true. I would love to hear them live too❤️

Fr

Yess,tha fact that they just 4 members is soooo impressive. They really mad rn 😏

As usual…. Lip singing again and their dance has no energy and no stage presence… i’m laughing at those highnote part which is obviously studio version coz if you look closely who the f*ck hitting a highnote while smiling 😅 lol SM is wasting their talent for letting them always lipsync… so nah… pass…

🔥👏

Winter did really well, she really needs to step up and project a better stage presence or else Ningning will overshadow all of them. But, Winter indeed improved Giselle and Karina too. Now, they are beasts🔥

@@danissegomez7953 I think she's already improved a lot since Savage era. Obviously there are rooms for improvements, but she definitely looks more relaxed/lively on stage.

@@danissegomez7953 you always commented the same thing about winter everywhere. she's improved a lot here

@@AB-yk2pq giselle was always good, she just got more confident. She got a lot of hate nowadays thats why she was less confident about herself and her talents

@@sergio_07829 Giselle is good I agree. But she lacked in execution and energy during their Girls promotion. Glad to see that she's fixing that in their most recent stages.

FACT🔥

Fr

닝닝 덕질할맛이 난다고ㄷㄷ..,?

하 근데 닝닝 개이쁨 ㄹㅇ

An all rounder queen indeed

🔥🔥

❤❤❤❤❤

truee

she was the only one lip syncing lmaoo

진짜 미친것같아요

it will be even more deadly if Ning does the highnotes. Ning knows no mercy with her powerful and whole sounding vocals reminds me of Taeyeon🔥. They are in for a treat with Winter's highnotes, but they all be dead if Ning did those notes🔥😂

Tbh, Giselle has better vocals than Giselle annoyinv SM dont give her more lines they just let her focus on rapping

@@danissegomez7953 I don't think so, cause I've heard Ningning's high notes in Black Mamba and Savage live at performances and I think that she resorts to falsettos when she sings them live, She can do runs live but not the high notes, but Winter has better technique in singing high notes and is obviously the most stable vocalist of aespa acc to popular opinion. So ig, it should be like this, Ningning doing the runs, while Winter does the high notes. Another factor being, Ningning has the typical SM's Main Vocal Quality, she is a Vocal Queen but unfortunately that's the biggest drawback.. People these days want uniqueness in everything, and Winter is very different compared to other SM Main VOCALS, Ig that's what makes her stand out.🤷 So, if you ask me who is the better vocalist, I'd say Ningning but if you ask me Who is the more interesting vocalist, it is Winter.

@@danissegomez7953 but, she missed some of her lines in Girls so she is very good, but she needs more practice with the current line distribution ig.

@@markleeismylee1511 agree that ningning went falsetto but did u watch now? The real my world run was belted! Synk diiiiiive was belted! It’s okay to be nervous sometimes, what’s good about winter is that even if her high notes here went flat af she didn’t lose confidence. Ningning is a better vocalist as you agree and also according to most vocal coaches she’s more interesting and more promising vocalist

but there's lot of tree tho, like is it related to LSM's planting tree? 😂