Ron: Am I the one who steals the show? No, I'm not. Also Ron: Gets first place in a song ranking

This show has some of the best music in all of starkid. The only things bringing it down is the fact that its a stage reading and Darren's mic is *fucked*

i don’t have a fear of spiders, i just have a fear of jeff blim

I'd really like to hear Joey do sidekick again bc he's improved so much over the years and I think I'd be even better now

I didn't read the "arachnophobia" part in the disclaimer so I thought it was just for people with a general fear of Jeff Blim. Also, hot take: This is my favorite AVP show.

Always Dance is underrated

I think I Was would be more appreciated if you could hear the harmonies because of Darren's mic

get in my mouth is far better than senior year and this is the end T_T

me: “sidekick is amazing but not that amazing” also me: *aggressively points my finger to the beat every time he sings “DEFINITELY NOT”*

If Wizard of the Year is low on the list I swear I'm gonna throw some hands

I Was should be #1 but darren’s fucked up mic prevents us from actually hearing how crazy amazing it is. Senior Year probably sounds 50x better if we can actually hear Darren too, but it just sounds bad

if we voted when you have to go all the way home as worst i’m going to cry

Literally no one asked but here is my top 3 1. Everything Ends 2. Wizard of the year 3. I was/ Sidekick Also, I said it once and I will say it again, AVPSY has one of if not the best soundtrack of the starkid musicals

Wizard of the year deserves to be first

All of the music in this show slaps so hard, even the low ranking ones. (Also thank you for putting the Get In My Mouth warning thing, I didn’t want to see that song again)

I Was and Everything Ends are both in my top five Starkid songs

i was is such an amazing song. the harmonies are too beautiful

Everything Ends is my favourite Starkid song so I'm biased and thought it should have been first-

I was lowkey expecting everything ends to be #1, but sidekick definitely deserves to be on top

Even with the mic difficulties this was one of the most entertaining musicals for me.....it also had some killer underrated songs!!!

Fact people put get in my mouth at least Is heartbreaking

shoutout to joey's snort at the end of "this is the end" cause meredith pranked him

always dance needs more love :(

all of these songs deserve so much love and they don't get it and it makes me so sad :((

sidekick number one that’s a win

wizard of the year didn't make top 3???? yall don't have TASTE

Sidekick is going to be first. I just know it. Edit: I KNEW IT!!

I was will always my fave StarKid song

The music in this show is amazing 🥺

I just realized while listening to When You Have To Go All The Way Home... This is the closest Voldemort came to being good. When he thought he had a home to go back to, which he later realized he didn't have and turned evil again. And at the end of AVPM Voldemort says "I came home".

I think Senior Year should’ve been before This is the End

I adore Sidekick for featuring Joey and Ronald Weasley - Joey has improved so fucking much even with that song and you can so clearly hear his better breath control in more recent performances and the song just makes me feel soft

unpopular opinion: bellatrix’s riffing in when you have to go all the way home is messy and i really don’t like it 🥴

Honestly, kudos to them for "This is the end". It isn't easy to sing when running, even if you are running in place.

I feel like the top 3 of this rating would be top 10 of all starkid songs.

I've never liked Sidekick and always skip it when it shows up in compilations but I'll accept that I'm in the minority, lol. I'm happy Everything Ends was so high-ranked, though!

I am incredibly happy to see everything ends getting recognition

Thank you for that warning at the beginning

I always hate the fact that get in my mouth is the last. It's so out of nowhere but that's just epidemy of Jeff Blim. He's just here and nobody knows how he got there

wait i didn’t realise i was so early i thought this was ages ago 😂

My Ranking (Keep in mind this is my favourite Starkid soundtrack) 11. When You Have To Go All the Way Home - Good song, not my favourite. 10. Get In My Mouth - Super catchy and funny, doesn't quite stick with you the way some others do. 9. This Is The End - Great opening number. Not as good as 'Not Over Yet' or 'Goin Back to Hogwarts' but it's very good. 8. Senior Year - Super overhated. Could someone in the comments tell me why this song has such a low score? It's great. 7. I Was - Fantastic duet with great vocals. It's only placed at #7 because of how much I adore the top 6. 6. Goin' Back to Hogwarts (Reprise) - Phenomenal reprise. It fit into the story and scene perfectly and delivered the exact right amount of nostalgia. 5. Sidekick - Super hilarious, really sweet song. I'm glad Ron was actually a likeable character in this show. 4. Tonight This School Is Mine - Such a banger. I've always wanted this kind of a duet in a Starkid show, and this absolutely delivered. 3. Wizard of the Year (Gilderoy) - What a jam. The amazing piano skills, AJ's pitch perfect cadence and vocals, the perfect balance of instrumental and melody; one of the best Starkid songs. 2. Always Dance - The most underrated Starkid song of all time. It builds on the foundation of 'To Dance Again' perfectly, as well as building on itself in a way no other Starkid song has ever done. Dylan and Joe have amazing chemistry, the dance-off is pitch perfect and the last verse reminded me of the last verse of 'Kick It Up A Notch'. It's that good. 1. Everything Ends - The most beautiful song Starkid has ever written. Amazing melody, chords and lyrics all come together to make one of the few Starkid songs to truly choke me up.

SIDEKICK IN FIRST WHERE IT BELONGS

Ngl I like Tonight This School Is Mine better when Brian sings it but it could just be because Darren didn't have time to rehearse and his mic was messed up and Brosenthal's my fav

why is get in my mouth last that song is a masterpiece

I really thought number 1 would be Everything Ends (everyone loves that but I'm not a big fan) but I'm glad Sidekick won. Sidekick is one it my favourite songs in starkid/ever!

thanks for the TW 💜

When you have to go all the way home was done dirty

If 'I Was' isn't first...

my list: Get In My Mouth Tonight This School Is Mine Wizard Of The Year Sidekick I Was Always Dance This Is The End Going Back To Hogwarts When You Have To Go All The Way Home Senior Year Everything Ends so many people are gonna hate me for this

I cannot put to words my hatred of Get in My Mouth I can't it's so bad

im glad we all put Get In My Mouth as the worst, something about that song just does not sit right with me. And I'm not sure what, it just...... no

those who dont like get in my mouth either have spider-phobia (whatever its called) or asexuals or deaf there is no other reason for someone to hate it

I think I Was would be more appreciated if you could hear the harmonies because of Darren's mic