her voice sound exactly the same in the studio version, true talent ♥

At 0:12-0:19, the little Korean caption translates to “I wanted to write these lyrics for anyone who's experienced the classic farewell situation. While I wrote this, I felt like I was in a movie scene; fully watching and explaining the scene, and putting in lines. - IU”

I can feel her sadness.😢

1. How the heck does her voice here sound exactly like the studio version (a true talent OMG) 2. The lyrics on the point WHAT THE HELL 3. Her live versions just make me love these songs more... AND MORE

I left someone who i loved the most, i left because i was starving for the "self-love" thing, i left because i know i had killed my self along the way of loving him, i left although i know it was not the easiest thing to do, i left even though i knew both ways of staying or leaving was painful, i left because i loved him so much but I HAD NEVER RECEIVED THE LOVE THAT I GAVE TO HIM and that should not be begged from anyone . Love will be offered to you by the right person at the right time Ps. I cried at Iu's song , I still hate Trump

this song makes me so emotional ;(

보통 라이브보다 레코딩을 많이 듣는 이유가 최상의 음질에 표현력을 담았기 때문인데 아이유는 레코딩을 넘어선다......

Best ballad of the year so far imo 👍👌😉💯🔥❤️

아직도 찾아와서 듣는 사람 더 있나요 ?

Call me whatever you want, but I truly want IU and Taeyeon to sing this together like they are interpreting with their voices the storyline. It would be so beautiful;;

Her voice makes me cry, i don't know why

When this song came out, it became my favorite song of IU. This album was amazing and so mature. She's always creating great music and has an outstanding voice.

i dont know if iu like eating cd 😉

Sam did a great job too. such a great singer song writer

전남친이랑 헤어지고 너무 많이 들어서 그 때 생각나서 잘 안듣는데 오랜만에 들어도 최고네요. 예전처럼 잠도 잘 자고 밥도 잘 먹는데 그 때 행복했던 너랑 내가 그립다!

came back here after a year, and still.. every single time i ask myself "She's crying her heart out thru her beautiful voice to this song, just wHO HURT HER LIKE THIS?!??!???" and i cry myself in a corner :')

i'm in love with this women... everything she is doing is awesome, wonderful... I'm born to love music, i'm born to love her music ♥_♥

How can one sing THIS beautifully

Her voice have that particular feels of longing and pain.

I like that there isn't even one negative comment. . well it's a masterpiece ❤❤❤❤❤❤ IU ❤

IU voice just make my heart break into pieces. how she being delivered her song in so deep emotional. its really amazed

the saddest song on my track 😣

annyeong oraenmaniya mureumpyo eopsi cham neodaun moksori jeonghaejin gyuchikcheoreom chuun mungae neul ttokgateun ne jari jedaero jal meogeo da jinaganikka yejeoncheoreom jamdo jal jage doel geoya jinsimeuro bilge neoneun deo haengbokhal jagyeogi isseo geureon mareun haji ma jebal geu mari deo apeun geo aljanha saranghaejul georamyeo da mwoya eotteon mameul jun geonji neoneun moreul geoya oerowodeon mankeum neoreul neoboda saranghaejul saram kkok mannasseumyeon hae naega aniraseo mianhae juneun ge swipjiga anha geureon mareun haji ma jebal geu mari deo apeun geo aljanha saranghaejul georamyeo da mwoya eotteon mameul jun geonji kkeutnae moreul. soljikhi malhaejullae jebal neoramyeon da mitneun geo aljanha ne maldaero eonjenga nado na gateun nugungaege sarangbatge doelkka?

One year ago I was truly heart broken for the first time. I listened to this song and felt destroyed. The last verses really made me think. One year later I can say I healed and I know now, just like IU sings, that he wasn't the person for me, and that definitely you have to receive love from someone who loves the way you do. Thanks IU.

Must have been difficult for IU to write this song and get inspiration from her own experience but that's what makes this song more fragile and precious. Whenever I listen to this song, I can't help but feel melancholic yet comforted at the same time.

I’m thankful Jungkook introduced me to this song. This is heaven.

I’m so in love with IU there’s is really nothing to hate on her no matter how much you look. This girl has the face and the voice of an angel oh my god my queen!!!! 😭♥️

안녕 오랜만이야 물음표 없이 참 너다운 목소리 정해진 규칙처럼 추운 문가에 늘 똑같은 네 자리 제대로 잘 먹어 다 지나가니까 예전처럼 잠도 잘 자게 될 거야 진심으로 빌게 너는 더 행복할 자격이 있어 그런 말은 하지 마 제발 그 말이 더 아픈 거 알잖아 사랑해줄 거라며 다 뭐야 어떤 맘을 준 건지 너는 모를 거야 Wow oh oh oh ooh 외로웠던 만큼 너를 너보다 사랑해줄 사람 꼭 만났으면 해 내가 아니라서 미안해 주는 게 쉽지가 않아 그런 말은 하지 마 제발 그 말이 더 아픈 거 알잖아 사랑해줄 거라며 다 뭐야 어떤 맘을 준 건지 끝내 모를 솔직히 말해줄래 제발 너라면 다 믿는 거 알잖아 네 말대로 언젠가 나도 나 같은 누군가에게 사랑받게 될까?

나 ㄹㅇ 이 노래만 들으면 눈물 엄청남...ㅠㅠ 진짜 들을때마다ㅠㅠ

This is what you called 'talent'. She is amazing both singing and acting 👏

누구나 경험할 수 있는 이별의 이야기라..... 그래 누구나 경험할 수는 있지 근데 난 별로 겪고 싶지 않았어 보고싶다

its been 4 months since I'm listenig to IU's album and this song makes me emotional and I cried a lot by listening to this song.

i love this song,,and i see the songwriter (sam kim 샘김) release the english version in MBC music

eargasm . amazing voice 😍😍😍😍😍

How does this manage to make me cry even tho i have literally listened to it like a thousand times 😑😑😑😑😭😭

I left someone that I really love recently. I have loved him for 4 years and I have never loved someone as much as I loved him. We broke up a few years back and went on and off for 2 years until I decided I can't do it anymore, the love was not reciprocated and it was not the same anymore. I swear it was not easy to walk away. I kept on coming back. It was not easy to let go when you loved someone wholeheartedly. I had a lot of things in my mind and I tried to hold on like I always do but I kept thinking about the repeated pain that I felt. This song really touched my heart in so many ways and last night I realized that he still cares so much about me but I choose to just let it be

It's impossible for me not to fall in love with her~

Classic break-up farewell: 'It's not you, it's me!' 'You deserve someone better!'

wow.... 0:11 you see the emotion through her eyes immediately as soon as you see her

Her voice sounds like your walking by a bunch of flowers and you get a phone call from an old friend greeting you, later that day you and that friend meet up at a coffee shop and talk. A month later that friend dies from a car accident and that friend is saying sorry to you in your head. Later that day you go to their grave and place a rose from the bunch of flowers you were walking by a few months ago.

My sister doesn't like kpop but she's fan of her works. She specially loves Bbibbi and Through The Night. Caught her one time listening to it and now she's talking non-stop how her albums is so beautiful.

Ending Scene hurts so much. Even the way she sings is so painful

Painful. Sad. Heartache. Emotional. My heart aches listening to this song, and my heart broke into pieces when I read and understood the lyrics.

This is one of the saddest, most beautiful songs I've ever heard. 🥰

Dear IU ... teach me how to eat cd 😭

I will never get sick of this song, it's too beautiful

Just went through a breakup, this song means so much to my heart.

아이유 리듬감있는노래도 너무 좋지만 애절한 발라드 한곡씩 매번 내줬으면..

so talented!!!

노랫말,목소리가 이렇게 아름답게 공감될수 있다는데 진짜 신기하고 멋지네요.아이유 정말 내가수 인증!!

drops my tears

Best songwriter in all ballads that I’ve heard ... 2019 still being my favorite female K-Pop singer

The way she said "jebal" made me cry it's right on the feels 😭

still amazing to listen after 5 years

this song make me emotional

A retro chic double breasted sport coat on IU is excellent. This look really suits her...very sophisticated but almost nonchalant look. Oh, love her singing.

I really liked her 2-3 years ago but i lost my interest in her through time. When jungkook covered this song i wanted to hear it from her first and GOD thank you that i did because it reminded me how much i loved her back then. Also it is a really good song. THANKS AGAIN.

You're voice is so beautiful I love it IU😍👏🏼 I've always found it beautiful. It's so calming too

i din't know why but everytime i hear this especially the key change in the last part,my eyes starts to flood.

No wonder jungkookie loves her so much, NOW I DO, THIS SOUNDS LIKE THE STUDIO VERSION . THIS IS WHAT U CALL DAMM TALLENT. SORRY FOR ME CURSIVE WORDS BUT THIS IS SHIBAL GOOD

My heart has just been broken into a thousand pieces listening to this beautiful song.

this song is effortlessly beautiful yet so heartbreaking

Something better than iu studio ver ?? Yes b!ch iu live ver

Yes, she's the artist that do better during live performances

I cry every time I listen to this song :(

I really hope IU find that person who will love her genuinely. Someone who can understand her, listen to her, and stay by her side no matter what comes in the way. I hope that people who really love IU can have the courage to pursue her despite the obstacles (eg. her image and reputation/career/achievements etc..which might intimidate or pressure the other person in a relationship including the backlash/reaction that the public may give (considering her massive popularity and the media's and general public's interest in almost all her actions) since this same issue happened back when IU's relationship was revealed..)

I always think of this but...If I can remember correctly, I think IU broke with her bf on 2016-2017 and I wonder if this song was inspired by their love story since she wrote the lyrics her self (and IU once shared that she is the type of person who is more in love (or who loves more deeply than the other party) when in a relationship which exactly describes the girl in the song wherein the boy tells her that she deserves to find a better person who will give her love more than the love she gives, and sadly, that person is not him)

That's beautiful IU, beautiful. You've grown a lot as a singer and person

This song will never getting old

0:23 안녕 오랜만이야 0:27 물음표 없이 참 너다운 목소리 0:39 정해진 규칙처럼 0:43 추운 문가에 늘 똑같은 네 자리 0:55 제대로 잘 먹어 다 지나가니까 1:04 예전처럼 잠도 잘 자게 될 거야 1:12 진심으로 빌게 1:15 너는 더 행복할 자격이 있어 1:27 그런 말은 하지 마 제발 1:35 그 말이 더 아픈 거 알잖아 1:43 사랑해줄 거라며 다 뭐야 1:52 어떤 맘을 준 건지 너는 모를 거야 - 2:19 외로웠던 만큼 2:23 너를 너보다 사랑해줄 사람 2:31 꼭 만났으면 해 2:36 내가 아니라서 미안해 2:44 주는 게 쉽지가 않아 2:50 그런 말은 하지 마 제발 2:59 그 말이 더 아픈 거 알잖아 3:07 사랑해줄 거라며 다 뭐야 3:15 어떤 맘을 준 건지 끝내 모를 3:24 솔직히 말해줄래 제발 3:32 너라면 다 믿는 거 알잖아 3:40 네 말대로 언젠가 나도 3:49 나 같은 누군가에게 3:54 사랑 받게 될까

She is a soulful singer .. i love her.

정말 아름다운 목소리 ❤️😍

미쳤다…감동적이에여

I love how intimate these are, you can really hear every nuance in her voice.

너무 단아하고 이쁘다 ..

Her pitch control is so great,

오랜만에 듣는데 요즘 이래저래 힘든 일이 많아사 그런지 위로해주는 밤이네요

I still cry everytime I listen to IU's Ending Scene. It's just so beautiful, hope to see her perform live one day :)

진짜.. 촉촉하다..

i'm in love

i literally have no words omg HER SINGING❤

this song makes me feel nostalgic ahh i love it

Right in the feels,and as usual,very clean live👏

One of my favorite vocalists by far! 💕

this song never fails to make me cry

Cant stop listening to her album.. as in everyday... i❤u...

So beautiful and sad.... i love it

By far my favourite song from IU

Her angelic voice blessed my ears.

I love this song and her vocals are flawless!

이 노래 가사가 너무 슬프고 좋아요.

This song is soo beautiful and emotional, I can feel her emotions in her singing

숨은 보물같은 노래인것 같아요~♡♡

Thank you for existing

IU never fail to give me chills everytime she sing..😭😭

SHE BELT IT. EVEN BETTER THAN THE STUDIO I LOVED.

I will never get tired of this song! I can listen, on repeat, forever.

Her voice is so cold it gives you goosebumps

You can hear the hurt and pain in her voice. What a stunning performance.

this songs makes me calm idk why. there was the time that i cant sleep bc of my asthma but then i just listen to her voice and i slept well😭❤️