AMEN

Adriana Santiago is really clear of what side is the interviewer for,I agree Vandana Shiva is a hero

The interviewer is a city woman.i really don't think she has stayed in village or small town.

Adriana Santiago this programme is called ‘Hard Talk’... enough said... interviewees are scrutinised...Mrs Vanda Shiva more than held her own in this discussion and made the interviewer appear biased to the large companies...she was just doing her job.. Kind regards to all

Just another example of how media is controlled by the corporate world.This reporter is probably just doing what she was told to do and she probably wants to keep her job so she's being an attack dog in this case for Monsanto.That's why more and more people are going to independent social media channels for their news these days to find the truth. It's happening in the UK, US, and many other countries globally.It's global corporatism baby!

+Stella Azul I think you got it the other way round. How is the interviewer not holding back from slapping the ignorant anti-GM activist?

+Stella AzulBBC is runned by the corporate people, the very ones that are creating the problems we have right now. The reporter is just doing her work. This amazing human being by the name of Mrs. Vandana is too big and truly respected around the serious world. She is an angel of mercy

***** Ah... I see that you're referring to the " *how* *to* *kill* *a* *kitten* *with* *a* *head*-*squeeze*" video (*goo*.*gl/gX2SWK*). If you actually saw the video before cobbling together your pitiful _ad_ _hominem_ attack, you would have realized that it was a joke. Since you bothered going through my videos, I decided to return the favour. I went through your videos, and was shocked by what I discovered.... You actually believe that a *New* *World* *Order* exists, and that they're spraying us with *chemtrails*! You spend most of your day videotaping harmless contrails and weaving a huge conspiracy theory around it. *Get* *a* *job*. I may be a troll on KZfaq, but I'm otherwise a productive member of society. You sound like you're on welfare and belong in an asylum. It's nutjobs like you who support *idiots* *like* *Vandana* *Shiva* in a self-sustaining cycle. She harps on about chemicals... you buy her books... she whines even more... you buy *even* *more* books... it just never stops with you dolts.

*****​ don't feed the trolls! I am with you all the way. I work at an organic farm, sell veggies at markets AND I have parents and siblings who think the salads at McDonald's is healthy, though they always eat the burgers...they all have health issues and weight issues and what I see as mental health issues. They think I am crazy though I take no pharmaceutical products and no physical or health issues. They love me but still can't hear me on these issues. Hopefully the trolls will become an extinct race.

+Stella Azul Eating too many hamburgers and small amounts of vegetables is not the most healthy diet of course (!), but that has nothing to do with the difference between 'organic' or regular/non-'organic' grown food. If the hamburgers would be from organic cows your parents/siblings still wouldn''t have a healthy diet.

Why did you call her mother. She should have been called Amma or Ammi, umma or by the same way we call our own mother.

yes! BBC has some bad interviewers

@@shivashankaribeerappa4453 she is a professional speaker. N nothing else probably doesn't no e about d economy.....i have observed one thing if you speak fluently people find it intelligent.....

Agreed we r just to many to feed organically ..........Our numbers will drag us down.... more export means less earning..... What 🤗😂😀😉😁🙃 we have elephant in room which is population........ No one is talking about ittt

It's not her fault and she's just a puppet. She's doing what she's told to do . if not, she would be fired by BBC.

The interviewer just had lesson in Agriculture!

The reporters arrange these interviews with an agenda, most of the time paid by big fat chemical and GMO cats...you know who Im talking about. But this time they crashed into a tough rock.. :D

its BBC. HAHAHAHAHA

thats why she got hired

hahahaha 'she presents us with what an A.I sounds like' hahaha (::)

This is BBC's argument, not hers. They are telling her to say this.

That interviewer reminds me of my boss.

Only if our government was as smart as she is. Would be a better world. Monsanto wants to be the supplier of food controller.

Shiva lies to the teeth ...Sad you have fallen to irrationality and pseudo scientists like her

@@varma11235 I love bargain basement Kermit the Frog Gates🖕🤑😈

@@varma11235 r u blind duffer u hvnt seen her work ....her face light on face confidence in voice

She is the embodiment of Godess Adi Shakti. God depicted as Ardhanareshwari. Shakti is half and Shiva half. It represents male and female energy

...but sadly, most Indians are still unware, even abour Dr. Vandana contribution !

"I have travelled across the length and breath of India and I have not seen one person who is a bigger, who is a thief such wealth I have seen in this country, such high moral values, people of such calibre, that I do not ever think we could conquer this country, unless we break the very backbone of this nation, which is her cultural and spiritual heritage and therefore, I propose we replace her old and ancient education system, her culture, for if the indians think that all that is foreign and English is good and greater than their own, they will loose their self-esteem, their native culture and they will become what we want them to be, a truly dominated nation." That bastard McCauley 2/2/1835

@Saurabh Choudhary You are not a white man shut up and be real.

@Saurabh Choudhary English is is the most speaked language but also one of the worst as well . I comparison to Hindi and other Asian languages like madarin , English has too much of ambiguity . The real truth is " history is written by the winners " .It was there time for last few centuries and the Asian became too complacent . Good times create weak Men Weak Men create Bad times Bad times create Strong Men And Strong Men create good times . So I am pretty sure that times will change. China is already proving that and have many other Asian countries . Hopefully Indias time will come . Humans have lived for 100s of Centuries . It was only in the the last 2-3 centuries that West has dominated.

@dsndicmsa have you expired yet?

@dsndicmsa oh. Who should i support? Vile potty mouths like you. Everyone knows who you are and what you are troll. Go slide back under your rock. Say hi to Popeye while your there.

@dsndicmsa So dsndimsa is not a scumbag hiding the truth about evil GMO and emotionally manipulate the world by giving fake seeds?

I can. She's deliberately rude.

Irene Theochari: probably both!

It was a big mistake, to set, an ignorant hose in front of a physicist

I guess the show has to live up to its name of “Hard Talk” but at least this grilling gets the best version out of Vandana and in turn gives us the vocabulary to debate on such topics.

shiva lies to the teeth .... she is just a psudoscientists

Kailem Inrig She sounds like my mom... Would rather argue (& EVERYTHING comes back to "education" /eyeroll) instead of learning.

Absolutely! She has even brought out Dr. Vandana Shiva's brilliance the mire. Now everyone knows how brilliant the Dr.is. I am amazed at her composure and willing to engage despite the visible intimidation ....... And with a smile.

Typical mainstream media eh... Can't come up with an argument to the answer of her question so lets change the subject just like she was taught in school and by her superiors.

Sukriti Mishra try Cathy Newman with Jordan Peterson

interviewer seems to be a corporate rottweiler, very aggressive

+shannon winter News Headline "BBC reaches a new low"

what if the reporter gets canser from roundup crops so she can run to her pharma "friends" for chemotherapy ;-D if that happens would it be a miracle ??? :-D

Yeah, she was amazing !

***** or maybe you are being misinformed by these corporations that are in it for profit, and give no fucks about you or any human. These seeds created by corporations and are made so you can use their products; for example Monsanto with their Roundup Ready crops. These Chemicals deplete the soil and the microscopic life in it which have a symbiosis relationship with plants . Bio-dynamic farming is the way to gooooooooo. You can't just ignore the natural food web, that has been placed there since day one. The deeper history of life and the greater diversity of life on this planet is microorganisms-bacteria, protozoans, algae. Just because they have the money DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE ALWAYS RIGHT.............. DIVERSITY IS NEEDED. STOP TRYING TO MISINFORM THE PUBLIC.

Ever Growing www.ucsusa.org/food_and_agriculture/our-failing-food-system/genetic-engineering/failure-to-yield.html#.VNkUZPnF-Sp (CHECK THIS OUT)

Farmers have been not saving seeds long before GMOs, because it is a huge pain saving massive amounts of seeds, also the seeds from organic hybrid crops don't grow like their parents.

agent of Monsanto? How much did he pay you for writing against Shiva? Only a fool will hesitate to support her!

Indian farmers save seeds and very few know that temples gave space to farmers to save seeds!

+fanMJthebest Agreed. Very disrespectful!

Just another White British woman who doesn't know how to shut up and listen for god's sake. 🤦

@@rinchhensherpa6972 very very true

RINCHHEN SHERPA exactly

amma She is a Force! Vandana rocks

Shiva had to lie and obfuscate to get through the interview.

Olivia Smith you are pathetic saying what you say. Lets save the world from those thieves! including you bitch, how dare you to defend Monsanto?? how much are they paying you???!!

Adam Garcia t in

+SuperCorrector1 www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/roundup-weed-killer-can-probably-cause-cancer-warns-who-10124812.html

What is yr point

was a piece of cake for Vandana...the truth is hard to argue

well not sure what company you work for but you definitely dont speak from truth people arent ignorant to not see or hear whats going on...your gmo crops will be soon flooded out ....permanently

Vandana Shiva is not scum because she is not of of a lower class and she is not ignorant. She has completed a dissertation on non-separability in Physics. She is a doctor. She is very cultured. She understands that we are all connected. Ask yourself if the people who are raping and pillaging our world understand that we are all one. Does Monsanto understand that we are all connected or are they just interested in making money and poisoning us.

There is no point in having this conversation. But here I go. Indians are killing themselves because of this seed issue - Monsanto has manipulated seeds to give them ownership/patent of it and not nature. Seeds come from nature fool. Furthermore, Indians do not like debt - so they would rather die that have debt to anyone - something that Americans should consider. But of course, you would not know this because you are coming out of the American "public fool system". Only an uneducated, uncultured fool would speak in this way. Over and out.

But their arrogance tells them that they have to do it anyway. When someone refuses to grow up you can’t make them.

***** haha, nice try. Your tactics are getting old. Everyone sees through you.

***** ok

I looked into it, read lots of articles about it from varying sources and perspectives. I will continue to follow and educate myself on this subject and share what I learn.

You are not "educating" yourself, she is not a doctor, she is not a noble woman. She lies about suicide rates, lies about profits, and doesn't know shit about GE crops. Want to talk profits? She asks for $40,000 to make a speech. She is not a saint, she is not a doctor, she is a liar making millions off of the suffering of others.

moose656 Nice facelift.

Impudent teenager. If you were able to communicate your point effectively, you would not have to use foul language.

Bonnie I agree with you 100%, I found this video after following a trail of other videos and sites. This was my first experience with Dr. Shiva and this particular show, it was annoying. I hate when you ask a question and you don't want the answer.. Then don't ask! Interviewing someone is to ask and listen. You can ask challenging questions and be "hard" without being combative and ignorant. This British interviewer is much like the ignorant liberal media in the states.

Gmo creates a monopoly of one crop even from the same family for the profit of the one per cent who are the billionaires. This approach has no known good for the poor and the middle class who are the farmers and other workers. Gmo is artificially created to stop farmers from having seeds to replenish each year. Hence the billionaires can sell GMO forever to these farmers who cannot get profit and ultimately commit suicide. If every farmer in an area sold wheat then the price of wheat will go down naturally while the export will double to other countries. This increase in export isn't helping the farmers who die selling more for a lesser price. This is what I learnt from the interview.

She was not given a chance to explain.

True

Well, my perspective is that the interviewer couldn't, or wouldn't, grasp the concept that a doubling in yield of one single mono culture crop is not a benefit to humanity. It is a benefit to the corporation who profits from it. Simple, any idiot should be able to grasp this simple concept. biodiversity is needed to provide humanity with all the required nutrients. dsndicmsa, you made the argument in another comments section that this is true, did you not?

***** If that last is true, then why does Monsanto push roundup so aggressively? Me disingenuous, from the guy who right off the bat called me an idiot, lol. Anyway, I am impressed by your knowledge and I respect your persistence. This discussion has been a nice learning experience for me, on several levels, lol. Looking forward to more learning. Cheers.

"Why are farmers in Argentina growing only Roundup ready Soya? This is not a reflection of choice". Smells of predatory totalitarian shenanigans of parasitic capitalists.

***** Very compelling points, mate. Cheers, you almost have me convinced. I will be doing massive research. And you are right; I wasn't aware of the distinction between pesticide and herbicide. Thanks for pointing that out, you idiot, lol.

true😂

The wittiest take on this board! 👍😂😂

Because Shiva is a liar.

@Super --Ok, let's start with the lie that GMO cotton in India has resulted in hundreds of thousands of poor Indian farmers committing suicide.

The show is called Hard Talk, not Let's Ignore Shiva's Horseshit Lies About Agriculture.

@@BondJFK --Paid? Naw Jon, I mock you and Shiva entirely for free.

the economic system is much more complex, since our economy is "growth" driven and not "sustainability" driven. when we are into stop the monopoly, there should be a limitation of growth, and that would be a great challenge.

yusuf kurniawan NO, that would be a great blessing.

Now Bayer has acquired Monsanto. Bayer will exercise its monopoly in agro sector

tony thomas Let's hope they will turn this shit about Monanto around. Or We will have to force them.

EvenStar LoveAnanda tony thomas I'll tell every farmer i know about this shit and start to build an army.

Dumb city white girl.never done any psyical work.