No, I don't think she is cause: 1. There's way too many plot holes: She was born in 1998 yet Billy died in 1996 so how can she be his daughter and when did he have time to cheat? 2. Billy and Sam look nothing alike smh

I don't think she is, she may be mentally unwell

Well I did notice a girl looking at Billy when he's with Sidney and stu and but I couldn't tell if she was Hispanic or not at times talking to that boy on the bench. Or could've been another girl Sidney went to school with. Which could come out like in scream 4 Dewey deputy happen to find out she went to school with them.

No I don't believe it sam is the daughter of billy

Prepare for a BIG yap session: I definitely believe this theory. Simply, Christina developed a crush on Billy Loomis, and it became kinda obsessive, she decided to come up with fantasies about it and wrote them down as if they were real, eventually she got with Sam's father, or could've been with him during these fantasies Then the day came where Sam found these diaries, and read them, and yelled/cried at her mother about this, not knowing her father was there, causing him to leave. This "revelation" of Billy being her father, her dad abandoning her family, and her mother becoming an alcoholic, all led to Sam having a mental break, starts seeing Billy Loomis around (if its a ghost, drugs wouldn't be able to surpress that), and also he didn't start showing himself to her until after this revelation, and this mental break of her thinking she's psychotic due to being Billy's child led to very violent and delinquent behavior, as Judy points out. Also, Sam would be a little psychotic, but not because of the "Loomis bloodline", but because of a mental break due to several factors, and her mom probably had a little bit of psychosis or some other mental condition to be obsessed with Billy which passed to Sam which wouldn't help Sam's mental break. Also, there is no "Loomis Bloodline" of psychosis, like some think is the case. Ms. Loomis wasn't a crazy psycho capable of murder all the time, she was a regular woman who met and married Hank Loomis, and once she found out Hank cheated around with the town mattress, she left, kinda like Sam's dad, and this would have an effect on her mind, she was cheated on, and then she probably felt guilty for abandoning her son, and then a year later, she finds out her son was murdered by the daughter of the woman who broke her family apart, which would've broken her, causing a psychotic break. Billy, also was just a kid, he also wasn't just a "mamas boy", cause clearly, he didn't go after he father at all, he was abandoned by his mother, and as a teen, he probably blamed himself to some degree, clearly not his dad, and then Roman comes along and shows him that his dad slept with Maureen, his gfs mom, and again, he didn't go after his dad, so he was probably both a mama and daddys boy, and he was manipulated by an adult, so again, all this stuff, led to a mental break. Its not some psychotic gene passing down, its a bunch of conditions leading to mental breaks. Geez, yap session over Also, I remember coming up with this theory (well I thought I did) in one of your community posts for one of your early subscriber specials

It would be stupid because the whole point of Sam being Billy’s daughter is carrying on his legacy. Do not see how insane she is she is definitely Billy daughter and you can see in her eyes. Christina would’ve denied it tho and she would have not put it in the book in the first place if it wasn’t her daughter. Ngl it would be insane if she wasn’t but it wouldn’t make really sense for her story if they did that

Do you think Sam secretly ISN’T Billy’s daughter?

this theory would be funny in a way that it furthers the unhealthy obsession with celebrities and fandom. Like Sam being somewhere in the mix of being crazily obsessed too. but that could even still be the case if she is canonically Billy's daughter. Like she secretly is having her own Emma Roberts moment in both movies- loving the attention. Woodsboro must be like so boring hahha

i loved this video and this theory... also, i agree

Rather she is or not. I always found it weird how two Caucasians made a Hispanic baby. 😅😅

This theory falls apart when you remember that they got it tested when she was 13. Which is why Sam and Tara’s dad left.

what if i told you she’s just Billy’s daughter 😮