On my 3rd X5 (2010, 2014 and 2017 - each "ordered") and I looked closely at the Q7 when I got my 2017 X5. In fact, I tried to get the Q7 but the Audi dealer wanted more money for a car (off the lot) with a slightly lower MSRP (for a 3 yr 30k mi lease) and would not budge to even make them equal (even tho the Q7 "build" had about $1000 lower MSRP); that pushed me back to X5. I agree with this Autoportal review almost completely. There are a few other things Autoportal did not mention: 1) Wind noise in cabin at Highway speeds: X5 has unnecessary wind noise (experienced in all 3 X5s, reported in all 3 X5s, and never reduced), Q7 cabin is far quieter (even at highway speeds). 2) Even though X5 steering wheel is smaller (which I like), the design of the instrument cluster is such that with the steering wheel at a comfortable tilt/telescope - the top of the steering wheel obstructs the top of the instrument cluster, so even with HUD - some of the indicators on the instrument cluster remain blocked and are not replicated in the HUD (e.g. turn signals, top of tach, lane-drift indicator, etc.) - the Q7 instrument cluster is not blocked at all. That said, the 2018 X5 will probably have an all "display" instrument cluster (BMW's version of the current Q7 display) so, as customizable, this issue may get solved. 3) Drive mode (Sport, Comfort, Eco): here too Q7 takes the lead because it is programmable to remain in the mode selected until changed - in other words, if you prefer "sport" mode, the car can remain in "sport" mode until that mode is changed by a driver. X5 ALWAYS reverts to "comfort" every time the vehicle is started so if you prefer "Sport" mode, you have to manually select that mode each and every time you start the vehicle - HUGE mistake on BMW's part and an EASY fix (just establish a driver selected default setting or make the 3-way rocker to hold its position rather than default back to "Comfort" mode each and every engine start - I gave this exact feedback to BMW on my 2014 X5 [dealer says they got many feedback comments saying the same] and 3 model years later BMW has still done nothing about this obvious FLAW). 4) Autoportal says this, but less directly: While the X5 is by far more the "performance" vehicle (and I think BMW has their mantra right "the Ultimate Driving Machine", I think they make one big mistake: As realistically USED/Driven, these vehicles are more urban luxury (for the most part) over real "performance", the "performance of X5 is amazing for such a heavy SUV but the ride is a bit too stiff - especially for urban bumpy roads. Too much of the bumps transfer thru to the cabin/seats and this could easily be softened a bit to make the ride just a bit softer and more comfortable - drive a bumpy road and you certainly FEEL it. Q7 ride is much nicer in this regard. I think Audi went a bit too far and sacrificed a bit too much of the performance while X5 is a bit too far on the "performance" side so the vehicle sacrifices comfort - and, realistically, it is used FAR MORE on urban bumpy roads than true opportunities to push and enjoy the top-end of the performance scale; so I think BMW could compromise just a bit on the top-end of the performance scale to achieve an urban/bumpy-road ride that is a bit softer and more enjoyable (or at least offer that as an option on "ordered" vehicles). I am not an engineer so I do not know "how much" to move the needle but I would imagine there is a "sweet spot" somewhere shy of max-"performance", with more day-to-day comfort and still not sacrifice as much "performance" as Audi did in the Q7. All said, I think the X5 is by far a better looking vehicle and more "fun" to drive. I would just prefer a slightly softer ride (some of the bumps more absorbed by the suspension - perhaps to the level where drivers would not feel driving over a pencil, which I would certainly feel in even my 2017 X5) even if it means a slight reduction in max (max/high-end) "performance", cabin highway noise reduction, more engineering on the steering wheel/driver-visibility of the instrument cluster and user-settable-default on the drive-mode setting.

That is what we call as honest review... supporting both brands...great comparision once again..autoportal👌

After extensive comparison from tech spec's to actual long test drives- the 2018 BMW X5 xDrive 50i w/most options including the 'M' options w/21" wheels the X5 is an AWD beast upon initial take off/passing another vehicle at 65MPH/hitting the brakes hard at 75MPH and staying glued to the road in severe turns. In comparison the Audi Q7 does NOT offer an engine that compares to the BMW X5 xDrive 50i twin turbo V-8 which provides in excess of 445 bhp unless you switch to the Sport+ mode which is a significant boost from a dead stop. The Audi Q7 felt spongy/sloppy on any type of severe cornering at 35MPH or 'panic braking'. The seats are comfortable in both vehicles but the Audi does get the nod on plush comfort. The BMW gets the nod on 20 way adjustable driver's seat that you can custom adjust to have you feel securely seated w/the side bolsters, lumbar adjusted and leg extension embracing you to your level of comfort w/the seat belt on. You do not 'slide' in a severe corner or stop. After long test drives the Audi is a soccer Mom's ideal vehicle and is a sled when any severe turns are attempted at speeds above 25MPH. The BMW is quite the opposite and almost 'begs' to be driven...NOT beaten but driven w/confidence around any corner or on curvy on/off ramps to or from a highway. The BMW has NO highway noise/ or wind noise at 90MPH+ whereas the Audi wind noise begins around 60MPH-same as several others. Comparing the Audi Q7 to the BMW X5 xDrive 3.5i is fair as the BMW X5 xDrive 50i nearly negates the need for the X5 M w/540+ bhp! Just looking at the vehicles from the front and rear the BMW appears to have the fattest low profile tires out of ANY 2018 SUV (yes, the I loved the Porshe Cayenne Turbo but the cost difference made no sense) and when you look at the Q7, Volvo XC90, Porsche Cayenne, Range Rover, Mercedes GLE they all looked 'normal' until you see the BMW X5 50i w/those road grabbing rear 'slicks'! The BMW X5 is 10" wider at the rear than from the front! Out of all the SUV's I drove the two that were actually fun to drive and had phenomenal sound systems were the Porsche Cayenne and the BMW X5 xDrive 50i and for stupid money the Porsche Cayenne Turbo and the BMW xDrive M would be a blast! Where one could drive them to fully enjoy the vehicles performance is nowhere in my state. The BMW X5 safety ratings and crash test ratings were superior and as much as I wanted a domestic SUV that felt glued to the road, was fun to drive, offered all the various amenities I wanted NONE came close to the BMW X5 xDrive 50i w/the all the various options I selected. Lastly, the integration of the various screens and options you can customize from the driver's seat are MUCH easier and more intuitive in the BMW X5. The Audi, Porsche, Lexus were convaluted in comparison. In closing, I confess to being biased as I purchased the BMW xDrive 50i but before extensive and fair reviews of each SUV I test drove. I was leaning toward the Mercedes GLE loaded up until a friend mentioned he had just ridden in a 2018 BMW SUV w/the V-8 and he was very impressed. So thank you William! FYI- BMW came out w/a BMW X3 xDrive 40i that is supposed to be extremely impressive in all areas. I was VERY relieved when I sat in one and it was a bit to small/cramped for me as I am 6'2" and most of my friends all seem to be at 6' or more and there is nothing more irriataing then two large people rubbing shoulders/elbows for lack of space to spread out! Either way you go, IMHO you will be pleased with any of the above SUV's as the quality sadly puts Escalades/Expeditions to shame. On a positive note, technically you are buying American if you decide on the BMW X5 as it is produced in SC, USA!

both cars are really good, as bmw always make a car which are more liked by good drivers.

The best gentleman I have seen and soo honest reviews...Kudos Ashish sir👍👍👍👍God Bless

Awesome...I see all your reviews Ashish Sir! You add nice humour too! plz share bloopers at the end of the year

Autoportal all wheels reviews are simply best... To hear, to watch and to be like.... I really love all that your presentations....... Tq wishing you all goodness!!

I've test driven the new Audi Q7 and I have no idea how you can even compare the interior of the Audi to the BMW. No I don't see how the Audi is supposed to have a "better" interior, IT DOESN'T. Pay close attention to the Q7 interior materials and you will find A LOT more hard plastics than you would find in an X5. The screen in the Audi is far away from the driver/passenger and looks very small compared to the space available in the dash. The screen in the X5 is closer, larger, and looks a lot more high quality than the screen in the Q7 which looks like an after thought. In no way is the Q7 a better SUV than an X5.

one of the best review on youtube, keep it up, I proud myself to subscribe to your channel :)

I love my BMW X5!😍♥️♥️

One slight correction - 2017 x5 comes with a digital instrument cluster just like new 5 series and a slick touch panel for mmi interface. Overall its an excellent review.

That spare wheel in Q7....wtf were audi guys smoking :D

Your reviews reassurring for an when any one of family member have to buy a car I give your channel links

The X5 has a 4 Zone climate control system as standard, And the 2017 model has a Digital Instrument panel, and updated 19" Wheels, even the dashboard and cabin is much nicer than the Q7. I challenge to review both Cars better than him...!

Awesome review!👌👌 can u pls do a review on the Mercedes Benz GLS?

Wow i wish i had this guy at my dealership.. YOURE AWESOME!

bro your review is absolutely phenomenal. no one can touch your performance...

Really good review. So few reviewers spend enough time talking about the 2nd row. Well done.

Thank you for a comparison video that is to the point and does not drag on and on about unnecessary details. We enjoyed your video, but we wish you took a seat on the 3rd row of the X5, unless you got a 2-row model with sliding 2nd row, if this is available where you live. I don't think sliding 2nd row is available in the USA without 3rd row. Look forward to hearing your 3-row comparison of Q7 vs X5. Thank you.

Did you guys use the same 3L on the X5 with almost similar horsepower with Q7 ????

Great video 🔥💯

I like ur review

Excellent review! I'm in UK but find this very relevant in 2024. Thank you

Your thoughts on the Audi tdi v6 vs bmw diesel inline 6? Reliability?

sir you are king of car reviewer I love your channel autoportal

Best review

really good review👌

Really curious about where this road is, as many reviews are shot here. What a location!

i like ur channel and i like u sir its time to update ur cameras please ;-)

Very good review, i prefer comfort, went with the Q7, very happy with my choice!

Please do a comparison review between bmw 5 series and jaguar xf

can u plz compare x3 vs q5 vs xc60

sir no one can beat your style of car review.

bmw is fun to drive... no one can beat it..

Much waited comparison

I have been waiting for this review for a while nw ........happy that u've done it........as always u r the best reviewer..........

Also do the review of Range Rover evoque

I have no words to say about Ashish masih Plzz make review of Mercedes benz GLE

I have a 4 zone on my 2015 x50i and a digital cluster, seems you are outdated and not x5 and it does 100 in 4.8..u need to specify that you are comparing lowest x5 with top end q7

We salute ashish masih do review of mercedes-benz gle

Nice review But today Ashish sir forgot to bring his 1 litre bottle and to receive his mother-in-law from the airport all in his boot😂😂

Why you won't pic gls for comparison

Q7 is little bit longer than X5 that is the reason of little bit more body roll. However AUDI is better as compared to BMW.

Please review mercedes gls 350 d

If you drive then BMW, otherwise audi or whatever

Englsih fluency is quite amazing

Sir which will be better buy ameo or dzire when concerned about safety performance mileage and maintenance cost

And there was no end to the number times he said”and “ in d video....nice review tho

next time put both cars in white (or the same color) to compare, including interior

Man you are classy

Mercedes amg A45 ka review plz plz plz

Current X5d driver, but as far as the comparison, I'm curious about where BMW is hiding their air suspension, semi-autonomous driving features like lane assist, and rear collision avoidance, infotainment features like Android Auto for the 60% of the non-iPhone owners in the world and 4G connectivity. They seem to be missing here in the BMW, but all available features in the Audi.

could've done with S line and M sport

you forgot the torque in which q7 has 100 nm more than x5.

Bmw = efficient + performance

Please review jeep grand cherokee

😂😂😂😂he was all over the road in the X5 shots

Ur review was spot on , focusing on each and every detail of the cars. Q7 🤘

Q7 tech for me.

Audi 💪🏻

i liked the audi Q7

Bmw

x5

I have this q7 and the X5

Something is missing in this review. Oh yes, water bottles.

BMW x5 is the msot used from mafia because of its consistency.

BMW X5

I love my Q7! Lol

Wtf with that Q7 spare Wheel, in the the uk u don’t have a spare wheel just hanging around in the back

Compare toyota landcrusier and landcrusier prado

Looks sporty . You are funny 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😅😅

Audi is cheaper alternatives to BMWs or Merc

BMW exterior looks so much better

Hello everyone Good times friend and subscribe now okay bye 🇮🇳 jayhind wow both suvs are awesome but I like Audi cabin is so nice and comfortable 👌🙏🤗

That x5 interior color and carpet just look terrible.

BMW is nest

q7

X7 is the best

Gls

Gle is much better it's rugged and has better resale value

looks like somebody beat up this guy lol

Areh jeeta kon bmw ya audi drag race me ..???😂😂

An advice to Audi. Don't smoke weed while making space for the spare wheel.

BMW is best

bmw is the best

Even with the problems can occur Range Rover sport so so much nicer and better

Audi q7 is best

7 seaters vs 5 seaters failed

AUDI Q7 👎🤧😂😂

No one q7 and bmw x5 are same

X5

Bmw is nice audi is very 👎

Audi always better than BMW. BMW need to hire new designer. Looks so cheep.

first viewer and liker

The specs that you pick in audi Q7 are shity

हींदि नहीं आती है

I only like interior of q7

Q7 is the best like if agree

A turd competition which one smell worse

Maruti 800 beats them all