Ben de çook özlemiştim 💜😍

Aşırıı tatlı ve komikti dbdbhdhdhdhdh

Enwoo had made an appearance at their concert, but it was to see Sanha and not Binnie. Binnie was the only one sincere, he was too kindhearted 😞😥💔.

@@thachvyana3660 who told you that it was just to see Sanha and not Binnie and Sanha ???? ???

i don't understand how being in someones bday affects their friendship? i'm sure they have celebrated countless bdays for all the members. This year they were all extremely busy with their schedule jin jin was practising for his musical, mj on military, sahna and moonbin were releasing a new album and cha eun woo had to travel half around the world.... its normal that they didn't see each other much besides they were on a break and they were about to start as a group again, we can't come to conclusions without knowing them personally and why moonbin celebrated without them( cause he wasn't alone seungwan was with him).. ..its unfair to them.... who said that jin jin and eunwoo went to see live only sahna and not both? moonbin's tragedy is something really personal and painful for the fans but mostly for his close ones. from what i've seen binnies people including the other members, were always close and together but some things can't be helped by others.... so please leave them alone in their grief and support them while keeping monnbins memory alive! ( this comment is not against someone its cause i read a lot of agressive comments)

@@lovemoonland well, all of this are mere speculations but even may Korean netizens have always commented that Binnie's blood was in EunWoo's hands. They were always saying that EunWoo played a huge part in Binnie's death emotionally ALLEGEDLY.

@@onesoul1s I can't believe in these kind of speculations even if people say them it's extremely HEAVY and mean to blame someone for that especially someone you don't know inmao ... so I'm gonna ignore people who say that even if they are Koreans behind them there could be a lot of reasons to do it especially with a famous person like cha eun woo who was always in the bad list as someone who was in the industry only cause of his looks. Lastly people who believe that and say that shouldn't call themselves arohas, fans of moonbin but most importantly Humans I understand the frustration but we should never touch things that we don't know . ( of course I'm not talking specifically about anyone) Hope binnies soul remain in peace as it should be❤️. And we fans hold on and try to make him happy by being happy have a nice day!( and sorry for the long reply)

Çoook tatlılarr

Today Sunday,,,today 25/06/2023😊😊😊😊😊

Çok tatlılarr 💜🥹

Only binnie will explain why he ys not there or jjn jin should know too

You are asking the right question. Although it is still very painful for me, I tell myself that Binnie is now with the Lord and the evil and dirty spirits cannot reach him nor harm him anymore. Our duty is to cherish and honor his precious memories he left us.🥺💔❤️‍🩹💝❤️‍🔥💖

⁠​⁠@@thachvyana3660Binnie celebrated his 25 & last birthday with the staff & Aroha online, made his own Bday cake. He said members call wish happy bday. Life is unfairly treated our beloved Binnie. Good & bad Kama will come, let not drilling into the past. Love you forever bb Binnie.

I have seen a video of March 30, 2023 where moonbin also joined sanha and Jin Jin and were fooling around with eun woo.. see the video of butt hitting .. so I feel this video where only sanha n jin jin are there must have been of 29th late night where they brought in the birthday and next they celebrated with moonbin.. possible.

@@ThaoLe-js8hb You are all snakes! Can you explain to me how Moonbin was going to be at Eunwoo's 27th birthday? Black karma will catch up with you all soon! Snakes!

Astro members shared these videos on Astro's official twitter account.

I too got that feeling. I seems he wasn't too happy that they interrupted his Celebrations with his other friends. I thought he will jump thrilled on seeing them. Of course this impression is formed because of his expressions.. I may be wrong..

of course Bin wasn't there. It was Jinjin filming. That's why camera is shaking crazily when Jinjin puts birthday cap on Eunwoo

@@semidash forse non hai capito. Io parlavo della persona al tavolo che non viene ripresa, mentre le altre due sì. Era BIN che riprendeva con il telefono Sanha e Jin Jin. Aveva già il telefono in mano. E chi non lui poteva sapere che Jin Jin e Sanha avrebbero fatto la sorpresa a Eunwoo? E poi perché offuscarlo?

​@@user-hp1ye5on8dohh I really got you wrong. I'm sorry. What person do you mean, wearing a white cap or the one right next to Eunwoo whose back we see?

@@semidash nè l'uno nè l'altro. E' quello seduto a fianco del ragazzo con il berretto bianco. E' l'unico che non è stato ripreso da Jin Jin e la sua immagine appare sfuocata. Se vedi bene appena loro entrano c'è lo sconosciuto che con il telefono riprende la scena. Quindi significa che sapeva della visita a sorpresa. E poi scusa chi poteva dire a Jin Jin e Sanha dove erano a cena se non Bin? E perchè gli altri si vede chi sono ed hanno offuscato solo uno? Non ha senso. E poi strano che Bin non era insieme a loro a fare la sorpresa.

@@user-hp1ye5on8d ohh I get it now, thank you though that person doesn't look similar to Bin's proportions to me but I'm not sure. BTW, Sanha and Jinjin could know where Eunwoo was not only from Moonbin but from Eunwoo's manager or other staff member

Sorry I can't do that. because i don't know Spanish

Astro members shared these videos on Astro's official twitter account.

@@ASTROSEN k thx

This video was shared on Astro's official Twitter (X) account.

@@ASTROSEN thank you so much💝

I'm not sure as I don't know Chanyeol very well. but what you say may be true

@@ASTROSEN Eunwoo was with his brother and parents! They are the ones who told Jinjin and Sahna where they would be! I'm sick of Aroha vipers! And the very ridiculous ones claiming that Bin was not invited! They are absolutely idiots! Don't you see that that was this year??????

@@MARTHA.Patito what do you mean by that was this year?