Please share with everyone!! People deserve to hear how they ACTUALLY sounded live at Coachella. After filming this fancam in the front row and then going online after, I was shocked that people were commenting that the audience was dead and that they couldn't hear aespa's live singing over the back track. It must have been the livestream!! But in person the girls were GIVING!! (and so were the fans) This fancam is proof!!

After watching the Les sserafim's Coachella I'm once again proud of my Aespa girls, sm vocals are no joke.

OMG THEIR LIVE VOCAL ARE SO STABLE,THIS IS WHAT WE CALLED KPOP STANDARD.

THEY DESERVE THE BIGGEST APOLOGY 🥺🥺🥺 they did such a good work( their songs are almost 4 min long woth tonnes of high notes)with no stage props, no remix, no band, barely any back dancers😮😮😮

if it weren't for Le Sserafim I wouldn't know that Aespa had performed at Coachella and they sounded THIS GOOD live???! Damn say whatever about SM but they be debuting REAL talent, these girls slayed!

the vocals in this song are already difficult if you're standing still, but they killed it while dancing. put some respect on their names!

one thing for sure- SM vocals never disappoint 😭🫶🏼

I'm sorry but, I come back to this video again. They're really ATE.

now aespa has become a big group and can perform at the Tokyo Dome in two days and all tickets are sold out.

No because we FINALLY got an actual LIVE performance with their live vocals not the prerecorded ones. They look so energetic and happy 😭

Everyone did a great job honestly. We are all waiting for them to sing live and they SNAPPED!! My girl Giselle slayed👏

Who wants Aespa again perform at Coachella???

There was no band performance, just background music. I hope Coachella officially invites aespa once. They deserve a better stage.

i just can never stop admiring winter's stamina, control and power over her voice. It's amazing how her lungs and throat aren't even tired after performing 5 songs consecutively 😭😭😭

I just don’t get it why people throwing hate to aespa on twitter, they did so well here💕

WINTER, I'M SORRY FOR EVER DOUBTING YOUR VOCALS 😭😭😭😭😭. YOU ATE THE FUCK UP!!!!!!!!

Winter’s vocal is just WOW. She is really the definition of THE NEXT LEVEL!

Winter's high notes really deserve an award

I'm not even a fan but they did great all of them and winter gosh she slayed with vocals

Their live vocals is truly amazing. So powerful

I can't believe people are saying they weren't stable. They SLAYED. They were singing and having fun, so some parts may not sound like the studio album, but that's the beauty of live songs. They sound different because they're meant to sound different. Especially in an event such as this. No one at Coachella cares about how similar you sound to the original recording. What people care about in festivals is what the singer makes you feel, the energy they bring to the stage. And boy did they bring some AENERGY!

Omg winter ...how did such powerful voice came out from such a small body...shes sooo charismatic ..damn ace winter is no joke...her stage presence tho when singing gave me goosebumps

winter’s vocal is soooo strong, it literally pierces through my ears in such a good way 🤍

I came back here after watching Lesserafim’s coachella stage… That was rough… Now THIS! THIS is refreshing for my ears ahhh

Winter sound like the studio version and also so stable 😳

Vocals.. much better than studio

The confidence of Giselle and Ningning. They are the international representatives of aespa while Winter and Karina are the SK representatives. Perfect combo!!!

Here to cleanse my ears after le sserafim 🥲

Winter's live performance amazing👍👍👍

Winter's vocal is very stable and she always sounds so unique every time I hear her voice

Hello to everyone who just encountered aechella, I just want to say that THIS is rookie aespa and THIS is their first performance with real audience. They did well and continued to improve so much compared to this 2022 performance. 😊

winter’s vocal is so clear n stable such a slayer damn 😪

winter vocals are impeccable

my girl winter devoured that vocals! she slayed that. love how after 3 performances, she was still able to execute those hight notes! SO proud of her😩🙌🏻

Winter vocal is very stable. Impressed

After watching this fancam, I realized: 1. Giselle - really good at hyping the crowd. She's really good at the overall emotion of the performance. 2. Karina - good combo w/Giselle. Very stable and the ace of the group. 3. Winter - not dancing so much so that she can stabilize her voice since majority of their songs, she's the one singing the high notes. Very stable. 4. Ningning - very charismatic on stage. She has the potential to be one with the stage. (These are my opinions, so you can either agree or disagree. I'm also a MY)

Winter so stable all throughout their performance like... Did you ate all of your album cd versions??😳😳

winter is the most stable among them! Everyone else's voice trembled a little bit, but Winter didn't pant or shake his vocal cords! Really great! winter deserves praise! Of course karina is great too! Really like them!

wow Winter is really stable I said this a few times already but I'm gonna say it again, I guarantee you that if aespa had more members she would be their main vocal as well, she hits those notes flawlessly

What I love about this performance is that there's a perfect balance between Ning Ning & Giselle who are high energy and hyping up the crowd and Karina & Winter who are like steady anchors holding down the song, they did SO well

The just did great job! Never understand people who hate them

Winter voice didn’t even shake , wow that’s some quality over there

this proves why winter's voice doesn't need layering in their recording, she is the autotune itself👏 if the other members where not shaky i would say this is lipsync by just listening to winter, shes very stable .Scary

I really didn't know Ning Ning has stage presence like this She is soooo good

I did not regret choosing Winter as my bias since debut. 💅🏻💗

winter really did a great job despite her energy being not the same with the 3 girls. i feel like she was conserving her energy for the high notes because girl they have so much high notes in their songs. whilst ningning was kind of shaky on some parts because she was really shouting and hyping the crowd since the beginning but she still sustained til the end of their performance. spread love mys

Amazing performance ! Winter sounds so stable here!! LOVE THE ENERGY🔥🔥🔥

WINTER’s voice was stable and clear. I fell in love with your voice over and over again. ❄️🔥

winter vocal is no joke🔥🔥🔥🔥

Winter looked a little nervous but her vocals did not fail her😵she's soo stable!! My babies nailed it.

now we all know why sme was so adamant in keeping winter a 'secret' during her trainee days... she truly is a hidden gem.

Omg i didn't expect that winter is stable and slay those high notes. I understand that others was a bit sound shaky due to some hard movements but did great job too. Overall, all of them did great. Now haters must shut up and stop on hating aespa since this is the proof that aespa can sing live without using AUTOTUNE.

Especially Winter just slays with her live

How could people hate on this? This is fucking iconic. They killed it. They proved everyone wrong. Keep shining, girlies 💖

Winter's vocal is no joke

There's definitely alot to improve but I'm really proud of them. Imagine debuting during the pandemic, haven't fully accustomed to performing live in front of a big crowd plus the company not allowing them to sing live on appearances, aespa faced a lot but with such high replayability and unique music and members that you can sense that they wanna do what they're trained to do, they're gonna go a very VERY long way. HWAITING AESPAAA

I'm impressed by Winter. She's so stable.

I will never forget Winter at Coachella, her voice was so perfect and stable, the others did well too but Winter really left the bar high. 🥹

this was recommended after my watching Lesserafim(?). I thought they did superb back then and this time, I'm even more impressed. I'm not MY (I think this is how their fans are called, right?) but they are my favourite gg now

WINTER JUST SOUNDED LIKE THE AUDIO VERSION MYGOSHHH SHE'S REALLY DRINKING SM'S WATER EVERYDAY

Winter's so stable!

Omg so high, i don't believe that Winter' voice so good like on the studio, good job Winter, good job Aespa

The way Winter sing 'nex-tst level' sound fantastic hohoho

Yes My girls are Juniors in the industry.. debuted during the pandemic.. haven’t performed much in front of a big crowd but managed to Perform on one of the biggest stages in America… Yes they are nervous and shaking..and tired it’s showing but DAMN.. THEY SLAYED this sh*t !!! And the hate you are putting on them is NONSENSE!

All of them are good but especially Winter..... she's insane😮 i'm speechless love you Aespa😍🥰

WINTER's VOICE IS A MIRACLE

aespa slaying live vocal without pre-recording/autotune

Winter was so good 😭 im proud that the girls proved their haters wrong. Anyone saying it isnt live is deaf 😂

2:20 WINTER SLAYY. THEY ALL SOUND SO GOOD OMFG

THEY ALL DID WELL BUT WINTER’S VOCALS THOOO SO STABLE BROOO

How could people hate this performance??? They sound sooo good and almost the same as the recorded vocals.

damnn winter's voice is so stable

GISELLE DID SUCH A GOOD JOB!! SHE LITERALLY SLAYED, LOVE HER RAPPING SO MUCH OMG

The “Where we at? Coachella!” part literally gave me goosebumps, I’m so proud of them!

no because there were some many people doubting my girl Winter's live skills but she was the best one

Giselle and ningning served with their facials and their singing/rapping. Winter served with her singing, Karina served, ate, and left no crumbs

Oh my gosh Winter's voice is insane 😲 Their performances at Coachella were a smack for the haters ✨ Why doesn't SM let them sing live on music shows too?! 🥺

Winter highnote stability is the real next level .

I must admit that winter's voice was the one that stood out the most live

The way the crowd cheer after winter slayed her high note. I'm so proud of her

Giselle Stage Presence Ningning Attitude Karina's as Center Winter being stable QUEEN

No way but winter's voice😭😭😭😭♥️

Thats why a live performance hits different, their vocals are superb

I wasn't a fan of aespa before this. Actually, the baseless hate they received for their coachella performance was the one thing that pushed me to actually see the performance. I can tell I'm literally blown away after seeing this. NEW MY HERE ⚡ This affirms that those haters are actually HATERS, and not some "opinionated" people. Same thing happened to me when I found out about Ive's Wonyoung. I saw the hate, checked it out myself, ended up liking the artist. 😅

Ningning looks so confident here, and also looks like she has lots of fun.

Giselle knows to light up the atmosphere 🔥🔥

I love the way how the crowd shouted and ning ning smiled when winter hit the high notes

I'm not a MY but I like Ning Ning's energy and stage presence here. She's not flawless but obviously so hardworking. I honestly love this type of idols who cherish being on the stage and having the opportunity to perform for thousands of people.

Winter omg she was born to sing on stage😭😭

This fancam is a LEGEND like AESPA's performance 👏🙌

라이브 겁나 잘하는구만... 왜 못했다는 그런 .. 간만에 시원한 라이브 들으니 속이 후련

Let me drop an appreciation comment on Karina. She is so energetic and stable from start to finish, even hyping up the crowd and interacting with them. I also love her little adlibs and she looks so happy while performing.

i live for winter’s stable vocals

winter vocal is strong

Winter's vocals bro.. I'm glad I never once doubted her skills since debut

Winter murdered the vocals..

ALL OF THESE ARE GIVING ME GOOSEBUMPS HEARING THEM LIVE ESPECIALLY WINTER AND NING NING 😭😭❤❤

Winter is sooo good live

Finally got to hear winter's growl before she hit the high note 😭😍

Winter hitting that note live 😍😍😍