么多的大国都想听听新加坡的意见。

Beside the great dearly departed LKY this man has the greatest mind.

大约七百年前，朱元璋就采取了“高筑墙，广积粮，缓称王”的策略，最终建立了大明王朝。马凯硕作为新加坡的外交家，深谙如何作为一个小国，在中美两国之间平衡斡旋，确实很优秀。但恕我直言，想成为中美这样的大国战略家，远远不够，地理环境一定局限了他们的眼界。

Prof Kishore is a legend. Greetings from Adelaide, Australia

we all can support with China new global economic world interest

其实身处这个时代，身为中国人还是很幸运的。 在这个大的世界背景下，每个中国人在做人生选择时都需要再三考虑时代背景对今后个人命运的影响：）

A very wise person.

简直像是一個全世界都认知的地下黨在分析國際形勢, 着重美中關係的話題,就不怕被ClA盯上了。

居然看到有评论说又要世界级战略家，又要低调做人，这不就是诸葛亮吗？如果按三国当时两千万人口出一个诸葛亮，那么现在中国至少有七十个诸葛亮在后面出谋划策，但可以感觉到他们都会出一个策略，就是不要与天时地利人和的美国（曹操）正面冲突，唯有发展自身，连结欧洲（孙权），继而待天下有变，图取中原，成霸业，兴汉室

佩服❤

The greatest wealth of the world is it's COMMON DIVERSITY, a diversity that peacefully benefits and secures everyone without exclusion

今天中國的成就，並不是全部由既定策略做成，策畧提供了大方向，堆砌起基礎，其他的便由人民自我發揮，中國短短幾十年翻弱為强，其中一個重要原因是 ：只要提供一個穩定和有誘因的環境，聰明和勤奮的中國人就會創出一片天，中國政府恰好就在這期間提供了前者，美國想阻止或延後中國崛起，唯一辦法就是和中國直接戰爭，破壞中國稳定的環境，但她不敢，因無必勝把握，只會两敗俱傷，戰後復原的速度必輸中國，最後還是輸，而且輸掉霸權，所以美國的策略是誘使中國武統台灣，之後發動制裁，聰明的中國人怎會上當，所以台灣那班台獨自High和想維持現狀，繼續歌舞昇平的人，還有一段日子可過，先不用怕。

Except for the Soviet Union part, everything was perfect, and I can give him that. Nobody can be an expert on everything!

There is old saying "if top leaders are crooked, the followers/institutions/citizens will mostly likely be bad too," This seems to fit us quite appropriately.

哈哈哈哈，顶UP主

Soft power is especially the culture difference, one is with a long history, people collectively focused culture, the other is with short and young culture, America has always won, they don't know and don't want to know how it is to be oppressed, individuality is written everywhere in all policies. Sacrifice is definitely not considered.

summary from this seminar is you must help- china to be no 1, so you will not depend with USA and USA will not bully you again and again

❤intellectual talks

太理想化了，现实残酷的多。。。

一针见血

👍👍👍

China is already ahead of the US

✌✌✌

马生真的是了解兔子的，反观鹰🦅家，即使有这见识的人也站不到主导位置，这才是中美面临目前困境和影响将来发展走向的问题根源。

我居然在抖音上也看到这个视频,感觉内网外网互通了-_-

❤

@15:20--是ASEAN(東盟)，不是ASYAN。因為這個字英文解錯了，所以中文翻譯也離了軌，令人一頭霧水。如仍可以更正的話最好還更正，幫助你的觀衆明白。

中國人的思想其實很簡單，就是圖個國泰民安。老美就是沒辦法想通這個，他老是覺得中國人將來會像蘇聯那樣跟他爭當武林盟主，所以他惴惴不安，杞人憂天，鬱鬱寡歡，最後鬱鬱而終。老美其實是被自己打敗的。

和李光耀一樣睿智⋯⋯

The GOAT

It’s all about his BOOK.

that's right. the husband is largely the stronger of the couple but we all know the wife, having the last say, is often the most powerful.

我一直都很喜欢好莱坞有部电影叫[天国王朝 Kingdom of Heaven]里的一句台词 “Convert to Islam, repent later.” 道尽如今西方政治无论对内亦是对外时的双标 虚伪及伪善

US strategy is to buy more time so we can come up with a strategy 😅

in ppp terms CHINA is already the largest economy in the world

Being number one on the US side (8:35), I believe the US can do whatever it wants to any other country without any restrictions, just like it has in recent decades.

美國目標很明確啊，讓中國回到1990年代，全民都是輕工業勞工，用一億件成衣去換一架波音飛機，高科技什麽的就不要碰了。

Kissinger: “The biggest strategic mistake US is making in this contest with China is launching the contest without a strategy.” 4:10

講來講去,所有人都知到的事,,全世界政治人物的取向都係利益,只是有些人要的是眼前利益不是將來,有些人要个人利益多於国家人民吧！

China was the first country established free trade agreement with ASEAN 15:50

The Chinese innovates all the time..from block printing to printing money, gun powder...to fireworks to rockets, from small canals to large canals that transport small ships, diversion of water from south to the northern dry land..etc

微軟公司老闆回覆紀者他來中國開新創分公司是因為1萬人會有一個天才所以中國14億人口會有很多天才。

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Just before I skid into my grave, I hope the show is a good one and not a tragic ending with the US destroying another country

is there any Q&A Session?

Prof u knowledged Knowingly or unknowingly Xi's 做好自己 philosophy to a better society. Hope more countries can adopt the same to a peaceful world.

American had met their match, the real rival: China! Hegenomy American may have strategies to counteract China but China had their own strategies. Look at the effect of Petrodollar vs the BRICS on global economy…..

It is such an obvious pity that American elite has been too arrogant to consult the best diplomatic experts in the world such as Kishore, for their own benefits.

When 2 elephants fight, the grass below suffer. This is especially so if one of the elephant loses its mind. So get prepared for the bad days to come.

Kishore let out too much secrets..

If the ability to do sanction is there then they are still the hagemon! No matter how much dedollarisation if 30 to 40% of countries are still using USD as their Reserve. There is still some time before dedollarisation can be effective on USd hagemon Note China is still pegging its currency to USD.

Many in the west can't accoet a non western country becoming as good as they are.

Well question for a question?

有些字幕和翻译错的好逗😂

There's 8 billion precious humans today and every year another 80 million, 2X population of Canada, join us. The nation state model is clearly failing humanity. We need a new path forward without man-made borders

China is unstoppable ..hahaha 😂JIAYOU

Most of the time he mentioned China, US, China and US. I am waiting for Firstpost lady Palki to ask him "how about Indja"

excellence views 深度分析倆强对决 也是 “对抗与包容”策略的对决

當一個地方出現管治危機，最佳方法向外妖魔法地造一個敵人，咁就可以一致對外，繼續自己政權.

🎉😂❤😂

这是在阿联酋举办的吧，中东国家在掌握世界变化，在思考在行动，这很重要，尤其是找马凯硕这样的客观而深刻的学者！中东土豪们不土啊😅

The goal in actuality is to reflect the worst human nature of pride, God is the witness.

15:00 ASEAN

Oh my... The translation is appauling 🤣

中国的大战略就是： 上善若水 善利万物而不争 夫唯不争 则天下莫能与之争 桃李不言 下自成蹊 广结善缘 和气生财 都是老祖宗早都告诉我们的

牢记邓小平总设计师的四字真言：韬光养晦！美国目前仍有两大法宝：金融和科技，所以我们中国人要继续埋头苦干，拼搏奋斗！实现中华民族伟大复兴！华人才是最伟大的民族！😀

幸好這馬先生 不是中國人的敵人⋯ 如果是敵人就麻煩了。 幸好他不是美國那邊的人

字幕错误太多了

In some Native American cultures, hearing a wolf howl is seen as a sign of impending change or transformation, and may even be considered a message from a spirit guide😅

Of course, the #1 will dominate international rules. One simple question for every audience will be: do you want to send your kids to United States or China? They have the answer.

Where is the talk proper. This is just Q &A ?

@23:06 when the closed caption shows PUTOCRACY society I don't think it is a typo.

Tonight, I want to start by asking, with the upcoming U.S. election, do we expect to see any real potential changes in U.S. policy towards China before the end of this year? Is it a national policy or a policy related to the president himself? I will give you a very contradictory answer. On the one hand, the election results may not change anything; on the other hand, it may change everything. Because it is obvious that even today, the well-known fact is that the United States is a deeply divided society, unable to reach a consensus on anything, except for one thing they all agree on, which is that it is time to stop China. So no matter who the president is, the task of stopping China will continue, and this policy has deeply ingrained itself in the U.S. political system and society. But at the same time, why do I say it may change everything? Because if Trump is re-elected, he may take extreme measures against China, which will greatly change the situation. We must be prepared for all possibilities, as small countries like the UAE or Singapore have already realized that, whether we like it or not, we are now witnessing the largest and most far-reaching competition between two major powers in history. This competition will shake the entire world, affecting the lives of all of us, which is why we need to have this dialogue here, it is very timely. Regarding the future of U.S.-China relations, a key question is whether the United States has a clear strategy to deal with China's rise. Makaisuo pointed out that although the United States has initiated this competition, the goal is not clear. Is it to overthrow the Chinese Communist Party? Or is it just to contain and isolate China? These questions have never been clearly answered. For China, their goal is clear, they hope to surpass the United States economically and become the global number one. In addition, Makaisuo also mentioned how China is responding to U.S. containment policies through initiatives like the Belt and Road Initiative and establishing free trade agreements in Asia. He believes that China has systematically formulated a grand strategy to address challenges from the United States and ensure the diversification and stable growth of its economy. Finally, Makaisuo emphasized the wide-ranging impact of the competition between China and the United States on the global stage, especially in terms of economy, military, and soft power. He believes that the next decade will be an acceleration period for the competition between China and the United States, which will be one of the greatest performances in human history. This interview delves into the complex and crucial relationship between China and the United States, providing important insights into the changing global political and economic landscape.

The subtitles for this video is so bad...