Absolutely NOT. It is not for her. And she forces her voice.

Common, man ?!

They are usually gay 😂😂

IsiFantastique /5§

Just think: how much more amazing is this than Mariah Carey singing a whistle note.

If you know how, whistle register is not something special.Like any other register of a voice.

Algo lenta

Demasiado lento !!!!

Sospensione dell’incredulità

Don't talk about voices when you didn't hear them live. Harteros has one of the biggest spinto voices of our times. Everyone that watches her live gets really impressed by the size of the voice. You just think that the voice is not big because the middle is not dark. But color and size are two things totally different!

I know a bit about voice type here as a real dramatic tenor myself. Harteros sounds very very tired. Her voice is tired, period. She is a lyric soprano, period. She simply happens to have an actual Opera voice which is a huge voice when compare to a pop voice. Have you heard a true Spinto? Sondra Radvanovsky is a true Spinto soprano with squilo in all parts of her voice yet her middle in not that big or dark.

Yes, Sondra has a big spinto voice. But everyone that watch Harteros and Sondra live says that the voice is about the same size. I know voice too. I'm a singer but I had a lot of experience of how different are voices live and on video. I will just say two examples. I heard Roberto Frontali live and in video. In video his voice sounds like lacking squillo. When I heard him live was exactly the opposite. Is a very squillo the voice. Other example was Marina Costa Jackson that in video for me sounded false darkened and it seems that the voice would not project in the hall. When I heard her live, the voice was less dark and runs in the hall really effortless. So, even the most expert in voice in the world can not judge size and overtones by video. The only way to judge is hear live! In videos, we can discuss phrase, style, Dynamics, acting but definitely not size or overtones.

By the ways, I always prefer singers of the past but this is a very high level of singing!

True, the *timbre* of her voice is light; however, even on video I can hear that it's likely a theatre-filling voice. Btw, how do you know *you're* a "real dramatic tenor"? I mean, maybe you sing dramatic tenor roles, but how do you know you're "the real thing" and not some sort of imitation or imposter, like you claim Harteros is? Are you sure *your* voice isn't "too lyric" for the roles you sing?

Hai ragione e questa non nemmeno una delle peggiori!

è vero .

Assolutamente! Come tante altre (la Garanca che si prende per un mezzo drammatico!!!) Ma c'è peggio, purtroppo.

Bodolito reminds me of one of those comic-strip characters who always walks around with a cloud of gloom over his head. Or he reminds me of Eyore in "Winnie the Pooh."

bodiloto come sempre hai di nuovo ragione! Grazie!

+MrOlogramma Ne, Harteros...

I have heard callas and that is the standard for me ,although i still admire and congratulate all the other sopranos that do classical genre , life still goes on

She was glorious. I liked it. You going to be a bitch to me for liking it?