when u thought u decided on moonbin as bias but rocky pulls this vocal shit

Moonbin covering Jonghyun’s part is so emotional. hope they both rest peacefully 💔💔

Knowing that moonbin covering Jonghyun's part here making me more emotional. The feeling while watching this will never be the same again...

the fact that he covered jonghyun’s part made me burst in tears. you made our hearts heavy but i hope yours is at rest now.

Isn't rocky a rapper? Wooow that was a amazing vocal he did there👍👍👍👍

2 minutes 57 seconds and the fact they're singing my fav group that got me into kpops debut song is enough to convert me. I need names and ages!

If Rocky in this shocked y'all, allow me to recommend INNOCENT LOVE (by Astro). This man.. Is something.

i´m here to remember everyone they were rookies in this performance and rocky isnt the main vocal, he is a rapper. Stan Astro, Stan Talent

I DIDNT KNOW ROCKY COULD SING LIKE THAT IM SHOOK

Rocky just shook us all with those vocals. Hide your kids, hide your wives, cuz Rocky's out to steal them hearts.

Moonbin singing Jonghyuns parts hits different now 🙏🏻

Remember Rocky being the main vocal here in 2016 and then in 2021 he raps 64 symbols in 8 seconds. Bias wecking everyone since the beginning

Rocky and those high notes tho

/sees video "Oh cute my babies!" /Rocky hits the high notes "I came here to have a good time and I'm honestly feeling so attacked right now."

when a rapper sings like a main vocal that's our rocky sweegg!!

OMG!!! THE GUY WEARING GREEN HOODY HIS VOCAL IS INSANE AND HE'S CUTE OMG!!!!

HOLY F U C K I N G SHIT ROCKY'S VOICE HE'S LIKE A QUINTUPLE THREAT I'VE NEVER BEEN MORE SHOOK IN ALL MY YEARS OF LIVING

rocky did a good job at that high note but why isnt anyone complimenting jinjins vocals? ive been noticing it but jinjin is really underrated that im starting to think everyone is focusing too much on their bias that no one even notice the LEADERS talents.. just to let you know he isnt just amazing at rapping and singing also at dancing and he also is really good at bboying

Why did i see jonghyun face in rocky especially when he hit that high notes 😭😭😭 Really really miss jonghyun

I guess that time many viewers would be thinking that Rocky is one of the main vocals but he is main rapper of the group....as I am new AROHA this side of Rocky is really good to see

I like how the cameraman is focusing on the other members rather than eunwoo all the time. I love u cameraman💓😂

ROCKYS HIGH NOTES AND RUNS I ALMOST THREW MYSELF OFF MY BED THIS IS BEYOND EVERHTHING AROHA HAD EVER ASKED FOR GOD BLESS

Three years ago, I left a comment here how as a Shawol I said this is my favorite cover. Astro did a great job. Seeing it again, and Moonbin singing Jonghyun's part breaks my heart. Rest in paradise, Moonbin.❤

When moonbin started singing jonghyun's part.. I gasped out loud. Because I never expected, the same thing would happen to both of them. It makes me sad. 😞

I know I'm late but WHAT???? A rapper can singing like a lead vocalist??????

i've lost count of how many times i've watched this in the past 3 days help

rocky stole the show man, how isn’t he a main vocal what the heck?!?!?!

Hurts my heart to realize that Moonbin was the one who sang Jonghyun’s part here…

Back here after watching pd101 s2's replay covers and finding it even more impressive how astro pulled off this song. Not that pd101's were bad but Astro's is just on another level

this is the first natural sounding cover I've heard. they sang so well. most other cover I've heard sound very awkward or the voices don't match the song at all but they pulled it off so well

The best Shinee's cover

I don't think I'll ever get over rocky's vocals. ever.

WHEN ROCKY CAN DANCE, RAP, AND SING! STAN TALENT STAN ROCKY.

I think this is the best cover of Replay ever done. Astro fits SHINee's early boyish image so well and they sort or remind me of young SHINee (my bias group is shinee so to me this is a huge ass compliment)

Rest in peace Moonbin, you did good with your work. Thank you for your efforts!❤

Anyone here in 2021? Also I can't ever get over Rocky and his heavenly vocals. You could never tell from this performance that he's a rapper.

I'm fell for Rocky so hard (I broke my face fml) 1. He can rap 2. HE CAN SING SO WELL 3. He can dance 4. THOSE VISUALS

if you dont think Rocky is the most talented boy on earth,, we cant talk

Still the bestest Replay cover ever, not gonna change my mind.

IM NEVER GONNA ADMIT THAT MJ IS ACTUALLY THE ELDEST... i mean look how young and cute mj is... the six of them look like they are classmates...

I feel this deeply cuz when shinee released this song, I didn't feel much since they're all older than me. But with astro there are two members younger than me so I lowkey like when they sing the chorus 👀👀

This is probably the first cover of Replay that actually did the original justice, I love how they put their own color into the song while keeping the original spirit.

I'm a Shawol and this the best cover of Replay SHINee legends💚

so no one's gonna talk about Jinjin's vocals?

came here after watch pd101 😂 now i know that the difference between the trainee and the one who already debuted

When I first saw this I was praying in my head "Please don't butcher my song".. and it was so good! I don't know much about ASTRO, so I'm glad I saw this!

This cover age like a fine wine

Rocky actually seems like jonghyun🥺both are precious

As a Shawol I want to thank to Astro >< This is so fresh OMG ❤ When I saw Astro perform with Replay I just realized that SHINee has growing old lol Sorry love xD xD

actually rocky looks like a main vocal in this performance😂

This is the best cover of replay . No one can change my mind. I don't even stan astro but this...

Shawol turned AROHA thanks to this cover! Stan talent, Stan SHINee/Astro for a healthy life.

I'm a Shawol of 5 years so Astro just went under harsh judging... and they came out well! You did a great job Astro and SHINee would be proud that you guys did well. The guy (sorry, don't know names) doing Jonghyun's stronger lines thankfully didn't try and do the exact same and used his own voice in a great way. I approve!

Do you know the difference of this cover of ASTRO to other groups cover? It sounded natural just like how SHINee does it. Others think Replay is a song where you do aegyo or they think it's cute (I'm not hating on others but I just want to tell that Replay is kinda like innocent? Not being cute. SHINee made it looked cute because of their visuals that time, I MEAN TAEMIN'S HAIRCUT THAT TIME JUST MADE HIM CUTER, not because of their performance.) Plus their voices fitted the song well. That's all. I REPEAT I DONT HATE OTHERS WHO DID A COVER OF REPLAY OKAY I JUST WANTED TO TELL WHAT I THINK IS DIFFERENT AND WHATS MY OPINION. lovelots peeps uwu

mj was 22 jinjin was 20 eunwoo was 19 moonbin was 18 rocky was 17 sanha was 16 the power they have already hold since they were so young but people still sleep on their talents. i’m glad they’re getting more recognition these days.

The one wearing black looks like Jonghyun at some angles. He made me miss him more. Not a fan of astro but they did a great job

Well. Frick. Now I'm confused. You got Rocky, who can rap, sing, AND dance like he's trying to break the stage, JinJin who is basically the same, but THE DEEP VOICE THO, Moonbin who has a good voice and is a good dancer, MJ with those *Slaying Vocals*, Eunwoo who is absolutely adorable, and I ADORE his cute nasally voice, then Sanha the giant puppy. I- I can't- They make me want to simultaneously jump off a bridge and sing my little heart out. ALL 6 OF THEM-

when you come back to this video to peep at rocky again bc he's a quadruple threat omg LMAO

I'm pretty surprised by Rocky here😭💕

Best shinee replay cover.

Fantagio's artists are actually actors/actresses that can sing, dance, and rap also model.

The boy in green sings so well. He is handsome too.

sanha is so charming, i get chills every movements he does!!!!!! help... please stop moving sanha.

I need Rocky to cover Jonghyun more because damn he does his parts well.

When the lead rapper/main dancer can sing like a main vocal.....well damn.😨😱

Rocky sang Jonghyun’s part.... Jonghyun must be proud ❤️ You’ll always be in our hearts Jonghyun Oppa ❤️

Rocky became my bias after this. Jonghyun is my bias in SHINee and I have not heard someone covering him like Rocky did!!! Amazing (I also think that both look alike a little)

Rocky's high note just hit's me a lot

I'm a 9 year shawol so when I saw the title of this video, I was like "I know I didn't just see some rookies cover my babies. Man I'm ready to judge" BUTTTT HEY!! It may seem rude for me to say so but I didn't expect them to do so well! Thumbs up! And most importantly, I think they really add their own color to the song!

This group is so underrated. They should be worldwide famous

THIS REPLAY ROCKY WILL ALWAYS BE A TOP TIER

I'm both Shawol and Aroha. This is very special moment for me 😭💎

I feel like shawols are one of the best fandoms out there! I really admire them, and I love to see them get along so well with Arohas!

OMG I'M A SHAWOL SINCE SHINEE'S DEBUT AND I'M AROHA ALSO OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG ~~~~~~ WHY THIS SONG OMG MY HEART UGHUGHUHG. I WAS SO SURPRISED. THANK YOU ASTRO & FANTAGIO I LOVE YOU EVEN MORE

YALL I KEEP TELLING SOME OF YOU THAT YOUVE BEEN SLEEPING ON MY BOY ROCKY. he seriously has it all. he's a rapper, dancer, VISUAL, and we've now been FULLY exposed to his amaaazing vocals that's he's been hiding ps: who remembers that one ddoca when rocky was singing Crush in the back of the elevator GMFU

Ok but Rocky and JinJin slaying those vocals?! ❤️

This never gets old. BEST Shinee cover 100%!

Still the best cover of Replay

can we just talk about how handsome jinjin is

people be talking about rockys vocals but I NEED SOMEONE TO APPRECIATE JINJINS VOCALS AT 1:23 i a m s h o o k

rocky singing the high notes are my favourite parts 😭 sucha talented bb

Rocky is a triple threat My man can rap like 64 words per second, his ddance is the best omg, and he sings like an angel aaaaaaah I love them so much-

I think I will repeat this over every astro's videos but eunwoo is so beautiful im shook everytime I see him on my screen

After watching produce 101 and learning how hard certain notes of this song were , I was shocked Rocky slayed it .

Best Shinee Replay Cover I've ever seen 😭💜

still the best shinee replay cover✨

I'M CRYING!! I'M SHAWOL AND AROHA AND WHEN MY FRIEND SEND ME THIS I WAS LITERALLY SCREAMING!! SAW ASTRO COVERING SHINEE MAKES ME FEEL OLD, SHINEE IS A SUMBAE NOW!! I'M SO BLESSED NOW!!! THANK YOU MNET

Idc if people hate on me for saying this but this is the best rookie group of the year if you listen to their mr removed they are hella stable even with their hard choreography, perfect synchronization, and amazing visuals. Like seriously this group doesn't lack anything yet they aren't really popular

Moonbin doing Jonghyun’s part….😢😢😢😢😢😢 my angels rest in peace

the best cover in the world 😭

Nobody gonna talk about my rapper line singing!!?? Like I knew Rocky could somewhat sing but he SANG in this video to a point where I'm shook and in aww and... words cant describe right now!! JinJin bias by the way, who are your guys is biases?! PS was it just me or did MJ look taller?!

jonghyun and shinee have inspired so many. these boys included. it breaks my heart

Minhyuk a.k.a Rocky's face really resembles Jjong Oppa.. i'm Blingers since 2010 and i'm still crying whenever i remember Jjong Oppa, but when i know Astro and find this Rocky, OMG i'm crying because of their similarity not only their face but their body and voice too 🥺🥺🥺

Just watched this now and I should say they were able to capture the Shinee vibes.... but not totally imitating Shinee.... and I am not even a fan of Shinee and Astro...(but I appreciate and like their music)....

So this video proves that ALL members of Astro can sing. ♡

As a shawol , this is one of the best covers I've ever seen of other kpop groups covering SHINee. 👍👍👍

Sanha looks so young here... Actually they all look so young here and i am proud of what they have achieved and will achieve ...

Rocky and jin jin giving us vocals is everything 😫

Rocky and JinJin sang so well omo. More lines for them please!!

I don't think you guys know how happy this makes me astro are my precious angels and shinee is my ult group and I've always wanted to see a group I really like perform a shinee song and the fact that the group was Astro and the fact that it was shinee's song reply makes me so happy. It went together so well. I feel a lot of earlier shinee songs fit Astro well.