Loved this comparison, thanks for doing it, I am cross-shopping these two right now. Andrea you are looking just beautiful in red!

Awesome video guys! I still pick Q5 like Zack said this vehicle is an all-round. Cheers! 👍🏻

Great review. You two are the best car reviewers on KZfaq. I really enjoy your dynamic and all of the useful information.

Neither is good enough. Mercedes is the only one giving you a luxury interior and mainstream brands have caught up. These “luxury” brands are relying on brand cache to move metal. Great comparison as always!

You guys do a good job. I like your reviews quite a bit more than others. 😊

Great video Zac and Andrea! I love both of these as well! You guys are really gonna love the GV70!

Great comparison! These two Germans are closely matched and it comes down to preference. When I trade my M340i in a couple of years I’m going to give the X3 M40i a serious look!

Definitely Audi for me all the way. It's more luxurious and thought out looking. I love that blue color. The X3 may be more powerful but I don't need that. I have no interest in speeding.

You can’t just say you’d get the 400hp variant and not mention the SQ5. Youre comparing apples and oranges. If you are comparing the v6, the Audi SQ5 would be the choice.

I also like Q5, because I think Audi does a better job in switch and knobs, and overall interior fit and finish. I have an option to pick one of the 2 vehicle- current generation Q5 (MY 2018) Technik vs base macan (MY2018) with just a Premium package to get basic amenities such as memory seats etc if the price for both in used market is same?

What is the difference between leather seats and leather seating surfaces?

Audi Q5 for my wife while BMW X5 40i for me... perfect combination

Yay for Canadian pricing. I’m so used to seeing USD and it’s so annoying for us Canadians. Great review for cars I’ll never buy but pretend to buy in my head lol.

I’d be fine with either...but, we just bought the X3 and love everything about it

Thanks for this amazing match! Q5 same colour as mine! Still love it!

Bmw price does include some maintenance, not the Audi

I find that the Q5 shows its age. It lacks the new interior that Audi introduced in the Q7 (of which I believe the Q3 is also inspired), and the only "innovation" is that ipad looking screen slapped in the middle of the console with very little integration. The exterior refresh is ok but not as sharp as other models in the Audi line-up (I like the bold design of the Q8, but other new models like the S3 or Q3 also have fresher lines). Moreover, I can't get over the fake exhausts on the Q5. I would definitely not go for the Q5 and for the price I would pick the A5 Sportback or indeed the X3 (even though I am not a huge fan of the interior).

Ugh, my lease on my q5 is up in a couple months. I’m not a fan of the steering at all. I have an x5 35d( that I othat I really prefer. I will go test the x3

Andrea tends to match something about the car tested, be it the exterior colour or something interior, or compliment what Zack is wearing.The only thing I can match with her outfit is the red seatbelt release button. Another 👍video.

I'm down to the Q5, the X3, or the Genesis GV70...I love the GV70 look, horsepower, and warranty...

The BMW drive for me is unmatched but when it comes down to price and what you get, the audi seems to be the better option. The audi cabin space, while smaller, seems to be more plush and comfortable than the BMW. However, I will say a lot of accessory components on audi feel cheap to me sometimes.....All in all, they are both great cars. I can't make up my mind.

I know this may not be politically correct, but with the Audi being made in Mexico, vs the BMW being made in the US, I’m not sure I’m happy paying German Luxury car prices for a car assembled in a low cost labor market. So yes, the Audi is less expensive, but it should be.

The review is a year old, and last year the Q5 may have been the better value. However, in May 2022 Audi has shipped almost all Q5 without blind spot warning, adaptive cruise control, or navigation due to the chip shortage. The ones I looked at also had pretty basic wheels, and some had a detuned 2.0 4 cylinder engine with less power. The X3 has all of those features, drives better, but hard to get the Harmon Kardon stereo. The tie breaker for me was that at 6’1” the Q5 fits me awkwardly. I move the seat back all the way but then the door arm rest is too short and my arm doesn’t reach it, plus the touch screen is very far forward and high on the dash, I have to lean forward to reach it. BMW for me this time.

Your comparison is bang on! My question is, would you spec the Q5 Technik with air suspension? Is the $2500 addition worth the extra comfort for both short and long term ownership?

Great comparison. Both the two I’m looking at right now. Also noting BMW requires premium gas. With gas prices now that is something to weigh in.

I have to agree with Zack that the B58 Inline-Six is one gem 💎 of an engine. Silky smooth, naturally balanced and a sweet sound. Good comparison! Ty for sharing. The Audi wins this one bc of the great value it offers and a fresh new look that looks great. 👌

Thanks for an informative comparison for these two! And Andrea, such a tease.. looking good as always! 🙂

Q5 wins every time. Awesome exterior and interior design. Although I agree the discontinuation of MMI knob is a misstep, its interior remains more attractive than those of the X3. Given I had terrible experience with BMW reliability and customer service, the only reason to choose an X3 over Q5 is the low lease rates. If money is no object, nothing else best Macan GTS and Turbo w/Performance Package in this segment.

Audi for me all day. Love my SQ5

Any idea when the q5 sportsback will be out?

They are both so nice and just perfect small family vehicles. But for me lately I just fallen in love with BMW cars overall and feel like they been doing their thing.

The X3 M4.0 is a reasonable price if you purchase the end of year model and maybe get lucky and get the demo...In the US...and that's what I'm hoping to get next year! You guys have the format nailed down perfectly and your reviews are crisp and clear....Good stuff you....two By the way I like Andrea's summer look....as I said before, Zack, you're a lucky man!

for me my choice it will be SQ5 in any color

So funny---I'm literally choosing this week between the BMW x3 or the Audi X5---both in blue in shown here. But----for pure driving fun I'm leaning towards the X3. Will make final choice next week---waiitng for Volvo to finish my California Lemon Law Buyback on my 2022 Volvo XC 60 which has been in the shop now eight times due to electrical problems---. So----feels like the X3.

So, can't find one reviewer that would pick the X3? This seems very biased. As a side note, consumer reports prefers the X3 and finds the BMW more reliable.

Hey guys. The BMW of course with the 6 on line. Love your reports. Congratulations. Souvenirs de Champagne in Spring.

Can you do a 2021 Lincoln navigator vs a 2021 cadillac escalade sport platinum esv 4wd onyx package black on black proformece package

Great presentation of the 2 Cars, but they are to similar.

Can you do a 2021 Lincoln navigator

Does Audi Q5 require premium gas?

BMW Boastful Machine Winning

Q5 vs GLC, which is better?

Audi baby

If the Q5 had the Q7 interior, it wouldn’t have the Q5 price...

Zack, can you compare a honda civic EX with a moon roof, with bright red exterior vs a chevy tahoe 2WD with dull grey interior

The X3 and X4 are lacking in technology and are not currently available with adaptive cruise control. In this luxury mid-size category, how can they now have this available? Every manufacturer offers it except BMW.

Absolutely agree with the wheel in the center, Audi should have kept it.

BMW Beginning Manual Work

There is no comparison between the Q5 and X3. Let’s be honest, only people who doesn’t understand anything about cars or wants to save buy AUDI, BMW is technically at a different level: longitudinal engine and native RWD VS a mechanical solution on the AUDI which you can find on a SKODA.

BMW Being Manhandled Weekly

3:51 Did anyone noticed how ugly is the grills of the Audi. Probably it is the ugliest car front in the market :(

RDX Aspec is 15k cheaper, is more spacious, has more power, has more legroom and cargo room, has a superior AWD, has a much better audio system than mid tier x3/q5 and in my honest opinion looks much better than specially with red interior

Beautiful Maids Wondering

BMW Bounce Mama's Wig

BMW Beastly Monstrosity Warranted

BMW Brazilian Men Waxed

BMW Bavarian Motor Works

Just use a dummy for back seat test fitting ...

BMW Besieged Misfit Wounded

BMW Bicameral Minions Worrying

X3 shape is bad. Q5 is better looking

BMW Birds Migrating West

BMW Bisexual Men Whipped

BMW Badly Made Widget

Q5s are all over Toronto.. if you get one it'd be so unoriginal

BMW Bald Midgets Whistling

BMW Bad Mechanics Whining

Who the hell still buys a bmw 😂

BMW Bums Manufacturing Waste