I never thought this song would actually have this meaning for Astro and Aroha..

이 가사… 원래도 너무 슬펐는데 이젠 정말 우리의 이야기가 되어버렸네 빈아… 아직도 난 니가 없는 이 세상이 너무 서럽고 슬퍼서 이겨내기가 너무 힘들어. 정말 미래의 내가 나타나서 니가없는 세계의 나도 어떻해든 버티고 살아가고있다고 말해줬으면 좋겠다… 너의 아픔보다는 너의 빛났던 모습을 끊임없이 기억하고 추억하면서…

Rest in peace my dear Binnie, now our nights will be brighter because the Moon joined the stars.

人の死を受け入れるのは簡単に出来る事では無いです。いっぱい泣き… 枯れるぐらい毎日泣いています。 1人で抱え込まないで彼の死を受け入れるの時間かかります。泣いても泣いても帰ってこない😢 でもムンビンが望んで居るのはファンや関わる人達に笑っていて欲しい事。 その為に今は無理に笑わないで 泣きたい時には沢山泣きましょう… 辛い気持ち共有しましょ。彼が残してくれた物を無駄にしない為に👍

Astro’s vocals are freaking good, makes you feel goosebumps all over upto the deepest core of your soul…

I'm so glad to see this song finally get an MV! For those who may not know, this song was a digital release in Japan back in 2021, and is now being made more widely available for streaming. It has such pretty drama OST vibes. Also our honey-vocalist MJ, it's so nice to hear his voice again after all this time! :)

Who watched Sanha recreating the scene of train passing by on his instagram? He misses his bin hyung so much and seems like he wants to say goodbye but cant 💔

ビニとのヨントンの時間はずっと忘れません。直接愛してますといえて良かったです。ビニは仲間や家族を大切にして自分の身を削ってまで人を楽しませていつも素敵な笑顔をありがとう。元気を与えてくれてありがとう。他の世界ではゆっくりと体を休めて安らかにお眠りください。

I am not expecting to hear MJ's voice since he is in military but when I heard him, tears start to form in my eyes. He is the most perfect singer to deliver this kind of song. I love Astro so muchhh.

It has been so long since the whole group came together...missed MJ's vocals!!! The whole song..the feels..the vocals..the rap..amazing. ASTRO rocks!!!

Listening to this song after the news hits harder than it should

이 가사 원래 들을때부터 슬펐는데 현실이 되어버렸네…빈아 거기서도 행복해…아직도 너가 떠나버렸다는게 믿기질 않아…

no one must have imaged that the story of this song will become a real deal for astro and for arohas,now hearing this again it feels like the untold words of moonbin and it pierces through the heart

辛くて悲しくて、この曲を聴きにきました サヨナラなんてまだ言えません

Astro has one of the best vocalists in kpop industry sadly they're not as known as other kpop groups. I did the best thing by stanning them.

And then Sanha left us in tears by re-creating the last scene when he visited Japan to heal from what he had to endure.

自然と涙が溢れ出して止まらない。 さよならじゃなくてまたねだよっ🥺

This song hits different now 😔 It’s been a month since you left us Binnie😭 I’m happy that you’re safe now and that you won’t feel pain anymore. The world is getting cruel day by day that’s why God decided to save you so you don’t have to suffer anymore. It’s hard for us because we won’t be able to see you bright smile and hear your voice but atleast you are now free and you can do what you want. We’ll see each other soon 🤍💜

もう辛すぎて無理だ… なんで置いていくの、？ まだアロハと一緒にいてくれると思ってた。 まだ信じられない、優しい声で歌って欲しい、可愛い笑顔がまた見たいしみんなで楽しそうにわちゃわちゃしてる姿がもう見れないなんて… 嘘だって思いたいのに、5ヶ月経とうとして、なんとなくいなくなっちゃったのが飲み込めてきているのが嫌だよ、まだ嘘だって思っていたいのに受け入れたくないよ、またアロハの前にあの笑顔で戻ってきて欲しいよ… 欲張りかもしれないけどずっと元気でいてくれるだけでよかった アイドルだってやめてよかったし、体調だって完全に良くなるまで休んでてもよかった。

The song just hit different now😭 Binnie my love🥺 how can I say goodbye to you ?💔💔💔💔

This song for rocky😭😢 i will miss him

Just listen to this again after Sanha's IG post. I'm feeling so much pain inside my heart 💔😭😭

완전체 마지막 뮤비구나 의미심장한 가사에 은우가 떠날지 알았는데 락키가 떠났네 7년간 고생했고 다들 각자 위치에서 더 승승장구하길 마지막을 기념할 멋진 뮤비 찍어준 차은우에게 무한 감사 🫠

This hits differently now, cause the person i love the most was bin ❤️‍🩹

Listening to this while reading the meaning of the lyrics with the sudden news of Moonbin's passing,,,,,, 💔

Love you Moonbin. Miss your voice like crazy.

ASTROはスペイン語で星……(天体) ほんとうに輝く星になってしまった どうかみんなのことを見守っていてほしい ……ただ、送り出す心の気持ちも出来ていない 家族や友人、メンバー、世界中の아로하はどうしたらいいかまだ混迷の中にいる ビニという光を失って……

It's incredibly sad and painful to come back to these songs after hearing about Moon Bin! May he rest in peace, he'll be missed dearly 🖤

ウヌのMVが気になり見ました。聴いているうちに涙が止まらなくなり今でも終わらせることができないでいる片思い!一番好きな人にサヨナラが言えないで苦しんでいます。バカな私です。涙が出て止まらなくなるのに何回でも聴きたくなります。

ASTRO singing in japanese is a masterpiece!

Watching this mv knowing Moonbin is now in paradise. I can't help but cry in silent. 😭

Life must go on ...let's Rocky go with his destiny..be happy your fans arround the world waiting all your work Astro..smile and happy okay GODs never sleep to protect pure human being..belive that.🥰💫🌟🫶

astroのファンではなかったけど、ムンビンさんのことはほんとに衝撃的でした。 そんなときにこの曲を聴いて、ファンじゃなかった私にもすごく刺さりました。 好きな人に対しての曲だと思うのに、こんなにも重なるような曲を聴いて涙が止まりませんでした。 こんなにも素敵な曲をありがとう。

The lyrics now hit so much different. Binah, my ot6, my astro I miss you all so much. It's hard to not cry while remembering beautiful memories with you all. I will always be by your side and will wait for you. Love you all so much forever

Came back here after hearing that Rocky has left Astro and Fantagio. My heart is broken but I still wish Rocky all the best in his journey T-T This song cuts deeper now that Rocky is no longer a part of Astro. The 7 years with ASTRO as OT6 will remain a beautifully shining memory in my mind and heart. #MJ #JinJin #ChaEunWoo #MoonBin #ROCKY #Sanha #OT6 #ASTRO It won't be the same without you, Rocky T-T

차은우 웃을때 같이 미소짓고 울때 맘이 찡해지는데.. 노래랑 뮤비 너무 어울리고 예뻐ㅠㅠ아련한 아날로그 감성..청춘 그잡채…

Mr Eunwoo Cha perfect actor all HIS mimic Soo PERFECT .SAD ending for THE MOST person to say GOODBYE👌🖤🫰.

Now let's cry because this song hits differently now. O love you Binnie, for ever

Now this song hits different. Rest in peace my "Moon"

데시벨 태룡이도 그렇게 찌통이더니 아스트로 뮤비 결말까지 너무 슬픈거 아니냐고ㅠㅠㅜㅠ…차은우 요즘 내 눈물버튼 되버림ㅠㅠ

この曲も刺さるけど、女神降臨もなかなか見てて辛かったです。 絶対忘れないよ。これからもみんなを見守ってくださいね。 私もASTROのみんなを応援し続けます👍

ファンになって　数日な私　遅すぎたのかな😔 数週間前に初めて チャウヌさんのドラマと出会い惹かれて　アストロの歌と踊りを見て　もっと好きになり　ムンビンさんがいないと知り　この歌を生で聞けなくなってしまったんだなって悲しくなった 悲しい　残された人は　それでも前を向いて耐えないといけない 辛いです😔 もっと早くに出会いたかった

even if the somethings without notice, hopefully you who listen to this song will receive gentle consolation through songs with his tone. let’s be stronger person for alive . today you can cried as you want. but in someday you’ll be fine and smile with beautiful memory about him . let’s hugs together roha💜

rocky's singing is so beautiful

この曲はASTROのメンバー皆の声にピッタリで大好きなナンバーの１つです。楽しいASTROの違う魅力が感じられる切ないバラード、最高です🥰🥰🥰

Aaa. MoonBin's sweet voice.

優しい性格と暖かくて素敵な笑顔で、メンバー、AROHAだけでなく周りのたくさんの人を助けて/幸せのエネルギーを与えすぎて、自分に使うエネルギーが足りなくなっちゃったのかな。 抱えきれない幸せをもらったのに返し終わらなくてごめん。 あなたを想う多くの人たちから離れずにずっとそばにいてほしい。

Moonbin 🖤 I will say goodbye to the love of my life 🕊 🖤 😭 😭 😭 I love you

Always support Eun Woo and Astro

My yesterday MV on air with Stange person , his last question was..why you down here? This place is my home. Than i leave him on train 🤭 what a miracles from YT turn into my life 🤭.weird scaryyyyyyy and aghhhhhhhh🤭

Listening to this song, it's like ASTRO was saying they will never again be the ASTRO that we know. Was this their goodbye to Aroha😢❤. It's sad but if that is the case, all the best boys. Can't say we will not miss you, it's hurts for us can't imagine how everything feels for you. Goodbye is never easy so we'll say, until next time. ❤❣️👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

"even in a world without you" "I'm happy as long as you are happy" "I'm sad, I'm lonely, I'm in pain" " I will say goodbye to the love of my life" - Moonbin, my shining star. Rest easy now I will continue be there for your family, brothers and friends for you. You've done well.

oh my god this pulled at my heartstrings this was so beautiful ;-; how do they always sing such a beautiful song that is so sweet but so sad 🤧

「なんとかやってると教えて欲しい 君がいなくなったその世界でも」 一回会ったっきり、もう一生ビニに会えないなんて😭

Here I am again.

I love how sweet Rocky's voice sounds on this song. Dong Min always knows how to convey the right emotion in each scene. We have to give this video a lot of views, they deserve it 💜💜💜💜💜💜

My goodness I am speechless!!! 😭😭everything about this is beyond beautiful just PURE PERFECTION, their outstanding vocals and multi talents are a given but the lyrics to their songs always hits truly deep into your heart and soul, us Aroha are the luckiest!!! Makes me so happy to hear our precious OT6 singing together, love you sweet angels forever 💜 always stan Astro!!!!

泣く泣く泣いた😭 みんな、みょんさん、じぬさん、ウヌ、ビニ、ラキ、サナ、みんなだいすこだよ!

너무 사랑해 진짜 너무너무..사랑해 아스트로!! 각자의 자리에서 멋지게 빛나고있자 언젠가 다시 뭉치는 날에는 아로하가 너희에게 잊을 수 없을만큼 멋진 날을 선물해줄게오하고🍀🌟

日本語の発音めっちゃ綺麗🥺 こんな素晴らしい歌をありがとう🥰

日本語で歌ってくれてることが凄く嬉しいです☺️💖ありがとうございます！！！ウヌくん、忙しい中MV撮影お疲れ様でした🌷ありがとうございます！

빈아 … 너로 인해 이 노래를 알게 됐고 가사가 우리 이야기 같아 또 눈물이 나고 아려온다 가수해줘서 고마워 영원히 너의 목소리를 기억할 수 있게 해줘서 너무 고마워 이별은 언제나 시리고 익숙해지지 않는 낯선 감정이지만 잘 이겨내볼게 잘 자 나의 우주 바이바이

It's been a year after Moonbin died, but every time I hear this song tears will flow by themselves. 🥲😭

次は6人でのMVや、6人で歌ってるステージを見たいです💜

ムンビンが空の星になってからこの曲を聴くとほんとに悲しくなる 人は亡くなってから4年5ヶ月かかって生まれ変わるらしい。来世では幸せな日々を送ってほしいな。 ご冥福をお祈りします

サナくんのインスタからこちらを思い出してきました。 切ないです。

Sayonara Moonbin 💔😔 thank you for everything…

MV見れて幸せ😇 久々にMJヒョンの声聞けたし ヌヌのビジュ神だし よりストーリー性が見えてほんとに感動

the lyrics especially jinjin's part at the end 😭 "but the word won't come out" "but I've lost my voice" deym I'm literally crying

when i saw the news, i instantly remember this song 😭

I love you. All 6 of you. Forever.

The more I see him ..the more I fall for him...and I'm still falling harder....i wish I could meet him in person for atleast once in my life...LOVE EUN WOO FOREVER...LOVE ASTRO FOREVER...

The vocals alone proves that ASTRO deserves more recognition. I mean, I won't be tired telling you guys that don't sleep on them.

Said goodbye for person that you loved you Soo by ASTRO💫

愛してる、ずっと

This song hits different when you just lost a loved one❤️‍🩹

This song sing out my heart .. "We are not gonna be afraid of getting hurt, even sad and pain may stay for a long time❤️‍🩹....but It’s alright and we’ll be fine. Your happiness is all that matters"☄️🫂 Now you should free and happy on the other side, if afterlive really exist, please enjoy your youth, be more selfish and love youself more, find a love who love you as well, dont get sick......ok? 🌕🌖Thank you for being a singer and bring us such many joy and happiness ,you are so sweet and kind...miss you always...

This song, footprint, Eunwoo Focus on Me and Uta - Kaze no Yukue will be my Anthem when I'm missing you Moonbin 🌸🤍

oh I miss you guys so much, Nunu nailed it by singing this song solo... It made me cry, I miss you Binnie...

日本語が綺麗。 感動しました。

this song make me cry louder after all the situation, but astroha fighting life must go on💜

I have lost the love of my life - Moonbin! It's hard to look forward. His voice on this track is beautiful. It's hard and I'm still struggling every single day of his loss. How can I feel better? 💔💔😪😪😩😩😭😭💔💔

Every time I listen to this song it reminds me of how much I miss him. ❤🥺

Eunwoo he's voice so very smooth and very unique voice and he's vocal range is good to heard..♥️♥️😍

大好きな曲です！ 日本語上手い！ 切ない～ サランへ！

Astro's music is incredible, it makes me sad that I can't continue enjoying this group. Despite that, his music will continue in our ears, it transmits many emotions, joy, and sadness, it brings many good and bad memories. That's why I love them and they will continue to be the first group of this genre that I listen to and I will continue to listen to them and I will also expect more music from their members. Great star, you fill my life with the harmony of your voices.

The more i listen to it just getting more sadder.

Astro has a good voice, no matter what genre of song they sing, they always manage to give those who listen to the atmosphere of the song. stay together forever, Aroha will always support Astro💜✨

Our Astro always tries their best to make their Arohas happy

Moonbin's voice is what I'm living for Love you my sweet big kitty

Sayonara ..goodbye to someone who loved you most...goodbye sayonara!

最近しんどいことが続いたけど、この曲に救われてます。ありがとう。

これからもずっとASTROが大好き💜

The end,sayonara,goodbye for someone who loved you MOST goodbye,sayonara,the end.step your own journey by yourself.the end.

Most underrated group in the industry

Escuchar la voz de MyungJun y escucharlos juntos, a pesar de que es una canción que ya conocíamos, me hace llorar igual... Dios!!!!!

Astro's voice compliments with one another. Eunwoo is always a boyfriend material. He always exceeds our expectations! Love this MV of Eunwoo!

Apart from the song itself.. the story of it and the background is literally so sad 😕 and the visuals gives me like 90's early 2000's vibes so its more nostalgic. Bro... this itself felt like ive watched a whole kdrama, reminds me of twenty five twenty one. 💔

What a beautiful guy 💓

This song suddenly plays back to my mix list after hearing Moonbin's sudden news... I don't know how to express this feeling. I feel like a farewell message... I deeply feel sad and lost at the moments just by hearing the melody and reading the lyrics... I can't stop listen to it