You can tell Dave's insecurities were keeping him up that night, making him repeat "DID I give that pizza place a fair shot by just doing the casino branch vs. the main branch?", and finally he gets up after staring at the ceiling all night and says "fuck it, we'll just go so nobody can say I didn't give these people a fair shake", and that's clip #2.

Hey, Dave! That was me serving at the register that day! I'm super sorry that you couldn't get a whole pie and for the long wait, but hopefully you can come back on a day not as hectic so you can enjoy the full experience! But nontheless, it was a joy to have you in our shop! Happy Tuesday Keith S, Kitchen Manager

First two day pizza review! Dave's dedication knows no bounds!

Mikey's Late Night Slice started out as a food truck selling pies by the slice for the drunk college kids. That is why it was named that, and that is why the pie is made the way it is. They also had a signature sauce, which they had to change the name of when they rebranded and became big. Just an FYI for anyone outside Columbus who is interested about the place.

Prez pulling no punches lately with the scores. The man's back!

An hour late everybody knows the rules

That looked like the doughiest, soupiest, dominoesiest pie I have ever seen

My friend worked with Mikey when he started the business out of a food truck. Funny enough all he did was get some Dominos pizza [ingredients], sell it out of the truck, and he'd be open later than most businesses at the time. MLNS is definitely the best pizza in my hometown, but you gotta try the unicorn sauce :)

as a guy who loves doughy pizza.. that shit looked amazing lol

"Way better", goes up by 0.4, every body knows the rules

Respect the dedication and thoroughness, especially for a not so great pizza.

Love ya, Dave. Guaranteed a laugh every day.

Two days, everyone knows Dave was up for longer than that. 😆 Bro has those shake hands, but I give him credit, he's still out there doing the damn thing!

I always look forward to these videos :)

Dave holding that garlic bread like a fine Cuban cigar 😂

The kind of pizza you eat when you really crave pizza But the good spots are closed

Much better then the casino and then a kick to te nuts 6.5 😂😂😂

Dave already set his (expensive) watch back an hour to fall back.

Dave snatching at that garlic bread like a man that's addled off his face, everybody knows the rules.

Almost gave him his slice .. and didn’t know pizzas got crispier after driving around with it damn mind blowing

Tex in the back still rocking that crazy haircut. Was wondering when I’d see him in a barstool vid again

Is there a schedule of where he's going next? It would be cool to come out and see one!

So I've always known Big Cat to have brain damage, but apparently to him pizza gets crispier after it sits in a box and you take it to your room. Wow.

2:39 Big Cat: "How many bites?" Looks like Dave forgot his own slogan, 'One Bite, Everybody Knows the Rules.' 2:43 Dave looks like he lost his memory and responds, "One, if you want." Barstool Pizza Review - Mikey's Late Night Slice (Hollywood Casino) 🍕 6.1 Next Day: Barstool Pizza Review - Mikey's Late Night Slice (High Street) 🍕 6.5 Barstool Garlic Bread Review - Mikey's Late Night Slice (High Street) 🥖 5.8

He’s wearing the same clothes as the day he went to the Jack Link’s wrecking room…shit’s about to go down! 😂

Wow, I agreed with Dave in both spots. First location was a classic 6.1 drunk pie, kind of a soft, doughy blob, this one looked like a different pie but still not great. For a 1 am dorm room pie, I'd kind of prefer the 6.1 in a strange way because that "chewiness" is strangely satisfying when you're drunk. The second one, while technically "better", is in kind of a no man's land for pizza, it's not one thing or another.

Damn - real score Dave is back?

Lived in Columbus my entire life, Mikey’s is as Dave said - drunk pizza. You get it at 2 in the morning when you’re hammered and can’t make it to a 24 hour McDonald’s. It’s no one’s first choice for day time pizza.

Mikey's Late Slice downtown (457 N. High) is definitely different than that pizza. Mikey's Late night downtown location is closer to a Columbus version of Joe's Original on Carmine St. in Greenwich Village. Similar taste cheese and pepperoni but slightly softer crust.

Thank god!! I’ve been shouting this for years that late night slice is crap pizza and thankfully the score reflects that!

1:12 Dave: “ I’m independent, I don’t owe anybody anything.” 3:36 Dave: “ I owe it to these guys to give them a fair review.”

From a Columbus native, Mikey’s has definitely fallen off. Their speciality pies are good though.

The thing with Mikey's is that the pizza is good but the "rebranded" sauce is what makes it great. Also the classic slice with the hotdog smothered in the sauce is one of the best drunk foods of all time lol

How was that Miami bet! Lost $250,000 large didn’t you.

This is fair for Mikey's late night slice. Glad you were treated well here in Columbus. Love the game, love the fans. You're toast next year Portnoy. (Michigan's schedule is so screwed).

soon as he opened the box: doughy, drunk pizza. That's a 6.1. Nailed it.

I spent 10 years eating that pizza and also working right next door to it for 4 years. The review was absolutely fair lol. But where the pizza shines is ordering the "Cheesus Crust" at 1 in the morning after a bar shift.

I'm glad Dave is an UNDEPENDENT guy!

Still waiting for a Jack’s coal fire pizza re-review

All of daves employees are scared of getting roasted on camera by him

I would go into any restaurant that advertises "Booze" as prominently as this place.

As a pizza guy who grew up in columbus ohio and has seen just about every pizza review on this channel, the columbus spots Dave visits makes me die a little bit inside. I can only assume other columbus people are recommending these places which makes it even worse. There is a book called Columbus Pizza: A Slice of History by Jim Ellison that describes the underrated rich and flavorful history central ohio pizza has. Thin crust cut in squares. None of these jabroni joints are worth any attention. Visit places like massey’s, bexley pizza plus, rubino’s, ange’s pizza (any location), Joes on east broad, or even donatos!!! These frat bro drunk slice joints like adriatico’s, hounddogs, and this spot do not represent columbus pizza and we do not claim them. After this review i can only assume now that these choices are intentionally meant to slander columbus because dave hates ohio state.

Mikeys is open in Cinci till 3 am, I think they used to be open later, great place to go near rhinegeist

When dave doesnt love a pizza he either goes with "drunk pizza" or "football pizza" Every time

joe dirt in the background, gotta love it

I have been waiting for this dave, a few years back when you tried adriaticos or whatever you mentioned a place open late and I knew this is what you meant. The one on campus is the spot

Better late then never!

5:14 an inna wanna no fo garlic. Classic Dave.

".......if we're being honest." Very articulate for a whacked man. I missed by one point. Keep it real Mr. Portney.

High Street in Columbus... drank in a bar for the first time there when I was only 17.

There’s so many better pizza places to try in Columbus :/ but it’s cool to see you trying Mikey late night, classic

I lived in C-Bus for 6 years and I never really liked Mikey's. I tried Taft's Brewporium last month and I thought it was pretty solid. Not sure if anyone else has had that one, but I was hoping to see a review!

I was dead on the garlic bread 5.8 lol

Great vid

“So much better” 6.5 😂😂

This time baby, I’ll be bulletproof!

Try Lupi’s in Chattanooga, TN

I think the "Go Marquette" dude was the same guy that Pres demolished at the casino lol

Dead on review. Not bad, not great. It's in the name, get this late at night when you're drunk with friends. They do have some pretty good sauces though

Mikey's S. 4th St. location is the one to go to. Unless their slices are fresh, better off ordering one of their whole specialty pizzas. Those are pretty good. If the wait is too long for you, go a couple of doors down to Dirty Franks.😁

Dave was late. He had to pay the bookie. Big $$$$.

Brutal honesty😘

The branding on the place is awesome. Pizza doesn't look great though.

literally looks like costco pizza w/ fluffier crust

From thumbnail i thought it was a collab but the collaberator is dave portney

Holy crap! I said 6.1 when he took the first bite 😂 I am playing the lottery tonight

I wish you could drive 20 min north to 4 points pizza. Smashes anything your gonna try in town!

Dave you gotta go to St Francis Apizza next time your in SW Ohio…. It’s some of the best you’ll find here

He's never done Tommy's in Columbus has he? He should do a Tommy's VS. Icanos . Icanos is the son of Tommy.

Lookin snazzy Dave

pretty much spot on you were being nice with the score even the place is not good at all the spot in the casino is horrible like the service i mean look at how its staffed and the staff- their supplier is restaurant depot what do you expect- no one in columbus is going let me go out and get some mikeys late night NO ONE i've never ever heard anyone say that its like a last resort their better be no line and no other options or you just have pizza on your mind and thats it

6.1 = Don't Pay for this Pizza. If you get handed a slice, and you're insanely drunk, go ahead and eat it, but you're gonna regret it tomorrow.

First ever Big Cat review?!!!!

"This time, baby. I'm coming through." 😅 She knows the rules.

I was just in Columbus. Also, my dad works there and this is his go to. (Best pizza near his work place) I am not sure how he will react when he finds this in his feed.

"1 bwite, everybody knows the woose" 😂 WTH!

Try seven mile pies in stone harbor NJ

Moravella's Pizza in Naples, FL was my #1 to go spot... check them out if you're ever there!! I'm in OH now.. looking for that to die for Pizza!... Original Pizza Place in Marietta,OH is my spot for now.

I'm pretty sure that's Chad Kroeger from Nikelback behind the bar... 🎶 Look at this beer on tap... let me pour you a draft 🎶

One slice everybody knows its way past Daves bedtime!!!

So many hours spent there. Always got the Chinese food instead. It’s 🔥

There’s no way “Big Cat” can take that pizza home and have it “crispier.” The cooling and grease would make it softer/soggier.

I wish dave would come to chico ca

You should go back to lakewood and give Angelo’s pizza another review!

"Waaaaaayyyy better than the casino" = 0.4 points higher

L.A. Knight does pizza reviews now?

Two different pizzas, and things are always 'crispier' when reheated

Is that Quinn Ewers behind you in the gray

“FUCK YEAH, MY MAN!!”

Looks like a fun city though!

So this was filmed back on March 17?

Geezer Butler tending bar

You're supposed to eat it with the casino's cheap cocktails after winning a few bets. Hollywood Casino likes to offer slots only promo money. You can play and cash out at least 50% of it to pay for the pizza too, essentially making it free.

Dave, good call with Miami to win the tournament. They still have a shot

The Prez keeping it real with an honest score. That pizza had more flop than Dave after a little too much tootskie!

DAVE IS LATE 7PM EST POST😂🤷‍♂️🤦‍♂️

One bite!

I was wondering what Iggy Pop was doing nowadays. Apparently working at Mikey's Casino location. I'm thinking that score may have been inflated.

now ive had mikeys late night slice and it hasnt looked like either of the ones he had,, the one I had was definitly not a 6.5 it was an 7.6 although for the insane price of $30 for a full pie id give it a 6.8

Big Cat does not know the RULES!!!!