Bertrand Russell on God (1959)
Рет қаралды 111,656
13 жыл бұрынThe fantastic Bertrand Russell talks about his thoughts and beliefs on god or lack there of. Regardless of your own personal beliefs you have to admire the way in which he stands by his own beliefs when under scrutiny.
@donaldwhittaker7987 23 күн бұрын
Great guy. First learned about him when I was 16 and he had just died at age 97. I felt like I knew him. He made me feel smart. In time, I became smart. And it has stuck with me ever since.
@orion7592 Жыл бұрын
Bertrand Russell was the embodiment of an immense intelligence. He was a sincere human being who seemed to be most honest with himself. As a fellow atheist, I resonate with his intellect and ideas. His honesty enabled him to challenge Mathematics in the most provocative way by introducing his famous paradox. As atheists, we do not necessarily dismiss those who endorse religious values and beliefs. We merely ask if whether you truly and honestly accept those tenets and ideologies to be true!
@vaxrvaxr Жыл бұрын
That's of course a very inconvenient question when you're trying to convince yourself of some religious belief.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
@@vaxrvaxr ??? I know most religious beliefs are in fact true. Pieces of the larger picture. Im not a cuck.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
@@dianemorrell9638 Just imagine for a moment that everything you've ever been taught is a lie. Vaccines are Safe and Effective, Flouride Microplastics are good, Monsanto Bayer Pesticides are good 5g is good Climate Change is Real and you need to give us totalitarian control because of it. War Is Peace The Truth is A lie Ignorance is Strength Wake up You don't believe in science. Thats the dumbest thing anyones ever said. You do the science you follow the facts wherever they go. Anyone that says X can't be true aren't scientists they are brainwashed normies. Read My Quote From Betrand Russell. You wouldn't know reason and Facts if it hit you in the face. 1984 is the Elites plan for the World As is brave New World Orwell and Huxley were killed for releasing it to the public. Its like animal farm things we knew to be true have been trained out of us over the generations. I'd read Bill Coopers Behold a Pale Horse. He predicted the 9/11 attacks and that the Government would blame Bin Laden and use it to start wars and sieze our rights. He was killed for that.
@Samael-Metzger 11 ай бұрын
overrated.
@markymark8196 Жыл бұрын
One of the greatest minds of the last 100 years. I love his philosophical writings and thoughts.
@stelioeffrena6909 Жыл бұрын
he was a technocrat commie mistaken for a philosopher. Mathematicians speaking about morality always ends up in dull unfounded cringe
@CIMAmotor Жыл бұрын
@@stelioeffrena6909 Yep, agree.
@Rumplesti1tskin Жыл бұрын
Stella, how painfully ignorant. Russell condemned Marxism and communism.
@blumpkinspicelatte4580 5 ай бұрын
One of the greatest turds of the last 100 years. English accents don't indicate intelligence contrary to popular belief.
@tgunersel 9 жыл бұрын
A true hero. I read his essays -including "Why I am not a Christian*- when I was 13 and felt the need to question my "liberal Muslim" upbringing and first I decided to become an agnostic, then, at 15, I categorized myself an atheist citizen of the world. I prefer to call myself a naturalist and the supernaturalists 'a-naturalists".
@tgunersel 8 жыл бұрын
Alexandria School of Science Thank you. Would you be interested in the Earth Civilization Project I initiated 3 years ago ? :)
@solidus1995 8 жыл бұрын
Yes I prefer the term naturalist over atheist as well. But ironically I like atheism because it's most known, despite many believers having misconceptions about it.
@JeffRebornNow 6 жыл бұрын
Bertrand Russell was an agnostic, not an atheist. I should add, also, Lord Sathanus, that whereof you cannot speak, you should remain silent.
@TheTariqibnziyad 5 жыл бұрын
congrats i left islam at 21, then again its harder when you live in an islamic shithole
@harounrashad1052 5 жыл бұрын
@@TheTariqibnziyad Which country do you live in?
@petproshorts 11 жыл бұрын
I can't get enough of this guy face after answering each question, I'd pay a lot of money to know what was going on in his head during the intervals lol
@like_the_comment 9 ай бұрын
Are you still alive bro🤔🤔
@Ojcovito-ck5le Ай бұрын
I suppose there is ride of valkyries being played in his head
@MMaximuSS1975 9 жыл бұрын
Beautifully said.
@MsJavaWolf Жыл бұрын
Deathbed conversions are the opposite of logic. Scared people, who are in pain, will do almost anything to alleviate it, take any medicine or drug. Bringing up deathbed conversions seems more like an argument for atheism to me.
@Electronite1978 11 жыл бұрын
Such an irony that so many simple minded representatives of our specie come to mock one of the most brilliant minds in history. It is like throwing pearls to the pigs. What would pigs know of the real value of this mans thoughs.
@seanb6626 2 жыл бұрын
i couldn't agree more
@bluetc1474 2 жыл бұрын
💯
@alexandriabaroque937 Жыл бұрын
The word is "species." There is no such word as "specie."
@Umbriel92 Жыл бұрын
@@alexandriabaroque937 Come on man he typoed it it's no deal
@dimitrioskalfakis Жыл бұрын
brilliant man with valuable lessons to teach all of us.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.
@marcusaurelius9123 3 ай бұрын
@BertrandRussell2 you need help. Look into your hateful soul ..this gentleman is all that is good. You resent him because he calls out your fallacious beliefs. Reflect & repent. Seek the truth not ancient myths.
@archie977 11 жыл бұрын
thanks for posting
@Ben-vf8jv 7 жыл бұрын
This is one of the most concise arguments against christianity I have ever heard.
@CHRISDABAHIA 6 жыл бұрын
Ben No kidding....
@ishmaelforester9825 6 жыл бұрын
Nonsense. It doesn't touch Christianity on a single point. The idea the followers of the Lord think it is merely expedient is nonsense. No, the Lord incarnated and confirmed selfishness as the supreme evil when He united man to the God on the cross. Expedience or mere feeling has nothing to do with it.
@FMB_Bmg 4 жыл бұрын
@@ishmaelforester9825 selfishness is actually the cause for morality. Without selfishness, there would be absolutely no point in having a morality whatsoever.
@ishmaelforester9825 4 жыл бұрын
Prisons are built with stones of law, brothels with bricks of religion - Blake
@HughJaxident67 2 жыл бұрын
@@ishmaelforester9825 *Prisons are built with stones of law, brothels with bricks of religion* It seems to me the concept that an all knowing and all powerful god cares so much about what people do between the sheets is an utter nonsense and only deserving of ridicule.
@bliots8369 10 ай бұрын
I watch this video and all I can think about is Ecclesiastes when Solomon writes about the meaningless of life apart from God, "I said to myself, 'Look, I have increased in wisdom more than anyone who has ruled over Jerusalem before me; I have experienced much of wisdom and knowledge.' Then I applied myself to the understanding of wisdom, and also of madness and folly, but I learned that this, too, is a chasing after the wind. For with much wisdom comes much sorrow; the more knowledge, the more grief." What's the point of devoting your whole life to growing your intellect as much as possible? Apart from the fact that you will never know everything because 1. the human mind is limited and 2. there will never be enough resources or evidence to learn everything, in the end, you're gonna die and leave everything you've worked for behind you. It's just sad. I guess if I had that rigid mindset I would try to make the best of the time I had. I just don't get it. What's the point? He says he sees no evidence for God. How? If there was a God, look where you could see His fingerprints. The trees, the ocean, the order and cycle of the earth, the sun, the moon, the stars, the universe, our minds, our consciousness, morality, justice, virtue, love. There's so much more to life than "the facts". God made our minds for more than that. That idea of strictly living by what you know to be true because it has been tested and experimented and studied just seems sad and flawed to me. Your life will always be limited. Not because what you know to be true is holding you back from what you want to believe, but because you refuse to believe anything which hasn't been tested and validated by science. "I think, therefore I am." Okay. What's the point of being if all you do is think? I don't know, I'm just spitballin' here
@johreh 2 жыл бұрын
There is an immense intelligence and curiousity behind those eyes.
@bpresleyc 11 жыл бұрын
This lady interviewing him is guiding the questions and imposing some a perspective on the questions that appeals to his views...done watching this.
@rekdinhopoetico 10 жыл бұрын
Russell é o meu maior herói na filosofia e ele tem razão em dizer que não há uma razão prática para acreditar no que é falso. Por outro lado, não é possível provar que "não existe uma vida transcendente", seja no sentido cristão, platônico, espírita, panteísta, ou seja lá qual for. Eu não acredito em "after life", entretanto, não posso provar a veracidade ou falsidade de "existe vida após a morte". Nesse ponto, o Russell se contradiz na sua "busca pela verdade". Ora, na ausência de provas, suspende-se o juízo! Eis o cerne do agnosticismo! Não é mais uma questão de "acredito/desacredito". É óbvio que a religião se apoia nessa impossibilidade de prova, assim como o "mau gosto musical" se apoia no "gosto não se discute". Enfim, gosto demais do B.R., principalmente do seu "Análise da Matéria".
@314westender159 Жыл бұрын
Wonderful moments with one of the 20th century's greatest minds. Just imagine how much greater it could have been if the interviewer was up to the task.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.
@HuntingHorn 4 жыл бұрын
where can i find the full interview?
@jamestownf 2 ай бұрын
He seems to have thought himself very smart indeed!
@RobertBDANIEL-ouest7est 27 күн бұрын
as winner of nobel, he likely was quite ' full of himself. ' BR : british rot
@brinderpalkang7827 4 жыл бұрын
Philosophers are roots of mankind,,
@nsjx 2 жыл бұрын
intriguing statement. you may be onto something, and whether that is a good thing in the grand scheme is also an intriguing discussion
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual.
@bigmacdaddy1234 11 ай бұрын
And those roots can be good and bad. There were some bad philosophers.
@RobertoCha 11 жыл бұрын
Brilliant comment about a wonderful human being...
@dickyboyryw Жыл бұрын
Please post more of this interview or say where we can see it? Footage and audio of Bertrand is so limited but usefull*
@mf-h3659 6 жыл бұрын
what a lad
@englishwithmuzammal3596 3 жыл бұрын
This is the man who lived before us, having the views utterly against the existing dogma of religion and seems to be satisfied, which shows intelligence is not about having knowledge by reading the books replete with views, science, philosophy as the truth matters and nothing can stand against it; that said, what, I guess, he could not fathom is something that our intellect is unable to comprehend, and there are many examples in which it has been demonstrated; for example, our inner voice is the proof that evidence cannot physically prove it, but we know that it does exist. The dream is another miracle. Though science explains mechanics but not, why question...
@Lemon_Inspector 2 жыл бұрын
"Don't you think most humans are weak and stupid and should have principles forced upon them?" The interviewer really missed her calling.
@dongjuang4196 Жыл бұрын
You can't force anyone to become strong and clever.
@orion7592 Жыл бұрын
Well said - you noticed it!
@vaxrvaxr Жыл бұрын
Honestly that's what almost everyone thinks. I can be trusted to decide what's right and wrong, but everyone else should be forced by law.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
@@dongjuang4196 ‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.
@cjhoare 10 ай бұрын
Marvellous.
@strafrag1 9 ай бұрын
Brilliant man.
@TheEvolvedprimate 9 жыл бұрын
So smart.
@georgeraviable 5 жыл бұрын
watching in 2019, I read his book about dogmatic statements, its very important what he tells about it, it mainly focused on religion, if people are radical religious please read the dogmatic statement what Russel says.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.
@user-ky5dy5hl4d 23 күн бұрын
''Mathematics may be defined as the subject in which we never know what we are talking about, nor whether what we are saying is true.'' Bertrand Russell
@thepalebluedot4171 5 ай бұрын
It was none other than the french sociologist thinker, Emile Durkheim who has explained about the very mechanism of the societal phenomenon called religion better than so many others before or after him... 🌐
@richardkemp5550 Жыл бұрын
I'm sure that Paul Whitehouse could do a marvellous Bertrand Russell
@moppt6495 3 жыл бұрын
❤️
@gamelightsyt9197 4 ай бұрын
If something is not visible does not mean it is not true, It is one of the basic fallacies, you can never observe an electron or even an atom ,does not mean they do not exist! And even then philosophically , arguments have evolved and one of the finest arguments are in brief as : Contingency argument: Every dependent thing has resource. this resource dependency will inevitably come to an end where there has to be a independent resource , on which every other dependent resource depends on. Fine tuning argument : it describes the probability of the creation of this creation with all odds against it having more probability as close to 99.1 percent but still we came to existence. Non-dual infinity argument etc!
@BalugaWhale37 28 күн бұрын
Russel does not argue as you suggest. To go beyond the perceptual, man had to use concepts. These concepts must be formed using evidence of the senses and logic. You can know about the existence of the invisible such as electron through observing their effects at the visible scale and then using induction and logic to generalize. Russel, as a teenager, found the evidence for God and Christian dogma to be without evidence or without proper logical transformation. Better than Russel, I recommend Ayn Rand's theory of concept formation for a fuller explanation of how we come to understand the world.
@ismailhakkisulucay4596 Жыл бұрын
Please provide the dialogue in text as well since the sound is not clear.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@mobiustrip1400 3 ай бұрын
That's what sceptical enquiry will turn you into.
@jespersorensen4462 2 жыл бұрын
Yep Mr Russell was ahead of his time. (Religion is a weakness.. Bob Dylan: "I just can't make it by myself".).
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual.
@AYVYN 20 күн бұрын
I believe he was agnostic, like most logicians. Talking about the afterlife requires too much linguistics for an answer that should ease one’s mind, but I believe the answer is optimistic.
@Turjak_art 11 ай бұрын
It would be interesting to know what was his last thought before death. Maybe he changed his mind?
@shuaybmhd Жыл бұрын
🖤
@TheMovieAlex 2 жыл бұрын
Alright. Honestly. I listened to alot of interviews. My English isn't bad at all. But I couldn't understand most of the stuff he said, cause of the bad soundquality (maybe also because I was watching from my phone). I just found out about this guy, 30 minutes ago and can't stop watching interviews/biographys about him. Could someone do me a hughe favour and write his sayings down. Would interest me truly, but the mixture of bad sound quality + not motherlanguage speaker is horrible
@ajoybaksi3654 Ай бұрын
Very likely the greatest mind that "lived" during my lifetime; only close competitor would be Albert Einstein. Never untrue to himself or his beliefs. Rest in peace, sir.
@7146533 11 жыл бұрын
he was a prolific thinker and writer - read his essay on the free mans worship - more inspiring than a burning bush or smiting your neighbor or promising hell
@bliots8369 10 ай бұрын
bro really said an essay is more inspiring than the presence of God
@7146533 10 ай бұрын
@@bliots8369 presence of who, dog? Does the world offend you?
@bliots8369 10 ай бұрын
@@7146533 I didn’t mean to sound offended or anything and I apologize if I was too harsh in what I said, but coming from where I am as a Christian who knows and loves God and who tries to live by his word, it seems silly to think that anything that comes from the mind of a human can be more inspiring or powerful than something that comes from the mind of God. And I know a lot of people don’t believe that the Bible came from the mind of God or even that there is a God in the first place, and I get it. No matter how hard you look, you can’t physically see God in the same way you can see the world. But there’s a reason so many people believe in him and love him. The Bible says we see God’s glory by the work of his hands. I just wish more people would look for God with an open heart and mind. I’ll read that essay with an open mind, and I hope you’ll do the same with the Bible.
@samuelbailey2000 4 ай бұрын
@@bliots8369The bible didn’t come from the mind of god. At least not directly whether or not you believe in a god. They came from the minds of the people, claiming their experiences. The Bible is largely a recollection of stories pertaining to god or events surrounding a god, but it comes from the mind of mortals (I’m assuming). I find it ironic that you would hold it at higher value strictly on such a poor premise. For who is to say god did not inspire Russell to write his essays, god works in mysterious ways. There are likely logically rigorous arguments for gods existence, if you wish to be more compelling seek them out and also seek out what the compelling arguments against god are; then you will be able to be much more convincing.
@vaxrvaxr Жыл бұрын
Based and Bertrandpilled.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual..
@vaxrvaxr 10 ай бұрын
@@BertrandRussell2 And you're a lunatic, which is why you want us to believe in God or at least the spiritual.
@familyvideoacct Жыл бұрын
We really need subtitles or captions on this. he makes great points you cant even hear
@garyfoster3854 8 ай бұрын
Time for hearing aids.
@stingray7074 2 жыл бұрын
We are NOT created FOR Fun …..we are created in the First Place TO worship God…..GOD SAYS I AM A TREASURE WHO WANTS TO BE FOUND
@tijgertjekonijnwordopgegeten Жыл бұрын
We have not been created for any reason
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
@@tijgertjekonijnwordopgegeten Read Betrands Russells Quote on Scientific Society's he's one of the Most evil men of his time a nasty Satanist.
@MarthamadaySaamanu 10 жыл бұрын
Soul? LOL! Any theory you have about a 'soul' or a 'feeling' is useless unless it can consistently predict the real world. This is not to say they are meaningless, but merely that they are not precise, just poetic. Surely Russell would know the loose way it is used in the language.
@hawkeyenextgen7117 2 ай бұрын
Funnily enough, Mr. Russell’s reasons for not being a Christian are the reasons to which I myself am a Christian
@JB.zero.zero.1 25 күн бұрын
Makes zero sense.
@paulhease1007 Жыл бұрын
3:22 Bertrand- you would agree that much that makes life LIFE is not material but transcendent and spiritual. Love, consciousness, come to mind. So if we as humans know this, why is it falsehood to ascribe the source of these gifts as a GREATER SPIRIT rather than arising from material beginnings ?? Which one is more logical??? For being so intelligent he doesn’t seems to have grasped simple obvious facts about human existence.
@billthestinker 8 ай бұрын
Tremendous courage to express his opinion
@VincentVonDudler Жыл бұрын
I hope to see Bertrand Russell at 'Blips and Chitz' after I die. Shake his hand or whatever the equivalent is in terms of the beings that are playing this simulation.
@JohnMRockwell 14 күн бұрын
The Hitch of his time
@stevennorton485 Жыл бұрын
since what may be known about god is plain to them because god has made it plain to them for since the creation of the world gods invisable qualities his eternal power and divine nature have been clearly seen being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse, romans 1 v 19
@siyabulelatshali1012 10 ай бұрын
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣, "No, no, I think that's nonsense." 🤞 I love this man.
@stelioeffrena6909 Жыл бұрын
Bertrand „Reddit“ Russel
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@benjaminbessett7798 11 ай бұрын
You shouldnt believe something if it isnt true. But by what basis does one come to truth? Why is there even a concept of truth if God doesnt exist to set the standard. We would only have personal opinion, like Bertrand Russell's, just one more belief among many. Therefore, in order for there to be truth and facts a personal God must exist.
@jameseverett9037 11 ай бұрын
The guy is incredibly, almost unbelievably shallow for being known as a "philosopher." I've never heard a real philosopher make such quaint and poorly thought-out assertions. He sounds like a 5-year old who's mad at his parents because he didn't get the bike for Christmas.
@AYVYN 20 күн бұрын
He’s a logician; every conclusion follow a strict structure composed of evidence or proofs supporting it beyond any reasonable doubt. We know how oxygen was created. Is it an opinion that you need to breathe oxygen?
@user-ky5dy5hl4d 23 күн бұрын
We die and turn to dust.
@peterwesolowski5223 6 ай бұрын
Absolutely the concept of plural multiple Universes applies randomness not creationism. If that is the logic then logic is the most unlogical science of all of them.
@amellirizarry9503 2 жыл бұрын
what a Chad
@BuLYjonnybravo82 Жыл бұрын
I spent most of my life being an atheist and pondering the same questions until on argument without a doubt shook that and have not seen it refuted. Intelligent design and impossible sophistication and and balance of precision MUST be at the hands of a creator. Chaos does not lend itself to to this in any way However you want to refer to God is up to you, but the fact everything had a creator is simply obvious to me.
@vaxrvaxr Жыл бұрын
Ponder again. "Intelligent design" must be at the hands of a creator, but you're presupposing that it is intelligent or designed. What you refer to as "impossible sophistication and balance" is obviously possible, otherwise it wouldn't exist. There is no reason it /has/ to be this way, it might as well just /happen/ to be this way. "The fact is obvious to me" translates to "I have a feeling".
@Poximab13 11 ай бұрын
To what degree is impossible? A sports team being down a bunch of points might lend the words " it's impossible for them to win now" we know it's not impossible but understand that it would be a very difficult feet so we deem it impossible,yet it's absolutely possible. Just because you don't see how it could be any other way than an intelligent creator doesn't mean it can't happen.
@jameseverett9037 11 ай бұрын
@@Poximab13 "Just because you don't see how it could be any other way than an intelligent creator doesn't mean it can't happen." Doesn't mean it did either. You just ignorantly argued for the great unlikelihood that it did though.
@alexandriabaroque937 4 ай бұрын
In "A History of Western Philosophy" Russell states: "I do not myself believe that philosophy can either prove or disprove the truth of religious dogmas." Yet here he is categorically certain that there is no God or afterlife. This seems to be a contradiction, no?
@TheFelimon Ай бұрын
Any question or predicate involving god is not provable as it contains no observable referent, so questions of God are resigned to speculative metaphysics, something that philosophy (in Russells view) has no interest in. This is because it is not a question of logic. The idea of something creating the universe is not provable/disprovable precisely because it is not a matter of logic. If one is led by logic, he is led to believe god does not exist. However, that is not "proof" in the strictest sense. I cannot speak for Russell, but i do not view this as a contradiction.
@TheFelimon Ай бұрын
In attempt to make this more clear, to say im sure that there is no afterlife is to say 'my views are guided by reason, and there is no reason to believe in the afterlife' (reasons being rational or observable evidence) To say that we can disprove or prove the existence of the afterlife is to say 'i can show you through some anlysis of concepts, or observable phenomena, thay the afterlife certainly exists/doesnt exist' The first is rational, the second is impossible.
@milansvancara Ай бұрын
No, it's not an contradiction. If something cannot be proven or disproven it doesn't mean there is any reason tobelieve that it's true. For example: If someone tells you that there is a leprechaun with unicorn dancing salsa together in a different galaxy, it cannot be proven or disproven, but it doesn't mean that you should think it is true. Do you understand?:)
@bonniejean2093 Жыл бұрын
The fool says in his heart, “There is no God.” - Psalm 14:1
@bobbart4198 Жыл бұрын
... " There is a PRACTICAL reason for Believing in God " @0:15 the interviewer states ... and what is that exactly ? ... Pascal's Wager was nothing more than a cop out - if you don't know what that is, look it up ... in the meantime, both Mr Russell and I are waiting for the answer ...
@jessewallace12able Жыл бұрын
His ideal is “good”. As meaningless as what he imagined the concept of “God” to mean for believers.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@fajardofje 7 жыл бұрын
Those people... me la paso por los weeeeebosss
@Polynuttery Жыл бұрын
LOL, how times have changed. Atheism is now intellectually dying and mostly dead, and Christianity is back in force. It has not made it back into the churches yet, but in the bedrock of the academy it is back. Christian apologetics is surging within many Christian communities and I’m personally feeling really good about the intellectual future of Christianity. #AnthonyFlew
@TheSimonBOULDER 11 жыл бұрын
Is "It doesn't happen very often" on deathbed conversions the best argument that the great philosopher and thinker of 21st century can come up with?
@paulbrocklehurst7253 4 жыл бұрын
I'd say it's spot on. I remember when Christopher Hitchens was diagnoised with terminal cancer & I even predicted that as soon as he was in his grave people would start making up stories about him turning to Christ in his final hours & guess what? As soon as he was dead the internet was awash with exactly such claims just as I had predicted they would be. Someone even cashed in on the claim & wrote a book stating that he had because *they knew there was plenty of £$£$ to be made once he was 6 foot under* & unable to call them out. So much for 'Thou shalt not bear false witness' eh? I guess it's just fine & dandy to do so if you want to pretend that atheists are all Christians after all. How did I know that would happen? The same was claimed as soon as Darwin died. Funny how these conversions never happen a little earlier when the atheists in question can be heard saying they've found Jesus for themselves isn't it eh?
@theguardian6464 4 жыл бұрын
@@paulbrocklehurst7253 As a Christian Catholic I still agree with you on a fact that there are many made-up deathbed conversions which is not fine (telling a lie is not ok) . But you never know. I'm just saying that "Deathbed conversions do not happen very often" is not an argument based on facts that men like this seem to be after all the time.
@seanb6626 2 жыл бұрын
what other argument is needed? christians like to act high and mighty when they convert people and it doesn't happen. simple as that
@seanb6626 2 жыл бұрын
@@theguardian6464 seeing as the christian faith lacks a multitude of factual foundation I don't think you're particularly entitled to critique him on that
@glenallen7047 2 жыл бұрын
Why don't you elaborate on what the Bible doesn't have for factual foundation because if you read the the Bible it covers everything from how the earth was created to how we should take care of ourselves, others, how we feel, what to avoid. I tried to prove the Bible wrong and ended up seeing how right it truly was maybe instead of saying its not factual try reading and proving what in the Bible is wrong
@brankozeljeznjak 4 ай бұрын
love him, "god" is pure logic, nothing else, undestroyable, omnipresent. however, reincarnation is absolutely true, the behavior of each individual has an impact on their reincarnation, this is also part of the healthy teaching of Jesus, demonstrably, this is where I differ from Mr. Russell, otherwise the man is completely correct.
@susandrydenhenderson6234 Жыл бұрын
Isn’t this what most intelligent people think when they are about 13, until further reading and experience of life makes them understand religious teachings better.
@jameseverett9037 11 ай бұрын
Exactly. He never grew out of teenage hate for "authority" or greater and longer experience.
@sedad5341 Жыл бұрын
He was a believer, he was believing in what he was saying and that's what a believer is, Russell lived for more than 90 years and was a top philosopher of 20th century and saying am not believer!, Get out of here.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@kellykyunghan3317 2 жыл бұрын
evel
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits.. Spread this Quote.
@bvierville1 Жыл бұрын
Some people are just too smart for God
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
Hows those boosters treating you. Look up Chlorine Dioxide and DMSO if you want to save yourself and everyone you know
@jameseverett9037 11 ай бұрын
@@BertrandRussell2 good info, thanks. I'll pass it on.
@divemylollol6152 8 ай бұрын
Some ppl are too dumb to acknowledge that everything has a Creator The fool has says in his heart There’s no God you fool
@markfurnell6748 Жыл бұрын
Science says seeing is believing. But GOD says believing is seeing! He will NOT place HIMSELF under man's microscope. I expect Russell is no longer an atheist...".the fool has said in his heart there is no God"....Bible
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
Of Course He knows God is real but he was a High Ranking Satanist pushing the 1984 agenda of the UN and the New World Order. Listen to Alex Jones! All our science is just Lies by Evil people and Eugenecists its Dogma
@drbonesshow1 Жыл бұрын
When Bert lost at the track he gave up on the idea of God.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or Spirits..
@stoyanfurdzhev 2 жыл бұрын
From the mouth of the master of false assumptions, it sounds almost like an heresy.
@Atheistic007 3 жыл бұрын
CBC!
@bornaxo55 5 ай бұрын
Seek God!
@skinwakker Жыл бұрын
Ong
@damonbernard2802 11 ай бұрын
Belief in magic/religion is no more than a warm blanket
@calohtar 11 жыл бұрын
Lmfao I need to start doing this to people
@mesija89 11 жыл бұрын
It is not an argument. Please learn what an argument is before you go ask questions about them.
@glitteresque 2 жыл бұрын
well, I still believe my beliefs
@seanb6626 2 жыл бұрын
and they are still wrong
@FelisThis 2 жыл бұрын
On his death bed he sought repentance. Hopefully that was enough for him to enter Paradise.
@FelisThis 2 жыл бұрын
@@karlharrison4726 Very true, friend. God Bless. 🙏✝️☮️💙🕊🙏
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
@@seanb6626 You'd be suprised to know that the majority of every non ironic religions beliefs are true. They are sometimes tainted with Dogma or get a few things wrong but Mostly True nonetheless.
@alparslanseljuqlu7791 2 жыл бұрын
what is the point of being moral while you can do the way you wish
@Lemon_Inspector 2 жыл бұрын
You mean you don't know!?
@alparslanseljuqlu7791 2 жыл бұрын
@@Lemon_Inspector let us know
@Lemon_Inspector 2 жыл бұрын
@@alparslanseljuqlu7791 You really don't know?
@tijgertjekonijnwordopgegeten Жыл бұрын
@@alparslanseljuqlu7791 the point of being "moral" is generally that other people don't hate you.
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual..
@JohnB-uf7ft 2 жыл бұрын
Can you prove love? Can you prove faith?
@Lemon_Inspector 2 жыл бұрын
Yeah. Obviously.
@MotoWorld777 Жыл бұрын
Sad, seems so wise and yet does not believe in the creator.
@leej70 Жыл бұрын
Why would he?
@jameseverett9037 11 ай бұрын
He seems wise? In what way? He sounded like a 5 year old rehearsing a frequently concocted tantrum to me.
@Poximab13 11 ай бұрын
Quite the opposite, further reading and experience gives you atheism.
@maSHEALY 6 ай бұрын
Simple common sense
@giuseppinasalvucci628 Жыл бұрын
Afterlife is a reality
@leej70 Жыл бұрын
How do you know?
@divemylollol6152 8 ай бұрын
@@leej70afterlife is a reality from facts But how do you know we pick the right religion?
@leej70 8 ай бұрын
@@divemylollol6152 What facts?
@divemylollol6152 8 ай бұрын
@@leej70 religious experiences
@leej70 8 ай бұрын
@@divemylollol6152 I don't think you know what facts are.
@augustorafaelpereira6505 Жыл бұрын
A man who prove 1+1 is 2😂
@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY Жыл бұрын
What he was saying was that he did not give a damn about human happiness or suffering! Great philosopher indeed! BAFS
@vaxrvaxr Жыл бұрын
Interesting interpretation.
@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY Жыл бұрын
@@vaxrvaxr I wonder how an ATHEIST can be qualified to speak about God although we saw one Bill Gates being celebrated by the ruling tyrants as the Pope on health matters with zero qualification in Medicine???
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual.
@funtimes8296 Жыл бұрын
As opposed to... religious people?
@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY Жыл бұрын
@@BertrandRussell2 Satanists are the world biggest parasites!
@defjoeffo 11 жыл бұрын
faschism needs obidience. what provides more obidience than religion? the bible states follow your worldly authority and not question it. it says give up real-life aspirations for some bogus about an afterlife. atheism isnt a thing, it is the counterposition to saying "i dont care about what i know is right and righteous and i will spite myself and rather go with some stuff i read in a book" filled with manour. god isnt in the occasion. if god exists, he isnt part of something, think about it..
@tijgertjekonijnwordopgegeten Жыл бұрын
You can be moral without religion, you know that right? Also the fact that you said atheists would rather go with some stuff they read in a book is extremely ironic as that is exactly what christians do (in case you didn't get it I'm talking about the bible here).
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual.. Fascism Requires the Obedience to Man over God.
@vincentparrella3424 6 жыл бұрын
Sad,No Hope,No Hope,No Hope.
@NearVSMello 6 жыл бұрын
For eternity? Maybe. So often religion spoils people that way. Raising their standards for a happy life so ridiculously high, that they smile only in exchange for an afterlife of eternal bliss. Some of us are content with the time we have and even feel lucky to have it.
@antevrcic1529 2 жыл бұрын
Irrational traditional taboo morality that comes down from the savage ages. Perfect description of Abrahamic religions
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual..
@honestabe6926 Жыл бұрын
I hope he changed his mind before he died.
@YT-uo7fc 2 жыл бұрын
There is no religion at all. There is philosophy and people who follow a particular philosophy according to their intelligence.
@AtamMardes 4 ай бұрын
"Religion began when the first scoundrel met the first fool." Voltaire
@johnnya9001 Жыл бұрын
The dogma is not good, the moral lessons are good. When life gets really tough it can offer some solace. I like the expression; "there are no atheist's in foxholes".
@Rat-Salad 2 ай бұрын
Zero evidence of gods or magic. I’m with Berty.
@late8641 Жыл бұрын
What's the use of having a clear set of rules if they're based on a delusion? You might live your whole life following ridiculous rules that will restrict your life and suck all the joy out of it.
@dongjuang4196 Жыл бұрын
Well, to be true everyone does so. Every old man or woman whom I talked to was saying: "What did I live for?"
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual
@fondelmaddick5085 6 жыл бұрын
If you have faith, other than being stupid, you lamely rely on Pascal's Wager .
@seanb6626 2 жыл бұрын
@@littlecousin5630 you can take a dna test that scientifically proves the validity of your parents. truth is subjective, try again
@tijgertjekonijnwordopgegeten Жыл бұрын
@@littlecousin5630 it's not faith if it is based on evidence
@BertrandRussell2 Жыл бұрын
‘’Scientific societies are as yet in their infancy… It is to be expected that advances in physiology and psychology will give governments much more control over individual mentality than they now have even in totalitarian countries. Fitche laid it down that education should aim at destroying free will, so that, after pupils have left school, they shall be incapable, throughout the rest of their lives, of thinking or acting otherwise than as their schoolmasters would have wished. Diet, injections(vaccines) and injunctions will combine, from very early age, to produce the sort of character and the sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable, and any serious criticism of the powers that be will become psychologically impossible...’’ - Bertrand Russell, 1953 He wants to Bring about the New World Order and make the world into 1984. WAKE UP! He's a satanist which is why he doesn't want you to believe in God or the spiritual..
@gavrilopricip11 6 ай бұрын
Bertrand Russell is god
Diana Belitskay
Рет қаралды 22 МЛН
Diana Belitskay
Рет қаралды 22 МЛН