“Favorite moments in slow movement of Brahms 1st symphony” *plays entire piece :)

Never clicked so furiously on a video.

i could feel my teeth clenching during during that section that introduces the pink motif - that is some incredibly scary rhythmic stuff going on. major props to the solo oboe and clarinet players for not getting thrown off during such an exposed part. also, brahms's string writing is so great. he manages to get such a rich and heartfelt sound, and one thing i admire is that he liked to make his string parts genuinely fun to play, even during the most banal of accompaniment passages!

To me, the opening notes sounded remarkably similar to the opening of Beethovens Pastorale symphony

I've been along for this ride for years now, and I keep being amazed by your depth of analysis (even in a kind of "greatest hits"-cavalcade through a movement like this) informed, at all times, by a very distinct sensibility and warmth of heart that I find very endearing, and familiar. The analytic Atkinson is always also a phenomenologist in applying the mind music as this demands of you. I don't know, man. Just thank you. It's like sharing a spark of a wonder of the world with a kindred spirit for a short while whenever one of these videos go up. Like the mind(s) and the music fit together in togetherness in this little, 20-minute long crease in the wrinkles of the world, feeling just right, belonging, peaceful, and happy while it lasts.

Brahms' 1st Symphony was my introduction to classical music as a kid. Completely blown away by your analysis of this very special piece.

That was another incredible analysis. This just makes the case to convince me even further that the First Symphony is the best of the four Brahms symphonies. I hear the seedlings of the third movement during the B section of this movement. I look forward to the First Symphony, third movement, analysis because it is my favorite movement out of the entire symphonic catalogue. My applause to you, sir.

Absolutely overwhelmed! I have heard this at least 50 times before and now the 1st time with opened ears. THANK YOU!

My favourite composer!

Wrapping up the night with this video and am even more taken away by this music than before. Truly there is something great about Brahms when you can hear just a couple of the parts and be in bliss; the whole orchestra, reciting several of these lines at the same time and enfolding them into one voice is almost too much to name. Best wishes

the violin solo is so beautiful

Fragments from this movement are quoted by none other than Charles Ives in his amazing 2nd Symphony.

Once again .... mind blown! I had never heard those disguised themes from mvt 1.

What a great way to start the day! I love the low strings in this movement especially, and that transition back to the A section is indeed absolutely gorgeous!

The slickly winding lines fascinate me. Thank you for sharing

I was waiting very patiently for this and you clearly did not disappoint! This video is particular has really opened my eyes about how great this movement is, which I didn't really see before, even so I have listened to the symphony so many times. The use of motifs that you explain and analyze just astounds me, I cant even put it into words. Can't wait til movement 3!

Wonderful video! I never noticed how the chromatic motive in the first movement is so strongly present in the second

I dont know if someone added this but the lightgreen theme incorporates the tail of the darkblue theme making them heavily related. I would personally separate the lightgreen theme into a combination of new material and darkblue material. I love your content, more of this is needed.

I've been so excited for this. Thanks a lot!

A sublime movement. Amazing work as always!

Excellent analysis! thanks!

As always, great film!

Thank you for letting me appreciate this beautiful music even more!

Made my day

Siempre descubro nuevas cosas con estos vídeos, gracias!!

Thank you for another enriching analysis.

Truly wonderful music.

Such noble work you have done here... Thank you!

Poise and direction.. oceanic .. Thanks !!

Another fantastic video, thank you! Although slightly unrelated, would you ever consider perhaps doing some sort of analysis or any similar video on Mahler's 10th symphony, I think that would be great!

This is a piece that I had never fully appreciated until I watched your video. The way you break it down really helps me understand the movement more. Thanks for all your great videos! Also, are you familiar with Joachim Raff's music? I think he is a very underrated composer. I'm curious to hear what you think about his music.

Woah is the 'pink' Oboe theme quoted by Mahler in his 9th symphony? The introduction to the passage with the Flute/Horn/Basses counterpoint in the recapitulation of the first movement? Thanks for another great video!

I try to follow your older videos, can learn so much from it: 20:48 this is very Wagner, isn't it? I guess the end of Tristan. Have to check it tomorrow.

Thoroughly enjoyed! This movement feel very comforting at the moment. By the way, there's a little mistake in the vid description, where you refer to the opening movement rather than the second movement.

Brahms managed to write an entire movement without a single musical theme, just "motivs".

Good evening, dear Richard Atkinson! Thank you very much for this meticulous work accessible to understand, that you're doing! I'm certainly going to watch this video as I did with your previous detail analyses of excellent quality. It would be interesting for me to know your opinion about the different interpretations of Brahms's symphonies. Which do you consider the closest to etalonic? Unfortunately, I'm not very familiar with Brahms's creation (well, thank you for getting me more acquainted with his masterpieces!), but what do you think about Mravinskiy's interpreatation of Brahms's symphonies? I'm very interested in knowing your opinion. Thank you again! Sincerely yours, Ivan P

actually, the opening reminds me much more of LVB's 4th piano concerto, 1st movement, a 6-note stretch that is almost identical. just before the return of the opening theme. Ever notice that the famous theme from Schubert 8 ("This is a symphony/ that Schubert wrote but never finished") follows the first eight notes of the trio in Beethoven's 5th? There are only so many ways to write a sequence of notes, so there are bound to be coincidences. Another thing that is almost certainly not a coincidence is that the opening theme of the Grosse Fuge exactly reproduces the harmonic outline of the G-major section near the beginning of his 1st symphony, in the same key, stripped down so much that until you figure out the harmonic structure it's hard to make sense of it.

Now that you mention it, the opening is also present in the second movement of Beethoven concerto no. 2. Perhaps the chords are a bit different, but the melody is the same!

I've recently found out something related to what you posted here early: the cadence Brahms used in this movement many times 12:58 (IVm add6-I in a major key) is the negative harmony of V7-I in a minor key. Surprising that Brahms unintertionally performed (or even created?) this.

Richard surely the opening of this movement resembles the opening of the pastoral symphony

Yay! 😊

The first theme in E major bears huge resemblance to Mozart String quartet No.21 (second movement) too, melodically and rhythmically! ❤

Superb - as per your usual! And as per my usual, I'd love more emphasis on Brahms's dissonances' contribution to the piece's emotional power. For example, what in the world is this movement in *E* (!) major doing in a *Cm* symphony? And: the melodic arrivals on the tonic while V(-like) chords clash underneath. The melodic shape and shifting pitch range of this particular movement seems to call for a larger scale view, in addition to your primarily thematic analysis, of what's driving its emotional power. Ditto for B's rhythmic variations. But don't get me wrong... your analyses beat your KZfaq competitors by long shot, so I ain't complaining, just wanting more.

Epic

also I like the allusions to the other great works...

I'm mad at you for not including the FIRST MVT EXPOSITION REPEAT.

I hear some Mahler 3:58-4:44

For whatever reason when I hear that opening, I think of Beethoven's Elegischer Gesang, but that may just be cause you mentioned it sounds Beethoven-esque... Regardless, phenomenal video as always!

The beginning theme sounds like the second movement of Beethoven 2

Hello Mr.Atkinson, I was wondering if it at the end of your analysis, you could play the whole movement of the music uninterrupted with the color coded score? Thank you.

👏

Will you make an analysis of any of Brahms' late piano works or his piano quintet in F minor for example?

I often feel in listening to this symphony that Brahms was trying too hard to provide sufficient musical depth to act as a worthy successor to Beethoven. Only when he got this out of the way was he able then to produce the other symphonies which seem to flow much smoother, while still complex. It just seems to lack any real feeling. But an excellent analysis as always.

They're playing Brahm's 1st in a concert tomorrow in Valencia. Obviously I'm attending it.

To me, the opening sounds like the opening of the second movement of Mozart's clarinet concerto. But that's probably a coincidence.

interesante

Rick, what do you think of Moszkowski's work? I would love to see a video about it.

It could sound weird but i didnt see anything from saint-saens from you😅 hope you are planning something🥺❤️

I wonder why Brahms omits the clarinets in the final chord.

What do you mean when you say inversion?

4:10. Brings to mind Wagner's Prelude to Tristan und Isolde, beginning with measure 3. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y7eIaseYp9fKl6s.html

Hmm. I love the first movement and how energetic it is.It even gives me chills. But when the second movement starts I feel it's so bland when it's supposed to be silky creamy dreamy. Can anyone relate?•́ ‿ ,•̀

:D Hello

Can you do a video on Wagner's Tristan und Isolde prelude, including examples from Mozart and Liszt (Die Lorelei)? Mozart String Quartet No. 16, K. 428: II. Andante kzfaq.info/get/bejne/mNF-iqapkpilkok.html Piano Sonata No. 15 in F Major, K. 533: II. Andante kzfaq.info/get/bejne/nLilaMlop-DIgmg.html ( 5:05 ~ 5:35 ) Tristan und Isolde prelude kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y7eIaseYp9fKl6s.html ( 7:00 ~ 7:30 ) Rondo in A minor K511 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f5ZzrbN41J--dps.html

subtitles please, at least in the original language