You literally stan Loona and NewJeans... half of both groups can't even support their voice with their diaphragm, a basic necessity to be a proper vocalist. You don't really care about vocals after all

​@@itsrainingcaratzens THEY STAN NEWJEANS???? See, lowkey that explains everything 😭

@@dozenology I'm so tired of "youtubers" acting elite.

@@itsrainingcaratzensLike fr ain’t no way she’s acting like an elite vocal coach when her faves are worse than some of these groups in this video

@@wooksieswdym bro?? Whats wrong w newjeans?? HAVE U HEARD NEWJEANS RAW VOCALS?? They SLAYY

Frr

ofc prob this is just for humorous purposes

or Sing without sounding like a dying frog and have fun at the same time.

@@noneofyourbusiness-tw7dp or don't pressure them lose their smile thinking that some international fan is gonna hate them for EVERY TINY THING!

@@peppa_111 that tiny think being their ability to sing…which they struggle with.

Every time I think about those old women booing them and shaking their heads because their favs lost, makes me FURIOUS. These are lovely and talented girls deal with it 🙄

exactly.. like the unnecessary mean comments in this video just threw me off. i'm all about idols doing their job (singing) properly but the commentary in this is just NOT it.

exactly! throwing such hatefull comments hiding behind a screen like they could or would do better, i know some encores could be better, but one thing is giving constructive criticism and another one is being a hater.

Ik look I understand it can be off putting when a group doesn’t have good vocals but the unnecessary mean comments ruined it, comparing main vocalists to members who specialise in rap or dance just doesn’t make sense, the clear bias was PAINFUL to watch, she really had it out for the 4th gen groups she’d criticise the bad stuff and cut out/ignore the good stuff. They are overall a toxic content creator and it doesn’t take you long to figure that out just look at their videos, I don’t understand why kpop “fans” can’t just be a little more positive, outright bullying underpaid overworked idols isn’t going to get you friends.

but why are they idols if they don't have talent???

womp womp

@@Strwberrymoonstan just tell me where that improvement is, I can't find it anywhere

@@bymylife_47any of their concerts or live performances you’ll be able to see it. Especially compared to debut.

exactly like listen to that one Heya performance, they've really improved

isn’t that the purpose of the video…?

@@dozenology lmfao throwing hate? 💀 get a life ma’am,you just put all this clips,edit and add a bunch of ahh text 🏃‍♀️

​@dozenology and the way your snsd just breathed not even and you're like 'omg they ate' all I saw was dancing WHAT WAS THE REASON for adding them if you were not going to show vocals rather than dancing weirdo

@@dozenology the jimin clip did make me giggle tho ngl🌚

@@lorineakoth834they did show vocals tho???

😭😭😭

If they learn to sing. At this point only Yujin knows to sing.

they're better now thankfully

@@gyeomibearThey were always good? It happens to have some bad encores IVE only have like 2 or 3 bad encores their first Eleven and 2 bad I AM encores one of them was in this video and the other was an M countdown one Liz and Wonyoung were slightly off key

@@_Wonnielvrs true, but I'm saying some members like leeseo did struggle initially lol

True

Most of it even sounds like they didn't hear themselves... if you're not sure whether you're singing right, you will most probably have no proper breath support at this moment and will sing badly as a result. Sooo funny! 🫠

right, and a lot of these idols ARE good at singing. these are just bad moments. i hate kpop ‘fans’ who hold idols to impossible standards. these are idols who are constantly singing and dancing and working, of course they’re not going to sound perfect all the time.

@@grlsneverdiewhen has Sakura ever been able to sing

@@aeniverse4- there - ouch! - oh fenriz you hit me - ouch! I hit! you watch me 😰 - Did I scare you? you bit me and I just reacted - Nocturno Culto-shi was giving fenriz affection - biting? Your bites hurt, look here, it's marked! - ok *nocturno whimpers* your annoying - *giggle* oh baby don't cry my love - *pig laugh* sorry sorry I didn't mean to scare you it just hurt... - look, put your hand on my heart 🤕 - giggle there, sorry for the scare, baby, two kisses - Sly guy didn’t shout, it was just you telling me to stop… - laugh, sorry, I'm not going to scream anymore 🤕

@@noneofyourbusiness-tw7dp womp womp

@@bymylife_47 using the child technique I see. Admin is so weird for deleting the replies under this comment. 🤣🤣🤣

@@lesserafimisthebest. bro ur name is lesserafim, just accept the hate. they suck, is a fact

@@bymylife_47Shouts my narco ho's, shouts out Juggalos I got an AK-47, it's solid gold Sunset burnin' down,  I will never fold I got an AK-47, it's solid gold aK-47 AK-47 aK-47 AK-47 Virgin Mary, Guadeloupe, I'm on Fury Road Say your prayers, save yourself  god only knows Bloody horns, bright red, you already know RedBull fallen angels at the arco In my Truey jeans, walkin' with my shadow Ion listen to no dumb fuck Stupid talkin' ho's i been workin' hard I'm gon' buy some guns John Doe, Federales get fuckin' blown Shouts my narco hoes, shouts out Juggalos I got an AK-47, it's solid gold Sunset burning down, I will never fold I got an AK-47, it's solid gold aK-47 AK-47 aK-47 AK-47 World's burning, I'ma buy an AK On Fury Road, lookin' at the sunset Oh, I couldn't really feel nothin' If they try me, I'ma fucking kill 'em World's burning, I'ma buy an AK On Fury Road, lookin' at the sunset And I couldn't really feel nothin' If they try me, I'ma fucking kill 'em Aaahhh Shouts my narco ho's, shouts out Juggalos I got an AK-47, it's solid gold Sunset burning down, I will never fold I got an AK-47, it's solid gold aK-47 AK-47 aK-47 AK-47

The title says that the video is about bad encores, not necessarily has to be new. Since we all know those are just old viral videos that had been going around for some quiet time, we can assume that they should have made some improvement of their vocal considering many people had criticized them.

Sure, these aren't good, nobody's saying that they're good. But saying things like "Yujin fasted" or "I hate you 4th gen" is so unnecessary. And if y'all think this is funny, it really is not. Also, there's other groups like NewJeans and Enhypen that also have really bad encore stages, and those weren't included. So this person doesn't seem to care about vocals when it comes to their faves, they only care when it's groups they hate

period

@@itsrainingcaratzens omg they didn’t include every single possible example of bad singing??? 😱 that just proves their point that 4th gen has a problem with bad vocals. Again, they didn’t say they hated specific idols, they said they hate 4th gen as a whole, which is a perfectly valid feeling. I’ve seen plenty of needless hate in my time as a kpop fan and this is not it. This is legitimate criticism conveyed in a comedic way.

@@LaurenPebble Why are you being so overdramatic?? And the fact that you think this is funny tells me all I need to know. It's only funny for y'all when people get physically or emotionally hurt by others

@@itsrainingcaratzens the fact you think this is hate tells me all I need to know about you ie. oversensitive, can’t take criticism of your favs. IVE is one of my favourite groups (like top 5 favs) and they’re the first group singled out in the video. Justifiably, cause that example is awful. I see some people complaining that they didn’t use more recent clips of any of these idols improvements, but the fact that they were ever at this level is a problem for the industry. I know IVE has improved since this example, but it took them over 2 years from debut, and that Yujin and Wonyoung were already working as idols prior to that should be unacceptable. Not on them, but on the industry. They became idol TRAINEES with the expectation that they would be trained, and their company sends them out to perform like that? It’s laughable, it deserves to be clowned on. And sure, every singer has bad days, but none of the idols showcased in this video were having a one off bad day, and there’s plenty more examples of them out there to show that. I’ve seen plenty of actual hate amongst kpop fans, plenty of fan wars, hell I’ve been called ableist for not stanning ateez. This isn’t hate. I’d say it’s certainly on the line. But the overall tone of this video is not hateful, it’s critical. Hate is when people were picking on Lia and saying she wasn’t good enough to be ITZY’s main vocal, that she shouldn’t be in the group, even body shaming her and calling her names because of her singing. That was all directed at Lia when it’s not her fault JYP never gives Itzy songs or her parts that suit her voice. She sang a jazz song on a variety show and she was incredible! She’s a really good singer when she’s singing in the right range. But she was the one that was the focus of the negativity, not the company. While this video is clearly targeting the industry as a whole, not specific idols or groups, just using them as examples of the problem in the industry as a whole.

which one

it was just humour lmao i cringe with a LOT of things lately

Imagine crying over winning a music show trophy. They are obviously overeacting to Gain sympathy from fools like you.

thats gfriend actually

And then you clicked again to comment? Anyway mamamoo was shown as an example of a good one girl

she always admits she’s a dozen herself like this is just humour

@@safetypin127 but not all of them win on music shows + have good music…

​@@lucyyy222just say nmixx girlie you ain't slick LMAO

Oh and a pls change the thumbnail to that boys face. I wanna see something. You think he's bad too right?

While I do understand what you’re trying to say, and I do definitely think this person was overly critical for no reasons, they don’t necessarily have to be a singer to hear if someone sang good or not.

We have ears and know when someone sings bad. Also these idols are paid to sing. They can’t even do their job right.

@@vixxexo6855 so because idols are not perfect and sometimes mess up when they sing, that means they’re not good at their job?

Fr we love cyber bullies😻👍

momo 💀💀

his voice is so bad that hybe took the video down 💀💀

@@wooksies oh my word where can I read the book . I knew taeyeon is shady

@@wooksies believing everything jessica says in her books knowing the other members can't respond and she can just say its fiction is crazy lol

@@kevinawarner1005 jessica herself is shady for releasing that book knowing she can say anything without any backlash. None of the girls can respond to her crazy stories since she claims its fiction inspired by her kpop journey lol

Singing while standing still is not an impossible standard. I like one of the groups that was shown to have a bad encore, but I can acknowledge that they’re weak singers. Whether you think being a good vocalist is necessary for idols is your opinion, but wanting idols to sing their own songs well is not asking them to be perfect.

no cuz it’s the way the crazy Jimin stans were tryna defend him…like babes he just can’t sing

@@wooksies this has happened to other idols too, Yujin and Chaewon were top 6 best vocalists in IZ*ONE and then BAM they redebut and can barely hold a note? idk what goes on behind the scenes of some of these companies but it certainly isn’t vocal lessons.

ty i guess (?

period blood

It’s basically a trend now that when idols sing bad in encore stages they fuck with their earpiece to look like they’re having a problem and that’s why they sound bad. If the earpiece was really the problem they could just pull it out and they’d be able to hear themselves and the music and no longer have a problem. But they don’t, they just touch it and shuffle it around in their ear.

they disbanded actual amazing singers to debut dancers 🤧

Well you should be blaming your Min hee jin instead of those girls