Boosted: the EMD GP 20 EMD's first turbo charged locomotive.

  Рет қаралды 19,744

The Alco diesel guy

The Alco diesel guy

Жыл бұрын

KZfaq Credits:
Chasing a Chesapeake & Indiana: GP20- SkyhawkACE123
• Chasing a Rare CKIN Mo...
Toledo Peoria & Western GP20 in 1991, Amtrak F40PH,
Santa Fe B40-8W GP60 F45 SD40-2 (Part 12.4 of 4)-
Walt Loevy
• Toledo Peoria & Wester...
Picture Credits:
Turbo
Commons.wikimedia.org user: Bobbobson CC BY 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
SP Alco RS 32
Commons.wikimedia.org user: Drew jacksich CC BY-SA 2.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/...

Пікірлер: 62
@calebm8307
@calebm8307 2 ай бұрын
So far it's probably my favorite favorite diesel engine
@Trains-With-Shane
@Trains-With-Shane Жыл бұрын
Interesting that even with their first real effort into turbo charging the GP20's apparently were so reliable that almost 40% of them are still being used today. Seems that EMD really did their homework before jumping into turbocharging. Also interestingly is that Detroit Diesel, basically EMD's little brother in regards to diesel engines, followed a similar recipe. Early on the Detroit 2-stroke diesels had blowers on them, for scavenging efficiency rather than horsepower, they also later adopted turbo chargers as well for increased power.
@n5ifi
@n5ifi Жыл бұрын
Early on they had blowers? Two stroke Detroit's always have blowers. Every last one of them. They don't have any intake valves. All the valves in the head are exhaust valves. They have a liner with holes at the bottom of it and the piston goes down below that point and intake air is blown in by the BLOWER. When the piston rises above the holes the intake air is captured and compressed. The blowers are there to feed air to the engine. Not to make positive pressure like a blower on a dragster or a turbo even though the dragsters original blower design was taken from Detroit D. It has to have a blower to run.
@aaronshipley5594
@aaronshipley5594 Жыл бұрын
40% are still being used because the railroads found a loophole - rebuild dirty, smoking 2-stroke engines instead of buying new locomotives. When your engines still have every part available on the market and are emissions exempt, rebuilding is the obvious choice.
@aaronshipley5594
@aaronshipley5594 Жыл бұрын
@@n5ifithey switched to turbos with a clutch. At low engine speeds the turbo functions as a blower and then at higher speeds the clutch disengages and exhaust pressure spins it to create boost.
@rearspeaker6364
@rearspeaker6364 11 ай бұрын
@@aaronshipley5594 well, not exactly........ rebuild dirty applies to pre 1973 locomotives, 1973 onwards to the beginning of tier1 need to be retrofitted to the FRA 1033 standard, which don't make them that much cleaner.
@AJ67901
@AJ67901 Жыл бұрын
I'm amazed at how many GP30s are still in service, considering they were introduced in 1960!
@Dr_Reason
@Dr_Reason Жыл бұрын
The EMD turbo was mechanically driven at low power and then as the exhaust caught up to demand, it over-ran the mechanical drive and moved even more air. In essence it had no true turbo lag. Without this setup they would have had to keep the mechanical roots blower to made the 597 even run at idle. In effect, a 567 diesel is not an air pump at all and does not move any air on its own.
@300poundbassman
@300poundbassman Жыл бұрын
Love that Turbo sound. Thanks for featuring Gp 20
@alcobufff
@alcobufff Жыл бұрын
No problem! Glad you like my video! Please feel free to sub if you haven't already.
@danielbackley9301
@danielbackley9301 Жыл бұрын
You forgot to mention that EMD went to turbos largely at UP's urging thus the turbo research known in RR circles as Omaha gp-20s. Which is the real reason EMD got it right. As far as the low sales numbers it was simply put too early for most roads witness the low numbers for the GP-18 which would have been worse if not for Missouri Pacific's 180 or so units and the 200 extra horses weren't worth the extra costs for most of the others.
@brianburns7211
@brianburns7211 11 ай бұрын
The GP18/20/SD24 introduction came at a time when most railroads had only recently replaced steam and had new diesels already. I think there was a recession then too.
@danielbackley9301
@danielbackley9301 11 ай бұрын
@@brianburns7211 Yes many roads weren't in need of new units yet and the recession of 1957 had given way yet to the booming 60s.
@michaelmcdougall4527
@michaelmcdougall4527 Жыл бұрын
A great video and a lot of information. Thank you it’s to bad General Motors Automotive Division stopped making Reliable Cars!
@afleetcommand
@afleetcommand Жыл бұрын
Excellent video, and love the history. pretty good "mechanical" explanation of turbo v supercharger. :) The "thermodynamic" explanation would harder for most to get.
@Amigafur
@Amigafur Жыл бұрын
Fun fact: the GP20 demonstrator is still in revenue service with the Great Western Railway in Colorado.
@jeri_v2578
@jeri_v2578 Жыл бұрын
5:50 I live right next to Georgetown, TX where the GRR ran, it still exists as the switching power for the Georgetown limestone quarry as well as a couple local businesses, they don't have any GP20s anymore and only roster 3 switching units, it really makes me sad looking back at old pics and seeing how it was compared to now, I wish they still ran, it's one of the last shortline railroads in the Austin area
@maquetedoalto
@maquetedoalto 4 ай бұрын
Wonderfull locomotive ❤
@mattbalboa1349
@mattbalboa1349 Жыл бұрын
Just so ya know, the EMD 567 was actually introduced with the FT in the very late 1939's... 39 I think, or 1940.
@user-su8rk6cg6d
@user-su8rk6cg6d Жыл бұрын
Actually the 567 was introduced in 1929 in ea units an evolution of the winton 201 design
@andrewwilson4451
@andrewwilson4451 9 ай бұрын
The SD24 was the first turbo EMD
@colmornane5684
@colmornane5684 Жыл бұрын
Your description of the turbo charger suggests that the EMD turbo charger is purely exhaust driven, this is not accurate. Unlike the turbo chargers used on ALCO's etc. where these are purely exhaust driven, Yes they suffer from turbo lag with the engine blowing lots of black smoke if the throttle is opened very quickly until the turbo charger spools up to provide air for correct combustion. An EMD turbo charger is engine driven through an overrunning clutch, the engine continues to drive the turbo charger until the engine is working hard and reaches 85% heat efficiency where the exhaust gases drive the turbine and the turbos air compressor scroll faster than the engine is driving it. At that moment the overrunning clutch works and the rollers of the overrunning clutch roll down the ramps disconnecting the engine from driving the turbo charger. Also, EMD have never built a supercharged engine. The blowers on the 567, 645 engines provide scavenging air, the valve overlap on these engines do not allow any supercharging effect to occur, it is for that reason they are referred to as naturally asperated engines. The EMD turbo chargers are largely engine driven until the engine reaches its thermal efficiency as described above at which time the engine is relieved of its burden of driving the turbo charger.
@bwan13
@bwan13 Жыл бұрын
Alco never used Napier turbos, they used Buchi and later GE turbos.
@colmornane5684
@colmornane5684 Жыл бұрын
@@bwan13 Oh! ok, I remember seeing one here in Australia and remember seeing the Napier builders plate on it. Goodwin were the agents for Alco here in Australia. Maybe they used them, maybe not, maybe the railway the locomotive was delivered to fitted them??? I have also removed the Napier reference from my description above for accuracy. Thanks for the info, I was generalising from that one experience I had with Alco. Regardless of that the ALCO turbo charger was purely exhaust gas driven where as the EMD version was gear driven off the engine until the exhaust gases reached a level that they could drive the exhaust turbine and its associated air intake compressor scroll faster than the engine was driving it causing the overrunning clutch to operate and the locomotive receive the benefits of turbo charging. Again, Many thanks for the information.
@ianisaacs2340
@ianisaacs2340 Жыл бұрын
Southern Pacific is my favorite road overall, but my second favorite road would have to be Western Pacific who had my favorite GP20’s. Orange or green they looked good to me, and I absolutely love the high hood, topped off by a Nathan M5 horn… Nearly perfect.
@msgproductions3515
@msgproductions3515 8 ай бұрын
Looks like a lot of this was filmed in central Illinois. I recognize the grain elevator in Fairbury Il.
@jeffreymcfadden9403
@jeffreymcfadden9403 Жыл бұрын
A certain RR(looking at you PC)de-turboed their GP20s. A cost saving measure.
@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis
@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis Жыл бұрын
This is pretty common on switching locomotives that don’t work at altitude, to save on maintenance. Since it doesn’t affect tractive effort, the reduction in horsepower is not usually an issue.
@scotteakins7203
@scotteakins7203 Жыл бұрын
I've always wondered why EMD never produced a SD 20 or a SD 30. When they produced a SD 7 & SD 9. Along with their GP 7 and GP 9's .
@arthurbagby5406
@arthurbagby5406 Жыл бұрын
There was a SD-24 offered by EMD. It was a poor seller. Most railroads were looking for higher horsepower 4 axle locos due to customer demands (mainly the auto industry) for faster transit times. A 6 axle works best in a slow speed drag freight setting, coal trains for instance. The small horsepower gain vs. the increased maintenance cost wasn't worth it to most railroads. If you had a low speed drag operation like the B&LE Railroad, you still had a relatively new fleet of SD-7 and SD-9s. GM was kind of resting on their laurels when GE came out with the U25B. The horsepower race was on, and other than a 'quick fix' of strapping a turbo on a GP9, EMD had no response. They needed a block with a bigger bore and stroke, thus more horsepower, and they did get that accomplished until 1965 with with the 645 series block. That retooling takes years of planning and testing. The '1966 line' of EMDs would include the SW-1200, SW1500, GP-38, GP-39, SD-38, SD-39, SD-40, and SD-45, with some variation on some models. With the new models in development, no SD-30 was planned. Hope this helps.
@joshbenton4080
@joshbenton4080 Жыл бұрын
@@arthurbagby5406 Didn't the SW1200 get produced before the 645 engine was introduced? If I'm not mistaken, the SW1200 was first built in the 1950s by EMD and had the 567BC engine and later the 567C engine. (The SW1001 and SW1500 were built with a roots blown 645.) In my "neck of the woods", the B&O / Chessie System had a number of SW1200 switcher engines with "blunt trucks" from about 1954 or so. I'm open for correction if I'm wrong though.
@crsrdash-840b5
@crsrdash-840b5 Жыл бұрын
What is a EP20? I thought the first was the GP20
@fascination.sound.and.groove
@fascination.sound.and.groove 10 ай бұрын
Great video. Excellent! 👍👍👍I can't keep up with my first diesel video.😉
@wildbill9919
@wildbill9919 Жыл бұрын
5:55 Nice CB&Q inspired paint scheme.
@wazza33racer
@wazza33racer Жыл бұрын
A turbo doesnt make more power than a supercharger.......it just does the same task much more efficiently. Where it gets complicated for turbo chargers is that they are centrifugal compressors, which are only efficient at high rpm, and introduce high charge air temperatures. By comparison, the EMD engines used 'rootes' style super chargers like their smaller GM 2 stroke diesel engines, which were much simpler from an engineering and installation point of view. 2 stroke diesels need a positive style rootes blower to start and run, adding turbo chargers would have seemed like a lot extra inconvenience. Over time, turbo chargers became smaller and more efficient........and charge air cooling was introduced to make the best of their output. Modern heavy diesels now operate with 40+ psi of boost, which represent a massive improvement in performance and fuel efficiency........compared to just 14psi that was common in the late 1970's.
@user-ku5wk1yy9x
@user-ku5wk1yy9x 6 ай бұрын
THE GP20 IS A GP9 EQUIPPED WITH A TURBOCHARGER.
@jims6323
@jims6323 7 ай бұрын
It would have been nice if you explained how it was mechanically driven at low rpm's, then decoupled to be driven by the exhaust gas only, at higher revs.
@JaredBallou
@JaredBallou Жыл бұрын
At 5:32... is that a window AC unit in #272 on the left?
@Trains-With-Shane
@Trains-With-Shane Жыл бұрын
LOL it sure looks like one doesn't it? It's actually a little window extension, similar to what you see on wide vision transfer cabooses.
@NJP76
@NJP76 Жыл бұрын
@@Trains-With-Shane Oh man, it really DOES look like a window A/C unit, LOL! I will never look at one of those window extensions the same way again. 😂
@heathwirt8919
@heathwirt8919 Жыл бұрын
Seems like prime movers in this era were plagued with premature failures, apparently the manufacturers didn't have an adequate system for rigorous testing. An engine was put in a locomotive and set out for use by the railroads to see if it would hold up.
@Webbcityrailfan_productions
@Webbcityrailfan_productions Жыл бұрын
I live near Missouri northern Arkansas goes through my town
@0fficialdregs
@0fficialdregs Жыл бұрын
You might want to change the title and GP20 not EP20
@GreatNW
@GreatNW Жыл бұрын
We're the rebuild gp11 turbo charged or did they revert back to root blowers?
@arthurbagby5406
@arthurbagby5406 Жыл бұрын
Roots blowers.
@SPSteve
@SPSteve Жыл бұрын
Top Fuel drag cars make 10,000 horse power with 500 cubic inches using super chargers. Dodge Hellcats, Shelby Mustangs, Camaro ZL1 are modern super charged cars. Today every auto manufacturer has turbo charged engines in their entire car ranges. My BMW X3 has a turbo charged 4 cylinder. Turbo lag is a thing from the past and is unnoticeable in modern production cars. The advantage of turbo chargers over super chargers is their long term reliability and low cost.
@mattbalboa1349
@mattbalboa1349 Жыл бұрын
1938
@arkie74
@arkie74 Жыл бұрын
EMD got it right, how come from the beginning Alco, and GE turbos have been crap? they smoke constantly, till they get real bad then they smoked like they are on fire....till they are on fire to this day! lol
@dennisrichardville4988
@dennisrichardville4988 Жыл бұрын
4 stroke revs slower the a 2 stroke...... longer turbo lagging......
@robertcampbell6349
@robertcampbell6349 Жыл бұрын
Alco rushed their locomotives into production and skipped a lot of testing. It's sad, since Alco had some innovative ideas.
@arkie74
@arkie74 Жыл бұрын
oh yeah, gp 20s sound like that going forward or reverse. not to be a smarta88, jus sayin.
@ralfie8801
@ralfie8801 Жыл бұрын
You’re comparing apples to oranges. EMD uses two cycle engines and the rest use 4 cycle engines. EMD engines won’t even start without a blower. The other engines will start and run without a blower, they just won’t rev very high or make much, if any power. On the other hand, the EMD uses a combination blower/turbocharger in one unit, so at lower rpm it runs on the crank driven blower and above notch 6 throttle there is enough exhaust pressure to drive the turbo faster than the crank can and then the turbo comes off its clutch and spools up to 20K plus rpm to make full horsepower.
@mattberg916
@mattberg916 Жыл бұрын
@@arkie74 "going forward " as in reference to time, not direction of travel.
@haroldbenton979
@haroldbenton979 Жыл бұрын
2 stroke Detroit diesels are the same way. The 238 and 318 are the same engines it's just the 318 has a turbocharger also for the extra horses. Or as their called in the case of the 238 the gutless wonder and the screaming 318s. The only way to freaking make them work properly was to drive them angry. Or as we said slam your hand in the door then hit yourself with a hammer in the balls
The first is not always the best: The GE u25b
16:27
The Alco diesel guy
Рет қаралды 32 М.
EMD bl2 EMD's ugly duckling.
14:46
The Alco diesel guy
Рет қаралды 40 М.
OMG😳 #tiktok #shorts #potapova_blog
00:58
Potapova_blog
Рет қаралды 3,9 МЛН
DO YOU HAVE FRIENDS LIKE THIS?
00:17
dednahype
Рет қаралды 32 МЛН
ИРИНА КАЙРАТОВНА - АЙДАХАР (БЕКА) [MV]
02:51
ГОСТ ENTERTAINMENT
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Leslie Supertyfon S5T Train Horn
0:59
Hybrid Bell
Рет қаралды 201
Taking a 100-Year-Old Model T to a Ford Dealer for Service
35:16
TFLclassics
Рет қаралды 3,9 МЛН
3,000 HP Turbo V16 Locomotive Start Up And Tour
23:53
Vice Grip Garage
Рет қаралды 2,2 МЛН
Oddball Locomotives of the KCS! "What Once Was..."
13:41
Louisiana Rail Productions
Рет қаралды 13 М.
Starting a GP9 with various amounts of success.
7:09
Johnny_Wad
Рет қаралды 2,5 М.
More isn't always better: The EMD sd45.
12:42
The Alco diesel guy
Рет қаралды 34 М.
How the SD50 Became The Blunder That Destroyed EMD’s Reputation| Garbage on The Rails Episode 8
18:40
Andrew Raila ‘Bammers!(AKA The RocketCity Railfan)
Рет қаралды 152 М.
An important stepping stone: The alco RS 2
17:58
The Alco diesel guy
Рет қаралды 32 М.
The lesser known relative: The EMD F45 series.
13:55
The Alco diesel guy
Рет қаралды 35 М.
OMG😳 #tiktok #shorts #potapova_blog
00:58
Potapova_blog
Рет қаралды 3,9 МЛН