Disagree with feast for crows being so low down, I thoroughly enjoyed it and thought it was some of George’s best work, I think it gets a bad wrap because it wasn’t the sequel to storm of swords that everyone wanted

finally someone appreciates adwd as it deserves 👏🏻

I think that ASOIAF are split up into 2 parts Part 1: The War of 5 Kings A Game of Thrones A Clash of Kings A Storm of Swords Part 2: The Great War A Feast For Crows/A Dance For Dragons The Winds of Winter A Dream of Springs I think that this is why it seems AFFC is like a begining, because it is for the next war.

Love Brienne's chapters in AFFC, brings back memories of Arya's adventures in the Riverlands, so dirty and creepy and violent, Nimble Dick is a great character and obviously Septon Meribald, really brings home the horror and futility of war and its aftermath.

1. A storm of swords 2.A dance with dragons 3. A knight of the seven kingdoms 4. A clash of kings 5.A game of thrones 6. A feast of crows 7.Fire and blood 8. A world of ice and fire

Cersei’s POV chapters in AFFC are my favorite out of any of the POV. We really dive into her character a lot more and seeing her being such an paranoid and incompetent and maniacal reader with all these schemes is exactly why I love the series in the first place.

"A Clash of Kings is just as good as A Game of Thrones, and that's why I'm putting it one tier lower".

A feast becomes way better when you read along side Dance. The pacing feels significantly less sluggish you’re reading all of the character’s stories at once. The Brienne chapters really killed a Feast for me but they’re way more enjoyable when they’re a bit more staggered

I really liked this video, man :D I watched the whole video thinking it was very well done and when I scrolled down to subscribe I was surprised by how few had seen it! And the worst part was nobody even left a comment. Keep up the good work!

You mention how it feels like Feast is the start of a new series. The thing is, the books from Feast through Dream are essentially a new series. At the end of Storm, the old guard (Ned, Robert, Viserys, Jeor, Catelyn, Robb, Joffrey and Tywin) are all gone and we're seeing the rise of the new guard with things like Dany ruling in Meereen, Jon becoming Lord Commander, Tommen and Margaery rising, Sansa learning under Littlefinger, etc.

A knight of the 7 kingdoms is S tier for me. It’s so damn cozy I love it so much.

I thought the Dorne storyline was the best in the feast and crows and Sams early chapters where okay but I really enjoyed the second half of his chapters

This is AMAZING! this is exactly what I needed.... I watched the entire series multiple times already, and am just now finishing the the fifth book,but just learned of the other "add-on" books...so now I am thinking I should probably read/re-read the series with the original 5 books along with the "add-ons" in the correct /best order to read them!!

I personally LOVE AFFC, it's my favorite book of GRRM till now.

You just earned ur self a new sub+like+2comments+ notification bell! THANKS FOR THE GREAT CONTENT!!!

I think feast for crows and dance with dragons should exchange their places in your ranking. A feast for crows was AWESOME and is second only to storm of swords . The pacing is perfect . really enjoyed cercei's and brienne's chapters. When I saw dance with dragon's size , I thought there would be more story of every character than there actually is. particularly diasppointed with Bran's story. There are only 3 or 4 chapters of him in such a big book . George should have ended the book with The hardhome attack , The battle at winterfell , The battle of Mereen and none of this happens despite the size of the book. now , this cliffhangers will affect the size of winds of winter for sure. Danaerys and Tyrion's plot lines were so slow and lagging. their pacing really annoyed me . The book failed to reach the level of other books despite having this interesting Aegon Targaerean and Quenten Martell add ons. Dance with Dragons did not reach my expectations and is definately the least good book of the five released so far. My ranking : 1) A Storm of Swords 2) A Feast for Crows 3) A Game of Thrones 4) A Clash of Kings 5) A Dance with Dragons

I think Winds of Winter is shaping up to be A Feast for Crows and A Dance with Dragons in one volume.

I knew a storm of swords would be s tier

My list: S-AWOIAF, A Game of Thrones, A Storm of Swords, and TLOIAF. A-A Clash of Kings and A Dance with Dragons. A and B-Fire and Blood. A Feast for Crows is a C or D. I haven't read A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.

Rankings below... but first, I struggled with Feast the first time as you said mainly because of the pacing, but with rereads I went for the boiled leather reading order, combining Feast and Dance into roughly chronological order and I loved both books much better that way! The slow bits of Feast were broken up so didn't feel like they dragged, which then made them feel more interesting to just be travelling around the world. Also, the more complicated and confusing bits of Dance I found the first time was also broken up so I didn't feel like my brain was working overtime. And on top of that, it's nice to not have to wait so long between returning to favourite viewpoint characters! Anyone wanting a small quality of life tip on how to do the boiled leather read without feeling like you constantly have to look the order up, I made two bookmarks, one for each book, with the set of chapters I needed to read before switching books. That way I didn't feel like it was a lot of effort to follow the order. Rankings: S: ASoS ; A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms A: ACoK ; ADwD ; Fire and Blood B: AGoT ; The World of Ice and Fire C: AFfC D: The Lands of Ice and Fire ?: The Wit and Wisdom of Tyrion Lannister

1. DANCE OF DRAGONS,all of the threads of every book coming together left me more anticipated for anything in my life since Black Panther. REEK and Stannis,Victarion and Barristan Selmy,the wedding of frey and Lanniser at Riverrun. Euron Greyjoy and the Iron Fleet. AEGON's return to Westeros. What is Varys Plan? The blackfyres return ? All of these have me salivating with anticipation. This book really made me go back and reread every single book over and over and I always found a connection to something else that was set up before,changed the story entirely,and then sets up something else. 2.The world of Ice and Fire. I love history,greek Mythology and relatable fantasy that I can take seriously. The histories behind every culture are so vast and worth exploring it shows you the lack of imagination behind the studios at HBO. The biggest takeaway I enjoyed learning about was the trade relationship between the Early Varliyan Empire and The Summer Isles. I just keep imagining a tiny Valryian Girl begging her father for a panther Cub from the summer Isles. 3. Storm of Swords is an all time classic ,the only drawback is that I ruined the red wedding twist for myself already. Not one of most rereadable for me personally but a great book nonetheless and I enjoy what they set up. 4. Feast for crows gets a alot of flack,but hands down the best storyline for me personally was the introduction of the ironborn and Dorne. The scope of the war expanding. The histories of the lands,fighters, cultures,grudges,betrayals,and house hierarchies are great. VICTARION AND EURON GREYJOY deserved to be introduced to the story properly. the Kingsmoot is one of my favorite scenes. Meanwhile in Dorne you learn things are not as United or as powerful as they claim to be. Prince Doran got killed-wasted on the show due to being a man. He deserved better. 5. Clash of Kings is the tyrion show and he deserves it,not one other character shares the same amount of depth,Personality,likeability,and political power as Tyrion,and he still gets manipulated by Varys. 6. A Game of thrones is great,and the show copied it to its success despite leaving out alot,but also improving some things. 7. Game of thrones the tv show by d&d ruined the tv show for me personally. It's one thing to have a bad ending. But the problems were there since season 5 with no dorne or Iron Islands,no prominent POC characters who aren't white,female,or emasculated. And shoddy character development for every except maybe Theon.

The night of the seven kingdoms is the best book out of all of them

I have the books where Storm and Dance are split into two separate books, so the ranking will be different. 1. A Storm Of Swords 1:Steel and Snow 2. A Game Of Thrones 3. A Storm of Swords 2: Blood and Gold 4: A Dance With Dragons 1: Dreams And Dust 5: A Clash Of Kings 6: A Dance With Dragons 2: After The Feast 7: A Feast For Crows The last three can be changed around. I liked some aspects of Feast such as Cersei as a new POV and returning characters in Jaime and Arya. (Personally i think that Feast is the weakest of the main story line).

S: A Storm of Swords A: A Game of Thrones, A Feast for Crows (Cersei made this book for me, and I loved Sansa, Jaime and Arya and Arianne's POVs too, if not for those Greyjoys it would've been S) B: A Clash of Kings, A Dance with Dragons (So the main problem I have with Dance is that besides Tyrion's POVs, I didn't really enjoy it alot. Despite having characters like Melisandre, who I was very curious about and Jon, whom I'm not the biggest fan of but his POVs I enjoyed after the second book, I couldn't fully enjoy it. It might have something to do with how heavy it was on Davos and Bran whom I don't necessarily dislike, but their POVs don't really get my interest. And Dany not reaching Westeros is getting really frustrating now, though her struggle with power does make it a little interesting.)

I think a feast for crows is the second best book, it introduced my two favourite POVs ever (Cersei and Arianne)

gonna be honest flip clash and game of thrones and I'm pretty much on board.

1. Dance With Dragons 2. A Game Of Thrones 3. A Storm of Swords 4. A Clash of Kings 5. Fire and Blood 6. A Feast For Crows 7. Knight of the Seven Kingdoms

1. A Storm Of Swords 2. A Dance With Dragons 3. A Feast For Crows 4. Fire And Blood 5. A Clash Of Kings 6. A Game Of Thrones 7. A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms 8. The World Of Ice And Fire 9. The Lands Of Ice And Fire

I think a clash of kings is underrated the battle for kings landing is probably the Best an most detailed battle in any fantasy novel

In my opinion A Feast for Crows is very underrated. The main issue people have, is that the book is much slower than ASoS, which is absolutely true. But why is that so? After ASoS, things changed, major characters like Robb and Catelyn, Joffrey and Tywin died, and the war between the south and the north ended. Thats the reason why it couldn't be a ASoS sequel. The reason why the book is that slow, is, because merely every major character slowed down themselves: Daenery's chose to stop heading for westeros and stayed in meereen, Stannis stopped focusing on Kings Landing and sealed to the wall and is now restoring a few castles, Sansa is 'safe' at the vale and Sam is heading for oldtown to become a maester, which is basically the definition of slow and boring. I still think it is a great book, because all the new plotlines are interesting and really felt like AGoT. The Dorne and Ironborn plotlines expand the lore immensly, which had to be done, because these two kingdoms and families didn't have much screentime in the previous books. The more character and drama focused approach were refreshing aswell and the new point of views were logically chosen, and mostly very good (Victarion, Cercei, Arya, etc.). AFFC isn't my favorite book, a few Brienne chapters for example were unnecessary and boring, but it doesn't deserve that much hate.

in what order should I read all of these books in?

Nooo!! Not AFFC being so low on your list. I loved the shit out of that book. Probably my favorite book so far!

What is the order

Sam isn't a pov in the 2 novel loved the video thanks

For me A Feast for Crows and A Dance With Dragons is at the same level as A Storm of Swords..A Game of Thrones comes second and A Clash of Kings at the bottom..

S: Storm of Swords, Game of Thrones A: Dance with Dragons, Clash of Kings B: Feast for Crows All are great reads

I was really looking forward to read A Feast of Crows and enjoyed it for Cersei’s POV is finally introduced. And boy, she is worse than in the show.

I’m Reading a feast for crows right now and that’s why I’m here. It just feels like a big step in the wrong direction to me. I’m enjoying it, but it’s nowhere near as good as A storm of swords. I was just curious if other people felt the same. It’s by no means a bad book, but I literally just finished a storm of swords and I’m left feeling like “wtf is this”.

Personally, I'd put Dunc & Egg in S, and WoI&F into B (albeit, I'm admittedly a sucker for his fake history and world building). Just my two cents.

Crows is awesome.

I was happy with your ranking until you placed fire and blood in A section instead of S 💔💔 Everything was on point until that

i think fire and blood is a good book

For me it's: 1. Asod 2. Agot 3. Adwd 4. Affc 5. Acok Haven't read any of the others.

The kingsmoot chapter in AFFC might be the best chapter in any of the books

Dunk and egg series is confirmed by HBO.

Wow i'm finishing today the second book thinking they will get better because the first two have been so boring, and there are three books worse?

Honestly after George finished winds ( hopefully he does) I hope he knocks out like 4 more dunk and egg stories instead of writing the final book and leaving dunk and egg standing

1.ASOS(The only flaw in this book is Bran) 2.ACOK(This one has some extremely boring storyline(Bran, Jon, the begining of Arya), but it also has some of my favorite plotlines of the entire serie(King's landing with Tyrion&Sansa, the war with Catelyn, Theon is good too) 3.ADWD(Also a book where I really dislike some parts but love others. The lows are lower than for clash of king) 4.AGOT(The most consistent book, but it has few "wow" moments. 5.AFFC(It really sucks. Character arcs that go nowhere, horrible pacing, just meh).

Honestly all of the books are s imo

„Never gonna appear in any tv show.“ That didn’t age well…

I think the Tyrion Lannister book shoould be in f list because this book is only for tv show fans and not for Fucking book readers

Feast is way too low. That is an S, buddy.