Love your reactions mate. When you and Black P were watching Violets tale, the sheer joy / awe / amazement you showed was so heartwarming 👊

I’m very glad I found your channel. I like when reactors have a good foundation to give their prospective. Yours is very good. I love that your attention goes to Sam. It is well deserved and it’s usually all about Ren.

Ren pulled this together at his friend’s apartment. The extras were friends willing to spend hours as they tried to get a good one-take shot. This one had so many moving parts and complications! But the flow is incredible. I also love the final backlit shot from the headlights! I also love the thought Ren put behind the video concept. Definitely influenced by Orwell’s Animal Farm (with the writing on the walls in the first scene). But also influenced by Kubrick, Clockwork Orange, The Shining, Eyes Wide Shut, etc. And top it off with a little Willy Wonka 😼 It adds another layer to the song interpretation! You should also watch the live acoustic version … very different feel. I’m really enjoying your reactions! It’s a fun rabbit hole to explore 🕳️🐇 Lots of gems 💎

Great reaction to a great song bro. Ren said he bought like 200 animal masks from Amazon. Got a bunch of friends and friends of friends and shot this masterpiece. The attention to detail and the fact that they were able to even get one clean shot all the way thru is amazing. Plus thinking about Ren and some of the others that had to probably run from one spot while the camera wasn't on him briefly to get set up for the next shot. Id love to see the BTS for this one. After the ladies drag him off we see the kitties and the camera spins goes back out the same door and the sheep is waiting🤌🤌🤌perfection

Dude, 8.6. is Ren's new song drop time...

Oh yay! Thanks for doing this one Joe E, I love your perspective as someone who specializes in this type of creation! Definitely more Ren my friend! Have a great day!

I knew this reaction would be awesome, and you didn't disappoint. That beat is so compelling. My ears just love it. 🎉 ...I subbed after your first reaction with BP, but so glad to see you doing your own reactions as well as your personal artistic pursuits. ❤

so glad BP brought you in -i really get literal joy from watching you react to these videos. there's this great balance of hearing your perspective as a professional, and also just getting to watch you repeatedly put your hand over your heart because that expresses your feeling better than words. you are a great addition to the reaction world and the ren corner of it. and you seem like a pure, creative soul. looking forward to more from you. :)

Ren is just something special, isn’t he? Love seeing your excitement as you’re journeying down the Ren rabbit hole. The videos for The Hunger and Genesis are one takes too. And other ones. Even when not one takes his videos are still something special. He pours creativity and passion into everything he does.

Love your reaction..you made me smile all the way through...How you get giddy 😅.. Absolutely LOVED your reaction to 'Jenny & Screech' with BP..So you have a new sub now! BTW Ren's 'Suicide' just knocked me sideways! Totally different.. again.😢

Looking forward to this one - what a treat - your reaction to AF and then an hour later Ren drops his latest track! Id better get the beers & 🍿 in lol

Oh heck yeah. I am SO here for THIS one. Oh boy oh boy oh boy

Yes, please keep reacting to REN because your perspective is so valuable! We know his 1-takes are special but you can really speak to how challenging they are to produce and your appreciation is catching.

Awesome reaction bro , such passion for your craft ! Ren has unreal talent, and you give it the justice he deserves.

I'd love to know the layout of that building, just to get an idea of how these participants moved about off camera to adjust their positions. The white dog on the stairs for example was in the first room. The black lagoon creature in the bath was one of the ones grabbing Ren later I think. So well done. There is so much going on behind the scenes that a lot of people probably don't even consider when watching this!

Fantastic reaction! Knew you would enjoy this one!

AbsoF'nlutely keep on the Ren train. Great reaction, I expected you to delve much deeper into the insane amount of nuance in the shooting of this video. A much more analytical breakdown of not only the visual concept/content but also the techniques used to produce them would be awesome coming from someone steeped in the knowledge and craft. Ren also said that there are loads of Easter eggs, not so much hidden but rather subtly slipped in and to watch you find the ones we fans already have and likely more that we have missed would also help to knit us, your viewers and subscribers and you into the community you are developing. Great video my brother and new Ren lover. Big ups from Humboldt County.

Please continue with the Ren reactions Joe E 👍. If you want something a little different, then I think you would love the unconventional filming of Losing it (Fisher retake). It looks like they may have filmed it on something like an Insta360 with a fish eye lens. Also there is a live street performance version of the Jenny and screech trilogy with a huge organised audience. Again, this one is filmed in proper 360, but if you watch it on a 360 enabled device like a phone or iPad, you can spin your device round and view anywhere such as the crowd or Ren. It’s really cool.

Love your reactions man. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 your passion for it comes through in spades!!

You may want to do a live one.

Your words at the end, I love so much. It’s inspiring. I have lost count of the number of people that have reacted to REN that have said those very words. It is so beautiful how his art inspires so many people. You can see the excitement in their faces. I love to watch your reactions as it is a different perspective for me. 😊

Really enjoyed your reaction and thoughts on the video! Ren posted a description of making this video under his KZfaq Community tab that you'd probably be interested in reading. It's about a month back, and has a thumbnail of one of the dogs playing cards. Looking forward to your future reactions! I think Ren inspires all of us in a variety of ways. I'm a nurse and a novelist, and he makes me think in new ways about the experiences of my patients, and about the craft of writing.

Loving your reactions to Ren....would of been great for you too do the live acoustic version straight after this one❤

I knew you would like this one. The Actors are all friends and friends of friends. They were amazing they all worked through the night-188 takes until they got the one they wanted. Amazing! Great reaction. I agree you bring so much joy to your reactions.❤

Loved seeing your technical perspective on this from the lighting, pacing and camera work! Gives a whole new appreciation for the video 🙌🙏 The amount of detail Ren put into this down to the classic “Dogs playing poker” matching the painting of Dogs playing poker is just incredible and I love that so much!

Yes, more Ren please! Love your insights into the videos. It’s great to hear that perspective!

Loving your Ren journey! The Cats ultra talented!!! Multi instrumentalist and genre defying dude who still surprises me!! Wow

Love this! I love this community! It's so fun learning about all of the different aspects of the artists involved in Ren's music. It's even more fun sharing it with cool nice people. Thanks for the live chat!

Great to hear from someone who understands how difficult these amazing pieces of art are to create. Good job Joey!

Well living here in Japan and seeing the notify me saying 3am. I will have to wait till I wake up to watch it. 😂😂👊

Yesss! Can't wait!!😎

I love your reaction! I loved it when I first saw Animal Flow, but definitely needed a brush-up cheat sheet on Orwell's Animal Farm before a re-watch. My favorite moment is when the Shepherd (person in a German Shepherd dog mask) is leading the lamb down the stairs (maybe to slaughter?) as Ren's spitting about Mary-had-a-little-lamb getting its throat cut. The timing is so en pointe. Love Ren & his team. Great work!

Love your heartfelt reaction on the Black pegasus - Ren reaction

What a great reactor you are! You notice so much. I'm also glad that BP got you on to Ren and his genius. You should really check out the live acoustic version of this. Rens breath control alone is outstanding, let alone his guitar skills. Please give us your reaction to that. Sam's talent also fab! Thankyou. Love from the U.K ❤

Loved your reactions to Ren with P and subbed to you. The genuine love and respect I saw in you for Ren shone outta the screen

Great reaction lol, thank you 👍🙏🐊🦉

Great reaction. Ren doesn't miss so this is going to be a fun ride.

I absolutely love your reactions. So much pure joy and thoughtful consideration of what you’re experiencing. Please more Ren reactions! I can’t wait to watch them 😁💖

Yeah the level of creativity Ren has is out of this world. I am rooting for him so much, he deserves all the fame and 👏👏 out there. ❤️❤️❤️ Thank you so much for reacting to his art.

I love it how Ren just shows up somewhere else magically like he the heck did he get over there in a one take?

Followed you from BP 😊 Glad I did! I dare you NOT to go down that rabbit hole. I was a 72-year old rap despiser before discovering Ren. He is a genius. How lucky we are to be alive for this ❤

Hey Joe E, thanks for great reaction to #ANIMALFLOW. Love seeing it through your eyes. Looking forward to the next one. #REN

Heck yeah, more Ren. This is a generational artist/talent moment

Loved ur reaction to this 🙏🔥🔥🔥it’s great hearing from someone who knows how it’s all done from the other side of the camera we dnt get to see.Keep em coming plz 🥰 I think you’ll appreciate Losing It and Chalk Outlines, they couldn’t be more different from each other but they’re equally amazing imo xxx

Loving your reaction from over the pond. Please keep going down the Ren and The Big push’s Rabbit hole. There’s no going back now😂

I super enjoy you Joe yes please keep going on REN ✨🎶it’s magic 💫 have a super good day until next time 😉✌🏽

You are in for a very special treat Sir. Ren is remarkable...

Hell yea brother Sparks! Keep going down the Ren rabbit hole. Love your perspective from a man behind the camera. Sam deserves a lot of love too

I love watching specialists in different fields react to REN’s songs/ videos. I just know that the songs and videos are the greatest that I have ever experienced but I don’t know exactly why until people like you explain the complexity of it all. I have seen so many professionals talking about how Ren inspires and energies them. I think that is one of the best things to come out of these reactions. It’s exciting watching this all morph and grow in so many ways & in so many directions

I LOVE your pacing and insight. You’re the first to see comment on the head in the cage in the kitchen. It’s actually the Ren head from a picture cover of a recent released song

great reaction JoeE. there's so many details woven into this video/song/production it's hard to catch everything on a single view. great reaction, love your passion

First thing that I must say is Thank you for your thorough reaction to Ren's talent and genius. I love to watch your facial expressions while watching the different scenes. I am passionate whenever it comes to explaining just how phenomenal Ren and Sam are when it comes to filming the videos. Like me, you can't help but move your body to the music. You are completely connected with the music, the little details that many people miss. You are a blessing to me. I feel like I understand the passion you bring to your videos. You have a fan for life, my friend. Love your work. You are an inspiration to me. I hope you realize the genius you possess when it comes to your video reactions.

Ren-Right Here, Right Now Retake--1 take that doesn't disappoint 👍

Yay, I am really glad you covered this video. Your reaction was exactly what I needed. 💜

I love getting a videographer's viewpoint of Ren and Sam's brilliant artistry! Props to you, Joe! Thanks for your insight! You caught so much of what they did...and more importantly WHY they did it! All the way to the headlamps black-lighting to end it. Bravo 👏 👏 👏

Another thing about Ren he is therapy for so many with his Hi Ren song and as you said he inspires you so in theory or practice he is also a teacher. All the best with your Ren journey and your channel

Yup...Ren is mesmerizing at what his doing ! Great reaction ! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Watching this waiting for Ren to drop his new music. 🌹🔥❤️

Loved your reaction to Animal Flow! I love it more & more each time I view it. Interesting that Ren made a LIVE acoustical guitar of Animal Flow. Yeah, you read that right LOL! I couldn't figure out how he could do that with this ;piece of work....until I saw it. Of course..its Ren. Look it up, you will be so glad you did.

Love to see people inspired. Let's see what you can do with it.

Your reactions are on point. Great job Black Pegasus be proud. 🎉👍👋✌️💯

Ren and Sam are perfectionists. They really want their pieces of Art to be remembered in decades to come. If it takes them 100 times they are happy to do whatever is required...all in the name of ART!! I wish them well, and hope they get their Netflix special out. They deserve to reap the rewards of all their hard work and commitment....for bringing some fresh new performances to a really predictable and boring market.

This video was so well done and I heard Ren said it was just a bunch of his friends that helped him do it, no hired actors. It took them about 9 hours to set up and shoot the whole video. He and his friends doing the camera work are just so talented.

Yeah baby, this is going to be a great reaction video!!! Here we go 😃

Here for your reactions bro! Not just Ren but all your other reactions! Keep the grind

Glad to be here for this. Great reaction Joe. Keep going with the videos - they are as different as the music!

On the road to 2k subscribers twelve days ago and with Ren reactions it is at almost 6.5k now. I love how the Ren community helps support smaller channels that produce good videos.

Great reaction! 🤌 Chef’s Kiss

Great reaction mate :) Its nice to hear from someone who can appreciate the video side of the song too! All the extras are his mates and mate of mates - they ended up filming for like 8hr or something- i remember him thanking them all for hanging in till late when they got the completed 1 take.

That was one brilliant reaction, Sir. Thank you loads 👏

Still love that where the camera transitions between rooms they go for the constantly changing angle to highlight they arent using the door frames and wall edges as cut points

Loved your reaction! Very insightful and enthusiastic. The backstory is as much fun as the video. This is set in a friend’s apartment in Brighton. It was filmed over 9 hours one night from 7:00pm to 4:00am using a large number of friends helping and/or wearing masks for the shoot-not paid to my knowledge. Sounds like a fun project to help Ren with.

Awesome breakdown - love seeing new perspectives and seeing new things from the reactors catches!!!

I’m here to stay; your surprised and blown-away cognition because of Ren…..we all had the same feelings from the first song we saw him performing,any of his creations are absolutely out of this planet ❤

Definitely keep falling down that Ren rabbit hole. I love watching each individual’s takes on everything. With you coming from a videographer’s perspective you have a real unique insight to what’s going on.

Oh yeah, like others said, there's an acoustic live one-take of Animal Flow - you will be pleasantly surprised! Thanks for this video man, great stuff!

Yes Joe 👏🏻 love seeing you react to Ren on BP’s channel. Awesome to see you doing more here and getting your perspective on the videos and camera game

OMG I have watched this loads of times and never noticed the head I thought it was somebody watching the butcher!!

He is amazing I listen to only Ren thank you great reaction ❤

The way you jumped when dude popped out in the hallway 🤣🤯🤣🤣

Right here, right now is a fun easy one take.

This video was shot in one night. All those people were either friend or friends of friends. Low budget no paid actors. It's great

I would love to see your reaction to Chalk Outlines. It's so beautiful. Make sure to find the live version!

Great reaction!!! Go Big Red!!!!

Ren is insanely talented and knows how to capture people and make them feel involved and keep things on point and interesting! Just all around amazing!!! Love the reaction - you pointed out a lot of great things and love when people catch the smallest of details! He is truly inspiring! Much love xx

Finally got round to come back for commenting after I was understandably sidetracked with Ren's latest release just dropped straight after... I like how you said you're hoping to get to 2k subs and you're already over 3k just 12 hours later😃 Congrats! Animal Flow is a visual feast and there's a Lot to take in, especially when hearing the music for the first time too (if you listen with headphones you hear even more as there's detail & layers in the beats he produces too). Yep, you got the Metronome movement of the cane at the beginning. Great you noticed the head in the birdcage - did you notice it actually swings in time to the beat? For most people that would just be a lucky coincidence but as you get to see more of Ren & Sam's videos you'll understand that was more likely also a deliberate intricate attention to detail. The dogs playing poker for example was a reconstruction of a famous painting - right down to the same shaped red lampshade as in the painting. Numerous film references in there eg The Shining, and the scene at end with the headlights and Ren walking with a slight limp was a nod to A Clockwork Orange but also Willy Wonka. I like how you noticed the light on Ren's shoulder highlighting him - something I wouldn't have noticed and didn't know there was a term for it - these are the extra details that you bring that other reactors can't as its not their specialty. The writing on the wall if you watch again is the 7 Commandments from George Orwell's Animal Farm where (if you don't know) the animals take over the farm but then end up behaving just like humans and the commandment "All Animals are Equal" gets changed to "but some are more equal than others". When Ren sings about the King's illegitimate crown, King Charles was officially crowned 2 days before Ren released the track... Love how this has inspired you (Ren is the God for inspiring people in a myriad of ways!) to step out of your safety zone when making videos - what I'd really love to see is an interview / discussion with Samuel Perry-Falvey, Ren's videographer and maybe discussing in detail how he (& Ren) bring Ren's music to life. I know that every single thing we see in the videos is both meticulous and deliberate from timing to lighting to reverb, the locations they choose (on Ren's YT community tab he gave a brilliant account of how they got the location for Illest of Our Time (please react to that one! ) and all the difficulties they had to overcome including junkies trying to nick the equipment to sell on for drugs lol. More Ren definitely!

Had to come watch this bro after seeing BP get you all into the Ren Rabbithole 😂❤

Loving your Ren reactions my dude. Appreciating everything the rest of us do about Ren and seeing things in a different way from your unique perspective is awesome to see. Ren really is a genius and I don’t think many understand quite to what level. Dude is an inspiration.

3K subs let’s gooo! Great reaction! You are extremely expressive it is nice to see you in front of the camera too 😊

I'm here from Ren/B.P.,second addition to my subs after Ian Taylor :) As you have seen Genesis there is an acoustic version where he does the beat himself,absolute fire

A wonderful piece of art. Utter brilliance on every level. Ren and Sam are phenomenal 😁

Thank you! Love your enthusiasm! You have a new subscriber because of Ren and Black Pegasus. ✌️✌️🐷🐷

great reaction and the word you were looking for at the beginning is metronome. losing it is a great retake on a fisher beat. im sure you'll really enjoy it

That’s was amazing thank you great reaction love Ren ❤

thank you for reacting to this one, great breakdown sending love from the UK to you and your family ❤❤

The thing is he is doing so much of this on a small budget and a few good friends. He normally is the one to overspend on the videos. Now this one is more than the others. But the parts are played by friends in those huge animal heads. But his so humble and honest. For the interviews so very real as a person. It is really hard for me to believe that its been 2 or 3 months and has exploded!!! And I am hoping he stays true to himself. Great talent and grateful to be on the REN RABBIT HOLE. ❤

"It's a long way down into the rabbit hole, Alice" -Ren; Hell yeah man, I will watch you go through the Ren Rabbit hole for sure, maybe even check out some of his fellow artist; Romain, Sam, and Chinchilla as well. I don't think you will be disappointed!

More Ren for sure !

I'm so glad you found Ren, this is a great reaction. I'm really looking forward to seeing you do more. Apparently it's his friend's flat, and all the animals are Ren's friends. They had to shoot it quite a few times.

Yo! Sp happy to be turned onto you by Black P. You are super dope. Love to see your passion on the craft bleed out of you! No reservations it feels. It's great. Super real. Cheers 🍻