Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 22 - What do elves do in The Halls of Mandos? - And More!

  Рет қаралды 1,364

John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar

John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar

Күн бұрын

I am a Tolkien scholar who has been enjoying and studying the works of Tolkien since the 1980s.
If you wish to submit a question - the best place to do so is via my Quora account - www.quora.com/profile/John-Si...
Every week I will choose the best questions to be featured in a video, though I will answer all that I can on there.
My Tolkien space - thegreyhavens.quora.com/
00:00 Intro
01:00 Brief reading from Unfinished Tales
05:34 Why didn't Sting glow in Moria?
07:20 When do elves start to fade?
15:31 Is Valinor analogous to North America?
18:30 Do elves scar?
21:49 Can Maglor be redeemed?
23:09 How much of their past do the wizards remember?
26:06 Does Gollum wear clothes?
28:05 Could Eru make a being stronger than himself?
31:53 Hoes was Beren able to steal a Silmaril from Morgoth?
37:30 Could Radagast have convined Smaug to leave?
39:36 What do the elves do in Mandos?
44:19 Who named Elrond and what does his name mean?
46:50 Did Tolkien create a multiverse?
48:46 How are Galadriel and Celeborn different?
52:40 Did Bilbo pay rent at Rivendell?
54:48 How did the spiders see Bilbo's sword?
I also have a gaming channel! - / necrovmx
#tolkien #lordoftherings #tolkientalk

Пікірлер: 14
@raydavison4288
@raydavison4288 4 ай бұрын
The elves in Mandos' Halls spend a great amount of time watching "Mandelbrot sets" while meditating. 😊
@peteg475
@peteg475 5 ай бұрын
“And there is not now upon Earth any place abiding where the memory of a time without evil is preserved. For Ilùvatar cast back the Great Seas west of Middle-earth, and the Empty Lands east of it, and new lands and new seas were made, and the world was diminished, for Valinor and Eressëa were taken from it into the realm of hidden things.“ My assumption is the "new lands and new seas" are the Americas.
@John-Sierra
@John-Sierra 5 ай бұрын
This refers to the east though, I believe that it refers to the fact that Cuivienen was destroyed and replaced by other lands.
@neilgoldsmith482
@neilgoldsmith482 6 ай бұрын
Tuor is my 2nd favorite character He is the only 2nd children of Iluvatar who is counted among the Elves in Valinor & actually seen Ulmo My favorite Estel in Imladris, Strider in Bree, Thorangul in Rohan & Gondor, Aragorn & King Elessar
@franciscordon9230
@franciscordon9230 11 ай бұрын
Thank you! Very helpful!
@John-Sierra
@John-Sierra 11 ай бұрын
Glad it was helpful!
@Vlakell4476
@Vlakell4476 10 ай бұрын
In The Fall of Gondolin, how did Morgoth know about Maeglin's desire for Idril if he doesn't know of Gondolin's location? If he simply read his mind to gain the information then wouldn't Morgoth already know Gondolin's location and was his threat a ploy to inflict cruelty onto Maeglin and The Noldor for his amusement? The more i analyzed it, it starts to make sense that Morgoth merely just used him to get revenge on Turgon and The Noldor, this is my opinion, i'm curious as to what you think.
@John-Sierra
@John-Sierra 10 ай бұрын
It isn't very detailed, but we know that he was captured, so it's likely that Meaglin just told Morgoth. He may have played a little good cop/bad cop and asked what his greatest desire was.
@RobRoss
@RobRoss 10 ай бұрын
I wonder if the question “is there a multiverse in LotR” might just have something to do with “are there other worlds other than Arda?” There’s no clear answer to this in the cannon, but since Eru is God, it’s not out of the question to believe he has created other worlds besides Arda. In this limited way, thinking of a “multiverse” could be thinking of other worlds that Eru made besides Arda. Just a thought.
@John-Sierra
@John-Sierra 10 ай бұрын
He certainly made other places, like wherever it is that men go after they die.
@whyukraine
@whyukraine 4 ай бұрын
Sting was a noldorin sword. The ring did not effect it the same way as a hobbit.
@GRWelsh7
@GRWelsh7 7 ай бұрын
Isn't the Dagor Dagorath still supposed to be in our future? With Arda Remade as the Tolkien version of the New Jerusalem from Revelation in the Bible?
@John-Sierra
@John-Sierra 6 ай бұрын
I suppose one could see it that way, though with it all being a "mythological past" I always thought that if we accept this conceit, we accept that it happened already. Of course you and me and probably the author would agree that the modern world doesn't currently and never has looked like any sort of "Arda Healed" but at the same time it is just myth. I think the real issue with trying to discuss Dagor Dagorath is that it was left on the cutting room floor, so to speak. There's a few differing versions of it, none are very detailed (as prophecies usually are not) and usually just build upon the previous version here and there, adding or removing details. But according to Christopher Tolkien, his father abandoned the idea of Dagor Dagorath. It's hard for a lot of people to accept, as it's just a likeable idea, and the thought that there is a climactic and final end beyond the scope of The L.R. and it's appendices. One of the last versions seems to have morphed into the Andreth prophecy, making it "of man" rather than of Mandos - and this mentioned Túrin returning to fight Ancalagon, not Morgoth, leading some to believe this 'final battle' was The War of Wrath but of course we have no record of Túrin's spirit re-appearing there. Soooo, long story short, I don't know (sorry!)
@RobRoss
@RobRoss 10 ай бұрын
To be fair, there’s more information available about what happens in the Halls of Mandos than in Christian Heaven. 🤷‍♂️
Voyage of Eärendil & War of Wrath | Silmarillion
33:59
Dan Iel
Рет қаралды 26 М.
Iron Chin ✅ Isaih made this look too easy
00:13
Power Slap
Рет қаралды 29 МЛН
Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 26 - Which elves are The Eldar?  - And More!
57:21
The Valar | Examining Their Role in the Third Age
14:00
Steven Gibb
Рет қаралды 20 М.
Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 54 - What was Gandalf's Plan to Enter Mordor?
56:21
John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar
Рет қаралды 2,1 М.
Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 20 - Does Gandalf Summon the Eagles? - And More!
1:00:41
Mandos, Doomsman of the Valar | Tolkien Explained
8:43
Nerd of the Rings
Рет қаралды 240 М.
Lore of Middle-earth: The Elves
48:50
Arachîr Galudirithon
Рет қаралды 134 М.
Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 21 - What Weapons Did Sauron Use?  - And More!
58:39
John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar
Рет қаралды 1,2 М.
"The Hobbit" Reading and Analysis - Part 1
3:27:11
John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar
Рет қаралды 1,3 М.
Answering Your Tolkien Questions Episode 8 - Is Sauron The Devil? - And More!
48:47
John Sierra - Tolkien Scholar
Рет қаралды 1,2 М.