I’m with you! I didn’t like that she made it seem like those scents were straight up garbage. We need to stop obsessing over the idea of ‘not being like everybody else’. Wear what you love, period.

Now this is a review I can get behind. An educated, detailed description with a personal opinion. Not a bashing video basically calling millions of women and men "boring" because you think fruity florals are over done and youre sick of them.

Dylan Blue smells like a juicy green apple shampoo, I love it! Sometimes you just want something easy and fun.

I'm really glad to see people standing up for themselves and wearing what they like. We are all adults and cannot let someone tell us what to do with our money or what to like. I really like your approach for this video and the way you expressed yourself. It's ok for everyone not to agree but don't insult anyone's taste

I think sometimes fragrance reviewers forget that most of us have jobs where we cannot wear beast mode or crazy sexy perfumes, but it is interesting to hear multiple perspectives on fragrances. I love Idole and libre especially for work!

I didn't buy Versace Dylan Blue Pour Femme based on the review she made. I do like her reviews, have blind bought many fragrances based on her reviews and she has always come thru. Having seen many other reviews though, I decided to invest and I must say on this occasion girl, she was wrong! This fragrance is gorgeous on my skin, not generic at all and the compliments....OMG daily. People literally chase me down asking me what I'm wearing.

The Si Passione smells AMAZING!!! And it's the perfect combo for my chemistry. I don't understand saying it doesn't last. EVERYONE notices it when I wear it...

Thank you for this. I did see the review you are talking about. It is nice to get another take on things.

And I know exactly who you're talking about. I thought it was ridiculous when she vocally trashed and basically begged everyone not to buy idole. That was a bit much. She also went off on my juicy couture. I still rock some of the viva la juicy and juicy couture. However, some people get so into niche that they become snobs to scents. So I say, try things anyway and form your own opinion. I myself am finding that as I get more into niche I can't do some of my favorite celebrity scents anymore. My pallet is changing.

Appreciation for your video. I don’t mind if somebody disliked a favorite perfume of mine but it’s not ok to tell other people what they should or shouldn’t buy or smell like.

Love the way you share your opinion in a confident but respectful way 💙 keep em coming with this great content :)

I love layering of idol to any rose purfumes to make it personal. It’s easy and everyday wear. It’s perfect for being at home or after the shower. I East it out shopping and to church. It’s perfect. I agree with all you said about each one of these. Thank you for this review. People need easy and good basic perfumes to wear. Great review and appreciate your words. Your awesome!!!!!

Thank you for your honest and mature take on these perfumes, I own two of the four you reviewed plus a ton of others in different "families" and price ranges and I love them all. What works for someone might not work for someone else, and our nose and likes change so much through the years. I own perfumes with notes that I use to hate when I was younger and I at my age I dislike cult favorites that A LOT of people swear by *cough "Black Opium" for example. I very much enjoyed watching your video

Here here Rebeca! So thankful you did this video! I like everyone of those perfumes and didn't agree with the other review. I love designer perfumes and don't really care what others think because I wear perfume for me. It makes me happy. Great video and thanks for standing up.

you're so right about so many things!!! especially about lancome idole! your videos are really fun to watch!

I really appreciate how you focused on how a fragrance has been marketed and what the target consumer is. Not many reviewers take this into account when reviewing fragrances. Would love it if you do more of these kind of videos..reading through comments it’s seems like many of us enjoy this approach.

I love that you did this video because I think that oftentimes when we look up to someone, their opinions affect us. I love Versace Dylan Blue and just picked up a full bottle. But I have to admit, watching that video made me almost second guess whether I liked it or not, if that makes sense. I can see how someone can categorize it as being “basic”, but like you said, it’s unlike anything I have in my collection and I love how versatile it is!

My beloved Dylan blue yessss!! I literally crave this perfume 😭

You are spot on about Idole, I’m 23 and I love it, it’s perfect for everyday

Totally loved how you put your thoughts into this video! I am a 27 years old girl and I really want to get Dylan Blue.

I’m glad you made this video in response to “that” video. I think it’s right that none of these are groundbreaking, but they can still be really good and work for someone. It’s all about what someone likes...I happen to like Idole despite knowing it’s a boring, run of the mill rose fragrance, but I do enjoy it on my skin.

I love Dylan Blue! I have a lot of soft floral, juicy sweet, and warm vanilla in my collection and this scent is like none of those. Its clean and fresh but sweet and feminine. It has this very fresh out of the shower feel with lots of cotton and Im obsessed. I cant wait to layer it with other scents

Hi, i decided to subscribe because of this video. I share your opinion that fragrance is sth personal and we don't necessarily like the same things. I think your positive attitude and honesty are the things that attracted me to your channel. Thanks 💓

This was such a thoughtful and thorough review! Loved all 👏🏼of👏🏼it👏🏼! This video made me an instant subscriber!! The video done by the one whose name we aren’t saying here led me to yours. Yours was such a perfect non-judgmental and informative review. Everything you said was spot-on, especially about Idole and how reviewers should think about viewers/consumers (ie, we’re not all collectors or into niche or OG’s in the frag community).

I agree with you 1000%. The breakdown you gave for Idole was spot on! Every product whether it be a fragrance or fruit snack has a target audience. The safest way to decide on a fragrance is to get a sample! Fragrance is so personal and attached to memories in my opinion. A fragrance performance can also depend on how and what you moisture your skin with. Overall great video!

I just bought the Versace in a gift set from Macy’s and I love it!!! And the Libre is next on my list!! I got a sample of it from Sephora. Thank you for your video!!! It really helped!!!

I have 3 out of the 4 & I absolutely love them all. You know as Perfume Reviewer we do understand that everyone has different body chemistry, what works for you might not work for me & I love your take on these Fragrances even tho they don't tickle your fancy 😊

I had a sample of Dylan Blue, and I loved it had to get a full bottle. I thought it was beautiful. I do get the expensive shampoo but I love it. Great review 🥰 BTW I totally agree with you. Stay safe

Rebecca thanks for this. Great Work!

Definitely great everyday scents! Thanks for sharing, I just smelled Si Passione and I really liked it. I think it would be a great everyday scent, it may be basic but sometimes basic is what you need. Awesome video!

I love all of them! On my skin I can’t see any of them be too basic. Really do appreciate your honest review ❤️

I’m totally with u on this review !

I really appreciate your take on these perfumes. I know Idole seems to get a lot of hate, actually I hear a lot of negative stuff about black opium as well because it’s “too popular “. the fact that something appeals to many and isn’t “unique “ doesn’t make it bad!! Great video!!

I love your description. Comparing to other products and similarities in them. I come to your videos when I'm interested in a perfume. Would love your take on men as well.

Was trying out the chanel fragrances on Macy's and none really impressed me until I tried the Dylan Blue Pour Femme edp and YSL Libre. And man that Dylan blue just smells amazing to me. Not basic at all. Decided to get for mother's day.

Hi Rebeca! I have been a subscriber to your channel for a while, so I was so happy to see you take part in Eva Monroe’s collab video, “9 Sexy Women & The Sexiest Fragrance in Their Collection!” Epic video and thanks so much for your contribution! I enjoyed today’s video... Thank you! ❣️❣️❣️

Hello, Dylan Blue may seem basic and casual but to me it is way more, I feel this is Versace take on modern sophistication. It is a stunning unique fragrance especially in our very hot and humid climate (Bahrain). The bottle is to die for (Obviously I am a big fan).

Love this video. It also made me subscribe. Enjoyed your content before...this made me love it. Keep it up with spreding love for perfumed and understanding of them and people. ❤🤗

LOVE that you addressed this!!!!! Lmao I felt the same way about her video

“Someone else” lol! I agree with pretty much everything you said! Fragrance is subjective so of course there are going to be various different opinions, but I personally wouldn’t tell anyone not to buy a fragrance based solely on my opinion either as they may miss out on a fragrance they’d actually love!

Great review! Every time I watch a review dragging Idôle to the ground I’m so confused. I find it to be such an easy to wear, happy scent.

Si Passione got me two compliments in of all places Costco! I sprayed it early in the day and by the evening I was getting compliments. I guess I’m one of the people it performs on quite well🥰

I loooved be delicious by Donna Karen so I'm excited to get my bottle of Dylan Blue.

I was going to purchase Si Passione but because of your honest description I didn't. I prefer fragrances that project and last longer. Thank you for being honest.

I would like to give this video 1M likes!! I don’t like Si Passione & YSL’s Libre but I won’t go around & “bash” them as we all have different tastes or preferences.

Recently blind bought Lancôme’s Idole and was scared to receive it since I saw so many negative reviews. But after seeing this video you calmed my nerves. I loved hearing your perspective and now I’m so excited for it to get here! Thank you 💗

I was supposed to buy Idole last week but I changed my mind because I watched Demi and Paulina's review about it. I opted for YSL Libre which I do not regret. I am the kind of person who like strong scents and perfume. I got a sample and been trying it and I can say that it stayed in my wrist for about 6-8 hours so it is not bad but the projection is weak.

I know this video is a little older, but I was in the market for some new scents and two of them are in this video. I LOVE Dylan Blue pour femme already and you're right it's not basic unless you wore DKNY back in the 2000s which I did not lol I work straight fruit scents back then. But Libre is a scent I've been wanting to try for a few months now. I was not expecting to love that scent but I do, it's a little light on me but it's perfect for every day.

I was actually quite offended by what she said because it was very harsh! Just because she's boujee as hell for being able to afford $300-$500 bottles, doesn't mean we all can! I actually Versace Dylan Blue, at first I hated the way it smelled, but smelled it again another time & realized it's a very nice refreshing/different scent from that house alone! Thank you for making a more detailed polite review of the perfumes! ☺ As I am a fragrance collector/enthusiast, I am slowly adding more niche to my collection, but I will always love my designer & as well as enjoy some celebrity scents ☺

LOL I thumbs down that video and didn't bother leaving a comment. She even knocked perfumes I liked. But she pushes $240-300 perfumes on her viewers, I am not buying bottles for $300. I think she likes strong niche scents, which is fine, but offer options for everyone else. Using terms like "mass pleasing" or "commercial" annoys me too. There are some real snobs perfume reviewers.

I love Dylan Blue however after about an hour I don't smell it anymore. I blind bought Idole and I can't wait to receive it. I want to try Si Passione and Libre. I've tried Si however it triggers my allergies. Tfs😨

Thank you for this video. I do enjoy niche, but I also love designer fragrances. I think the perfume community sometimes turns their nose up because designer is not as unique as niche, but there are some wonderful designer scents out there. So thank you for giving them some credit. I really appreciated this video!

I got Versace Dylan Blue from Scentbird. I had it for 3 months before I put it on. I just didn’t care for it in the bottle. One day I decided to give it a try…it smells AMAZING on me! I’m in love. It just may be my new signature scent!

Great video... I Don't own any of them but I want to test out idole

Saw your collab Eva, great video

You totally sold me on Idole 😂 sounds perfect!

I agree with you about Libre. It is not boring, nor is it a typical citrusy white floral. Neither you nor the other reviewer mentioned that it is a fougere, which is a rather uncommon category in women's perfumes, these days. This perfume projects, it lasts, and a little goes a long way. I layer it with Ariel Grande's Moonlight (a cheapie but it works) for a softer version. There are several flankers now for people who don't vibe with a lot of lavender and orange blossom (which I find fresh), some with more vanilla. I don't like any of the flankers sofar (haven't smelled Le Parfum yet) but other people might find one that they love instead of the OG Libre.

Thanks for sharing your opinion. In my case and weather: Si Passione- kinda strong scent but definitely milder than the original Si. Lasts only 4hrs on the skin and yes weak projection. But i like it. Dylan Blue- fresh but sharp for me. Gives me a headache. I wish to try Libre and Idole 🙂

I love all these! I am young (20) and cannot afford niche nor do I want niche, my nose cannot handle all those strong oud scents 😷 I also could never justify spending $200+ dollars on a perfume, having grown up poor. I always buy on either fragrancenet or through Mercari! I love my designer florals! Some of my favorite scents are by Jo Malone (not sure if that's niche but hey I pay under $90 for full sizes).

Love a fruity floral....with a musk, Amber, or green base yummy ! I seen that video ! ....I thought it was a little dismissive as you say from a regular purchaser most of the fragrances mentioned Would be wearable...I own some of the scents mentioned ...also not crazy about others mentioned...but none were bad bad !,,,.....fragrance is such a personal thing ...Look I love No 5 ...its called old smelling granny ! ..and makes some gag lol lol .................I love old school fragrances as well as some newer releases...it’s all opinion, taste, it’s fragrance! 😉 Great video

I absolutely love ❤️ all four perfumes especially Dylan blue by Versace

I didnt like versace DB and I revisited it after adding to my collection and was like I like this. DB is nice. Idole is a easy reach. Love it.

I just picked up Idole and the intense version from Ulta. I think it could be a great every day, got extras as gifts. It’s such a cute little bottle for your bag.

Great video as always :) just wondering if you have tried Chanel allure original in Edt? I’ve read so many nice reviews I’m thinking of ordering it but would like to hear your Opinion on it if you’ve tried it :)

Love Love Love Libre, beautiful scent! Dylan Blue is quite nice, i enjoy it. The Si passione is a no for me. I have the original Si which is one of my favorites! Idole is a definite no no for me! Its my worst from Lancome!!! Nice review!! And you look lovely too!!

Here from Eva's channel, 👋🏼 I just purchased a sample of Narciso Rodriguez Her because of your opinion on the video you did... Have a great day😊

Tried 20 perfumes at Ulta today and ended up buying Versace Dylan Blue for my fiancée. The finalists were Dior Poison Girl and Dolce and Gabbana Light Blue Intense. Dylan Blue lasts long with a powerful and opulence scent. My fiancée was very pleased with the selection.

Subbing because I love your positivity.

I gotta admit, I'm very curious about the video you're talking about lol. I haven't tried Pasione but I have the original and Si Fiore and adore them both. I'm very interested in Dylan Blue. I enjoyed this video. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Even though I’m not the target for a perfume, I wish I could wear it without being underwhelmed by it. Idôle is one of them. It smells amazing in the bottle but it smells like nothing on my skin. It’s now sitting in the bedtime bin. Dylan Blue is the same for me. Terrific in the bottle but gone after 2 hours. It’s all body chemistry I know that! 🙂 But still... I wish they were a notch better. Libre and Sì are on my wishlist. I like them both in the bottle but haven’t got the chance to try them... 🙂

I'm undecided if I should blind buy Versace Dylan blue I seen mixed reviews.would you consider this a summer scent?or an all around season scent?😋 btw love your content❤

I own all of these fragrances except YSL Libre. I get so many compliments on Idole! I bought Dylan Blue and Si Passione right before quarantine, so no compliments on those yet😂

I am subscribed to both you and Demi and I love you both. Ironically I watched her video tonight and then yours was recommended to me to watch next. So I appreciate both your opinions on these scents. Bottom line these five scents were made to be crowd pleasers and for the right person they work. They are not necessarily ground breaking, I agree. So I think you both said the same thing but just in a different way. Both good videos! ❤️

Libre pull a strong lavander on me. I dont like it but I may revisit and I may change my mind. 😊

Thinking about getting the 5 mL version of the Versace perfume. I have never smelled it but it sounds promising. (Some of my favs are Viva La Juicy, Downtown by Calvin Klein, and Good Girl by Carolina Herrera [don't own yet, swear this will be my wedding perfume one day lol]) Does $9 for a 5 mL mini perfume sound reasonable? I think that's about 50 sprays? Might give it a go :)

I don't know who you are talking about but to hear that someone is saying what I shouldn't buy and that these lovely scents are the worst???? I never liked people sharing their opinions as the absolute truth, we are all different with different taste and experience, let us decide what we like. You shared great content with us and I can't believe how come I haven't subscribed yet, I am doing it right now because I don't want to miss YOUR lovely reviews

First ☝️let me say, "Girl I saw your sexy self on the Eva Monroe calab"😉 you were great. Hey ! I love ALL of those perfumes Dylan Blue and Libre are my favorite.tfs 🌺 stay safe and well 🙏🏼

I'm newer to fragrances but I have binge-watched like 30 of Eve Beauty Etc's fragrance videos from past 2-3 years because she's so knowledgeable, having worked at Chanel and knowing so much about the history of fragrances. She also has correct French pronunciation and it is a relief to NOT have to cringe every time she says Guerlain.

I love idole, its the perfect everyday light fragrance

I'm in my 20s but I don't live that Lancome perfume. I really bought it because of the packaging since it's so unique. But I like more complex smells and it smells really basic to me. I do think it's a good one to give as a gift because most people will like it.

I have Dylan Blue and I’m enjoying it for sure. I think the other perfume Demi had not so nice things to say about was Dior Joy which is on my list so sniff.

The YSL Libre got so much hate from the community to my surprise. I really like it. It smells very old money to me but also a little 90s.

I got offended by the other KZfaqr. Made me feel like I wasted my money but then I thought to my self I love the How they smell so screw her! I’m going to buy Idole I did smell it and I loved it. Just those negative reviews have made me think about it.

This one was I lavender bomb on me... Thankfully the intense version balanced out better for me, with the vanilla being more prominent.

I have over 100 bottles of perfumes and many of them are niche scents, but I love all these scents here! Being a perfume person, it also means being open minded to other scents and how even if they may not be what you’re into, they can be great for a specific person/target group. Just like anything in life, being open minded and objective is better than always being subjective and close minded. Idole for me is such a flirty scent and very youthful!! You don’t need to always be dipped in oud and tobacco and vanilla. Maybe, everyone who swears they’re so different are the real basic ones !!! Please wear what you want !

I agree with you for sure. x

Perfume is so subjective! Everyone is different and it doesn’t matter what others like or don’t like. Sometimes I agree and sometimes I don’t. It really doesn’t even matter. Lol On that note, Dylan Blue reminds me so much of my Nivea lotion! I love my Nivea.

Have you tried Dylan Turquoise? I am curious about your thoughts on that one…

Such a cute video... Thank you! #teamidole... (And libre. And Dylan blue lol)

Versace blue smells allot like pear to me. I see why it's perfect for spring/summer. Unfortunately it gives me a headache

Si passione I find it comes off strong with an incense note..which I'm not a fan of but when I smell it in someone else its nice..versace dylan I like as well but its alil masculine...Ysl libre I find the lavender alil off putting but I might give it another chance...lancome idole is nice but not different...thank you for your review on these...I might try ysl libre again and wait until the dry down🙂

Your overall look today makes me think of the Viktor&Rolf Flowerbomb bottle🙈🙈

So pretty in the blush pink tones

Heyyy! How are you? I’m so very interested in Dylan Blue! I always hear it’s “basic” so I’m so hesitant. But I trust you since we like the same perfumes so I’m going to order it. I have a recommendation for you though! Versace Eros pour femme! Omg! It’s amazing. The edt is beautiful! But I also bought the edp too. You just have to try it 💜

Thank you, sometimes I dislike reviewers that don't seem to understand that if I'm watching your reviews, I'm probably not the 'perfume collector' that you are. Like it's fine to have your opinion, but lets not get tunnel vision.

Great video. I feel like I'm missing out. No clue who the other person is.. but I think I have an idea lol. Ah I figured it out lol

Great video! I LOVE Si Passion, and not a big fan of Libre!🤗

Ysl iv orderd yesterday have tryed and last all day so nice one thing I look for in perfum that it last on my skin.Dylan blue is nice too but not that good on my skin but on clothes ok would like to get as well as not got anything like it xx

First of all, you look so beautiful! I love this look..so romantic! Although I am not super fond of Dylan Blue I wouldn't call it basic either. On the other hand, I am in LOVE with Libre. I think it is soo incredibly sexy! Idole I think is so pretty and easy to wear.

I know which KZfaq review you are referring to. Personally I find her obnoxious like most niche freaks who tend to come across like they are so cool and above wearing what appeals to the sweaty masses. Most people can't afford 3 or 4 hundred dollars for a bottle of perfume, when I see niche in the thumbnail I just keep scrolling.