ROCKS !!!!!!!

Eddie's also spot on, Night in the Ruts (1979) is underrated as hell, loaded with bluesy heavy rock

Toys are in the attic,Rocks are on the roof...Tops ! (Two best,Peak years)

eing 37 years old, I first heard the later Aerosmith albums starting with Pump. When I decided to explore their 70's releases I started with Rocks after reading that it was Slash's favorite Aerosmith record. Upon first listen I was just blown away by the raunchy, heavy rock n' roll mixed with blues sounds of each track. Not long afterwards I listened to Toys in the Attic expecting to hear an even better record, as a lot of fans and critics rank it as the absolute pinnacle of Aerosmith's discography. All I remember is being completely shocked by how tame the sound was compared to Rocks. Take away Round and Round and the two mega hits (Walk this way/Sweet Emotion) and the rest of the album just seems to just sputter. I feel like it's very much a "you had to have been there" type of record, because without any Nostalgia to boost the tracks it just isn't a heavy hitter compared to Rocks in my opinion.

Toys has absolutely no filler, Rocks has some darker underrated heavy songs though, as Eddie was saying

Two different sounding albums.. produced differently. I love them both

I wish Trunk's Top 20 commentary (and other bands like VH and KISS) was still on here. The uploaders account got deleted a few years ago

Its ROCKS. Both a major part of my rock and roll development.

Two completely different albums. Both great albums...id have to say rocks.

2 classic albums, but Rocks IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE albums of all time.

Rocks...hands down, both good but Rocks rocks!

They’re both great because they both represent Aerosmith at their best which was earlier on in the 70s. The real question should be a comparison of 70s Aerosmith with Mid 80s MTV era Aerosmith. I was surprised how many people prefer the 80s crap, barely aware that Aerosmith even existed prior to “Janie’s Got a Gun”.

💎Rocks 💎 is the winner

Kings and we queens was on draw the line people.

Toys in the Attic. Good starting point for newcomers to Aerosmith

Rocks. Although Eddie likes to go on a tangent about his personal opinion every 2 minutes, I enjoy hearing his stories.

Rocks does what the title saysROCKS

Toys is one of the greatest records ever made.

"Rocks" for me.

Toys...It has the Rock AND the Roll. 🤠

Thanks for these i cant get trunks shows from my country only the weekly podcasts.

Toys in the Attic 1A Rocks 1B

Rocks.

Rocks is the cool one to pick, but Toys is a better album.

Toys has two great hits, but Rocks is the better album.

Here's a category: Who was a higher maintenance frontman: David Lee Roth or Steven Tyler?

I love toys, but they were out of there minds on rocks it was their pinnacle, don’t get me wrong there best song kings and queens came after rocks

Toys by a mile!