No video

Avatar Vs. Vietnam Colony

  Рет қаралды 34,481

mallubhai0MBBS

mallubhai0MBBS

14 жыл бұрын

Let's see the story of Avatar and Vietnam Colony (1993).
A paraplegic marine Jake is assigned, as an agent to an inter-galactic construction company, with the mission to infiltrate the the Na' vi COLONY in the planet Pandora and live among them and eventually find Intel to move them out of their homes .
A virtuous Swamy is assigned, as an agent to a multinational construction company, with the mission to infiltrate the Vietnam Colony and live among them and eventually find enough Intel to move them out of their homes.
Now this is not a copy or James Cameron pinching the 1993 Mallu Movie, as Cameron has the idea written
even before the conception of Terminator (1984), he didnt venture into it mainly because he felt the technology was inadequate at that time to make such an enormous movie, creating an open world from scratch. When he saw the character Golem in Peter Jacksons Lord of the Rings trilogy, he was satisfied with the CGI technology and started working on Avatar. Still its nice to see the Vietnam Colony concept going through the hands of James Cameron.
__________________________
(Update on Feb.10)
I am getting a lot of mails from around the world saying Avatar is based on a story from their own culture or entertainment industry.
It's no wonder that Avatar has such a common theme of a mole in hostile territory. One could even interpret Joshua in Canaan!
According to James Cameron he got the idea from every science fiction stories he'd read as a kid and acknowledged similar theme stories like Dancing with the Wolves, A Play in the Fields of the Lord, Emerald Forest and the classic Lawrence of Arabia. Speaking to Empire, Cameron said "It owes a lot to good, old-fashioned, adolescent adventure storytelling like Rudyard Kipling's The Man Who Would Be King, Lawrence Of Arabia and (Edgar Rice Burroughs' ) John Carter Of Mars."
There are broader perspectives ranging from Iraq War to the struggle against imperialism. As the theme has a simple but broadly common and "open", any views can be fitted with the story.
Now, what I personally think is, yes James Cameron most probably based Avatar from a particular science fiction story. It was Poul (not Paul) Andersons short story titled "Call Me Joe" (1957). Why I am saying it could be a copy is primarily because too many similarities that defy a weird coincidence.
Like the protagonist in the story - Ed and Jake Scully in Avatar are both paraplegics and both use genetically created artificial bodies (BLUE in colour!!!) to survive in an alien planet!!! And both characters end up empathizing and being adapted to the alien culture. So there it is it could be a copy...
I said "most probably" and "could be" because, there is still benefit of the doubt. For example Robert Silverberg sci-fi novel, Revolt on Alpha C (1955) has similar theme with lush alien rainforests and fauna, where the hero going native by empathizing with them. Whatever it is, I ended up enjoying the film and thanks to Cameron it was a brilliant movie.
Now, I would like to listen your comments about if Avatar was indeed based on other fiction or fact. Send me your comments...

Пікірлер: 47
@Amal-cb3rq
@Amal-cb3rq 2 жыл бұрын
12 years 🙂
@vaisakhthegreate
@vaisakhthegreate 13 жыл бұрын
wow...this is one hell of a comparison....
@gArBgebIN
@gArBgebIN 14 жыл бұрын
when i was watchin avatar, i couldnt help but think of vietnam colony...
@anoopmknair
@anoopmknair 14 жыл бұрын
hi . long time no see. good work with the mixing, as usual. I suppose you've heard of the animated movies 'Pocahontas' and 'Fern gully'. 'Avatar' is a rehash of these, & the theme is quite popular. You know, the history of the conflict between the settlers and native Americans. One wouldn't be surprised if Siddhiq-Lal's story was actually inspired by these two animated movies. Remember, their story of 'Mannar Mathai' was a rehash of that of 'Vertigo'. That said, they did do a great job.
@MaheshN142
@MaheshN142 3 ай бұрын
ഈ വിയറ്റ്നാം കോളനി പഴയ 1983 ലെ ലോക്കൽ ഹീറോ എന്ന ഹോളിവുഡ് സിനിമയിൽ നിന്ന് ചുരണ്ടിയെടുത്ത കഥ 😄😄അവതാർ ചിലപ്പോൾ ലോക്കൽ ഹീറോ inspired സിനിമയാരിക്കും
@greatm0ments
@greatm0ments 14 жыл бұрын
Good point anopona, thanks for the feedback and it's a good observation, when I get a better video of Avatar I will definitely include the scene. However, note also that such a scene again is very general, James Cameron probably never heard of Vietnam Colony. Still, a good observation and thanks for the posting :)
@subinfx5426
@subinfx5426 2 жыл бұрын
ഇതാരാടാ 12 വർഷം മുൻപ് ഇട്ടേക്കുന്നെ 😨😨
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS Жыл бұрын
First one, bro
@gArBgebIN
@gArBgebIN 14 жыл бұрын
wow i thought i was the only one who noticed this
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
@prasoon186 Very true, the story is quite a prominent theme. As Anoop said Pochahontas could be a great inspiration for both Vietnam Colony and Avatar...Thanks for the comment :)
@aneeshar230
@aneeshar230 2 жыл бұрын
❤❤
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
@SonofSivadas It's not, if you check the comments, we have already discussed it. Please read the description for possible copies...
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 13 жыл бұрын
@vaisakhthegreate Thanks for the comment, unfortunately when I made the clip I had to use all the Avatar scenes from the trailer :) Please read the description too...Boeing Boeing and A Fish Called Wanda is also on my list..
@generalawarenesswithrk9303
@generalawarenesswithrk9303 Жыл бұрын
Add subtitles
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS Жыл бұрын
Will try, originally it was subtitled but after they remove the annotations it was removed, just like my video Fugitive vs. Nirnayam and Mookkilla Rajyath...
@generalawarenesswithrk9303
@generalawarenesswithrk9303 Жыл бұрын
@@mallubhai0MBBS there is auto generated option
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 13 жыл бұрын
@Dubbel06 The discussion was about if Avatar was a copy not if Vietnam colony is a copy...Dances (sorry for mistake Dancing :) with the Wolves is possibly an inspiration, but only possibly as this specific plot is very common. Just because Dances with the Wolves released early or a similar plot we cannot say it's very clear the film is a copy. Only the screen writers know that for sure, I guess...Still I am not denying the possibility of inspiration came from the classic (as it's a well known)
@Rin19862002
@Rin19862002 14 жыл бұрын
In VIetnam we are discussing about Avatar, We things Avatar is adapted a Vietnamese ancient story. Same story, an enemy spy loves Vietnamese princess, but stil try to defeat Vietnam....
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 13 жыл бұрын
@philipzown7 Nope, it was just comparison, please read the description (click on show more) about the story and explanation behind this posting :)
@greatm0ments
@greatm0ments 14 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the comment Rin, much appreciate it. Yes, people around the world send me comments like Avatar is inspired by a movie of their own...However, as I explained in the description, Avatar has such a common theme one could even point out that it's based on the hostility between Cowboys and Indians :) I am adding another comment and elaborating the description. Thanks again.
@anoopmknair
@anoopmknair 14 жыл бұрын
an extremely common scene.. it's there in a lot of movies.. for eg., the scene with Jackie Chan and the Red Indians in Shangahi Noon ... The update in the description should be the best explanation.
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 13 жыл бұрын
@williams2d Thank you :D
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
@anoopmknair I was waiting for a good one for the 100th upload but couldn't find any good clips for Avatar or Vietnam Colony, which is why it's delayed. Thanks for the comment, nice to hear from you. :)
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 11 жыл бұрын
Read the description :)
@greatm0ments
@greatm0ments 14 жыл бұрын
Hi Anoop, have checked the description update. Did James Cameron indeed nick the story...?
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
@gArBgebIN That's the thing...the theme is so similar :D
@anoopmknair
@anoopmknair 14 жыл бұрын
Hey! Cameron's explanation seems convincing. Wonder why 'Lawrence of Arabia' didn't cross my mind. haven't read 'Call me Joe'. But, 'Avatar' is more about the effects than the story. I think 'Vietnam colony' is the most unlikely source - there are so many more probable works which came much before a movie from a minuscule industry in south India.
@parkersmock359
@parkersmock359 11 жыл бұрын
Avatar has nothing to do with this film. Avatar is about the USA involvement in the Vietnam War being Cobalt.
@thengolathamburaan3456
@thengolathamburaan3456 5 жыл бұрын
But it shows very accurate resemblance to many scenes as shot in the film. How do you explain that?
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
Oops, wrong login...greatm0ments is me too :)
@Rin19862002
@Rin19862002 14 жыл бұрын
you are welcome ^^
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 12 жыл бұрын
POS (Point of Shit?) well, you need to read the description before judging the video. :)
@SonofSivadas
@SonofSivadas 14 жыл бұрын
dude vietnam colony is itself a remake of the kevin costner movie dance with the wolves.
@thengolathamburaan3456
@thengolathamburaan3456 5 жыл бұрын
Dude, nobody claimed it's a remake. Avatar can also be a copy of Vietnam colony and dance with the wolves etc.
@greatm0ments
@greatm0ments 14 жыл бұрын
I am getting a lot of mails from around the world saying Avatar is based on a story from their own culture or entertainment industry. It's no wonder that Avatar has such a common theme of a mole in hostile territory. One could even interpret Joshua in Canaan! Please read the video description for a detailed answer for if Avatar was indeed inspired or not :)
@mallubhai0MBBS
@mallubhai0MBBS 14 жыл бұрын
@gArBgebIN I did LOL
@philipzown7
@philipzown7 13 жыл бұрын
@mallubhai0MBBS ok :) i got uu
@philipzown7
@philipzown7 13 жыл бұрын
so ur saying Avatar was a copy of vietnam colony lol james cameron athinte avisham undo?
@thengolathamburaan3456
@thengolathamburaan3456 5 жыл бұрын
illennu parayaan kazhiyumo?
@reign225
@reign225 12 жыл бұрын
avatar is better !! B-)
@thengolathamburaan3456
@thengolathamburaan3456 5 жыл бұрын
Hence the reason to check if it's original or a master copycat. Cause this movie came long time back.
@anoopmknair
@anoopmknair 14 жыл бұрын
Point noted. But Ferngully was released in 1992. Pocahontas was in production for 5 years and is loosely based on true events. I agree an instance of inspiration can be ruled out. Sidhiq-Lal was one gifted team of movie-makers. Heard they were the ones who actually created Dasan-Vijayan duo.
@ALANunni
@ALANunni 12 жыл бұрын
enikkumm thonni.....
@ronny1034
@ronny1034 12 жыл бұрын
yaak this alien language sucksssss! wud pud vud illai ede....tor baaper maatha...
EVOLUTION OF ICE CREAM 😱 #shorts
00:11
Savage Vlogs
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
😳 Все русские уже знают итальянский?🇮🇹
00:15
Inside Out 2: Who is the strongest? Joy vs Envy vs Anger #shorts #animation
00:22
EVOLUTION OF ICE CREAM 😱 #shorts
00:11
Savage Vlogs
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН