I would love to see the choice options that you both get and then hearing your thoughts on the categories and reasons that you chose what you did. Kind of like when you do the Fab Fit Fun unboxings.

I'm super pale and use the bare minerals warmth I just use a light hand and it's nice and sheer works great

I know their lip oils may be good but how can you back a brand that claims a palette sent to us is $60 but the SAME one is in Walmart for $20. I have never seen a brand do that before. I mean we are not talking something similar. We are talking the same exact one and nobody wanted these products for 1/3 of the price. Never in my life have I seen a new brand go into walmart and be gone with everything on clearance in 2 weeks

I like Rachel’s box because I like skincare.

Don’t pass on the bare minerals “warmth” before you try it out. It is very flattering on pale skin. I used to use the whole bare minerals line, and I came to work with makeup one day and my boss asked if I was pregnancy because I was glowing 😂

Still watching the video so may update my comment... I wanted to share "warmth" is one of Bare Minerals all over face colors. It's more versatile than you'd expect. I'm on the fair end of light neutral and used warmth for years pre-covid. Don't tend to use it now because I got bored and tried other bronzers 🤷‍♀️ It's worth looking at a few videos of folks with fair complexions using it... also good as eye shadow. 😊

Very light on the bareminerals. Warmth is actually a great shade even for pale skin.

Warmth works for everyone and it's a great eyeshadow!

Red undertones are great for pale , cool toned skin. It mimics the color your skin turns with a bit of sun.

I liked Rachel's box better...but lately I haven't been wearing a ton of makeup since I work in a factory. I liked how ur boxes were totally different in terms of products that way I can get a feel for whether or not this is a box I want to subscribe to. It does seem very hit & miss. Sometimes these boxes are fabulous & other times it's a ton of brands I've never heard of. Great video ladies!!😊

That warmth is very universal for all. They later came out with darker shades if I remember. Warmth is one of their major products in their line up. It lasts especially if your fair to light a little bit goes a long way. Loved both your boxes thanks for sharing 💓

The bare minerals goes on light. I’ve used it before and I’m pretty fair cool toned

I added on the palette. It is stunning. Katrina wins for me just because I would use everything. Sis has a great bag, too. Have a wonderful week. I only get the small bag. ❌️⭕️

The bare minerals bronzer is great. Tap the powder into the cap. Swirl your brush around the lid and tap excess product off and put on your face. Don’t rate it badly until you try it.

Fun one, ladies! Katrina wins this month - that Natasha Denona palette alone is good enough for me ❤

BYRO is one of my 😍 FAVORITE Brands!! I love it and so does my skin!❤

I agree with Katrina on the bare minerals. I wasnt happy with my April box.

I’d say both are 4/5 but I’d pick Katrina’s cause I prefer more makeup. I’m in Canada and I’m not even sure if I’ll get all the items I’m supposed to get. I didn’t in April and neither did my best friend. Ipsy made substitutions without letting us know

I wasn’t sure how I’d like picking three out of my five products but i actually really like it. I kinda miss the mystery aspect of BoxyCharm but i do like being able to pick out what i want

Rachel and i got the same power picks

You both look GREAT!

The Natasha Denona palettes we have received in BC/Ipsy (the ones they say are a "Boxy exclusive") are just a mix of shades that already exist in her other palettes. That's maybe why it looks familiar! :)

I got the same "power picks" as Rachel and I'm pretty happy with my box. If I were Katrina, I'd give the Bare Minerals warm a try with a light hand. I have very fair skin and have used it as a bronzer.

Yes ladies. KAB cosmetics lip oils are amazing. The light pink one is outstanding 💄💋

I would love if you started showing what your options were for your choices!

The bare minerals brought me back 15 years ago. I used to wear it all the time

Loved my boxy and Ipsy this month!!! They really started this merge out with a bang, in my opinion. It’ll take time to work all of the kinks out, but I definitely notice them trying very hard to please.

Like both boxes but I would choose Rachel's box.

Hi! I prefer your box Katrina because I like a mix of skin care products and makeup products but both boxes are good 👌🏻👌🏻Thanks for sharing, it’s always nice to see you both, have a good one!🙋🏼‍♀️🇨🇦❣️❣️💐💐

I was actually really excited about my products and getting to choose three items but when I got my box I was really sad. First, everything was just thrown in there and three products were damaged. My LYS stick was smashed, my Natasha Denona palette had some cracks, and my Pacifica body cream was scratched up and opened. Ipsy is sending replacements for the ND palette and the Pacifica but unfortunately they couldn’t replace the LYS and gave me a $13.01 refund and 1200 points for it. The 1200 points are basically worthless because there’s no longer a charm room and the items offered for points are horrible! One plus, the packing material is like Christmas for my cat Honey. I’ve gotten it three times now, the first two times I had a huge amount in my Boxy drop shop orders but the third time only a handful. We put it in a box for our tabby and she’s obsessed with it. She sleeps in it every day. 😂

Rachel day!!!🎉

I look forward to your vs videos

Try the warmth. Use a light hand. You should be fine. It can easily be sheered out or built up.

Fun to see your sister vs sister on this. I received a shipping notice on my box, then they cancelled it?.. I’m kinda glad. I really didn’t like Boxy Charm, and now I’m seeing some makeup dups from past boxes. I think I’ve gotten that Natasha D twice from Boxy. Looking for a new box.

I love Byroe skin products!

Hi Girls I'm still waiting for my box it says it will be here today I'm super excited!

Great boxes this month, but I vote for Katrina's, especially because of the N.D. palette!❤️❤️

Still waiting for mine 😢I wasn’t really impressed with my choices .

I love watching your videos! I used to have family in Germany, so I love your references to it. My favorite European countries are all German speaking - Germany, Austria, Switzerland. I can speak just a little. I hope you add a Sister vs. Sister ICON Box.

Oooo I haven't gotten that ND palette before, nice! I feel the same as Rachel about serums, a little hesitant. I feel like you both got good boxes, I'm feeling like it's a tie

Hey 👋🏼 Katrina and Rachel my favorite box 📦 is definitely Katrina’s ❤.

I liked both for different reasons ❤

You girls got good choices! All mine was skincare. With the exception of the face powder I chose that too! I agree that's one product you can always use.

As always, love the sister vs sister videos!

Love watching you!!! I get really excited when I see that you have posted a video. I love that they're getting more often.... Just don't overwhelm yourself please, just you do you hun.❤

Thanks for showing your boxes

I cannot use AHA. I have such sensitive skin. I’m excited about the lip mask. Thanks for the video!

Hey ladies! Ty for the vid! I don’t have mine yet, I always get it very late I’m the month. I like Rachel’s bag , I love skin care and a little bit of lip products or foundations. Fun video. 👏🏼

I got the Byroe serum and I loved it!

KAB cosmetics is my favorite lip oil that I've tried. I would probably have chose the highlight blush as well. On the opposite spectrum I'm not a fan of the Basic Beauty lip oil at all.

I love the warmth from bare minerals. Give it a try

Katrina - I picked the Natasha palette too! I'm excited to be trying it

I’d have to pick yours bc of the ND palette alone. I received it and I’m liking it. 🤗💜💜🤗

Great video. Natasha D eyeshadow is awesome ❤

Good evening Rachel and Katrina!!! I think you both got great boxes this month. I can not choose a favorite because everything looks and sounds amazing. Thank you so much for sharing with us, and I hope you both have a Blessed night!!!

Aweee this is one of my fav videos on your channel Katrina. I just like watching you two ladies interacting. You are both so beautiful and uplifting. You both always get me to laugh and smile. Rachel you are really coming into the zone. I’m loving it. I think both your boxes are great. Rachel my power picks are the same as yours and I’m very excited to use them. I do wish now that I also had chosen the Tovegan toner and the Sinoge Vit C ughhhh. I wanted makeup though 😂 and Katrina in my other box I’m getting the ND pallet as well. I do love ND’s eyeshadows and I will keep buying them for sure but I’m not excited for this one. It’s a bronze/neutral lovers palette and I have worked my way more into some colours. I will keep it and use it I’m sure. It’s a great one for travelling. I also chose the KAB blush so I’m excited for that as well. You ladies both have some great boxes. Katrina it would be lovely if you did a video of you using the ND pallet. I would like to see some makeup looks you create with it. Thanks ladies for sharing your boxes ❤

Katrina’s box for the win. I got the pear serum too, and it is very difficult to get out of the bottle. If you have any tips, let me know!

My box was a 2 pointer😮. I have never been so underwhelmed

This ND palette is supposed to be new and exclusive to IPSY/BOXY. I've received the other 2 palettes that kind of resemble this one. Ipsy chose the Drunk Elephant Drops and ND palette for me and I chose the KAB what I thought was blush (because like you thought Katrina, this category didn't have great choices), the Sonage C Serum because I just ran out of another C serum I was using and the Bobbi Brown shadow stick. I like Katrina's box better because I prefer makeup. I agree, this wasn't the worst and wasn't the best. I will probably skip next month because I wasn't able to add the Boost Item-my favorite Ole Henriksen moisturizer....the Boost was too popular and they are not adding any more people to the wait list, per Ipsy today. There is a slight chance it might become available. I have to check my account every day.

Warmth is for all skin colors.

I would love Natasha denona pallet

That's the best ND palette I've seen of course I didn't get it!

I loved both boxes! Rachel’s was amazing skincare heavy!!! Katrina had more makeup loved the ND Eyeshadow Palette n the Kab Blush n the Pacifica body butter! Loved the lip mask. Only that wrong color loose bronzer power pick was off. So I agree w/yr score. I guess Rachel’s box won this time! But, I love the 4 out of 5 in yours Katrina! So really hard to pick a winner. She had the setting powder. Which I wouldn’t pick. So gets to me is 4 out of 5 so really both boxes r equal! U both r winners! Love u born! Ty for sharing! Would love to see u both do a tryon video w/each of yr boxes! That would be so fun! To watch u both use the items u get! Please consider that! ❤ Just “food for thought!” I know all yr subscribers would love that! ❤❤ Even w/the Ipsy GB! If u both did a tryon video together w/all yr items! So fun! Think about it! Love u guys so much! ❤❤

I think the two items they pick should be from different categories!

I would probably have to pick Katrina's box bc i want the pallet and lip mask.

Hey girls heyyy. Im honestly glad they are using up whatever boxes they have left. It would be so wasteful if they didn't. A lot of people felt the same way about the shredded paper, not protecting any of the products, a lot of products arrived broken and damaged. I definitely like the foam. The ND looks too similar to the one boxy gave. Many thought it was a repeat. I think it's ridiculous I wouldve loved like white gray black from ND or how about spring colors instead of fall. At least for the people that like colors or cool tones, it's always the same colors every single month. I know that may be exciting for people that like warm toned neutrals but not everybody does. I'm glad I got the drunk elephant instead. Not fair. I wanted the byroe. Badly. It's so annoying all 5 items of mine were make up. I like skin care hair care heavy. I am very disappointed in all of my products my choices were complete trash. The drop shop is a complete joke have you seen the prices? They have ruined everything with their money hungriness. I know many people will not say it but I have no problem saying what's on my mind. It's the truth. The power picks should be true top shelf items. I was chosen the loose bronzer for me. I do not care for bronzer and do not like loose powder at all and far too warm. I wish I would have received a contour stick that Id actually use. The Tula so smooth.. That's a product that I'm using right now and I do not care for it. I mean I will use it up probably put it on other parts of my body but it's just not doing anything. It is a very light exfoliant. Your choices must have been terrible if you chose k a b, just guessing 😂 They went into boxy at the same exact time they were going into my Walmart we received an eye shadow palette from them that was supposedly like 58 or something like that but the same exact one was at walmart for 20 but it was like in white packaging and we received it in black. Ever since that happened I could not stand the brand.. I thought it was incredibly misleading to have something 3 times the amount supposedly that's at Walmart for a 1/3 of the price and it also got all clearanced out and left my Walmart within 2 weeks flat, no more kab. I've never seen that happen. I would really appreciate a solid setting powder I can't stand loose power. Also would really love a powder foundation even a cream one. I wish I had the Pacifica as a choice

Mine hasn't shipped yet, and one of my add-ons was out of stock. Both boxes of yours are good; I wouldn't have picked one over the other. Good products in both. I was really bummed I didn't get the Drunk Elephant blush drops that came in your PR.

Katrina wins for ND! I was going to laugh if Rachel popped Katrina in the face with the magazine 😹 y’all are so fun to watch! Rachel I dare you to make faces when Katrina does her intro! Rachel if she does it and you see it editing you have to post it! 😹👅

Rachel I'm currently using the vitamin c serum. So far I really like it. Kinda sticky tho. Slight smell. I have dry skin and this doesn't hydrate very well.

I like Rachel cus I luv skincare🎉❤

lucky you got so much makeup .... they didn't offer much to me .... and now I wait and wait for them to decide to actually ship the product I paid for weeks ago .... the label has been printed .... last month they held on to my money for a month then told me no product .. refunded then charged for this month's .... the waiting game continues. ipsy has taken the charm out of boxy .... so they get NO MORE of my $$$

I think Rachel’s box won this time around 🎉

I think Katrina won I really like your box I like all of your things in your box

I've been a member of ipsy for 3 years now...On April 1st I was charged my glam bag, my boxycharm, n I also paid for My Icon for May n I paid for my boost plus I had over 2300 points to redeem for wen i wanted to so everything was great but on da 4th I wen to log in my ipsy app on my phone n I cudnt get in so I went on Google web to log in n it was da same, it was saying that there no account wit my email or wrong password so wen I try to reset my password it ask me to put my current or old password then to put my new one but since everytime I'm putting my password it doesn't recognize it so It won't let me reset it to a new password so they give me a one time code which let me get into my account for Dat one time only n wen I'm in there's no points or any glam bag, boxycharm, icon or any of them active it's like I'm a new member at ipsy starting all over now it's just glam bag active n I was charged 15$ again on da 4th for it wen I already paid for it on da 1st...wats going on

Me and Katrina have the same box!!❤

I was very unhappy with all of my choices and the choices made for me. I did like the lip mask and will use that. This box was a 1 out of 5 for me. I cancelled for now. I’m going to let the merge kinks get worked out and then possibly come back. I liked you and your sisters boxes equally this month.

My Kab blush was destroyed!! They refunded me $8 for it but still super disappointed I didn’t get to try it

I noticed the box this month didn’t come with the card that shows the price of everything. Where can I find the prices to the products now?

💜💜

Well they were both decent boxes . I don't think one is better than the other. As for what is in my box. ...well it still has not arrived. It was last scanned early in the month and no movement. Not happy with Pitney (whos is AWFUL) and Ipsy. Probably going to cancel because this is the 3rd month in a row with shipping issues.

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Hi Girls ❤❤❤

Rachel box is better

I am not sure I like being able to pick the products. It’s weird. I’m expecting mine next week.

The bare minerals all over face colour should come in 2 shades. Faux Tan & Warmth. I would think Faux tan would be most suitable for your fair & light colouring. Warmth will probably be too orange/ red/ dark for both of you. More suitable for medium to tan skin colourings.

I bet the toner is pronounced “to vegan”

Not a fan of Ipsy & totally disappointed that Boxy sold out.

This looks so cheap smh