not true

@@Omrankasiga oh really? So tell me what is the truth

@@oguzdemir1058 your brainwashed that attaturk is good,that's the trutg

@@crizs_noob8423 says who plays fortnite how old r u kid?

@@crizs_noob8423 go back to your fortnite 😐😐

❤

When religion killed its empire and he killed the religion then how would God bless his soul??

Shut up Reuben what do you know idiot

​@@muhammadansarahmed6039 B- What are you talking about

​@@muhammadansarahmed6039 Atatürk didn't have a religion, thanks to him, we don't take religion bullshit seriously.

This is the official Türkish propaganda.. Other countries dont agree... 👍

@@LEO-tm1ck even the fascist Germans referred him as such also Fidel castro or the fact that many tried to copy him we also forget that he was mentioned in Times magazine.

@@LEO-tm1ck You are an idiot propaganda xD

No,he is a devil

@@crizs_noob8423 shuuush

@@crizs_noob8423 shut the fuck up

@@crizs_noob8423 you miserable insect

he fought for peace? ha! the opposite i would say

Kayılıyorum şimdi 2024 ne kadar ilkelerinden uzaklaşan iktidar Durumumuz aşikar

❤

He’s a bad man

@@scg4201 😂

​@@scg4201 go you cant talk like that

Scg, anlat ne kötülükler yapmış? Muhtemelen Siyasal islamcısın size açıyorum hep laik ülkelerde yaşamak için bir çaba içerisindesiniz. Neden şeriat ile yönetilen ülkelere gidip yaşamak istemiyorsunuz?

May i ask what were you doing back then and what were your impressions, sir?

@Misbah Ghouri no ataturk is in heaven pedo Mohammed is in hell islam is a terrorist religion

@@MsBeyoglu astaghfarullah al-azeem,shame on you mate

@Misbah Ghouri f u

@Misbah Ghouri don't even try to speak about him tho literally. Who tf are you to talk about ATATURK?

Thanks for your comment. We, as Turkish youth, are trying to protect the republic he founded. We also see ourselves as devoted servants of this republic.

​@@mustafakemalpasha983 Sadly U have Erdogan

​@@anshuraj4277yes, because the people elected him thanks to the republic. For some, he may be a good or bad ruler, but this is what a republic of freedom and independence is like.

It's lie pakistan was the only country who helped turkey and non other muslim country

@@tarakmahetakaooltahchashma7627 wtf no I am Turkish they teach us in Schools Afghanistan is first Country that recognise Turkey Afghan leader Amanullah and Ataturk was friends

Don't you guys support erdogan?

@@tarakmahetakaooltahchashma7627 pakistan didnt exist that time

@@vrcptssxx2212 do you think erdoğan wins the elections with 100%? Not every turk supports him

@K. P. geographically, it is in the levant. no need to objection

No he was a devil. He changed the quran to be read in turkish and they changed the athan to turkish. Athan is supposed to be in arabic. he said u should be reading quran in turkish not arabic.

@@Abdulrahman-du9hy so what if u read the kuran in turkish or read the azan in turkish is there a rule that muslim must read the kuran and the azan in arabic? No there is not so stop talking shit people like you make our country look ignorant and stupid.

@@Abdulrahman-du9hy çölüne gidermisin lütfen burda işin yok

@@oguzdemir1058 no u can read quran In turkish but u can't read it in turkish when u praying or when u making athan out loud. Whatever u can believe a devil if u want u can believe a devil who was not even muslim saying u should pray I turkish u have to do everything is turkish. Ask ur dumbass head would prophet muhammad allow that to happen if he were there kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rN1kZ6qJt7mzlI0.html watch this vid

which I did not understand after the Ottoman Sultan Abdul Hamid II and died, why Mustafa Kemal was forced to alienate the Royal Family? Then why was the mosque converted into a museum? And the call to prayer is prohibited from using Arabic? And for women prohibited from using hijab

@@chanuch656 you are so funny man, Ayasofya so old unpriceable place so Atatürk made it a Museum.

@@chanuch656 The Royal Family was degenerate and sold the country to the European powers, check the Sevres Treaty. Only Hagia Sofia was converted into a museum, it was a church before being a mosque, and there were plenty of mosques if you needed one. The call of prayer was turquified because Turks don't speak Arabic. He never forbade the use of headscarves to women, bans in public space came after him, but yes he tried to separate politic life which he wanted to be secular and private life in which you were free to practice as you wished

@@chanuch656 Uhm because ataturk was a progressive person and he knew, with religion and dogmatic ideas a nation can never prosper. I'm turkish and and i'm glad for what he did, i wish he had lived for another 15 or 20 years, then our country would be fully free from desert people and their religion.

Piyamaradu la nat olsun

Respect to you, to Australia and to its proud people brother!

🌹♥️🌹

That he was.

Noriaki kakyoin how can God bless a man that hated God and belief in God? 🤕

@Dawud Bryant Oh we found a clown who judge people by what they think they are than what they've done . Tell me clown , what did you achieve in your life as a muslim ? Did you establish a brand new productive country from the ashes of an utterly fallen Empire ? Did you give equal rights to women in an era where almost no other country give ? Did you fight at any fronts in any wars except pathetically in comment sections of social media applications ? Did you make it compulsory for women to go to school to get educated in a period where again almost no other country did ? Did you make bold moves on education system which enabled for literacy levels to skyrocket ? I can go on and on but I won't because I know I can't win a fight against an ignorant person .

@Sultana Razia Parvin those questions in my previous comments apply for a lowlife man like you too .

@Tajrian Jahan How's my username relevant ? It's not but you addressed it anyway, which speak volumes about your true intentions of being here. You clearly chose to read my comment in your own dirty minded way because I've never said Muslims are clowns anywhere in my previous remarks. By the way, don't worry I am aware of what you all are capable of doing in the name of Islam for good or worse, however being a Muslim alone isn't an achievement by no means and the good deeds of one Muslim doesn't make the rest all of them heroes. All my words apply for that clown that judged a national hero who has done more to humanity than his entire generation can ever do.

He did great things for Turkey but was terrible for the Muslim world a better example of a leader is King Faisal although I don't regard him as Muslim still better than this guy and definitely an example whether you regard him as Muslim or not

The narrator of this documentary is Sir Donald Sinden. The detail is mentioned in the description of the Turkish language version of this documentary (kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jbNmeLFyq8XGYmg.html)

What would Ataturk think of Erdogan if he is alive today?

@@wanrazul He might not like him.

Tahar Lounes It takes one to know one

Hasan Taskiran your Muslim and your speaking very cahil We already have and had a leader for over 1400years ;) Hazreti pejgamber

@@taharlounes4990 He was in Gallipoli during the armenian genocide

Really? After he witnessed his people try to eliminate the Armenians?

No. Atatürk is an evil man. He is no "great" leader. He was a liar & a manipulator, as well as he's the enemy of God.

​@@gevorkgk You don't even know .d Armenia is enemy

@@gevorkgk haha xD Atatürk save many Armenian family in 1915. He in war ww1 againts the brisith on Galipoli in 1914-18 era. So shut the fack up you liar facist.

🙄😐

the shah of Iran didn't make Iran like this never the dizzy people made ..

🙄when you have lack of information you should..

@@elham-persian8721 ok but at least he didn’t make Turkey like Iran

dont blame iranians we were just lucky that we had him

M kamal ataput. Or us bu cocugu Kamal put

@Yusuf Isa Mr Yusuf Isa, it would be a great service to history if you could kindly explain your reasons for labelling my commentary as "utter bullshit". From the language you use I can easily say what kind of person you are, your background, the people you hang with etc....I will not say it now and wait for your response. If you have difficulty in expressing yourself effectvely enough in English you can respond in Turkish. My Turkish is good enough for I have been living in this great your country for more than 20 years and have a wonderful wife with three children...Eagerly awaiting "cevabınızı, izahatınızı".

@Yusuf Isa I really became anxcious and concerned whether your brain works properlly and normally.. ..And, whether you have ever read any reliable book about Ottoman history. What a stupid and self- accusatory sentence that you use: "Turkey under Ottoman/Islamic rule was much more wealthier and literate." True, it was wealthier until the end of the 16th century. Why? Because it invaded and stole, looted, robbed the riches of the Balkan countries and Eastern europe. During those centuries, the Crimean Khanate was linked with the Ottoman Empire and its main "economic activity" was looting, stealing and taking prisoners from Ukraine, Poland and Latvia. Prisoners taken from these countries were sold at slave markets of Istanbul. But, this unconsionable, immoral, inhuman method of economic enrichment came to an end when the Western countries got the upper hand by using science, logic, reason in every sphere of life. Thus, from the 16th century onwards Ottomans lost the only means of terrorising other peoples, i.e. murder, the sword, slavery etc. Now the funniest part...This Yusuf İsa guy claims that during the Ottoman period the people were more literate. (Senin çook muhtemelen acur tipi bir vatandaşımız olduğundan eminim...Yeme bizi...) Let alone the men in the street, in the highest levels of the civil adminisration as well as of the armed forces, the Pashas ( a title used for high civilian and military personnel) and many others under them were ILLITERATE. During the 1900's the estimated number of literate people was 10 per cent. Mr Yusuf İsa, I hope that I have made a dent in your brain. Good bye...

@Yusuf Isa I am not sure whether you are just and simply ignorant, or also stupid. In the first case you you have a chance....Read, read, learn learn, learn from reputable sources. . This may perhaps helps. In the second case...I can't think of a remedy, a medical procedure... Wait...I just remembered...Since you said you live by İslamic rules/traditions , I am sure there are many traders in religion , sorcerers i.e. Islamic hodjas, fortune tellers and the like around you. (Such people make lots of money in Turkey.) One of them may write couple of lines from your holy book on a piece of paper and you swallow it...Wow!. A miracle happens (maybe) and your stupidity is gone... Note: It was fun to communicate with you. But I am a busy person and this much fun is more than enough. Take care Yusuf.

Tüürk olduğuna eminim, bu yüzden Türkçe yazıyorum. Gerçekten harika özetlemişsin. Bu güzel yazıyı Atatürk ile ilgili başka bir yabancı sayfada copy-paste yaparak paylaştım. Türkiyenin senin bilincindeki insanlara çok ihtiyacı var. Emeğine sağlık, iyi ki zahmet edip bu yazıyı yazmışsın.

@@herseydenbirseyler6034 Değerli kardeşim merhaba....Ben, Atatürk'ün mucizevi şekilde yaratmış olduğu çağdaş Türkiye'nin 83 yaşındaki bir vatandaşıyım. Osmanlı ve T.C. tarihi hakkında yüzlerce kitap/belge okudum. Ne güzel ki, son yıllarda bu konularda çok önemli kitaplar yayınlandı. Bu arada belirteyim, ülkemizin barışı/huzuru bakımından önemli olduğu için, Türkiye yerine Anadolu demeyi tercih ederim.Selam, sevgi, saygı v.s.

Gunny akdo he was an atheist of albanian heritage, great 'turk'

@@malenedietl3369 what does atheism have to do with it? Also, I struggle to believe he was Albanian when even his grandparents had Turkish names.

@@raanasyed8249 you dont think it will change a muslim state if an atheist comes in and changes alphabeth, dress, constitution, rootsout all traits of belief in God. Just a thought. Okay, I am wrong about the albanian stuff. Ataturk was not a lover of religion am I right there?

@@malenedietl3369 sure, I can see how the reforms were too sudden and harsh for Turkey. I see some of them as to extreme myself but him being an atheist didn't harm Turkish society in any way. In fact, a lot of people have speculated that he might have been Muslim but chose to not bring his personal religion into politics to remain as secular as possible. Nowadays, (this doesn't represent converstaives or AKP) a lot of Turks love him and see him as an icon for a modern and secular Turkey which we wouldn't have had without such drastic measures. We aren't like Arab/Muslim countries in which religion is a part of our cultural identity/nationality considering the fact that a lot of us liberal Turks are atheists ourselves.

@@malenedietl3369 Oh we found a clown who judge people by what they think they are than what they've done . Tell me clown , what did you achieve in your life as a muslim ? Did you establish a brand new productive country from the ashes of an utterly fallen Empire ? Did you give equal rights to women in an era where almost no other country give ? Did you fight at any fronts in any wars except pathetically in comment sections of social media applications ? Did you make it compulsory for women to go to school to get educated in a period where again almost no other country did ? Did you make bold moves on education system which enabled for literacy levels to skyrocket ? I can go on and on but I won't because I know I can't win a fight against an ignorant person

Bro I am Bangladeshi too

i am surprised by this. i thought all muslim countries hated atatürk? could you give me names of the roads, schools, avenues etc

@@de-tz6hy yeah, we have Kemal Atatürk Avenue in Banani, Dhaka.

@@attitudeboy5379 Wow! That’s amazing. 😍 I hope the Pakistani anti-Atatürk Ottoman 2023 menaces leave us alone now so I can focus on this newfound friendship with Bangladeshis 🙄❤️🇧🇩🇹🇷

@@de-tz6hy thanks 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷

immortal? even the earth did not accept the crimanals body , he isnt even burried. he died with a disease that was never seen before , a slow death where ants ate his blood and flesh from inside.. read history dude

Turkey, or the whole world

"If you are waiting for a leader to save your country, it means I couldn't teach you anything." -Ataturk

No, they need the very opposite of a nationalistic leader...

@@DanyPell they need Nationalist leader cuz today Erdoğan is acting like he's Arab lover and he's traitor to Turkish people we need a President that is Nationalist and Secular today

Yes 😞

you would have been in a better place under the great ottomons , the empire which lasted 800 years.. and read real history of this man, how he destroyed turkey and made it a small country from a vast empire ..

@@roumanfirdous8707 600 year state just 100 year empire and very dumb one

You are right and sometimes I can't hear and understand some words. Maybe because of his pronunciation

If only the Shah had succeeded and not become a hated puppet

She shouldn’t

Yes because now you have your dictator RTErdogan

In Turkey they try do make us forget about him but NEVER we will

​@@nilthegamer06 I'm not a huge fan of Erdogan but to be honest I'd rather have him as leader rather than that kaffir Atatürk. Atatürk has so much dark history behind his back that they don't want you to know, he was a liar, a manipulator, a racist ultra nationalist, but most importantly he was an enemy of GOD. That when he died even the ground refused to take him in. He's no "great" leader. He was indeed an evil man.

Yalnız unutturmaya çalışmıyorlar aynı zamanda Ortadogululara yoğun bir şekilde vatandaşlık vererek de mografik yapımızı da bozuyorlar.

No. Andrew Mango is secret Atatruk hater. Fack him!

That's because the modern western man is a child, both in mind and body. That's why a real man like Ataturk scares you so and why the west was forced to respect him.

What do you mean nationalistic? Bruh the man fought a war against 3 different armies and other rebels and then made a whole new country out of it. What do you expect from him? He was one of the kindest people and a great leader. Your just anti Turkish and you just had to say something negative even when saying something positive. GTFO

@@binbasesatoktayyldran5236 Yes. Was needed at the time as I said.

The strong nationalistic thought has to go today though.

No choice, but he is also peacemaker for sure

There is a version with a Turkish language voiceover here (kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jbNmeLFyq8XGYmg.html)

Why?

I guess you need to learn English better.

really? where are you from?

@@ruvoli Philippines we learn about these too

@@user-ky9gz8wk1m What do you think of Atatürk so far?

Kesinlikle yok! Siyasal islamcıların nefreti bizim için gururdur.

Rıza Pehlevi'nin saltanat sürmesini de istersin sen.

@@muhafazakarturkcu162 ben değil tüm iranlilar bunu istiyor😉

@@kimiakarimzade8174 kanka bunu bırak bu Atatürk’e bile hakaret ediyor.Yani çok sallama bunları.Bir şey sorucam sırf meraktan, Müslüman mısın?. Bu arada Pehlevi döneminde Atatürkle Pehlevinin ilişkileri baya iyiymiş hatta.

@@josephc5851 dinlere inanmıyorum

@@kimiakarimzade8174 hmm ateistsin yani. Çok şaşırmadım açıkçası sizin ülke de bize benziyor bizde de çok var senin gibi olanlar. Hatta sizde daha fazla olabilir

Ataturk didnt leave his land during the war. Also, Ataturk didnt get help from other countries (Army, Soldier i meant) Russia and Turkey was allies on politics... Ataturk had not an army... he established a parlıament and army against the Sultane Autorithy and France, England, Greece, Italy... I think they are different. Also Ataturk had to join to war from 1912 to 1922... not 2 years or 3 years... Napoleon was a great military strategist. But unfortunality he lost. Ataturk didnt lose. And did very strong reforms. He changed regime from royal to republic. Alphabet, education, teochrasy to secularism... he did all of them in 15 years. I didnt talk about Suleyman the Great his age was so different. And he was a king. Ottomans was very powerful. He was a great king to Turks.

@@medusa7872 first it was the young Turks who overthrew Sultan Abdelhamid ll, and BTW Ataturk was part of the young Turks.

@@medusa7872 Ataturk was a sell out, he sold the Turkish people to the west, the same west that came to destroy the Ottomans.

@@medusa7872 because the Sultan had to be destroyed from within, if the west killed the Sultan the Muslims will make another Sultan, that's why at first Ataturk kicked out the Sultan but kept the caliphate then in 1924 he kicked out the caliphate.

@@medusa7872 when Ataturk was making his army in the war of independence, Ataturk was getting soldiers to fight against the enemies of Islam. When Ataturk got all the power he then waged war on Muslim's. BTW Ataturk was born in a Jewish town.

@@medusa7872 because Zionist control almost everything

He was a freemason

He saved a nation while other Muslims betraying us. You are uneducated and didn’t search his life or ideas I suppose and only read something really biased or most probably from Tiktok or something.

Kemal hated Islam. Some say he was a donme.

If muslim world gets a higher understanding, you will see what his contrubution to İslamic world is. You cannot understand him from your position now. You see him Just as enemy now and this is not related with him. It is related with your sick understanding unfortunately.

Film hem İngilizce hem Türkçe olarak yüklü

@@Tolga_Ornek İngilizce olarak ama İngilizce altyazılı demek istemiştim :) çok şey mi istiyorum 🙂

Shut up foolish ar*p

@Sofiane Gharbi I count as an insult.

@Sofiane Gharbi he's lying about everything bro lmao only %8 of Turkish words has origin of Arabic And Turkish people originated from Central Asia not Arabia Religion doesn't make nation

selam müzik listesini buldun mu

You guys are lucky one man change turkish peoples destiny

He wasn't neither tho

His Family go to Balkans from Anatolia. Maybe he has Greek and Albanian dna in blood. But he was Yörük Türk. Whe Ottomans take the Karamanids. They sent them to different Balkan region. Because of this he born in there

Bu belgeselin Türkçesi var burada Tolga Örnek Atatürk Belgeseli yazın çıkar

Me too still waiting a answer to your question :/

@@erenaktash it's so good!

no he tried to change islam and the quran

@Misbah Ghouri hassiktirlen bilmeden konuşma dalyarak

@@hasantariq869 I dont give a shit about islam and quran. You brainless fuck. Do you hate all non-muslim leaders?

@@cemilalp5639 so? You obviously care enough about Islam to support a leader who changes the Quran

@@hasantariq869 What do you mean by changing the quran? What does that even mean

My friend you have to read and learn more about Atatürk and Abdulhamit. There are dozens of books and articles written about them and their periods. Happilly we have the internet where you can reach some of these sources without paying any money. Try Google...

@@bassoprof I have already researched about Ataturk and found answers for conspiracy.But at this point I changed my view to learn more about his personal life,his mind and his function as a reformist.

He died much moyrned byxTurkush citizens except the mindless religious bigots that under Erdogan are trying to make a come back. Enjoy your partially latinised Turkish script and alphabet. Kemal Attaturk was a great man. A true war hero and thanks to his educational reforms took education away from the Ulema and the religious narrow minded and made Turkey a secular nation.

As a non-Theist Turk, I am proud of Atatürk.

Atatürk islam saçmalığını benimsemedi. İslam boktur

@@hazretiegoist4658 dhakdjsjajjdhdaiajjddus

There are so many errors in your statement that I don’t know where to start.

No. May Ottoman royalty earned Ottoman Empire and consequently Turkey a bad reputation. They were bad leaders, AND they were bad as Muslims for waging war on countries who did not provoke them.

JD it is obvious that you are a Muslim still willing to live in the Middle ages of your self- proclaimed prophet Mr. Muhammed Mustafa.... My friend wake up and come to your senses . Do not deceive yourself. The Western World, the world that uses logic, reason, science, in short the magnificent human BRAIN that THE NATURE gave us produced thousands of wonderful things for mankind...(Also, unfortunately weapons of mass destruction and suffering.) As of this minute we can say that they what they produced are mostly good things...Things that can be used for the benefit all human beings in the hands of good, capable, honest leaders. We are in the 21st century. Couple of years ago, the space telescope Hubble found millions of galaxies in the universe, each containing billions of stars...Hence, our world in this mind boggling universe is nothing but a dust that the most powerful electron microscope is unable to detect...It is therefore incredibly stupid , misleading, meaningless and a huge waste of time as well as energy to explain life on earth on the basis of religions which all are man made tales, stories.

@@bassoprof u will never know the logic of islam

very soon we will get the great leader like ottomons, like OSMAN gazi, like ertugrul gazi. insha allah.. ottomons will rise again

Lâiklik bir nevi özgürlük değil mi? Neden ne yazık ki dediğinizi anlayamadım!

freedom to deviancy, programmed by the matrix,makes the confusion understandable

Good. That is why he is great.

It was an empire means multiethnical and multicultural which ruled under monarchy. After WWI, Atatürk could create a nation state recognized by all world from Ottoman Empire's last pieces with fighting against world's superpowers. I think it deserves respect.