Nathan Daniels agreed Gimple really screwed up this time

I just caught up with the show today and watched that episode a couple of days ago and loved it. I thought his death was so beautifully done that I cried and I think him dying at that point in the story was the perfect time for 3 reasons: 1: Because if he hadn't have died and his letters asking for peace hadn't been his legacy, Rick's decision to let Negan and The Saviors live would have been out of character. 2: Carl's character development had him become the most compassionate character on the show in Season 8. His dreams bought on the new world of peace. If he stayed alive, they would still have to do character development, because that's how screenwriting works, so they would have just devolved him again. He died at the peak of his character. And 3: In the latter seasons, the walkers haven't been a threat to the major cast at all. The characters focusing entirely on Negan and the Saviors, only to be suddenly hit with the realisation they need to take the walkers more seriously is narrativley significant and impactful. He was in the original Atlanta gang, went through so much, then died so anti-climatically doing something he's done a hundred times. It reinvents the walkers as a threat from here on and reminds the characters that they have to take things more seriously.

Matt Vivian You must be a newcomer so you don’t know what The Walking Dead is really about. Especially now that ricks gone

Jesse Marano he’s a newcomer? We’ve all watched the same episodes.

i don't think so actually, i feel like, if caracteres are here too long , we lack interest in them, it's like in real life when a good man die, we all start to see how much we miss them and regrets to not do certain things, when carl died we see his true value

SI TWD WRONG!!!

Juku yes😂😂

Ong

Hayden Sevak negan* and keep in mind, rick took many good peoples lives too, negan did what he had too

Kaneki Ken Abraham yeah but Glenn no.

Suljo TWD ye, it was to prove a point, in retrospect despite me loving Daryl, its his fault Glenn is dead

Kaneki Ken but again Neagon wanted show them he is the man in charge if don't live by his rules you die brutally

Rick took a babies father away from them

*When I first heard...

InfiniteNumbaEight I agree

InfiniteNumbaEight Negan is a narcissistic psychopath and he realized when the world went to shit that he can beat somebody to a bloody pulp and sleep fine at night. So he uses fear to get what he wants

@@jessemarano5644 If you'd know Negans character well, u'd never say that he's a psychopath. It seems like people are in need to use that word to describe "villains". Try to read something bout his origin and then delete your comment.

Oh killing people is not something what god didnt want. So killing people for the bad can be forgiven? BIYCH THEY HAD A CHOICE, KILLING THEM OR FREEING THEM AND NOWS CARL DEAD

Well, it's about timeline and scenario. You see in the arch of Negan and saviors Carl was only 12-13, 14 is max. While the actor who played Carl was about 19-20. He just couldn't play Carl without a timeskip or smt. So creaters decided to kill Carl in the show, while in comics he lived until the very end, and he grown up as 30-40 years family man.

Simple yeah, it’s almost as though he’s always “careless” about that side.

katie yeah cuz that’s the side he lost his eye on too

thank you kind sir :3

thank you

Same lol when I first heard this music on this tribute all I heard was part of the start of Ragnars trubute "I'm a... Very curious.. Man .......Our Journeys have just begun"

thanks will do >:)

thanks :3 make sure u have tissue nearby :0

hopefully u had tissues :0

o wait i replied to u 😂 10/10 not embarrassed at all

NothingButBlade Haha Im sorry I saw this late, don't worry I grabbed some tissues

I wish we got some Henry and Lydia scenes, Carl already had Enid

James Dowdall true