In the credits if you listen very closely to the lyrics, mario actually regrets killing BF and GF because he never truly wanted to end them, he was just blinded by rage of being trapped in a video game because of daddy dearest betrayal to him.

Nah Racist Mario deserves pure evil for the fact that he doesn’t care about the other members of Nintendo characters, as shows with Peach’s black eye the the quotes, “He takes everything to seriously,” and the infamous “Mario stop! We’re brothers!” “I have NO brother…” line

I think there are 2 other reasons why M doesn't belong in pure evil. 1. He seems to have some respect towards Bf. He offered him a deal that if he beat M in three songs, he'd let them go, he only decided to go all out when Bf ran off instead of staying to finish the final song showcasing he would have kept his end of the deal. 2. Ultra M seems to have remorse for killing Bf&Gf at the end of All Stars (Act 4) during the credits, we can hear M singing in the background after successfully killing them instead of feeling satisfied he feels empty a bitter victory as he once again alone he even ponders on whether this is what he truly wanted.

1:35 Shows that despite being insane, he always cares for Luigi.

5:03 "this guy is a piece of crap and i'm happy that kratos smacked him up a bit" dude that opinion was personal

Man the facts that MX did not give a shit of killing Gf

7:38 Me: “hmmmm reminds me of someone…” William Afton: “shut up”

To be honest I think I’d also put Devil Mario in the “Wrong” tier as well, solely because the only reason he did what he did in the story was because he was possessed by Boos, and once he broke free he “stopped the invasion” for lack of a better term. That’s just my opinion though! Great list btw

2:34 "Day Out Mario wins the worst brother award." IHY Luigi: Am I a joke to you?

5:12 He should be in Wrong or Bad, he didn’t want to kill them, he took it too far. The Ending song is him regretting what he did

You forgot a fact regarding Mr L One of the main reason he came back as vengeful spirit isnt just due to being accidentally killed by his brother, but since it happened in bowsers castle its believed that the evil aura of the castle corrupted luigis soul turning him i to the monster we know and love today

I'd personally put costume on high wicked to low pire evil tier, in the creepypasta he's based on, he's a machete weilding serial killer who specifically targets kids, luring them in with a mario mascot suit. Kinda like william afton.

I can’t help but laugh when he took a long pause when saying that dictators name

I honestly never knew GB was more powerful than MX. I've always thought that Horror Mario was the strongest one

I Dont Think GB Is Pure Pure Evil, I mean, he's messed up now, but he was never evil out of the start. He was made by accident by his creator and she experimented with him, which put him through pain. And he begged her to stop. She didn't listen to him, So he had enough. So at least he isn't, you know? Straight up evil for no reason He just Became hateful for humans after what his creator did to him.

I just realized that your explanation of Mr Virtual is not only spot on, it also sounds like the amazing digital circus without the massacre and the murdering. Let me explain. So when someone put on the cursed headset know, of course, as the virtual boy, they are Mr Virtual’s next victim to kill. The amazing digital circus is very much like that except it doesn’t murder anyone. As we know, Pomni said she put on a headset and ended up there. Trapped forever as a victim. I’m seriously beginning to wonder what would happen if The amazing digital circus crew met Mr Virtual, or even the rest of the Mario’s madness v2 Characters.

I would only move Beta Luigi and Devil Mario- like already said, Devil Mario was possessed, so he wasn't in control, therefore basically just wronged- as for Beta Luigi, I wouldn't put him on the list- as you said, he wasn't brave enough to save his bro, but I see the whole song basically as him trying to mourn his lost bro

the costume mario was a mexican serial killer that killed people with a dagger and then transferred himself into the mario game, so he should be higher in the list

Aye you hit 900k congrats

Uhhhhh where is i hate you mario, the nintendo people, L is Real, and fountain luigi?

I liked this little video idea, would like to see more like it on older and newer mods.

If you look at secret history Mario’s wiki, it doesn’t only say his inspiration was the German dictator from ww2 (I can’t say his name bc KZfaq yada yada), The Ww2 dictator in Russia aswell, and the current leader in North Korea, and the reason Mario became a dictator was bc peach had an affair with bowser when Mario was saving her for years

These are the changes that I would make Starting with all of the characters who weren’t included Good: Grandad Chris Pratt Somari Day out Luigi Beta Mario Nintendo mania Mario (he’s listed as a seperate character from Stanley on the funkepedia page) Overdue Mario iHY Mario And l is real Luigi All of these characters are either heroes in their source material or they are generally nice to others Neutral: Classified Luigi John dick And The unbeatable crew These characters don’t have any redeeming qualities but don’t do anything outwardly evil either. Evil: Omega The tentacles Omega should’ve been placed with horror Mario The tentacles should have been placed at the lowest spot in the highest category due to torturing Luigi by forcing him to drown repeatedly, though it is unknown what the intentions of this creature are. As for characters I think should’ve been placed differently Turmoil: in a comic featuring him, he states that he only eats those who choose to wrong him. He is also best friends with GB. So I feel like he should’ve been placed slightly lower. Day out Mario: He has rescued the princess from bowser before, has a pet snake that he might care about, and might have some genuine love for his mother. So he should’ve been placed just a few spots lower. IHY luigi: it’s implied that he did once help Mario prior to the events of I Hate You. He also acts as the bot play for the mod (though this is questionably cannon). So he should have been placed lower. GB: As stated before, him and turmoil are friends. He is also friends with the game boy cameraman. So he should’ve been placed a bit lower. Horror Mario and MX: both of these two have friends, in fact, MX was the one who told horror Mario about GF’s resurrecting abilities and might be the one who told horror Mario about BF in the first place (due to hypno being shown when horror Mario states he’s heard stories about BF). Horror Mario seems to at least tolerate Mr. Sys due to them being former business partners. Horror Mario also seemed to regret his actions due to the end credits song. So these two should’ve been placed slightly lower. Mr. Virtual: similar to horror Mario and Mx, he is capable of forming bonds with others. Plus, the only reason he burned down the circus was due to the abuse he received from there. He also killed an abusive father (who kinda deserved it). So he should’ve been only a spot or lower Secret history Mario: he should’ve been number 1 because he doesn’t have any redeeming qualities (other than possibly caring for his brother and possibly having been brainwashed by the wizards from the secret history of Harry Potter video, though neither of these have been confirmed). He is a malicious psychopath who will do anything he can to get what he wants. He stomps on literal infants, abuses peach and performed unethical surgery on her to the point where she can’t smile anymore, and killed sonic, BF, GF and presumably many others purely because of them having any success.

I would lowkey like to see a remastered documentary about GB.

Hi keep up the great vids

2:59 For the Boos, higher. For Mario, good guy.

Costume is a serial killer using a mario costume, basically

I disagree with you for Horror Mario because while he did somewhat have a reason for killing GF, he didn't have a reason for killing BF, even if BF was in the way he already killed who he was really after and it's not like Daddy Dearest would even care if BF died as long as GF didn't die too. He could've just let BF go with the sorrow of losing GF, but he just decided to kill him anyway.

I hate to say it, but I don't think Horror Mario's motivations are enough to make him anything less than Pure Evil. The main reason I say this is because of something he says during his little spiel: "Do you know what all of the creatures down there have in common? They're all in my game. They all... belong... to ME." He basically converted everything in that little world into his personal stomping grounds. It's pushed even further by the fact that he calls in, fuses with and deploys the voices of nearly everyone else in the mod for the final phase - even some of the more benign ones like Beta Luigi make an appearance there, and I highly doubt they were willing targets. He was also just downright cruel to BF, insisting on royally screwing with him on a psychological level and playing with his food first before killing it. That's a pretty messed-up level of sadistic. A sympathetic backstory can only justify so much in my book before I stop accounting for it. As for his ending song, well. I see it less as him flat-out regretting the kill, and more the realization setting in that there's nothing left and he's out of toys to break in the hell of his own design.

Another bagner vid from the goat!!!!

Amazing list

Costume is debatable. A kind of rundown on him from what I've heard is: His name was originally Mike. He was 30(?) Years old and was obsessed with the Mario franchise. In 1996, commercials showed the Nintendo 64 with of course, MARIO 64. It had not yet made it to stores though, but in Mike's city there was going to me an organized event where you could win a free system+mario 64. Mike of course signed up, but during his wait he was treated like some alien for being a grown man, saying stuff like "aren't you too old for this?" Finally the event begins, and after a while five finalists remained, including Mike and the hosts daughter. Turns out she was cheating the whole time with the hosts help so that she could win. Mike NOTICES this, and when the girl wins he absolutely loses it, openly trying to expose what they did only to be shunned even further with people laughing and the host "jokingly" accusing him of "eating too many mushrooms lately" while saying that he can just get another system when they hit the stores. Though, the host lures him out with the offer of another system, so Mike waits for him to arrive at the meeting time. Finally he shows up, but further rubs salt in the wound by saying how he was surprised that he really though he would give him a game. On top of other things. Mike gets mad again, and this unfortunately leads him to being nearly killed by guards who were on standby. For a while no one heard from Mike, until a costume contest was organized and he shoes up dressed as a demented mario (to say the least). Mike shows up to said event, and on live television threatens the host and his families lives. These are details that I cannot begin to describe here on KZfaq comments, but long story short he brutally goes through with these threats. Mike was never seen again after this, presumably having self deleted Really hope i didnt type all this out to be wrong 💀

Bro your list is so good bro the game of tag is Mimi got chills right now you’re scaring me now stop

By the way there are many times Lucas and MX became friends until Lucas accidently fell into a hole.. and then the cycle happened over and over

Well GB was tortured by his creator while she experimented stuff on him for Mario Land 2, so he basically went insane because of that, kind of like Horror Mario, so I think he should be in Wicked and not Pure Evil.

If the Unbeatable gang was on here they would either be in “Less Evil” or “Wrong!!” category. The Unbeatable Gang isn’t exactly evil they are just trying to say you can’t beat them, although the original commercial is kinda unsettling,it really doesn’t look evil since it’s just a man in a suit. But I think he would be in the “Wrong!!” category because he has villains in his gang. Let me know if you think they should be in a different category cause this was actually kinda hard.

Is bro going to ignore the fact the horror Mario's intent to actually kill them at the end of the mod is that they broke the deal he made with them, Not just to make daddy dearest suffer. Also he is the god of the game in this mod and uses all the opponents as servants.

Since you did the characters that got into the mod will you do one on the scrapped characters?

M/Horror Mario/Ultra M has every opponent in the mod as slaves, and when he becomes ultra M he fuses with everyone meaning he has all their bad deeds, so I think he goes in the top spot.

If you ever decide to remake this video, include a “Victims” category, as many of the Luigis are victims (Including Beta).

Actually, the thing with MX is that according to his lore, he EXCLUSIVELY kills children. He is completely fine and civil if the person he’s with isn’t a child (except for GF, but he canonically was just kinda told to kill her and BF so)

Me personally, I think Horror M isn't actually that evil because even tho he wanted to kill BF & GF, but a quick reminder that he was left to rot by Daddy Dearest in a(mostly) empty world for 30 years, meaning that he would most likely lose his sanity & in the credits after all stars, he seems to regret his actions

Thanks for all the facts about these guys I agree with the list too Also, Mr. Virtual reminds of William Afton. Starting out as a serial killer, to glitchtrap, I know it's not really the same thing, especially since we don't know if glitchtrap is Afton or not but who knows Edit: New Sub :)

The scary thing about MX is it doesn't not matter if you get away you will be trapped forever with no way out and no matter what you have to keep pushing your limits all to stay there again there's nothing to stop your suffering at that point💀

Also I'd personally swap MX and GB's spots but other than that I agree with pretty much everything here.

You forgot to mention that Super Bad Mario also poisons people with the poison mushroom, that's gonna be on the BAD!!! list in my opinion.

I would like one for the scrapped characters, but also maybe you could make a tier list for the scrapped characters and the ones in the mod from good to evil (Just the characters that are not boyfriend, girlfriend and pico.) Also you could make the tier list for the scrapped characters good to evil.

Counter arguements: - DJ Hallyboo just did his job, and also, the worse the punishment is, the lower the chance of someone doing a bad thing, and he just doubled down on that. And also, BF did not pirate any game, well its not confirmed, but he didnt pirate on-camera. So DJ Hallyboo could have been with Turmoil, above or below. - MX is told to actually be a chill guy if he is not hunting down a certain guy, also couldve just mistaken Lucas as BF and he killed GF because he could've thought she was helping BF.

I believe Costume was based off of a story from Mexico (I believe) where a guy in a Mario costume killed a father and daughter because they won a competition for an NES and he didn't (hence the background of The End), so he is definitely more evil. Also, Mr L is an omnipotent being who killed the entire Mushroom Kingdom and kills Mario at the end of the story so he is definitely pure evil at least. Finally, Horror Peach and Yoshi.exe are NOT allies of Horror Mario, since Yoshi.exe tries to kill Horror Mario and then he kills both Yoshi.exe and Horror Peach. (P.S. MX also kills GF in cold blood so yeah)

all agreed, but the fact that my favorite song of the mod has the most evil character is things im would be excited about.

I love how you called day's out Mario a piece of crap.

So what's FG's opinion on Arcade GP? (An official crossover between Mario Kart and NAMCO)

putting Wario Apparition in Bad is kinda odd considering he just wants everybody he meets dead

Hey make sure you credit crestamorph for the king boo footage

The most evil character is the sinner and criminal who made the stylus mechanic in "no party" they need to beg for forgiveness. As it is the worst mechanic I have ever seen in an fnf game that wasn't a joke. I would take the missingno hell mode warp notes, hypno pendulum, and the unknown type notes combined before ever playing that song again.

I think Devil Mario should go in like the first tier that you just told us about because he was forced to do it

some extra context: while i dont know the full story or much of the details, i do know that in the original ARG series by Joey Perleoni, DJ Hallyboo does actually kill Joey by trapping him in a DS that he then destroys. also, the Costume seen in MMv2 is likely based on an obscure Spanish creepypasta called Super Mario Asesino in which a man goes onto a gameshow to win a Nintendo 64, but is insulted and tricked by the gameshow host and is tied to a tree and beaten and so he murders the host's family with a knife while wearing a Mario costume

He should’ve watched the ending of the Mario party anti-privacy. DJ straight up killed the thief.

Awesome

Horror Mario ends up feeling remorse in the credits

Is there going to be a part 2? With grand dad, Somari, Chris’s Pratt, abandoned luigi, oh god no Luigi, thalassophobia Luigi, and ink bowser?

Those Mario’s and lugies are very spooky Bois AHHHHHHH!

Hey, will you ever explain the entire fatal and Sl4sh storyline? A good start would be the song "tetrabrachial" Please? 🙏

Devil Mario should be on a lower category because he is being controlled and has no control over what he is doing so I think he should be lower. Also I'm a huge fan of your channel dude 🤩🤩

I gotta ask, how many people did the dearest family (Gf included) majorly get mad enough for them to have beef with. They made Senpai hate them. Tabi, Agoti, NIkusa, Solazar, Annie (they technically killed Garcello), possibly some of the sonic.exes (lord X included) and even IRIS (Hex hacked). And that’s not including powerful beings like Shaggy, Matt, or Ronald Macdonald, they possibly hate the dearest family but don’t bother fighting them as it’s a hassle, and how strong is Dd, enough for him to transport beings into video games?

To add on to your choice of having horror Mario at the wicked part of the tier list is because if you listen to the song "A mad world without you" witch is the song that plays after the end of the last song of the mod, All Stars, (when you get to the credits part). The lyrics pretty much means that horror Mario has some remorse after he killed BF. (I looked up online on what some of the lyrics in the song represent and overall, at least what I got from it is that killing BF was somewhat a bad choice for horror Mario. You guys can correct me if I'm wrong but that's my input to agree with your choice for horror Mario)

Can you do with sonic.exe and hypno lullaby characters?

3:15 it’s also worth noting that Hallyboo is willing to, and even canonically HAS killed over pirated games

There is actually stuff about Costume. He is a high schooler named Mike who got bullied but then he found a life size Mario costume so he put it on and went to his bullies younger siblings birthdays as a mascot and then murdered the kids

Im assuming Grand Dad and Somari are on the same line as Beta/Depression Luigi.

I mean Horror Mario should be in not exactly wrong but not good either, In the credits he sings about how he feels bad about what he did and realising that even though he took revenge, he still doesnt feel fulfilled wich shows he was just consumed by a hunger for vengeance.

There’s one more thing about mx, I could be completely wrong tbh and read up in a wrong place but like, I’m pretty sure even when mx wins his games he can just choose to bring the person he’s torturing back to life for as long as he wants just to chase them all over again, only eating their soul once he gets bored of them and then does the same to his next victim, just like extra pure evil info for him

You forgot about Chris Pratt, Grand Dad, Somari, I hate you Mario, Beta Mario, Overdue Mario, and Mr Nintendo, plus Duck Hunt Dog and Unbeatable Bowser. And to credit Crestamorph for their King Boo Animation

Costume Mario is based off of a different creepypasta named "Mario Bros Aseneio" it's where a man named Mike Roberson gets mad after losing a competition for a Nintendo 64 because the host cheated by putting his daughter in the competition and giving her all the answers, later then he dresses up in a Mario costume to kill the entire host's family, his guards and everyone close to him using a large dagger, even going as far as to psychologically torment the host by killing off his wife and daughter and decapitating them while the host was awake and writing "It's a Me" with the blood of his loved ones on the walls of the host's house, then after that he finally ends the host himself. When the police found Mike's house before he could cause more trouble, Mike was nowhere to be found and the only thing they saw was a running Nintendo 64 playing Super Mario World. Therefore his placement is not really accurate.

The slendytubbies funkin in the Massacre night mod just dropped and i want you to explain the lore of it, and how boyfriend got into this situation and how did he become a slendytubbie?

I like Termoil Mario He just looks adorable.

In the actual power star series mario didn’t break free it’s just the boo’s who become greedy after they kill peach and Luigi to let him see that but they didn’t think he will stab himself

I'm Suprised GB Is On The Pure Evil, But Now That I Know The Lore Behind This Character I Kinda Agree With This

Pls can u explain rewrite sonic, I've been watching your videos for a while now and I stumbled across rewrite sonic if u can that would be great

Can you do scrapped ones

Hey I love your videos😀😃😄😁😆🙂😺😸🌞❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

I don’t know if its cannon but i heard that mr L is a evil spirit that doesn’t even know what hes really doing he just knew that a red man killed him and some core memories like bowser evil and princess peach.And probably canon luigi wouldn’t do something like that at all

Now cover Quohogs Last Stand or I will get angy

I think devil mario and GB mario and mr L are god tier

I thing Devil Mario is on the level of Turmoil as all his murders weren't carried out by him but instead by the boos that possessed him and in the end he did the right thing and saved the Mushroom Kingdom.

Costume Mario looks like the disturbed Mario meme

How is GB more evil than MX or even horror mario/ultra M?

One more thing the back story for Mario rhythm symphony 8 I think he has a back story and it goes like this

0:40 Yes they were.

Here before one hour gang 👇

Could you go over the Carmen winstead mod in FNF If you get the chance to

Can you do Mario madness characters weak to powerful

What about the guy who said... AIM YOUR ZAPPER GUN!

How are super horror mario, peach and Yoshi Ally's whenever they try to kill each other. can someone explain that?

I don’t know if they Intended this but SM64 On Ds has a room where you can change Characters, the Characters Are Luigi, Wario, and Yoshi, And a Mario door if you want to change back. Does that mean during Phase 2 of All Stars, When (Forgot the name) I will just call him Phase 2 Mario leaves. Guess who Appears… Luigi Wario and Yoshi…

The truly good tier: chris pratt, somari and grand dad

The first ever video was the Mario madness

He forgot John and I think he should go in the lest evil cause he’s just a dry bones that plays a trombone or trumpet

HEY! where is SOMARI THE ADVENTURER or GRAND DAD or any of the legends in world 1?

Costume actually has its own creepypasta it’s basically someone in a Mario costume that goes on a murdering spree so he should go up a bit