ilovepinkk95 Yes! And who the hell else is left for it to be?

ilovepinkk95 Hahaha I hope it does make sense!

xEm_0308x I know right. Maybe Lucas (but he's not 15 months older than Jason, obviously) and there's a small chance of Jason. But that's about everything I've got!

@@Mileyforlifex a was cece

Epic Face-Swaps Thank you so much!

KaylaSwEet06 Thank you so much, that really means a lot :))

Kayla Ashbaugh Thank you so much. :) I always thought Aria had something to do with it. The whole Iceland story... it never made sense to me. That's a good idea you've got there! Might make one on them both. I do have a Tumblr, yes! But it's not about PLL, sadly. :( Never felt like anyone would be interested in my thoughts, but since this video is getting quite a lot of views I might make one soon :) Thanks for being so interested, I love you!

Sydney Dixon Thank you so much!!

p. sawyer aww thanks lovely!!

Aria is A because of logic right?

sophie bawcombe Thank you! And that'd be awesome, but I doubt one of the girls is A. I'm 99% sure Aria has something to do with it, though.

Mileyforlifex do with what?

ranmashin With Charles being A. Like she is his cousin or something, that'd make sense.

If charles is aria's cousin then she is realated to the dilaurentis. Which makes zero sense. You would to have to exlplain that one.

Wow, that means so much thank you! :))

Meggy Taho Wow thank you so much. ♥

Adji Ba Wow thank you so much. So am I!! I can't wait to find out what Marlene has been hiding from us since season 3!

Ikr

xEm_0308x Exactly! Though, I've read Charles is in 6x07 (next weeks episode) without a mask, and Wren will probably not be in that episode. Jason, Ezra, Caleb and Toby are, though...

Mileyforlifex Damn. Ezra and Toby are my 2nd and 3rd suspects if it's not Wren.

Mileyforlifex guys calm down it's wren ;) they meant charles unmasked as a kid xD haha marlene's games again

тнє нoє кιℓℓαz † ► Omg you're right. I'm so stupid sometimes, haha. MY THEORY HAS BEEN SAVED! :D Wren could still be Charles, whooo.

thank you lovely!

ariana grande fan Aw don't cry! I'm glad you liked it though! :)

Emma Herselman THANK YOU!

JustShaydon Thank you! I really hope so. :)

I accidentally watched the whole thing on "auto generated" subtitles lol. It was saying stuff like "group parents give scones" & "I just feel the pinch I just touch portion every book " haha I was confused & I went back realized what I did.

BTW I love how this theory video is done. It's a lot different from others I've seen (& I've seen a lot!) I sometimes get bored watching them but this one is different. Kept me hooked. Great work :-)

Katie Galloway Thank you so much. It really means a lot to hear stuff like that, it keeps me rollin'! :)

Therese Ribakare Wow, thank you!!

Same here.

Maria Cristina Thank you! :) And that's what I think, too. Toby or Ezra would be ''too easy'' for me, I guess... Maybe because Toby has kind of already been ''A'' once, and Ezra has had his dark period already as well. Jason would be a little better, mainly because I'd like to know how he faked to be his own brother lol. But yes, I really hope it's Wren too!

***** First of all, thank you so much! Marlene will not change his identity even if the spoilers were true, because when they came on reddit, the finale was already completely filmed, along with the rest of 6A. And yes, the vodka soda did it for me! I didn't put the ''nosey bitches die'' part in the video because Mona wrote that, not Charles. But it could still be a hint!

Mileyforlifex ah I forgot that was during Mona's part, weird that she spelled it wrong though ahha. I just can't wait for creepy Julian/Wren!!

***** Me too! I'm so excited for A to turn around and get his mask off. I hope Wren's adorable face will be underneath it. He'd be the perfect Charles.

josue saintfort I'm glad someone mentioned that, because when I made this video that bit actually made me a bit emotional too haha. Glad I'm not the only one! :) Thank you so much btw!!

Chiara Kln Thank you!!

xEm_0308x I'm afraid I might cry when the summer finale airs. I have a feeling A's life has been pretty rough.

Mileyforlifex Yep. And Wren just seems to be an overall extremely troubled person.

OhMyGee THANK YOU. ♥

B25Revi First of all, thank you. :) And true story. But I've always wondered, are beach hottie and board shorts the same person? If not, I was poiting out board shorts in this video, not beach hottie. I know Ezra is board shorts, but you never know! :) About Aria, in my theory she's Charles' cousin. I don't know why, but somehow Marlene has always been giving clues about Aria being A or her having something to do with this all, for instance the photo frame with ''family'' in the dollhouse. And you know, in PLL nothing is coincidence. So in my theory, Scott Montgomery, who's Aria's uncle, is also Charles' father. Right now we know Kenneth is Charles' father, but we all know that Jessica is good at hiding stuff. But I could be wrong, of course! :)

arim2011 I know, Wren would be the perfect Charles. Although I highly doubt it at this point. Charles will be in next weeks episode without a mask, but Julian Morris will probably not be in it. Jason, Ezra, Caleb and Toby are, though...

Mileyforlifex Dont forget though...Marlene said we were going to see A's face in 5x25, and we technically did...it was just "A"as a child. Im guessing maybe we will see "A" again as a child( with no mask obviously ) because next week might be about Charles coming home for his birthday. Maybe we will see some flashbacks of past birthdays or something as a child. Marlene is really sneaky with how she words things. I dont know for sure if this will happen, but it is just my opinion. Like everyone else, I feel to many things point towards Wren. This video actually made me sad and tear up. Marlene has said we will feel sorry for "A" when everything is said and done. If this is the route they go, I will feel sorry for "A". Wren seems like he has had a troubled childhood/past when he talks. Great theory!! Im really hoping it turns out true, or Marlene is gonna have some explaining to do 😉😉☺

Ashley Harrison Oh darn, you're right! Thanks for being so smart and pointing that out ;) And yes, I hope so too!

Mileyforlifex We will find out in a few days ☺☺

Jeanette Vasquez Thank you so much!

Tiffaney Jordan Haha hey theory twin! Thank you so much :) Yes, I've always thought CeCe was hiding something about herself. But there's another theory I've got where Jessica DiLaurentis and Marion Cavanaugh are the twins.

p. sawyer He didn't hurt her because Charles actually has a thing for Spencer. So now it would make more sense if it is Wren! And yes exactly, just like the season 4 finale. Just pull it off already!

live4christ08 I hope it makes sense, haha. It'd be amazing if Wren would be A but I highly doubt it at this point, even though there are so many clues that point towards him.

Effy Boxall Thanks! :D

Green May Thanks!!

Samee😂💀

Gerard Burns Thank you! :D

p. sawyer Thank you!!

Thank you so much!!

Kat Katty Kat Kat I love you, just sayin.

Anna Danuta You're very welcome! Thanks to you! :)

Cosmic Amy Thank you!! Who do you think is A?

Mileyforlifex No idea. I think maybe Cece. No problem and nice video

kenna163 Very true! But if my theory is right (which I doubt, but anyway), then Bethany (and maybe CeCe and Wren as well) was adopted by Marion Cavanaugh. And remember what the girls said about Andrew when they found out he was adopted? ''He might be older than we think he is''.

Mileyforlifex could be. i actually really hope it's at least sort of true. what program did you use?

kenna163 Haha, me too! I used Sony Vegas pro 12 :)

Mileyforlifex do you mind me asking where did you download it from?

kenna163 No that's okay! I'm just not sure, because my dad downloaded it for me lol.

Zoozy G So do I, :(

So I wasn't the only one

Tessa Kalmeijer lol nop

She was talking about Mike not being the same as Byron's brother, Scott Montgomery (Mike's uncle).

Ow ok then -A

iBitterQxeen yeh... why's that funny?

+Mileyforlifex Just ignore the trolls. ;)

Jessica Eleanora Me too. I always knew Wren would be too obvious, but still some part of me really wanted it to be him, simply because then it would have been a guy and someone we've known since episode 1. That would've shocked me so much more than CeCe. My reaction would've been something like: ''Wow, all this time Wren was her brother and had a second personality''. CeCe just wasn't shocking to me, I would've wanted her as Red Coat as well. And exactly, it's like they couldn't come up with something better, so they just made Sara (who we've known for 6 episodes) both red coat and black widow. Ugh, PLL.

Mileyforlifex exactly!! my point! :)

Lol if Aria is related to Wren who would be related to Jason then yes they are related..??

New Americana unless a marriage is involved no they wouldnt be. Aria and Wren cousins... Jason and Wren brothers... Jason and Aria... seperate branches on an entangled tree lol

Dxdiva16 They would be extended family... I don't know why people try to bring Aria into this, she's the liar who's the most disconnected to the A plot, and I doubt that will change.It would make no sense for her to have anything to do with Wren, if he's A. He is related to Alison, this is about her, not the girls.

New Americana Because Aria has many suspicious reasons why she could be involved with A... sorry to say it but she does! Even Lucy Hale acknowledged it and thought she was A. Extended family...ok if your cousin had a brother you knew nothing about ( didnt even know he was part of your family nor your cuzzos secret brother) and was super hot...would you have any problem having a crush on him BEFORE any knowledge of being "family"...?

New Americana also if their is no marrital or blood relation...they are NOT related... extended or not because the only thing that would connect Aria to Jason is "Wren" and thats it. No same anything. So could be a possible theory. Not saying its confirmed nor its what it is...but it is possible and not incest.