I love how you had Trapped Under Ice at #2. Such a powerful and mesmerizing song, it’s almost scary how good it is. I personally would’ve had Fade to Black and Sanitarium inside my top 10, but I respect your opinion. Not sure why people are getting mad about another persons opinion. Really interesting and cool list.

you think there's 50 better Metallica songs than Fade to Black? Insane

Harvester of Sorrow at 92. Is insane 💀

If Darkness Had A Son is extremely underrated, one of my favourites in the new album

Fade to Black imo is not overrated at all. Fans love it for its relatable lyrics because most people will experience those thoughts at some point in their lives and holy shit that solo. It’s beautiful, fast and melodic as hell. It’s my #1 Metallica song

Ain't no way you put cliffs masterpiece that low

My top 10 1. One 2. Master of puppets 3. Fade to Black 4. The Unforgiven 5. Wherever I May Roam 6. Sad But True 7. Creeping Death 8. Fixxxer 9. Inamorata 10. Halo on fire (This list changes every second depending on the mood)

Now, it might seem “basic” to have One as a favorite Metallica song, but I could not care less. I’ve listened to a lot of Metallica, and none of their songs can give me chills the same way the opening riff for One has. The chorus effect on the lead clean parts has no right to go so hard. And the distorted guitar tones are just fucking magnificent. The lyrics and the theme too drive this song to one of the best metal songs ever conceptualized, produced, written, created, and played. The genuine vitriol you can hear in James’ voice when he sings: “Hold my breath as I wish for death” and the lyrics toward the end of the song are just perfect. You can hear the perfect emulation of pain that most veterans experience when talking of their career. 11/10 just for the instrumentation and the soloes as well. It’s all been said before, but I’ll still say it again because GODDAMN is One fucking great.

My top: 1.- Master Of Puppets (I know it may posser but this song has it all: badass, evil and fast downpicking riffs, an incredible and aggressive voice by Hetfield, that catchy and aggressive chorus, the melodic part, Hetfield's solo, the heavy breakdown, Hammett's solo, that waxing and waning riff, just wow). 2.- Creeping Death 3.- Blackened (the best intro song of all time) 4.- Fade To Black 5.- One 6.- Orion 7.- Harvester Of Sorrow 8.- Disposable Heroes 9.- Dyers Eve 10.- Battery

*Fav Songs!!* 1. Fade To Black 2. Creeping Death 3. One 4. Ride The Lightning 5. The Four Horsemen 6. Sad But True 7. Master Of Puppets 8. Damage Inc. 9. For Whom The Bell Tolls 10. Enter Sandman 11. Fuel 12. Whiplash 13. Fight Fire With Fire 14. ...And Justice For All 15. Seek & Destroy 16. Nothing Else Matters 17. Trapped Under Ice 18. Hit The Lights 19. Battery 20. The Call Of Ktulu (Ye I love the older albums most)

Putting jump in the fire at #5 has to be one of the most outrageous takes I’ve ever seen in my 17 years of life

2:51 My favourite song from St. Anger 4:03 my favourite song from 72 Seasons 4:40 My Favourite song from Death Magnetic

Putting Anesthesia at 101 is a crime

1. Mechanix 2.Of wolf and man(its electric if count covers) 3. Blackened (am i evil if count covers) 4. Enter sandman 5. Traped under ice 6. Jump in fire 7. Seek and destroy 8. For thom the belt tols 9.Battery 10.creeping death 11. If darkness had a song 12. Ride the lighting 13. Blackened 14. Master of puppets 15. and justice for all 16. Fuel(only load-reload song i like) 17. Fade to black 18. Orion 19. Whenever i roam 20. Things that sould not be 21. Fight fire with fire 22. Symphony of destruction

Escape is so underrated.

Eye of the beholder, Atlas Rise, Seek and Destroy, 72 seasons, To live is to Die, Frayed Ends of Sanity, Welcome Home Sanitarium, all deserve to be higher.

Very cool top! I'm glad you appreciated the new album so well

I would personally rank both Harvester of Sorrow and Moth into Flame higher. I would also move Leper Messiah up and bring Dont tread on me down

This list is actually nuts

Orion at 40 is like stabbing me in the heart. Deserves at least top 10

Ranking them all is nigh on impossible, but I'll leave my personal top 30: (also agree on Poor Twisted Me being the worst) 30. Phantom Lord 29. Suicide & Redemption 28. All Nightmare Long 27. Moth Into Flame 26. Sanitarium 25. For Whom The Bell Tolls 24. Shadows Follow 23. Four Horsemen 22. Halo on Fire 21. The Unforgiven 3 20. Damage Inc. 19. Bleeding Me 18. Blackened 17. The Shortest Straw (my favourite song to play on drums) 16. Enter Sandman 15. Wherever I May Roam 14. Fight Fire With Fire 13. Fade to Black 12. Nothing Else Matters (will be my 1st dance song on wedding one day) 11. Creeping Death 10. Call of Ktulu 9. Disposable Heroes 8. The Outlaw Torn 7. Spit Out The Bone 6. Inamorata 5. Ride the Lightning 4. Orion 3. Master of Puppets 2. Battery 1. One

This is my favorite metallica ranking video, because it's not your traditional list that one would expect. Definitely a lot of love to some of the songs that are rarely played live or on the radio. Was a good reminder to recheck out some songs that I haven't listened to in years, such as thorn within, God that failed, of wolf and man, fixxxer, and more. Even if I wouldn't place them as high as you did, gotta remember a lot of those are very solid songs that would be number one hits for other lesser bands, but metallica just sets the bar so high

Probably the most the enjoyable Metallica ranking I've seen on KZfaq; you didn't waste time, I enjoyed the descriptions and always love the different opinions of fans. Great video!

Don't agree with everything, but I'm glad I'm seeing another person who realizes some of Metallica's extremely underrated masterpieces

Imma just say, you are brave for doing this. but come on, ronnie worst intro ever

I love what songs you put for the top two! Disposable Heroes is my favourite Metallica song and Trapped Under Ice is my favourite off of RTL! I totally agree that they should play The Struggle Within live more often. Struggle, Don’t Tread On Me, and Through The Never are my favourites off The Black Album. Same can be said for Eye Of The Beholder and Dyers Eve from AJFA.

The fact that you put holier than thou at 8 gives you my respect

I love that half of St. Anger was on the bottom

Props to you for ranking Jump in the fire so high. I think it's amazing and deserves more attention

Al fin alguien que aprecia trapped under ice. Que temazo

1: The Outlaw Torn 2: Bleeding Me 3: All Within My Hands 4: Shoot Me Again 5: That Was Just Your Life 6: I Disappear 7: Cyanide 8: The Unforgiven (I, II, III, combined) 9: If Darkness Had A Son 10: Welcome Home (Sanitarium)

My top 10 1. Dyers Eve 2. To Live Is To Die 3. Orion 4. Blackened 5. Inamorata 6. Ride The Lightning 7. Trapped Under Ice 8. Disposable Heroes 9. The Frayed Ends Of Sanity 10. Spit Out The Bone

Wow, I did not expect to see a list like this. I really like that you appreciate Load. It is a great album and depending on the mood, it is one of their best (even having Poor Twisted Me and Ronnie, for me, two of the worst). I kind of agree of Disposable Heroes being the best, because it covers all things I love about Metallica. I will try to choose my 10 favorites here: The Call of Ktulu, Disposable Heroes, Battery, Blackened, Dyers Eve, My Friend of Misery (it grew on me recently), Wherever I May Roam (my favorite among the famous ones), Fixxxer, All Nightmare Long and Spit out The bone (for me, the best in this century)

Honestly happy to see “Don’t Tread On Me” get some love. Nice and groovy.

Kill’em All, Ride The Lightning and Master Of Puppets Are the best albums 👇

I've been a fan of metallica for so long and I liked your list

Very unique opinions. I appreciate that you threw many songs that are popular like Seek & Destroy. Tho I can't say that I agree with most, but cool list.

Beyond Magnetic, I Disappear and Lords of Summer: "Are we a joke to you?"

My top ten 1. Ride the lightning 2. One 3. For whom the bells toll 4. Disposable Heroes 5. Blackened 6. Battery 7. Fade to black 8. Creeping death 9. The frayed ends of sanity 10. Welcome home (sanitarium)

This goes to show , not everyone has the same opinions. I'm still gonna respect yours , even though 51-50-49 all deserve at least top 20 in my opinion.

Mad props for putting inamorata and Unforgiven 2 in the top 15. They are 2 of best and most emotional songs ever. You did fade to black, atlas rise, and mama said a bit dirty though

My top 20: 1: Nothing Else Matters 2: Ride the Lightning 3: Orion 4: Blackened 5: For Whom the Bell Tolls 6: Bleeding Me 7: King Nothing 8: Ain't my B!tch 9: ...And Justice for All 10: Outlaw Torn 11: One 12: Creeping Death 13: Fade to Black 14 Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15: Sad but True 16: Eye of the Beholder 17: Enter Sandman (This was also the first Metallica song I ever heard and the one that got me into Metallica) 18: Master of Puppets 19: The God that Failed 20: Wherever I May Roam

I recently revisited the Master of Puppets album and I gained so much more respect for TTTSNB, Leper Messiah, Damage Inc. and it really made me realize how much of a masterpiece the entire album really is. And I agree, Disposable Heroes is such a kickass song and deserved #1 😅

WTF? end of the line is way to low, massively underrated

Escape third?, the funniest joke id ever heared

Pretty unique list, and it seems well thought out from your experience

Everyone I know usually tears apart the house that jack built so I was pleasantly surprised to see it that high i absolutely love it

Disposable Heroes is the best song for sure. A epic anti-war master piece

My top 10: 1: One 2: Ride the lighthing 3: Master Of Puppets and Battery 4: Creeping Death 5: For Whom The Bell Tolls 6: Fade To Black 7: Whiskey In The Jar 8: Disposable Heroes 9: Lepek Messiah 10: Blackened and ...And Justice For All

Honestly I liked the list pretty good, 10/10 for making it. My preference is creeping death is 1. However where you put it isn’t wrong at all, phenomenal list my boy

Lots of interesting opinions. I’m glad there’s someone else who loves Escape. Definitely love that one a lot along with the title track.

You Must Burn! is a very good track you should go listen a couple more times

My top 15 (may change a bit depending on the mood): 15) If Darkness Had A Son 14) Hardwired 13) Sweet Amber 12) Just A Bullet Away 11) The Unforgiven III (Same as Carpe Diem Baby) 10) Carpe Diem Baby (This would need to be higher but it's a top 15 so...) 9) Wasting My Hate 8) Frantic 7) The Shortest Straw 6) Moth Into Flame 5) 72 Seasons 4) Lords of Summer 3) And Justice For Jason 2) Don't Tread On Me 1) Ride The Lightning

Excuse my english, please!!! (From Brasil) I have my disagreements with the author, but I must say: it was a great piece of work doing all this. It takes guts to expose one's opinion. And I also wanna thank the author for showing some "underrated" songs, witch I'm paying much more attention to right now. I mean… the guy had to put a lot of work in this thing. Let’s respect that work!

“The only correct Metallica song ranking is one’s own” - Marcus Aurelius

One of my friends is a big time Metallica fan, and his favorite is Disposable, so I respect the pick

SHOOT ME AGAIN IS SO GOOD😭😭😭

Surprised you didn't get torched for where you listed Puppets. But thanks for the cool list. You've inspired me to listen to the whole discography beginning to end tomorrow!

That was just your life is majorly underrated. Its a great opener for Death Magnetic and the riff is crazy. And finally some disposable heros appreciation

The "Everything after AJFA sucks!" contingent will probably hate this list. I definitely would have put Master of Puppets higher, but I respect the variety of songs throughout the list. I absolutely love "Escape" and didn't know back in the late 80's when I got into Metallica that the band hated it. I've always liked the catchiness that they didn't like about it. Kudos to you.

Harvester of Sorrow at 92 and For whom the bell tolls at 51 could be classed as a warcrime. Top 15 maybe...

my top 10 1. Motorbreath 2. Disposable heroes 3. Creeping death 4. Hit the lights 5. RTL 6. MOP 7. Fade to black 8. One 9. Battery 10. Damage, inc.

great video 🙂

I nnow some people will think " SeEk AnD dEsTrOy Is NoT oVeRrAtEd" it's his opinion not us

i mostly aggree but what the hell is atlas rise doing in 94th place that song is such a banger

It'd be interesting if you have this list in excel format or something already, to do an average song placement for each album and see how the albums rank to each other based on the songs ranked individually

Bro i so agree but man you did you must burn (my fav song on 72 seasons) dirty. Same with Lowman and please try to not take that personally. but other then that GOOD JOB and you are brave doing a tier list.

How'd you make this? Also here's my top 10: Master Of Puppets One Orion Fade To Black To Live Is To Die Suicide And Redemption And Justice For All... All Nightmare Long The Unforgiven Ride The Lightning

I wish they played Bleeding Me more often. It's my #1.

I appreciate that it would be difficult to rank this many things subjectively but you sir are a MONSTER

super late comment here, but i honestly wasn't expecting disposable heroes at #1 at all. my personal favorite, glad to see a person who agrees. i cant get enough of it lol

when you stated that Anesthesia is wasted potential what do you think could’ve made it better? cause i personally love anesthesia and think its cliffs most underrated bass solo

I could never rank Metallica albums honestly, I just love every single one to death, I'll list some of my favorites from each one though: - Room of Mirrors - Spit Out The Bone - All Nightmare Long - The Unnamed Feeling - Fixxxer - Mama Said - My Friend of Misery - Dyers Eve - Damage Inc. - Fight Fire with Fire - Metal Militia

The only one thing I want to say is Im happy to see that im not the only one to think that room of mirrors and inamorata are top 2 songs from 72s, no matter what is 1, these are the best 2.

Anyone’s list is his list.. we all can make lists like this and we would all be right. It’s a matter of taste and you have balls making it. My list would have ALL Load and Reload and Death Magnetic and St Anger and the last disc songs (with a couple exceptions) above number 60. Maybe I’m too old school.

I'm happy 'Escape' got ranked so highly. I think it's their most underrated song and my personal fav.

I dont understand why so many people seem to dislike Murder One. Its a banger

You arent gonna see this anywhere in the comments but I actually almost COMPLETELY agree with this list, very nice work and editing

At first I was kind of surprised that some of songs that i love was so high but i got into this list when i saw the Unforgiven on sixth place and as first on black album

I'm happy to see Inamorata so high up. It's one of the only songs I listen to from the new album

Saying anesthesia (pulling teeth) is “wasted potential” is crazy bro It’s literally the definition of Cliff Burtons potential as a bass player

Moth into flame is really one of my favorites.

Veeery interesting song choices there buddy! You surprised me every few songs. I mean, Escape is your 3rd best Metallica song of all time? Cool, why not!

I was so shocked to see For whom the bell tolls so low

72 Seasons > Hardwired > Reload > Death Magnetic > St.Anger > Load +Chasing Light is my favorite song from 72S lol, you ranked it pretty low

I agree with your opinions tho, literally we have the same opinions lol.

Disposable heroes and trapped under ice are also my both top 1 and top 2 songs of metallica. But honestly I totally forget about escape from time to time

i have been waiting for a review of the new album. Never went out of my way to search until your content popped up on my feed. I have been a fan of Metallica for decades. Your song rankings are brave and shall we say questionable. However quite entertaining. To each their own i guess 😊 edit: was gonna post my top 20. I'd rather not. Too many great songs. And too many fans will tear me apart

Not bad opinions, but enter sandman is way too high imo

MY TURN (i loved your rank btw) -1 Trapped Under Ice -2 Spit Out The Bone -3 Sweet Amber -4 Prince Charming -5 Disposable Heroes -6 Sanitarium -7 Phantom Lord -8 RTL -9 Shortest Straw -10 Room Of Mirrors

Finally someone who likes trapped under ice! It's such a good song but unfortunately no one talking about it.

Dude idk how trapped under ice and especially escape gets no love escape is the most underrated song of all time

They're our Lord's of THRASH METAL, so BOW or you'll be beheaded!!

Huge props for ranking Damage Inc. high

DUDE! IDK WHY ESCAPE AND THE SHORTEST STRAW ARE HATED THEY ARE SO FRICKIN AMAZING

The fact you put every song on St. Anger above If Darkness Had a Son is a crime

I thought I was alone on this one, but yeah, that's definitely their best song.

i agree on your take of putting disposable heroes at #1 but ride the lightning, fade to black and call of ktulu deserved a spot much higher imo. my favorite metallica album is ride the lightning and i love all the 8 songs on the album so much

Finally someone made justice to Escape. Dont think its top 3, but its definitely in the top 15 best. Underrated. Completely underrated. Overall I agree with most but Harvester of Sorrow and Seek and Destroy should NOT be that low. Hardwired and Master of Puppets are a bit too low aswell. But amazing video, loved it.

So happy to see Escape getting love like it should.