⚠NEW SUBTITLES 👇 🔴 This video is subtitled in 15 languages: ✅KOREAN; ✅JAPANESE; ✅CHINESE; ✅ENGLISH; ✅INDONESIAN; ✅PORTUGUESE 🇧🇷; ✅SPANISH; ✅PERSIAN; ✅TURKISH; ✅ARABIC; ✅RUSSIAN; ✅MALAY; ✅VIETNAMITA; ✅FRENCH; ✅ITALIAN;

If you look into lyrics you ll understand this song is a mixture of emotions , mainly D.O and Baekhyun's parts are about sweetness of love ,sweet memories they had,thankfulness towards her wanting to be with her again but Chen's part mainly is regret , blaming himself for selfishness , and longing with regret . What a masterpiece .

They aren't just kpop idols; they are PROFESSIONAL SINGERS.

1:58 Kyungsoo sounds so incredible here, I get goosebumps every time

I've said this once, and I'll keep on saying it again: *EXO's main vocal line is incomparable and unbeatable!* Not many artists that can move me into tears with their singing, and EXO is some of the very few! Their voices, their strength, their range, their emotions, and their techniques, are *perfect!*

I'm a baby ExoL because of Kai's Rover Song! Exo have thee best live, power, vocalist in K-pop for male's I have ever heard! They are amazing and I am blown away every time I hear D.O, Baekhyun and Chen's voices!!! I LOVE their vocal tone, runs, adlibs, control...they're true artists. I could hear them sing live all day!!!

ChenBaekSoo stands out from other main vocalists because they sing with EMOTION. Others have the skill and technique, but cannot convey the song's meaning and emotion as well as these three.

3:20 chen vocal here give me chills someone explain me how amazing is his vocals 😭😭

Chen is not human, he is out of this world . I miss you so much my angel .

I am lost again. This performance gets me goosebumps. I miss them alot *inserting crying*

Best vocal trio in kpop

This is the power of exo. Their vocals are out of this world.

there’s something about jongdae’s voice in this performance that i find myself tearing up at

This is the best performance of this song. I love it beyond all things.

SM IS LUCKY TO HAVE THEM 🥺🥺

Dear Jongdae omg I can feel so much pain regret in your voice the most, I feel so heart broken in your part the most. I know its because of lyrics but boy thank you for your amazing emotion delivery as usual . And I enjoy D.O & Baekhyun's bittersweet parts.

3:08 baekhyun's voice is so good ✨

im torn between being being heart broken about the lyrics, being comforted by beautiful voice and falling inlove with chen's visuals. damn.

I can't live without chen's angelic voice.

Chen was so outstanding in this performance but just Baekhyun’s voice touched my heart 🥺 I dont know why but his voice seemed to be full of paintfullness

Since no one mentions my boy D.O., I'm here to hype him. Your voice is so soothing and full of emotions. I just love your vocal tone. I hope you are always trying to improve your vocal.

I am appreciate to every single idols group who’s covering this song, but I have to say the original one was still the most legendary. Look how they just upgraded miracles in december with those vocals and emotional. It’s brings back the ot12 memories the moment exo sang this song.

D.O. Kyunsoo you Sing like an Angel You're Awesome👏💞😇💞

The fact that all these three amazing vocalists are in one group is just crazy.

It's impossible not to be emotional listening to this beautiful track from EXO's vocal triumvirate!!! 😢😢😢

Damn….. I’m just so glad that I gave myself a chance to watch EXO this past few weeks. Now I’m loving them.. specially Baekhyun! But these three?? Urrgggg main indeed!

I cried, this song makes me so much emotional. And their vocals are just amazing!

3:39 I like the way Chen sing DO’s part “gesokdwel kkeot gata” with his lips

The power of these three kings 🤧 Chen ❤

I need more song with this trio

I love this song you know a good song when u hear one you don't even need to know the language to understand what they singing

Exo vocals are just amazing!!!!! I k ow I don't have to tell this everyone knows this fact but still I'm writing this here again!!!!! Coz no matter how much u praise their vocals its not enough! The only reason why I stan EXO and not any other grp is their pure talent!

You know that they're a really masterpiece of vocal, so you must agree with their vocal

This performance literally brought tears to my eyes. wow.

I come again to this song but the last part of Jongdae always makes me cry, every time. I know it has nothing to do with it but I know there was a time when it wasn't easy for him so I really hope he's happy now. I love him so much.

Only EXO can sing this song so well

Their vocals alone are enough to make me emotional

this is the best vocalist in whole kpop who got within one grp , and never comes again for any grps

I miss them already😢😢😭😭

Falling in love with baekhyun everytime, everyday

I love these 3 men. Anytime they sing together, I get the chills.

抜群の歌唱力のボーカル奏でる美しいハーモニー❤チェン❤ベッキョン❤ディオ❤最高😃⤴️⤴️

All three of them are extraordinary.

Littlerally Chen's emotional delivery is top notch. So genuine .Chen's voice is harsh here because his parts are about self blaming himself ,almost most negative parts are delivered by him . Im a weak person , I was so selfish , I regret everything , I want you again . Honestly I have no idea about technique Im not knowledgeable about that ,but emotionally I feel best from Chen . His way of expression is much more genuine for me. His tone is full of regret , hate towards himself ,sorrow of breaking up,longing towards the lover he is littlerally breaking down even his expressions shows that a lot.

To myself, its okay if u wanna cry today. Its okay babee. Coz ur precious to urself☁️

exo top tier

Just no matter how much you listen to exo live vocals it's not enough each and everytime they just bring me tears. I'm really blessed to listen to their vocals.

Wow D.O live is amazing

Do such singers exist. Am still buffles in disbelief..

EXO 3 ♥️♥️♥️ always takes me to the heavens. Can you imagine if they were a subunit. ✨Baekyhun’s light 🌎 D.O.s strength and ⚡️Chen’s thunder bolts. Powerhouse!!!

ジョンデの声が綺麗すぎて、、、😭😭😭😭😭😭 これからも、ジョンデ大好きです

This song carry me to an another world ,when l hear this everytime, exo best vocals

Best live performance I've ever seen in my whole life

Музыка EXO точно не для фонового звучания! Когда exo поёт ТАК, я не могу больше ничем заниматься, как только с трепетом внимать им! 🙏🤗💋 Спасибо за перевод песни!

Why the lyrics of this song are soo good??? Even tho I've watched this millions of times but still getting the same goosebumps 😭😭😭I LOVE EXOO❤❤

This song has a very special place in my heart.

Chen voice so Satisfying

I really loved their legendary performance with their incredible vocals on point. So timeless but remains one of the best. 🥺🥰

this will always be my most favorite beautiful, heartbreaking song TT

This song made me their fan

EXO...the best among the rest!!!..love them most!

Bu kadar değiştiğime inanamıyorum

Missing them. Vocal line exo and everything with exo.

Why why their Winters are so good to brng a tear in my eye

I just got out of my final exam for my worst class... I needed to hear these voices, it's my healing 😭💗💗💗💗

3:03 fav part ❤️😭

Sadece bir gün önce yorum yapmışım ama sanki bir haftadır dinlemiyormuşum gibi hissettiriyor

You can definitely see they are trying really hard to fight the emotions while singing. But, with trembling voice they manage to delivered this song successfully. That's what makes this live more beautiful ❤❤😢

Jongdae you surprises me most

Love them so much

I miss them so much 😭 I will wait till all the members reunite again and will continue to support them forever

I MISS YOU I LOVE YOU WE ARE ONE EXO ♥️♥️♥️

This song so emotional and beautiful🎉😢❤😘💘💘

Cant believe mereka nyanyi live vocal mereka sangat wow wow👍

One word to describe this performance: BEAUTIFUL... I was just looking at the screen the whole time... at them.There is something in this song that brings comfort... Then there are these three who just brings storm with their singing. This song may be comforting but it is very emotional too and BaekChenSoo are singing it so soulfully here.

I feel like crying every time i hear this song.. exo.. you're love keeps me moving..

The voices of exo oppa can make me cry (exo l) when their voices is also not edited exo we are one

Reading english version so sad everytime i play the song D.O. CHEN and BAEKHYUN a good tandem in singing.Not the 3 but support all EXO boy band...I'm the momshies supporter regarding with my kiddos of Philippines.God bless

when i listening this song im still crying because i miss the three member of exo luhan kris tao we miss you😓😓 we are one😓😭😭😭

All I can do is CRY😭😭🤧

Every time I hear this song and read the lyrics, my heart immediately breaks because it's that emotional EXO is amazing❤❤❤❤❤❤

2023 still missing ❤❤❤

What a beautiful lyrics 😭

Vào một ngày mùa hè, bỗng thấy nhớ EXO đến lạ. Nhớ bản thân của năm 2015 khi mà mỗi ca khúc của năm ấy tôi từng nghe đi nghe lại vang lên, lại một lần khiến trái tim tôi bồi hồi

I think the miracle they are referring to is that they now recognize how true love changed them to become a better (less selfish, more understanding) person, even though they lost that love. Sometimes one doesn’t realize the value of something precious until they lose it but later they are thankful for the opportunity to have had it at all.

Literal goosebumps. They're too perfect

Essa música deveria ser um patrimônio cultural lá na Coréia. É hino demais! Exo jamais decepciona, eles sabem como fazer músicas ETERNAS! Que independente do tempo nunca perde o valor. Esse é o padrão exo de ser!

ฉันชอบเพลงนี้มากๆๆๆๆๆเลย มันมีความไพเราะ แฝงไปด้วยความรัก ความผิดหวัง เสน่ห์ของเสียงร้องที่ยอดเยี่ยม😊😄😁😆🥰😍

December 7 2021 🥺

When hearing this song,I miss ot12

I cannot hold back my tears whenever I listen to this song. Thank you for uploading!

We need more song from them 3

I love this song. I hope my lover can sing it to me someday ❤

😱 Ay por Dios!!!! Que bonita canción, estos chicos son increíbles perfectas armonías en sus voces, me encanto 💖 Bendiciones 🙏🏻💕

Aşkın beni yönlendiriyor

CHEEEEEN 😭

Ah my heart they are amazing😢❤️

es como escuchar un canto de angeles!!

Как перестать слушать😢😢😢😢😢😢шикарно, мурашки, постоянно на повторе.

I’ll always love this whole album praying we get another exo winter album but miracles in December will always be the best