Brian: "I have to talk you all into doing something, something I know we need to do. And I don't know how to talk about it." The Governor killing Hershel destroyed us, we loved him so much, we knew that his death was somehow inevitable, but honestly that really hit where it hurts. On the other hand we will not regret "Brian", he could have had a more brutal death after all he's done but this was as satisfying as it gets on this show. We kind of imagine now that the next part of this season will be following the different groups formed after the prison destruction, hoping that they find each other again. We appreciate guys all your support, so don't forget to hit that subscribe button, it really motivates us to keep up the content. And of course if you are interested in the full reaction, you can find us here : www.patreon.com/takeaticket (you can find Rob doing solo reaction to Battlestar Galactica, and the latest records of the current shows we are doing on youtube) Much love Rob and Trin

as much as i hate the governor, “Liar.” gives me chills EVERYTIME

The thing that always gets me with this episode is How truly proud Herschel is of Rick when he’s giving his speech after Herschel dies I don’t think anyone is the same in the group it’s truly heartbreaking. Such an incredible episode so glad I’m on this journey with you guys.

Maggies reaction to her dad breaks my heart every single time

I cried like a real family member had died when this episode first aired. Losing Hershel was one of the hardest deaths ever 🥺

The title of the episode, "Too Far Gone", is mentioned by Rick during his talk with The Governor. Rick believes that they are not "too far gone" to come back from the things they have done. This sentence was said to Rick before by Hershel. And at the end of the episode a walker is seen walking over a 'King' chess piece that Meghan had drawn the eyepatch on. This signifies The Governor's death as he had lost the battle and typically in chess when you lose or forfeit you knock over your king piece.

i absolutely lovee how at the beginning hershel says to the govenor that they can live together, and rick later echoes that, hershels smile at rick is so sweet he was such a good mentor for rick and taught him that they can be better - hershel had amazing character development, going from a denying the apocalypse and caring only for his family, to putting his safety on the line for the rest of the community and being one of the leaders, as much as i wanted him to live forever im glad he died here as his character was kinda complete and his death was soo impactful

So much gut wrenching stuff in this episode. I don't think I've seen Trin so upset before I got to say, understandably so. Can't wait to see you guys watch the next episode!

The road ahead is full of badass moments, chilling moments and incredible moments.

9 years and i still remember the exact same feeling i had watching it live by my sofa. Fucking epic.

Ive been dreading and anticipating this episode for y’all, seeing how much y’all have grown to love Hersh 🥴

It’s a bit harsh calling Rick spineless you could tell Rick was doing the right thing by the little smile on Hershel’s face when he was trying to talk to the governor,and Rick got shot in the leg I think before his fight with the governor which probably played a part in him losing the fight.

They are sooooo lucky when this first came out we had to wait for so long to see the continuation! Hope you continue to enjoy this show!

Great reaction guys. Just a little detail in case you missed it when you watched the episode... When Rick starts shooting at the Governor, it is in fact NOT Rick who hit the Governor with his shot, but was actually Carl. Makes you appreciate how much of a good shot he is after such a short time training

Rick wasn't being spineless. The reason Herschel was smiling proudly at Rick's words to the Governor was because Rick was using reason the way Herschel had been telling him to. Rick's words were almost exactly what Herschel said ("we get to come back") to him in 4x01 after Rick told him about the woman in the woods.

This is my favorite episode of the entire show, been watching weekly since season 2, phenomenal performances all around

I watched this episode as it aired and was absolutely emotionally crushed watching Hershel die. Knowing this is that same espiode doesn't make it any easier 😭😭😭

I’ve been waiting for this episode for a while now… always makes me cry, Hershal did not deserve to go out that way🥺One of the best episodes in my opinion, and the saddest🥺

"we" that is what this show does best, it makes you feel like one of the group. You care and you feel each death and are scared for everyone. We become a part of it. Loving your reactions, glad to be on this journey with you.

Gut wrenching episode this was. Hershel was , is, and will always be one of my fav characters. Sadly missed. Completely destroyed me when i watched his death. His smile knowing he had got through to rick before the inevitable was so bittersweet. Great reactions as always guys. Did you spot the walker at the end of the show? the weird lady that led rick back to her husbands head lol

I’ve been waiting for y’all to get to this episode. It just rips your heart out because of the sheer cruelty of taking Herschel’s life…he was the moral authority for the group. Broke my heart to hear Trin crying…I was crying… again with you 😢. Another big one coming so I’ll keep watching you guys! Thanks for keeping TWD reactions coming!

I’m enjoying going through this Walking Dead journey with you all. Rick tries his best to be a leader for this group and I love him for it. Can’t wait for the next video.😊

Your reactions to this episode still breaks my heart 😭 especially now were almost done s4 and this was the last time the group where together. Seems like so long ago now

I am so glad I started watching TWD when 9 seasons were already out, so I didn't have to wait a week for the resolution of this episode. So many things happening that shape the future character developments of our main group. Ugggh I cannot wait for you to see all the things yet to come. Stay strong and much love to you guys. I feel like Trin needs a big hug

You guys are the first reactors I've seen that recognized the crazy lady walker at the end! I always loved that little detail.

You can't get attached to anybody, everyone is vulnerable in this show. I remember my first times watching these. You two will be meeting a whole bunch of new characters throughout the show, but remember: No one is safe! Call it a morbid fascination, I could watch this series over and over. Even when you know what's going to happen your second or third time around, it's still captivating! Again, this is why I love watching these reactions, because it's like a refresh button, bringing me back to how I felt my first time! So, thank you Rob and Trin! You haven't really seen anything yet, the real fun is just getting started! lol

One of the most emotionally devastating episodes of the show.

I think the governor saying liar to Rick was him denying himself redemption. He thought of himself as too far gone and so after hearing Rick's speech he thinks it's bullshit before calling him a liar softly in a whisper only to himself no one else could hear before proving it by killing Herschel

You swearing, Trin swearing has to be the best reaction I have seen to this episode.

R.I.P to Hershel great character who brought so much love his theme song R.I.P to the actor Scott Wilson who played this character and who sadly passed away from Leukemia 4 years ago Oct 6 2018 Age 76 He was the ultimate voice of reason right next to Dale and R.I.P to the Governor as well who was a great villain and did a great job at making us hate him great work by David Morrissey portraying this character.

I've noticed that on everyone's reactions I watch, I always skip to the parts that i wanna see the most of and just skip through the parts not as important. Yall are the only reactors I will watch all the way from intro to outro. Never been disappointed.

i was dreading you guys watching this episode because i remember watching it for the first time and i cried so much. hershel was someone so special. maggie’s reaction was so sad aswell. scott wilson did an incredible job playing hershel. he’s missed dearly

An amazing episode and reaction! This part of the comics is one of the best arcs in the whole series. In the comics, the Governor actually captures Tyreese and beheads him in front of everyone. Not only does he die during his attack so does Axel, Patricia (Otis’s GF), Hershel and his son, Lori AND Judith went Lily shot her from behind. Lily gets mad at the Governor for making her shoot them and then instantly shoots him and throws him to the walkers. It’s a very emotional and heartbreaking arc that had a lot of fans upset.

There was a great meme: Philip: We have a tank! Team Rick: We have Daryl.😂

Hershel was the last moral compass holding the group together, the last bit keeping their humanity intact

I'm so glad Rob talks about context because it's 100% true and the show explores that more down the road. It's easy for us to side with our heroes because we know their story, we know their struggle, it's intimate, but that doesn't mean they're always the good guys in every situation. It's great food for thought that goes over the heads of the average viewer.

This is the best Episode of Season 4, just incredible War Vibes, It just reminds you of World War II, Hershel’s Death (RIP Scott Wilson), and the Prison, Definitely one of the best Episodes of The Show

This episode was one of the biggest turning points for Rick's group. How do you just deal with losing such a pure soul???

Notice how governor said “liar” and chopped Hershel head off , just like the headless corpse he saw last episode that had a sign saying “liar

Comic Comparisons : in the comics It’s Tyreese who gets decapitated his comic counterpart is actually introduced much earlier than in the show before they get to the farm the battle for the prison goes down a bit different The Governor is presumed dead for a while before he randomly shows up at the prison gates It should be noted that the Governor never kills all of his people or burns down Woodbury so he still had an army with him him becoming Brian Heriot is completely unique to the show I can’t remember exactly but I think their first attack failed Nonetheless they eventually bust through and kill a lot of people Hershel does die in this battle in the comics but not in the same way He begs to be killed after his son is shot right in front of him and the Governor grants him that Rick tries to escape with Lori and Judith but Lori who is carrying Judith is shot and falls to the ground killing both her and the baby after the Governor successfully wins the prison Lily who was already a member of Woodbury and dealt the killing shot on Lori realizes she also killed a baby and gets mad at the Governor when the Governor shows no remorse she shoots him dead in the head after that nothing more is said about the Woodbury group.

These four first seasons of WD were epic.

This is the season I started watching live, this was one of the craziest episodes of live TV I have ever seen. Great reaction as usual :)

it's so weird how the butterfly effect works in this world, without Andrea we wouldn't have had michonne, without Andrea stopping michonne we could have saved hershel, without Carl getting shot we wouldn't have herschel, Maggie, Beth, etc...

Couldn't wait for you to see this episodes, one of the top ones of the whole series. Fact is, Rick got his ass kicked but whether you like the governor or not, he's a bad ass. This episode is just so heartbreaking but the governor finally got what he deserved. I don't think anyone won, now the group is separated and the prison is gone. Great reaction as always, definately gets a like

Do you want a little fact? (If you haven't heard it yet). Remember when Andrea ran through the woods in Season 2 and was rescued by Michonne? So: under the hood was the actress playing Sasha (Sonqua Martin Green), she was originally supposed to play Michonne

This episode is a masterpiece!

I mourned for days after this episode. This is thee most emotional episode still to date. Even 11 seasons later there was no death like the death of Herschel. It broke my heart

Rick was shot on the leg and his hand is still messed up from his fight with tyreese so that's partlt why he was losing so badly to the governor

Rick isn’t spineless, and he got beat up because he has just been shot in the leg affecting his balance. Not to mention still had a broken hand from the Tyrese fight. Might as well throw in he was up all night fixing a fence and then killing walkers.

“Crazy lady” saying “you don’t get to come back from things” and ricks speech in this episode “but we can still come back, we’re not too far gone. We get to come back, I know we all can change” and then the governor striking Hershel followed by the crazy lady as a callback to that moment gets me every time. Also Maggie’s cry omfg.

As you can imagine, this is a big game changer for the show !. The prison is destroyed, Hershel & baby Judith are dead and the group is broken up without knowing each other’s location :(. The second half is gonna be an emotional trip ;). Atleast the Governor has finally bitten the dust. Although in a way he has kind of won in the end. I’m still a bit pissed though that he mentioned Andrea but there was no mention of Merle :(. And you are correct: The 1 zombie that walks into the prison is actually the woman Rick tried to help in episode 1.

You could see how much of an amazing acting Andrew did. The helplessness and the please attitude he portrayed was amazing.

"I wanna see RIck get angry. Really really angry" ah. those are some infamous thoughts for this episode XD Also, Trin...I am sending you a virtual hug from here in Japan. I don't believe I have heard you this distraught before.

Been waiting for this one for awhile, very happy it came out on my birthday! The tank, the final shot, even the dialouge from that shot is all from the comic. To some extent the Governors death is too, though he's shot by a woman called Lily in the books, a character whose backstory was filled out by novels. Also in the comic, spoilers for anyone who wants to read it (but I warn you, its rough at times) - - - - - - this is where Lori dies in the comic. Her and Judith are killed her, with Lori being shot though Judith. Its brutal, though Lily, the woman who kills them both and no idea who shes aiming at and when she finds out shes incredibly pissed, to the point of killing the Govenor. Its a brutal ending to Lori, though her ending in season 3 is also pretty brutal, just in a different way. Its also real brutal for Judith. Loving the reactions, looking forward to the second half of the season, its a highlight of the whole show for me. Extra note: Hershals death in the comics is kind of Axels death I guess? hes shot in the yard, also someone else gets Hersehls death in the comics but don't really want to say who until some time later.

Man.. such a terrible way for such a great character to go out. His journey was cut too short. We’ll be missing our wise voice of reason. RIP Hershel & rest easy to the great actor himself, Scott Wilson. He’ll be deeply missed. ❤️

I cannot tell you how long I've been looking forward to you two to get to this episode

I never noticed that lady that found Rick in the woods with the husband head showed back up this is why I watch reactions ❤

The fall of the prison, the end of an era. This is one of the biggest episodes. also this airs on cable they didnt show lori getting eaten so they definitely wouldn't show judith.

So, I really appreciate this channel. Hershel's death got spoiled for me all those years ago and in a unique way I get to relive the experience of not missing out because of you guys

I LOVE how proud Hershell looks of Rick just before the Governor swings the sword.

I remember before I had actually watched the show I walked in on my brother watching this episode and I saw the governor kill Hershel and I CRIED 😭 I didn't even know the context but I cried and now I cry everytime I rewatch it

never get over Hershel's death😭 right after he smiles at Rick like a proud father

I’ve also been waiting for this particular episode and the season ahead…definitely my favorites

First and foremost RIP to Hershel and Scott Wilson who played Hershel died IRL October 3 2017 I really miss him. I've been waiting for you guys to watch this one. All the fans can agree with that. I cried and cried plot with this episode. Great reaction again Rob and Trin and I'm ready for more

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO TO COME OUT SINCE YALL STARTED SEASON 4 😭😩

I love how this episode is soooo intense, massive character deaths and things happening and yet Rob is still smiling when a walker attacks Daryl and is like “we know he’ll be fine”. Lol that’s just how badass Daryl is. Even the show runners themselves can’t kill him and we know it. 😂 Gimple would be writing in the death and Daryl would pop up with his crossbow or some shit in the writing room. 😂

I was literally waiting for the notification. Which I’m sure a lot of people were, especially for this episode!

So glad to see the governor gone. The actor did phenomenal in making me hate him

Been waiting all week. My favorite episode followed by no sanctuary and no way out

You guys are about to see some of the best episodes in the entire series

This show is just SO good, and episodes like these just make it that much more perfect.

I think Hershel's death hit me harder than anyone because my grandfather lived on a farm like that and he reminded me of my grandfather so much.

Thanks so much for the content! I always look forward to seeing your reactions during my breaks not only because it's fun seeing people love the shows I love, but it's a nice distraction from everything for 40 minutes or so. I know what's ahead in this series, and can't wait to see your thoughts in it! :)

The Moment i saw Hershel smile i knew he was done

Ive been holding my tongue waiting for this episode! Thank you guys for the hours upon hours of content you produce for us :)

such a good reaction CHILLS !!

Another great reaction video. This episode, while devastating, it pays dividends. In time you will see. Hershel had a profound affect on people. And you will continue to see this play out over time. These people carry Hershel and his wisdom, and his sensibilities forward. Look forward to the next few episodes. That's all I can say. See you on Sunday! 👍

The title of this episode says it all. No winners here -- stalemate. According to David Morrissey, each actor receives one script at a time. Nobody knows what will happen in the next episode! When it's your time to die, they tell you ahead of time so that you can prepare yourself. When it's over, the showruners and cast treat you to dinner!

This episode broke my heart 🥲 poor Hershel.

Now it's time to follow more wonderful reactions, because you throw all the emotion and also exhibit sensitivity and logical thinking in the comments. I've watched this series twice, I cried in this episode the first time I saw it, but the second time I really realized how important Herschel was in this group, in the chaos of the zombie apocalypse, how much he brought values ​​to his daughters and also for Rick in building a new world that thinks of the past world. The appreciation of life, of the family, of building a strong community that would bring together those who wanted to fit in there. All of this Rick absorbed from Herschel. This episode only confirms the narrative that the series has brought with the governor in most episodes in which he appears, the dissimulation and persuasion, how a horrible person can be cute when he wants to, or even have feelings like every human being, but his essence is malevolent, therefore, so are your intentions. They usually don't change. He's a great villain. And Rick's line trying to find a point of consensus, but knowing he had a huge chance of not getting agreement (his voice and expressions said so) is brightened by the interpretation of the great Andrew Lincoln. And Herschel's proud smile before the beheading😭😭. In fact, Rick's heroism is put aside to give Michonne her turn in the final attack, in addition to putting him in the position of an ordinary man, who, regardless of his skills and leadership, can't be a man of steel. Perfect.

This episode changes The Walking Dead forever.

yeah, Rick needed that ass kickin'. no more farmer Rick. great video guys.

Brilliant reaction and a long time coming! I think that for me, his episode begins the most defining era of the show, pure brilliance and story driven perfection.

I’ve been waiting for this all week

This episode was rough, especially being 11 when it first aired. Hershel was genuinely such an important part of this group. Not to mention his actor who has since passed. Rip Hershel, Rip Scott

I sometimes wonder why the Governor didn’t kill Michonne and rather chose to kill Hershel.

This was the one I was telling yall I was waiting for. Love this episode, one of the most climactic of the whole series. And I absolutely cannot wait for yall to see who becomes the voice of reason. Its my next favorite character once hershel dies.

Scott Wilson, who played Herschel, was in a classic movie in the 60's called In Cold Blood. He played a member of a group of murderers who killed a family.

Ever since I started watching you guy's I've patiently waited till you got to this episode. Just all out war the entire time.

Saw this episode so many times, i'm always shocked and in tears, R.i.p Hershel 😢

Welcome to The Walking Dead. Always expect the unexpectable. Always. And especially from now on.

Hershel softened Rick. He has now left. There is no longer a voice of reason. To the mother and daughter. I mean the little one plays in the sandbox so to speak (what else is she supposed to do?) and the mother is on a viewpoint to keep an eye on everything. Which she did. She saw a walker in the water. And show me the mother who shoots at her daughter from a distance when there is a zombie right behind her. The daughter was between mother and zombie. No one even shoots in the direction of their own child. In addition, in a state of excitement and full of adrenaline.

Yes, Andrea blocked Michone on killing the Governor, but she failed as well not taking Carol's advice. She could have ended it; she was all about not wanting anyone to get hurt...look what it came too....

One of my favorite episodes of all time. It’s just so damn good.

I loved your reaction! Especially Trin’s, it reminded me of how exactly I felt and screaming at the TV when everything went down. And then realizing waiting a few months for the next episode. Enjoy the ride, more to come!

I love the 2nd half of this season. The finale and season 5 opening are some of the best in the series.

Rick was also shot in the leg moments before he had to fight the governor...

Hold on now guys. Go back and watch again. Rick got shot by the Governor right then. I think he did fabulously for a guy who was just gut shot.

Yay! This is in my top 5 for sure!

“We have a tank” Yeah?! Well we have a DARYL!