Guys this channel is full of video called PerpetualMotion, but you know those are great pieces of ART. Congratulations for the designs.

I'll have to admit, it's a great way to get website hits, even though trickery is involved in making them run.

とても瀟洒にできました！Your excellent craftsmanship is truly admirable. こんな分かりやすいデモンストレーションは学生たちがよく理解できます。We have very good discussions in class between students who believe the machine will work in the real world and those who recognize where the flaw is. Thank you very much for all of your videos! どうもありがとうございます。

this person is a mechanical genius he's really good at making things that really fool some people

Looks cool =D But if the wheel stays balanced when u stop it, it's not overbalanced =]

I've never seen the chain trick before. That one is really pushing the illusions limits. He presented the trick well until about 2:45. At that time he tries to make a smooth stop, as if the chain were just grabbed and stopped. Unfortunately the timing was off slightly from the stopping of the chain and the stooping of the drive wheel, the top most. The drive is stopped on que but the presenter continues to move the chain trying to come to a smooth stop. Can't win everyday.

Bhaskara Wheel is awesome to me it could turn it to power source with unlimited capability. thank you Im learning a lot about this invention.God Bless Joseph Bernal.

I like youre project very much! Makes ppl think! Greetings from Germany !

i love stepper motors, are compact with excellent torque at low rpm... good trick!

Let me ask you, wise man, what the solenoid does in rotational machine?

I'll admit this guys vids did inspire me (as he hoped)

Wow! It's amazing! (I mean... It's amazing the lack of people's education concerning basic physic laws...)

I hope this will go into a museum to show how some people still waste their lives when they lack a proper science education.

Oh I just love silent videos,, It's all so Charles Chaplin !

the second one makes th most sense......... more chain, more weight. keep up the good work. :-)

All of your videos look awesome and obviously the amount of negative comments is suggestive of the mind set of collective resistence... As if an industry or culture is resistent to simple ideas and fun physics .... Riddiculas resistnce to great demonstrations. I look forward to seing more of your awesome videos.

Just a casual observation that’s probably been made before, but since I haven’t seen it in writing, I’ll attempt do so now. For Bhaskara’s wheel, if you focus on where the center of gravity of the water in each bottle is at every position around the circumference, it is definitely closer to the center on the up side than the down side. This appears to be true through all (actually most) of the positions on one side as it corresponds to the other side. So why doesn’t it work? I think it’s because you need to make the same comparison only instead of side to side, measure the distance of the center of gravity of the water in each bottle to the center of the wheel from top to bottom. The distance is obviously shorter at the top than the bottom and the center of gravity of each water bottle must be lifted a full 180 degrees, however, the distance of the water bottle’s center of gravity doesn’t get to a point that’s farther from the center until approximately the 1:00 to 2:00 position, assuming a clockwise rotation. So, by the time the water bottle’s center of gravity arrives at the farther distance from the center of the wheel it will only offset the wheel for about 150 degrees of downward travel. You don’t need to invoke the laws of thermodynamics to see why this doesn’t work. That’s not a criticism of this very nicely made wheel veproject has provided for us. Actually, I’d like to compliment him because this obvious and fatal design flaw went unnoticed (by me anyway) for the past forty years until I had the opportunity to see in in action. Another point I’d like to make is that if anyone ever does come up with a design that really works, it won’t need a push start-it’ll need a brake to keep it from beginning to spin on its own.

For me in the first moment it was the other way round.

I have a similar if not the same book from 1899. it is a Joy, and clearly states none of the novelties work. Thanks for the Videos!

well said well spoken easy to understand you sir are a positive force in this world

Since the water on the left side is further from the center than the water on the right, this alone would indeed cause the wheel to turn due to the imbalance of leverage. Now here's what they DON'T tell you: The water on the bottom of the wheel is also further from the center than the water at the top. Thus, there is more leverage resisting the lift than there is causing the fall.

gracias a estas personas que ponen este tipo de videos no se puede confiar en la red

I liked the second focus! Top wheel driving.

I like the sound the chain one makes!

12 or 6 Volt?

Why does it need an initial kick? And why it can be stopped???

Hallelujah!!! It's a miracle!!!

oh that switch on sound... marvelous!

Long after both of those have stopped my wife will still be out shopping.

Everyone here is judgemental and rightfully so. ASAP, I will build a test model. If it works, I see exactly how one could produce enormous torque by way of a 16 foot by 50 foot cylindrical model. Then fit as many of them as you can on a twenty acre spread, stacking them 2 or 3 high. Since water is enormously heavy, the torque converted to energy on such a scale would power small towns, or a very large factory or two. Nay sayers are 90% action less and 10% know-it-alls. I'll simply build one.

I'm particularly impressed by the sound of the electric motor that drives it!

THANK YOU Zrowny!!! finally someone who knows what their talking about! im very curious to see what the universe will be like once everything settles into place and seises (sorry for typo) to move. yes molecules are always vibrating but at some point everything will reach absolute zero

С цепью, верхний ролик и нижний, крутятся с разной скоростью.

For the overbalanced chain, in time 1:37 and 1:38 it is possible to see something black behing the top weel. Sure it is a motor. This is the reason you only show the back side of the lowest weels !!!

If there is no trickery involved with the overbalanced chain, I have to say it looks pretty neat ! If there is any overunity here you would need a massive chain to generate usable power from it.

Okay that is so cool!

bad timing on the chain one watch the top pulley stop before he stops the chain by hand this was the drive pulley witch also he does not show us when he adjusted the bolt at the back because he did not want us to see the motor

I have a friend who still firmly believes that machines like this work for real. He's 30, it's sad.

i like this one very much i this is real perpetual motion thanks for sharing from portugal

It is very interesting. Thank you.Is not it okay to combine these two?

what if this is used to charge up a device that can restart the motion when it stops?

You could have at least used a quieter motor for your "overbalanced chain". Or just turned off the sound on the video like you usually do when there's an obvious pump, motor or servo in the machine you're "demonstrating".

Thanks for the information

I also am very interested in the quest for perpetual motion and over-unity machines. Both of these look & sound very promising. If this was presented in a theory - I'd definitely support building a model, however since the model has already been made here and is being demonstrated... there is one way that we can easily conclude that this probably doesn't work: 1) If the test tubes cause greater weight on the left side than the right, it should start on its own without the need for a "push". It is probably very close to a perpetual motion machine and could spin for a long time, but I think it would eventually stop. If he could stop it and let go of it with no push, then it could work. 2) The chain is slightly heavier on one side, but it is also slightly resting on the rollers so that will make up the difference. Same as the previous one... if it was truly perpetual motion, it would not require a push to get it started. As someone who is very interested in these things, I am quite offended by all the 'fakes' and tricks that are out there. It's great to publish it as an idea, but to claim that it works when it doesn't is just anti-productive.

i think~~i see something at the Back of the top wheel 1:38

now electricity company can go banktrupcy !

awesome experiment!!!! tqsm for sharing n utube:-)

if this bhaskara wheel build huge 1, will that thing more energy? im not mean spin fast but power,,

0:06 look at his hand 👌

Why u no let it spin longer?!?! Ill tell you why. It cant.

some of these ideas are cool to watch. I'd hook up a battery and solar charger to keep it powered for a LONG time.

Does anyone know where I can buy one of the little motors (like the one you can hear whirring away when he switches it on in the 2nd clip) to power my perpetual motion device? What batteries do they need?

It's not necessary to be a very smart physicist to understand is it work or not. Just ask a question why it's not already used in a practical way.

If the motion was naturally perpetual you should not be able to stop the machine because it would autostart by itself.

Nice to see there is still uses for micro pager motors.

great work, this should be used in proportional to move the electric generator and other small and heavy machines.

really people believe this video is for real?

we all know there is a free energie. just like teslas said.

Great job keep it up .

Unbelievable! :D

It is funny to read people despising these videos. First of all: these mechanical things are nice and elegant, they are witness of the human ingeniosity answering to an ideal goal. Secondly, who cares about what the builders think about the feasability of perpetual motion? Humanists have built these machines from all over the millenniums, it is an heritage which shouldn't be forgotten as any part of our culture. Thirdly: in our modern physics, spontaneous generation of energy is absurd. So what? Good for you knowing the second law of thermodynamics, go get your bachelor degree.

both are fake, why: 1. in perpetuum motion both will start if you dont hold it anymore but it doesnt. 2. in perpetuum motion it will speed up more and more until it will crash into pieces. nice fake at all

How long this works without momentum, how to bind a Dynamo to generate electricity?

By definition, PMM is the machine which, once activated, would continue to function

It is a Fake

beautiful bearings :)

i really really want to know how long this one turns without any physical manipulation after the beginning "activating first " impuls ? thank you ... love it .. christa from vienna

It's called magic!!!

What if you tried the wheel with a 'slightly' bigger model (some barrels and a large wooden wheel attached to a metal post)? Will it be enough to power a small electric generator?

The overbalanced chain was pretty cool. I wonder how much torque it could produce, maybe enough to propel a pinball up a screw-drive system?

It’s amazing how they hide the motor.

amazing.

interesting...I never know perpetual machines exist before today.

I think what you're doing is great, having a visual that's more than a diagram is very intriguing. Sure to make a few minds move on their own.

the test tube one looked cool. : )

Thank you for sharing. Are they continuous? Stopping time for both?

trop bien ! ;-)

Awesome.

That blue liquid is pulsing energy into the wheel as it sloshes over the top to the left... a Chinese guy has developed a heavy plate system with a drive and using the pulse energy to achieve overunity.

la maquina de movimiento bhaskara podria girar indeterminadamente? osea que generaria energia infinita??

great vid btw

Merci !

Forces are balanced in both cases. This youtuber is a known charlatain.

верхний ролик снабжен приводом, каким вольтажем вы его запитали 6,12 или может быть больше, поделитесь моделью двигателя.

I need to add this in my Tesla ;-)

well at least 2 machines work,thanks for the video, makes you wonder why we do not have giant gravity machines working 24/7 right now...

Hmmm. I'll have to build one and find out! I'll post a video with my findings :o)

こんな玩具欲しい！！

Good one 👍

if the weight of this material is always heavier on one side what could make it stop moving? If one could keep adding a link to an infinite length chain laying on a table it would continually fall from a table if dropped off the edge right?? so long as there is just one link more hanging off the edge....... this is similar as it just keeps adding chain on the heavy side because the chain is connected in a continuous loop. do you think this guy has a motor connected to one of the wheels? is it a continuous loop camera video spliced together what?

Yeas, next video

Notice how one of the parts it rotates on the wing nut or fastener rotates also? That means it is being driven.

i love it :)

It means free electricity, and engines without fuel.. Good job..

Even if there is a motor at the top - still want to make one :P

is it working by gravitation and liquid dinamyc forces?

I took a chain of 80 links on each side of the wheel and found it took 6 extra links to get it to drop on one side. Then I used another wheel to offset the chain and it took 9 extra links to get it to drop so I suspect that each wheel is supporting part of the weight. But I will proceed with the other offset wheels to make that side of the chain longer and see if it will continue on its own. Norman

I'm sad too

el video me gusto esta muy bueno

Can we use this motion for energy?