‘This death,’ rasped the voder, ‘this death is ours. We choose it. We deny you your victory.’

Temeter and Huron Fal's last moments was the first moment in the Heresy that actually made me have to sit back and take a moment. It's one of the best-written moments in the series and Keeble nails the emotion of the scene.

One bit of old lore is in the very earlier 2000s Indexes Astarte articles. The Death Guard article has a few paragraphs on Garro and the Eisenstein. It end with speculations on Garro’s fate. One theory is he became an Apothecary and devoted his life to curing the Death Guard. One theory was he ultimately fell to Chaos and became a Daemon Prince called the “Lord of Flies”. And there was a theory he may have become part of the early Inquisition. Reading this book when I first came out, it was fun to see James weave those multiple fates into the command squad.

This book club made me start reading entire Horus Heresy project. Thank you for this Mira!

Also, the greatest thing to see is how each time it's plain to see how more freely you're able to talk about those books. You joke more and banter - that's what keeps it so entertaining for me❤

Remember kids: It's not betrayal, it's correcting your mistakes.

I agree with Mira on this one. Garro and other characters feel distinct enough for me to stay interested. Keeler is the best underused character so far. That's my biggest gripe

Really liked this one. After the uneveness of Galaxy in flames, this was such a breath of fresh air. The first few chapters are a bit of a slog, but when the story picks up, it was such a rush for me

I enjoyed Eisenstein more than I expected to, but that's mostly because I'd previously listened to the Garro audio... 'media experiences' or whatever they were called, which all seemed very "And then heroic space marine Garro jumped up and fired his gun at the bad guys, and the bad guys exploded. Some bad guys were about to do a bad thing but then they also exploded. A figure strode into the carnage - who was it? GARRO". So I was kind of dreading it and got pleasantly surprised.

Straight as an arrow Garrow. One of/possibly the favorite book of the heresy series for me

Dorn gets a unfairly bad rap for Flight. The attitude is like how dare he not take our word that Horus, his most beloved, trusted and respected brother who is the Emperor’s chosen proxy, is now rebelling against the Emperor? Like it’s the most casual thing in the world. You’re kidding yourself if you think any other Primarch would handled such news any better. For them to do so betrays just how unthinkable the whole thing is and how beloved Horus was.

Garro's arc finishes SO strong in Siege of Terra.

The human parts in Fulgrim are going to be a treat for Mira ...

Religious Space Detective. Now I need that tee shirt. Haha!

Warhammer Book Club with Mira is the best thing since sliced corpse-starch!

The banter is always as fun to hear as the book talk.

An *extra* glamourous Mira today!

I simply cannot wait to see Mira's reaction to book 5(my personal favorite)!

I say it every ep but I love these vids. Lets me relive books I love and Mira is just so excellent. Im looking forward to fulgrim, my fav book in the series (followed by legion) and I want to see Mira's reaction.

I love this book. The build up watching characters react to stuff that we know is coming is the joy of the HH books!

I would have loved to know how Mira felt about Garro having to tell Dorn that Horus is a big big traitor.

Love the silent sisters in end and death. Few can even see them and the one who can thinks she's a war godess.

I think there's a fairly key difference between Loken and Garro although I accept the similarities (and I agree the Heresy books get annoyingly repetitive around this point, both in recurring stereotypes and revisiting the same f*%&ing event over and over again...). Anyway, of Garro and Loken, I feel Loken is the more flexible and intuitive of the two. He does what he does because he has been unwittingly distancing himself from his brothers for some time and learning to think for himself (remember all the books he was reading on the Vengeful Spirit directed by Sindermann). Garro does what he does because his actions are dictated by his strong sense of honour. As Mira said, unlike Loken he's already an outsider in his legion. When Mortarian joins Horus, Garro is forced to choose between his not-very loving family one side and his implacable sense of right and wrong on the other. I think James Swallow said something along these lines about Garro in Mira's interview: "at this point, all he has left is his honour." Loken had a moral decision to make, whereas Garro pretty much had none. Even without his religious 'awakening', hIs moral code would have dictated his actions come what may (One of the later Garro books is titled Garro: Weapon of Fate, which is about right. He's a passenger in his own story, bound to a course he cannot alter).

Caleb was an Emperor dammed hero! 🫡 He read the Lecticio Divinitatus over a wounded Garro; brought the battle captain into the Emperor's divine grace, saved the ship by sealing the weapons deck, and was possessed by Nurgle but stayed and died loyal (twice) He failed to become an Astartes, but was braver than most of them, and saw the rot of the lodge early on. Damn hero 😐

I really like this one. The Nurgle warp creatures are great and I also kind of enjoy the 'obvious baddies being bad'. Good review guys!

Best 2 KZfaqrs woooop

'Roberto Luis Vuitton' had me howling. Thanks Mira!

23:30 "ROBERTO LUIS VITON" !! had me absolutely dying, i don't think she even knows the joke so that just makes it so much better! poor robert guillotine

I would definitely buy a "Religious Space Detective" shirt. It would be neat if the I symbol was in the background.

One of the few books that are told from a space marines pov, is filled mainly with space marine characters and is really compelling throughout

YES! I read the first three books in the series years ago and restarted in 2023 with Eisenstein. So great to finally see you talk about a book I have read recently. (Even though I am at work and will be at a work party tonight. But Saturday morning will be all Nurgle all the time).

i am really enjoying going through the heresy books with you two. keep up the great work

Love this series so much. I'd love to see more time dedicated to each book, it seems like you guys are moving along at a certain clip but you have so much more to say. I'd happily listen to more of this per episode

Totally agree with the Loken/Garro sameness. Iv'e read pretty much every book the two are in and still get confused who did what.

'Dan will save me'. Yup.

It's going to be interesting to see how you guys - Mira particularly - present all of these. The quality of the writing in this series is, shall we say, 'variable'... I can't imagine you're going to enjoy all of them, but equally I can't imagine Mira will feel comfortable interviewing an author who wrote a book she found tedious and poorly written. I thought Flight of the Eisenstein was very bad (although it was a long time ago now and can't remember all the reasons why). The exception - and to finish on a positive note - is that I still remember the bit where they've jettisoned the engines and are just waiting in space, in the cold and feeling very small and vulnerable. I remember that bit feeling very powerful.

Somehow I missed out Fulgrim so am quickly reading it now before I watch Mira's interview and your next HH Book Club!

Excited to see what she thinks of Fulgrim and Legion. Legion being my favorite book so far

So far in the 5 books and 7 audio dramas I have listened to this was my favorite one. Nathaniel Garro is a bro

Mira's interviews are fantastic, must be the most under-rated channels on KZfaq. The retreading of the same events around Istvaan got very boring after a few books. Some of my favorites coming up are Mechanicus and Prospero Burns, ran out stream around there though.

Soloun Temeter and Huron Fal was my favorite sad moment from this book 😢

“On Wednesday we wear plague.”

I cant wait to see what Mira thinks of Fulgrim. It will sure be intense for her.

Loved the flight, and very much enjoyed your discussion

Another great novel, yay~ Somehow I never really picked up on how similar Loken and Garo are.

That has to be one of the coolest book names, ever.

Mira, "Do you... interesting..." 😄😄😄 Book Club is the best 40k content.

I've read nearly all the heresy books. I'm totally up to date on the seige of terra series. And I still can't tell Loken and Garro apart.

I'll pray to Dan Abnett 😂

Pray for Mira, Fulgrim next.

Best of luck getting through Fulgrim, Mira... you may need to keep a bucket nearby.

Lmao the “throat gang” is crazy!!!!!

Gene sperm? I see we're ramping up for Fulgrim....

Dorn is in the first book he’s says he convinced Horus to put Loken in the mournival

Garro gets one of the best moments when he -redacted- -redacted- right in the -redacted- during the -redacted-

When I read, "The Flight of Einstein" the first thing that came to mind when I thought about the ship's journey through the Warp, and the scene with the reanimation of traitor Death Guard and Garro's battle with them, was a song by Led Zeppelin called, "No Quarter". IMHO, that song just fits that scene and the Einstein's journey through the Warp thematically somehow.

I just found your videos yesterday and now I have a new one today. That's serendipity

is it possible that this video isn't added to the book club playlist? I missed it and just happened upon it in the recommended videos list, for which I'm very glad cause I love these

Title picture is perfect! 🎉

A story of mean girls, finding god and chunky vegetable soup.

I want a playlist of all the movie action summary !

Always up for old DG lore. Best legion.

Finally! Binged the previous three and was craving the next episode

Finally getting around to listening to these videos and really enjoying it as a recap of what happens in these books without having to re-read them, especially hearing Mira's non-wargamer perspective on all this not being completely de-sensitised from years of engagement with 40K lore. Also just a quick heads up, this video is missing from the Book Club Playlist.

I liked and subscribed just to spite you Ian

off topic but i love Miras longer hair and fresh look with the lippy and the shirts

I don’t think Garro and Loken are obviously the same due to similar personalities. It’s simply because they both don’t originate from their Primarch’s original world. So, issues like the lodges will be against the Emperor and their loyalties will be different to those who share a world with their Primarch.

"Rogal Dorn's personality is based on having no personality." That hit home hard.

I'm really enjoying these book club videos. You two have really good rapport and it's really interesting listening to someone's opinion who isn't fully into the lore. I'm a bit worried for Mira's mental health with respect to stuff like Fulgrim and The First Heretic lol... and Big E isn't quite the selfless good guy she might be expecting...

Everything in the HH series through this book was fantastic. After that it went off the rails a bit.

Fulgrim! That is an epic.

Not a fan of the HH books, but a fan of you❤

I really hope Roberto Louis Vuitton sticks

Thank the emperor, I aint the only one who thought Garro was boring. Honestly, the tenseness of the first act was really cool and had enough of a supporting cast for Garro to limp along, but when they threw in their first warp jump, i wad praying for Iacton Qruze to take over the novel. Garro's fight at the end felt like a good way to cap off the novel though. Deffo not my favorite, but there's still tonnes to like, in it. Edit: I lost it at throat gang ROBERTO LUIS VUITTON LMAOO

The Chapters going over Istvaan is a bit rough to read through especially if you just read Galaxy in Flames like I had - but it's very good once you get past that part of the book. Watching the human characters and space marines react and make choices around a literal galaxy changing events is very cool. I'd go from First Hereitic -> Know no fear -> Betrayer now.

Really enjoying these. Lookin forward to Fulgrim

This was my first 40k book and I still love it.

Like Ian mentioned, the Eisenstein is part of the lore from the very beginning. It is an important part of the story, Swallow did a good job and give the bone some flesh. Its not my favourite book, but I still like it quite a bit. And it was necessary for people who just start the heresy books without any background infos. btw. what is the name of the gloriuos intro/outro song? Can anyone help plz?

Another awesome novel from the Horus Heresy's literary collection!

In the headcannon of some fans the Sister of Silence were one of the two lost legions, but they did, said or saw something that "granted" them the demotion out of the Legions and got them forced to be mute. Checks the f#@k out considering that Warhammer is a satire of our society.

Thank you.

Malcador takes Garro away at the end to become one of the first Grey Knights.

just tickling the algorithm

Garro is one of my favorite HH characters. How will you be reading the short stories. Especially the Garro ones. For example Vengeful Spirit is really confusing if you haven’t read the first few Garro stories. Or will you do all the collections in order of publishing.

After avoiding all things imperium, i finally gave in and started to listen to the Horus Heresy series while painting.......and while skiving at work. These videos have been really helpful in picking up the bits I've missed. Cherrs, guys, keep it up. P.s. what books are skippable/poorly writren?

My favourite book. I read it at least once a year. I need to get a new copy though, mines starting to fall apart lol

Great book!

The thing I miss about the earlier Heresy books is all of these weird xenos and non-compliant human worlds who do things in entirely different ways. Sometimes better, sometimes even worse somehow

Should have been a Loken led book. Having a complete main characters switcheroo lowered how much I cared about what happened

I don't know what it is exactly but Loken and Garro feel very different to me. They're both humorless yes but Loken feels so much more human to me with the way he opened himself up to the Remembrancers and became friends with them. Also Garro getting all religious is a turn off for me I think.

"a religious space detective" - a jedi?

To me, saying that Loken and Garro are the same is such a simplistic thing. Both are military, so yes, they wouldn't have a very deep personality. But both of them are loyalist for very different reasons. It's kid of funny how Garro said to Hakur or Qurze that they were saved because they didn't followed their primarch blindly, when in fact they were saved because the did follow the emperor blindly. Faith and stuff applies. While Loken got there from the other end of the spectrum, he did participated in the lodge, he did look for information from a secular stand point. He questioned everything and everyone. Truth, not Faith.

Huron Fal went out like a G.

I felt loken is much more the squeaky clean Hollywood hero like Tom cruise vibes whereas garro gives me much more like an rougher older Clint Eastwood type vibe. I also think garro seems more flawed than loken due to his age making him more set in his ways. V similar core values but different enough for me 😊 keep up the book club! 🙌

Anyone know if this book will have a reprint? I can't find a new one at reasonable price

You guys should switch to the other “F” bomb... Fething.

The only thing I didn't like in this book was the voice for Rogal Dorn on the audiobook version, I got an Peter Griffin vibe out of it that I wasn't expecting for a Primarch.

Rogal Dorn not remembering Loken in this book is so damn frustrating

The "Flight of the Eisenstein" was a fantastic novel. For me, it helped redeem the Horus Heresy book series. "Horus Rising" was absolutely phenomenal, but "False Gods" and "Galaxy in Flames" were absolute horrible. Thank you James Swallow.

the great crusade is so funny to me because when i imagine an alien species wiping out another i imagine one that’s like technologically way mor wadvamced like bombarding the other from orbit or doing weird third body problem type stuff like turning their entire solar system into a 2d plane but the great crusade is just like we are the same tech level as you and we’re going to come down there and fucking kill you with our guns and stab you to death. like that spongebob meme where squidward has his arm around the little kid fish and the caption is “we’re gonna kill you”