This! I feel as though so many people, when criticizing Cathy and Heathcliff, step over how Cathy was the only one who treated him as though he was worthy after the death of their father. Without her, Heathcliff truly was alone.

Isabella,Harerton and Nelly tried to reach out to him and tried to be his friends but he shunned them, So how can you say that? Besides he was always a loner, and was even more of a loner after Cathy died And it wasn't their fault for Heathcliff rejecting them,it was his FAULT!... you have to remember also that Cathy and Heathcliff were very selfish, narcissistic,self serving individuals,who cared about nothing else,or anyone else,but themselves and for each other and the hell with everyone else, sorry but that's just the truth,so you can enjoy the movie, and book,but you also have to accept it with all of it's flaws. Now Heathcliff could've have tried to go on and be happy,like everyone has to be he chose not to.

@@shannonhughes203 Also I might also add that Mr.Earnshaw gave Heathcliff quite a privileged upbringing,he brought him in from the streets into his own home when he was starving,gave him nice clean clothes, and an education, and it was mostly Hindley who was always jealous of Heathcliff because he couldn't never measure up as a son,and after Mr.Earnshaw died that's when Hindley's wrath was poured out on poor Heathcliff and he made him a servant and became a horrible drunkard.

@@shannonhughes203 Muy de acuerdo con vos.

@@chancycat9822 También tienes razón, Heatclif pudo haber sido feliz con otro amor, pero lamentablemente él no lo hizo. Creo que en la actualidad sucede lo mismo, y tal vez es porque no sabemos amar de verdad. Bendiciones.

@Sky High ofc their dynamics were toxic but this quote and its meaning are beautiful

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰🥰

I know it's toxic as hell but that quote I'd yhr most romantic thing ever

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Yeesh, what a quote

I agree

Thank you for your comment!!

Thank the producers who made this version 😊

I could use a bit darker Heathcliff though, he was blackish in the book. Good acting by Hardy nonetheless.

What version of the movie is this...like what year was this movie made?

I like this couple

WHAAAAAT

@@gxxbyn9885 yeah WHAAAAAAT?

I didn't know that.

Why

Oh i forgot to mention the coloring. Very beautiful and unique!

can I ask a question? I hope you answer it is very important to me.. How did Cathy meet her cousin Linton?

I need to meet tom hardy

Oh jesus...

Christ that's good writing

Beautiful

Tom Hardy is the best Heathcliff ever.

Tragedy is terrifyingly beautiful sometimes

She was an author so ahead of her time. Incredible story. Just like her life was. Tragic ending too.

A genius and incredibly gifted writer, Emily died only 12 months after its publication and never got to witness the accolades it would go on receive. It’s the greatest gothic novel of the twentieth century.

​@@cazb877wuthering heights is one pinnacle of English Literature 😊

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Тогда еще не было любви. Они на этом фильме только познакомились ❤

Faith Buchholz his scream represent the utmost despair!!!! It's extraordinary!!!!!

I've had the unfortunate experience of hearing people scream like that in real life, and it's unnerving how perfectly he does it here. I can't imagine where he had to go in his mind to be able to express that moment.

And shivering. My God, it made me cry.

well it got me too.....

He was so lonely without her.

Do you know why 3 years later?

@Izzy Sprinkle good that you acknowledged this fact

Not even borderline ,he was abusive

So many romances have very scary men in them. So controlling and abusive... I still enjoy some but it's concerning how this influences us.

you are dumb all

It's 19th century fiction, Heathcliff is a Satanic/Byronic character. Spicy? Brontë didn't write Harlequin novels. lol Anyone who experiences this type of story thinking it's ideal, is a moron, ignorant of the context.

This happened to me as well😢 so beautiful and hard.

That's why it was a scandal by the time it was first published; because it didn't portrait a romantic, idilic, and good morality love story, so in vogue on those days; instead, it shows how destructive and toxic can be an obsessive relationship between two strong temperaments, when pride and vanity and immaturity interfere on decisions that we can make for a lifetime. There was love between Cathy and Heathcliff, I do believe so, but wasn't a kind of a salutar love; they loved each other as much as they hated each other,also, because of the mistakes they both did, mostly motivated by hurted pride. Sometimes, when we're deeply hurted, we do stupid things in the name of revenge. And that's a real thing that Emily Brontë tried to show in her romance, that love isn't always such a fair, plain,clean game; sometimes, can turn into a dark macabre game of strength between two broken hearts! That was a shock to the conservative and make-believe rules of the society by the time; how does she dare to show how cruel can be the reality? Anyway, I can't avoid to feel tears in my eyes for them both, this is one of my ever and forever favourite romances and to see the madness growing in Heathcliff after Kathy died, always make me cry, his end was so sad!

@@pollyanna8061 I have lost count of the number of times I have read "Wuthering Heights ". Read it first in High school and thought it was the greatest of love stories. It wasn't till I got considerably older that I began to view the story and the characters very differently. Your analysis was very good. How "dare" indeed does Emily Bronte have the audacity or even the knowledge to show us "how cruel can be the reality" ......of a total obsession with another human being. I agree completely in all that you have said. The relationship between Cathy and Heathcliff was one of passionate love and yet one that encompassed a good deal of loathing to the point of antipathy and utter disgust. I don't think the book was well received when it was first published, no doubt for the reasons that you outlined. For me personally I couldn't help but wonder about the author herself. I wondered if perhaps Miss Bronte could have had a deep fixation with complex characters and the sometimes dangerously horrid and morbid pathways they can embark upon. In any case the novel has become a literary classic and as far as I am concerned it is a Masterpiece in English literature. Thank you so much for your reply, I enjoyed reading what you said very much. You have a good day.

can I ask a question? I hope you answer it is very important to me.. How did Cathy meet her cousin Linton?

@@ilginaybilir1326 they are only allowed to meet on the moors, because they are both forbidden to enter each other's houses. Hope this helps

Wasnt Heathcliff black??? Or brown???

@@octaviolopez2014 Heathcliff wasn't black in the book, he was a gypsy🤗

@@NagoreBM thanks :P

@@octaviolopez2014 he wasn't black /brown. he was gypsy

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

The first time they actually met was when they did this movie, then they got engaged the next year, then got married in 2014! Pretty awesome! Such a great movie! Watched it for the first time last night and loved it!

what you said is NOT silly!!!

I felt exactly the same as you, it left me speechless, I watched it over a week ago, and I'm still amazed by it. Glad I'm not the only one, who felt this way.

Read the book he's not this handsome romantic individual that is portrayed in the movies, he's an obsessive psychopath and she felt most alive when around this bad boy behavior. All anyone has to do is pick up today's newspapers or get on the internet Heathcliff is everywhere.

@@rachelmiller9280 You're cruel to Heathcliff. He's an orphan, an outsider, a nowhere man. He feels a deep disconnection from everyone and everything. He finds one thing that he is so strongly bonded with; one person who makes him feel, passion and love, makes him feel human, what he's never had before. And then that too is taken from him, love itself betrays him. He lashes out and begins a downward spiral that he cannot escape. He is as much a victim of his rage as is Catherine or Henshaw. We all rage against love, we're just not bold enough to take it as far as Heathcliff. "Thy chase had a beast in view, Thy wars brought nothing about, Thy lovers were all untrue".

Ralph Fiennes is better

Olivier of course

Laurence Olivier

Agree. Hardy is Heatcliff . Fiennes has no constitution and Olivier emotional and social scale

I would love to see Tom Hardy as James Bond

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

not anymore😢

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Thank you very much! I agree with you I think this is the best adaptation even though it doesn't stick much to the book, it makes you understand the characters better and it's sort of more romantic and Wuthering Heights is my favourite book too ;)

Wuthering Heights is my favorite book also, and yes Tom is absolutely phenomenal💕💕💕

Yet Heathcliff still gets the glass slipper ending whilst Catherine who suffered over him till her alcoholic death suffers even in the after life. There is no true justice for some of us. Even The ladies ex husband does not get justice.

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

Which year is this one?

he was incredible!!!!!!

Same

What is the name ?

@@loulouxx3642 wuthring heights 2009

@@hajarbellamari2834 thank you so much

Mrswindy same here

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰🥰

can I ask a question? I hope you answer it is very important to me.. How did Cathy meet her cousin Linton? please

Yes he does!!!!!

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

I like Ralph he’s a great actor but he doesn’t even come close to Tom Hardy as Heathcliff!

Be aware of what you wish for.

@@damiangrey4675 Quite so! @Ferdousi Lina This isn't love it's obsession. It feels amazing and wonderful for a time but it always twists into something dark and very destructive; always!

This is a bad sign, girl.

@@ConstanzeWeber I don’t agree. That's love.

Вроде уже нет.😢

What are you saying? They always were together

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰

can I ask a question? I hope you answer it is very important to me.. How did Cathy meet her cousin Linton?

The passion in the scream is my favorite

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰🥰

It’s a sexual thing. If you’ve ever felt it you would understand.

@@sandrastone5847 I have. I have done in real life what the fictional Catherine Earnshaw has done when I dumped an ex who both wanted to marry and love, but I chose to reject him and told him that I was never coming back to him and to find someone else or learn to be alone. I asked for his forgiveness and when he forgave me, then I left him permanently. I kept my word - I never have nor will go back. It took eleven years of facing the pain and heartbreak before I was able to cope with and move on. I credit God for giving me that strength to persevere and to my surprise, I met another man whom after dating for over a decade, I finally married him - Frank, my husband. I couldn’t be more blessed to have found him. So yes, I do know what it’s like to have been in Catherine’s shoes. Catherine was a selfish woman to not have moved on.

que filme é esse?

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰🥰

Hello friend how are you doing nice to meet you here i really love and appreciate your comments for how long have you been my fan I'm very happy to meet you 🥰🥰

Puedo preguntarte ¿porque? Nunca le he encontrado mas que dolor y desesperacion... La he leido en español y en ingles, y la verdad... no logro encontrarle el gusto. La respeto porque es un clasico. Y los dialogos estan escritos de tal modo que plasma perfectamente todas esas emociones. Pero la historia, no termina de gustarme. Entonces, ¿por que te gusta? Tengo curiosidad... Espero que no te sientas obligada a contestar si no quieres. Pero si lo haces, gracias.

@@annabourbon estoy leyendo los comentarios de las personas es para ver si alguien coincide con la repulsión que le tengo a muchos personajes de este libro, sobre todo al que veo que aman tanto: Heathcliff. Casi lo aborrezco, es totalmente un demonio cruel y vil. Que si, que amo fuertemente a Catalina, que sufrió malos tratos en su infancia; ¿pero que más? Jodió a tantas personas, era un hombre terriblemente enfermo, vil y loco. Si acaso pude sentir algo, pero muy poco, casi llegando a la nada, de comprensión cuando murió Catalina. Pero de ahí en adelante... Jodido villano despreciable, manipulador. De los demás personajes también tengo mucho que decir. Pero bueno, el sentido de este comentario es mi incredulidad hacía tanta maldita alabacion a este personaje tan cruel. Pensaba que las opiniones serían como la mía, despectivas, ¡pero no! Al parecer veo a todas hormonales pidiendo un Heathcliff en sus vidas. Empiezo a preguntarme si realmente leí el mismo cumbres borrascosas que todas las demás. Fuera de eso, me encantó el libro. Odiar a un personaje no hace malo a un libro, para nada, admiro a Emily Bronte. Sus escenarios tan oscuros y góticos, me encantan. Su manera de narrar, lo mucho que te mete en la trama, la complejidad de sus personajes (que son tan reales que los odias). Revolucionaria a su época está autora.

​@@user-vc7po3mw6e Просто все любят Тома😊