I really loved the way the rocks and the water were painted. Especially the ripples and shadows in the water!

Welcome Home! You were missed! Been binge watching old videos. Enjoyed this one and now I am determined to join you next year! Thank you!

Bonjour Paul, je suis époustouflée par le réalisme de cette aquarelle. Merci pour le partage

I live in Venice Mestre, in a historic residence (Villa Malvolti) which has always been a good subject for me. I was an illustrator and cartoonist and taught watercolor for twenty years. I like your free technique, not conditioned by the traditional school which does not accept the use of white. I also used a mixture of water and bleach sometimes using the nib and interesting effects come out, especially rocks and water. My name is due to the fact that I am Scottish, but I have lived in Italy since I was a child. I like to think I'm a descendant of William Payne who created Payne's Grey! I follow you with pleasure. As if I were walking around with you looking for watercolor places!

hello Paul ravie de vous retrouver quelle belle aquarelle🤩 alors au boulot ☺🎨🖌. Encore un bel exercice, merci beaucoup.

I think this is one of the most beautiful paintings of yours.. I love how you have used colors in this piece. Hats off.. no words .. two weeks wait was worth it Thanks you so much as usual for being so kind❤

Welcome back Paul.. we miss u when you’re gone. How beautiful Ibiza is! The rocks! Amazing… forgot about the credit card.. ill dig mine up buried in my supplies 😊… Great lesson…

Buen día Paul. I see you had a great vacation. The Balearic Islands are beautiful islands, I have been there myself several times. Greetz from rainy Holland

Oh Paul! I think you excelled yourself with this one❤. I really wanted to sit on those rocks in the sunshine and dangle my feet in the water! Love it!

Welcome back! Glad you n Margot had a fab trip, Paul! This painting is Sublime. So much better than the photo. You are so talented! Up until now I thought Karen Rice was the Queen of the Store-card-rocks But no, it's YOU!! (Well, King maybe! 😆) Wow, are those rocks just fantastic!! If only I had a shot glass of your skill! Thanks for this Gorgeous tutorial. Mel in Devon 🍰🌻

You have such beautiful Paintings! Inspire ideas.🎨 Thank you! 🙏 To all who watch this video good, creative mood.🥰😉🤗

Le linee morbide dei tuoi acquerelli sono stupende. Hanno carattere e una forte identità. Grazie mille e al prossimo lavoro che aspettiamo tutti con gioia! Alessandra 💓

This is so lovely, Paul. I hope to join you and your lovely wife on one of your retreats. Thanks for always inspiring me to paint ❤

Hats off for going beyond most tutorials with the rocks and tree shade on the water. I always avoid painting rocks as I have had such poor results, but with your technique of the card, it looks doable 😂 though you only make it look easy. Your figures, also very helpful and believable, thanks for the finishing touches, pastels, really brings the scene to life. Loved the musical offerings and that they all had an accordions ! Salute to you 🍺

Brilliant. The water is amazing Paul. Looks a tricky one this. I will save it for my Sunday leisure painting

Lot many insights to enhance our skills...... Rocks, trees, reflections.... everything..thanks a lot....

Fabulous tutorial as always, dear Paul. It is one of the best painting of yours. Lovely scene .

Wonderful ❤…. I will most certainly try this….. btw I could tell by your tanned hand that you have been somewhere bright and sunny 😃

looks like another great place to paint. This seascape absolutely beautiful. Welcome back, Sherry.

I've missed you. You are a charming great instructor and I really enjoy your videos

An excellent and most informative demonstration put together in your usual entertaining way, and I’ve learned something which is always a bonus. 16:18

Wow, thats fabulous....and I've just learnt how to comment on here....thanks for all your lovely tutorials Paul.

Glad to see you back Mr. Clark. We all missed you so. But so glad you had a wonderful time on that island with so much beautiful scenes and blue seas. And thanks for this terrific painting. The rocks, seas and ripples are authentic looking and so are the skies. There is a question I want to ask. Should I use oil pastell or chalk pastell? I have some oil pastells and I would like to know if they're appropriate.

it makes me happy just to see you paint and having a good time with it! You're such a good teacher! Love the beach scene! Cheers!!!

I love the water. Thank you Paul

What a great technique for painting rocks. They look so realistic. Thank you for so generously sharing your amazing talent. Love the painting.

So beautiful ,👏. ,🙏 for this inspiring tutorial. In the beginning of the tutorial there was a nice picture of a very old and grey tree laying at the beach, I would like to see you painting something like that to see how you paint the structure of the wood.

I am so glad to hear you. Beautiful work!

Dear Paul, your tutorial is great as always! Thank you for this opportunity to feel the atmosphere of Ibiza paradise view. Hope we can repeat 10% of what you did. Have a nice time! Lilia from Moldova

Love the way you make water seem to move in your work As always Thank you for sharing Paul!

I am diggn' those bagpipes!!! Such a lovely video! I love the final touches on the water! No reply necessary.. life is busy!

Good teacher for my level. You are easy to follow your routine by labeling color to use. Thank you for sharing. Mart

Always awesome! Thank you! Hugs from Ukraine )

Beautiful! Especially enjoy watching you create the rocks and details with the water. Thank you!!

Stunning! my mouth still open...😮

Gorgeous painting! :) Do you ever think of making a tutorial on mistakes made in mid painting? How to mask them or fix them or just start a new one? Also, I would LOVE to see a rainstorm/heavy rain tutorial from you!

These rocks look so natural and really very good paintng.

Thanks Paul...That's the nearest to the Sun I have been so far this year.😂 A lovely cheerful picture 👍

Such a nice painting!

Paul, thank you for the mini tour. Mother nature is brilliant. I am in Illinois after 18 years in Hawaii. I always say what I miss is the ocean. I'm in a watercolor pencil class. It's really fun. And your plastic card trick is wonderful. I practice pages of rocks. What a difference it made. Again thank you for sharing your lovely work.

Love this, especially the rocks. So much easier in watercolor than pastel. Thank you for sharing.

Thank you Paul I’m learning so much from you thanks for sharing your skill.

Thank you for the beautiful and relaxing video with wonderful music. I enjoyed watching and listening to it very much.

Amazing rocks and water !

Beautiful!! Your rocks are fantastic! Thank you for your time

Such a pleasure to paint!! I spent a lovely afternoon getting lost in the lights nuances, waves, rocks... loads of thanks!! 🙏🙏

Absolutely beautiful as always

This tutorial is definitely on my to do list. I need to practice that card technique for the rocks and have a go at those water reflections. The movement you've captured in those reflections is wonderful.

Thank you Paul and Margo for taking us along with you! I loved seeing the video of the island. It’s beautiful! Your painting is amazing! I love the water!

Marvellous, amazing painting

Awesome. Love the beach.

Awesome!!! All of it! Painting, people, place...

So very beautiful ❤️ I could live there so easily. Away from everything.

You made painting the water look so easy to do. I have always struggled with water and reflections - like a block, but your video made sense of it for me. Thank you so much for sharing your skills and knowledge with us.

I love your enthusiastic sing a long 🎵. Enjoyed this tutorial so much I did it twice . Thank you Paul for such a beautiful subject to study and paint 🎨 🏝️!

That's a painting that really makes me want to go there. Just beautiful as always. ; )

New to your channel must say your tutorials really are the best

un merveilleux travail comme toujours bravo, vos tutos m'inspire et je progresse grâce à vous merci Paul

The details are Amazing. I think I start getting nervous when it comes to detail and too often stick to the less is more theory. I need to get over that and finish my painting! Thank you for sharing 😊

Perfect timing for this video. I just painted a sea beach scene and it wasn’t good. I’ll have another go after watching this. Thank you! EDIT my main problems were the sea and the white waves.

Lovely painting. Every bit was brilliant. Thanks for this tutorial.

Fabulous, Paul. Thank you for sharing this beautiful work. I especially loved your treatment of the rocks. I have been struggling with rocks for weeks now…..and I think you’ve helped me so much. Bravo.

Beautiful just gorgeous ! ❤❤❤

Very nice I should have a go at more of these. I'm currently working on birds but will definitely be watching this again and probably again so I can understand and not just see what is happening. Thank you

I absolutely love the water reflections and ripples! You always make it look so achievable. Thank you for always sharing your work with us and making tutorials.

Well donePaul. An excellent video.. But if it takes you three hours I hate to think how long it would take me! But very inspiring.

Och, you missed me diving off that rock at the front🏊‍♀️, oh well😂😂 Love the light on the light on the sea and the misty green trees..no a bad job at all m'lad😉

OMG!!! This is stunning. Can't wait to watch this, Paul.

Thank you for all the techniques you've demonstrated, much appreciated... Lovely painting as all your paintings are💕

Thanks greatly Paul for your inspirational video of the ibiza beach scene, greatly explained how to create the best result which you have achieved with amazing colours depth and detail

Спасибо,Паул! Добрых путешествий!

Fantastic demo!👌Thank you for sharing😊

Oh this is such a beautiful painting, I wish I had been there! Thank you Paul.

Many many blessings to you from Kennewick WA

what a great painting you have done-love it

Can’t wait to paint this 😍 looks amazing! Thank you so much for all of these great tutorials! It is clear that you put a lot of effort to create them. You are the best!! I really like the way you explain / teach how to paint. You make it fun! 😊 Thank you!!

Love this video and how relaxed you are, thanks for sharing!❤

Just catching up with the tutorials. Loved this one. Always enjoy the clips of your painting holidays. The bagpipe music was incredible! Had no idea that the instrument was that versatile. Thanks so much.

What a beautiful place to be and paint!

Wow! Those rocks! You make it look so easy.

Stunning piece, Paul. Way better than the photograph. As always, love to watch your process...such clever techniques. And of course, you make it look deceptively simple. Some day I hope to make it to one of the retreats.

Amazing. Adore the mixed media. Very freeing.

Beautiful Painting !!

This has to be my favorite tutorial of yours ever! Water and beaches are what I truly love and I’ve been focusing on painting them lately along with boats. I grew up on the water so this one is special. Thanks so much and I can’t wait to try this one tomorrow ! You’re the very best 😀

So so good, beautiful!

You make it look so easy! This one is beautiful!

I was pleasantly surprised to see your video today! One of my favorites! I loved seeing the water transformed into its photo-like quality... with each little touch! Also loved the rocks!!! Welcome back, Sir Paul & Margot! Thank you for sharing this & the exquisite photos of Ibiza! See you in 2 weeks... with love from a California Gramma ❤️

Un beau voyage merci c est magnifique

What she said, Krittika Biswas. Full agreement, wonderful, lovely, beautiful painting. I'll be studying how you painted this, especially the reflection and rocks.

Absolutely beautiful!!! Thank you!

Beautiful! I’m always amazed how easy you make it look.

Thank you for this detailed tutorial. I learnt a lot, beautiful painting. Much appreciated. Thanks!

one word !! WOOOOOOOOOOW !!!

WOW 🤩 What a beautiful place! Thanks so much for sharing. Looks like you two had a blast. And your painting is amazing, as usual! 👍😁

Beautiful as always!

Beautiful again! And the guitar was great! Thankyou! Have a nice break! XXX

I will work more on my rocks. Thanks for this video. Very helpful! So appreciate you.

It’s amazing how easy you make everything look. I hope one day to be a much better watercolorist. Cheers 🍻

OMG! What a gorgeous place. I love your videos.

Thank you so much,I learned technics about many details in this beautiful seascape ....