Whether you believe with the charlie kirk’s or not, this girl is more of a problem.

Charlie might hurt your feelings but he aint lying.

Call me crazy but it looks like the crowd disagrees with her.

Came in the country with $2000 in pocket as a student. No relatives or friends. As an Asian, never thought I had any privilege over anyone.

She just wasn’t arguing in good faith, she kept making false equivalencies and trapping Charlie into banal this or that’s it’s your only choice.

The government has been trying to fix this community for 60 years and after 60 years of work. The community is worse off than they were before To suggest that the government is the solution to the problem that they created is ludicrous.

Excuses, excuses black people come from all over the world to America, set of businesses and now living the American dream .

She's supposed to be at college to learn. Charlie's trying to teach her but she's not able to comprehend she could be wrong

Where do these kids learn this foolishness? Must be foolish teachers.

there are 58 black people in the us legislative branch out of 535 seats that's pretty close to their % of population......

People have fought hard to remove segregation in this country since Plessy v. Ferguson. Why are we now trying to bring it back?

i had a conversation with my black nextdoor neighbor a few years ago about voter IDs. he said what i already knew, most folks, black, white, etc... whom are legal US citizens have US Gov IDs. if you do not but want one, it is very easy, quick and cheap or free to get one. we are 60 year past civil rights with programs over the decades to specifically help blacks. but we have designed social programs that have kept too many poor blacks, poor. most white Americans are pulling for blacks to succeed thru hard work, effort and talent. hispanics and some asians come over here with nothing and do not know English every day. but they quickly find success and their children often do well in school and with Asians, outpace all other Americans in average wealth. there is racism against many of them just like against whites, blacks, etc... but no systemic/institutional discrimination holding anyone back from the pursuit of happiness. in fact, like i mentioned earlier, there are more programs to help blacks succeed that no other race in America gets.

Charlie is absolutely right. I didn`t find one flaw in what he said. If he did, enlighten me.

She’s still a kid she hasn’t learned a proper debate style yet. Her sarcasm downgrades her points impact like when she giggles inappropriately or says “great question” or “my favorite” when either example is obvious it’s pure sarcasm not genuine. If you are in a debate rely on your facts to win not sarcasm or like some other kids usually use, insults. But what’s better than arguing just to win it’s superior to seek more truth and to be correct rather than incorrect.

Name one country worldwide that doesnt that doesnt require a ID to vote.

Her giggling is so annoying. Almost couldn’t listen to her.

That girl wasn’t very bright

Men are not leaving because prison, they are also not getting divorced since they are not married.

Charlie forgot to take crack into account 😂

Regardless of race we should be encouraging young men to do better than our fathers it’s the only way

Something tells me this girl is offended by a LOT of things.

she really just laid out how she really feels.... either you believe her or you think it is based on genetics, ie you're racist.

One thing about welfare is that you can be thrown off of it easily. welfare encourages unmarried mothers, having more kids. when you're low income, welfare will subsidize your rent, your food, your healthcare, while not having to work. for most of us work socks, to be able to have 70% as much while not having to work is very tempting. It also encourages working under the table or committing crimes. since welfare isn't making anyone rich, you can still be on welfare and commit crimes or have a job that pays you under the table. so not only has welfare encouraged irresponsible behavior, it has encouraged crime

This chick was schooled…..

I so wish I could’ve accessed this “white privilege” during my working life! Where was it when I was immersed in my career in the U.S. Military? As a disabled Veteran I DEMAND my “privilege”!

Its funny that everything is a “great question” for her, but she had no answer

I can't believe how patient Charlie is day after day after day!

Id cards are racist? So every country in the world is racist. Every country requires ppl to have an id card.

Name the institutional racism boogie man point it one eample? She couldn't

She needs to go talk to Jesse Lee Peterson lol

Thank you for bringing up sensible questions and answers, people need to start thinking for themselves and facing actual facts

Just a statistic the lady left out. Currently, there are 62 black people in congress. This constitutes 11 percent of congress. They make up 13% of the population. Just a fact, she said they were very underrepresented, and that isn't true in that context.

She double backed on stupid😂

She is her favorite fan.!

Is this girl a teaching assistant or even a prof or propaganda? She keeps conceding point after point that Charlie makes and yet can not concede to his conclusions! If that isn't intellectual dishonesty I don't know what is! All she ever said was it's "complicated and nuanced" but she knows, somehow, Charlie is wrong?!! LMFAO and SMH all at the same time! Just for the record I'm Andy, Annmarie's husband and I'm responsible for the content of this post not her.

I think Charlie is on track with the argument that incentivizing single motherhood removes a father from the family. This in turn has been shown to harm the children and increase the likelihood of them growing up in the criminal system. I think that being in a loving family relationship promotes men to be real men and decreases the likelihood of them getting into trouble.

It must be awful for her to be so sure and so wrong.

This points to the importance, relevance, influence a of “Family” - the basic unit of society. Which Parents = Father and Mother and The Children,😊.

I’m Asian and I’ve got ID how am i oppressed 😂

She’s going to have a miserable life. Nothing she believes is real, and none of her answers are solutions.

I would love to hear your reaction to Thomas Sowell truth about slavery video

Shes smart but the way she carries the conversation is very obnoxious. I struggled to watch this

How many children in the black community are born in to a family? Meaning a mother and father in the same home. If they were born into a family there wouldn't be communities that are called the projects. When the requirement to provide for yourself is substituted with free shelter,food, utilities and funding, why would you do it for yourself?

I like her no matter how wrong she was

Male slaves did not have the responsibility fir their children. It continued after slavery.

She is so rude and needs to be quiet and listen.

I seriously dislike this type of argumentation. She uses sarcasm and acrid distain in her tone to attempt to sound superior. I'm embarrassed for both of us. She's almost as bad as the chick with the poster.

These silly students need to understand that they are at school to learn; not to try to "teach" their elders. How on earth do they even have time for all these shinanigans, and why do the authorities put up with it?

Very good channel love hereing your perspective

She is wrong about any laws keeping anyone in the southeast from voting. Most places to vote, in any city is walking distance where a huge majority of minorities live. I live in a small town with 45% minority population. Just in my small town, we have nearly 30 places to vote just within the city. For reference, you can walk from 1 side of town to the other in 2-3 hours, depending on how fast you walk. This is true in every city, always has been. There are no laws that afford one race over another. People can be rude or mean, and that is a discussion based on experience. The young lady was wrong on every account she brought up due to poor information that is easily disproven.

I’m white af. I need a id to do TONS of stuff.

Her arguments are so overly simplistic in that she declines to critically analyze her conclusions, ironically trying argue critical race analysis (which is based on correlation not causation) is preferred policy. When confronted (i.e. NBA & meritocracy) she replies, “I don’t care.”

Where do find these?

Gangsta culture, simple answer

He is 💯right

Charlie Kirk is absolutely right. I am old enough to remember when most black households were made up of a mother and a father. You are absolutely wrong about black fathers being in prisons and that is why they were not around. In late 1960's and beyond, welfare made it more profitable for black women with children to NOT have a man in the house. The carrot being dangled was to offer more money to single mothers alone. If a man entered the household, or the father was present, the benefits were reduced or stopped. That is when single black motherhood spiked. Welfare is a trap. It offers false security, but just enough to keep you from stepping out from under it and making more money (we still do this with older citizens now and collecting Social Security checks. The government raised the age of retirement based on the expectation of length of life and when the average death age is. The longer you wait to collect, the higher the paycheck, but the better chances you have of never collecting because you will be dead, whereas if young people were encouraged to set up their own strong retirement plans in the prime of their lives, they could afford to retire whenever they felt it was right, not because without working until they are good and old will assure they can maybe live in controlled, low-income housing and need food stamps). When men have no families they feel encouraged to provide for, they turn to other appetites that are not healthy ones. And it is PROVEN that without a man's influence in young men's lives, most will begin adopting things like street gangs to provide that relationship. (An interesting study was done with male elephants that became more aggressive and abusive when there were no older male elephants around to steer them in the right direction). Older men teach younger men how to be a true man who handles his responsibilities with family and to provide and raise his children. Another thing is education. Black people FOUGHT for education in slavery when it was forbidden. It was against the law for slaves to learn to read and write. More blacks did more with elementary school education than they do today graduating from high school. Part of this has to do with the deterioration of education. Schools in mostly black neighborhoods have abysmal grades. Schools actually graduate seniors who still read at elementary school levels! This was NOT the case 60 years ago with blacks, who understood the value of an education and had to fight to get it. Now they will keep passing them on. My mother was from the Dominican Republic, and i remember when public schools decided it was unfair for immigrant children to have lessons in English, so they began bilingual classes. To the white liberal, this sounds so wonderful. It's not! My mother stated that they used to put children behind a year when they immigrated here. The reason was so that they could become fluent in English and then continue with the level they left off with in their native country. They could continue their education stronger. Having children who grew up and graduated and still did not have a handle on English meant we had lots more low-income earners like janitors, maids and fast food workers. The need for immigrant children is to command the language so they can continue on to higher education, higher paying jobs, pursuing their dreams and goals. Please do yourself a favor and read some of the black economists and authors Charlie Kirk mentions, like Thomas Sowell. Even Denzel Washington has spoken many times on the need for black fathers in the home. And MOST black men 60 years ago were NOT in jail. They were working to support themselves and their families.

Another thing to think about and it's not necessarily a fact. Is it more important to be taught a good education or, is it more important for parents to educate their children about basic social normals such as how to treat people and how to have proper relationships with people? History says the latter as most, not all of US History, people of any race did better when the family home was together and both parents taught basic sociology.

She has a point but shes nit articulate.

No wisdom behind her, she is so condescending

I just have to shake my head at these liberal Einstein's sometimes. Then indoctrination runs deep. They argue for their own limitations.

Look at the past plantation...black had there own home or property like the white man, they were the same...black people invited us for BBQ and we invited it as well before the civil rights.

She needs to start a salad bar, wtf.

Is crazy saying that because you poor you area criminal omg I know people from the caserio in Puerto Rico that are doctors, lawyers, nurses,politicians,police,firefighters all start in the house how you raise your kids I’m single mom but dad is active in my kids life I don’t hide anything from my kids dad and we coparent together if he says no I say no and if say yes is yes we need to stop blaming others for poor parenting

To be fair, fact check, Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier in 1947 and not the 50s. The marriage statistics were true.

Both are correct

Misinformation alert

Robotic sounding

I don’t think u seem to understand just how much fornication occurs in America. U keep talking about marriage and divorce, but much of the single motherhood rate is not from marriage and divorce, it’s from fornication.

You can vote in estates witout an ID? in my country when you born you are issued an ID and yo nedd it for vote, wich is obligatory in my country. even in election time the goberments implements more way to renew your Id so you can vote.

Culture

Sorry dude your wrong. I stopped watching when u started commenting on the video

She is just miserable

Sorry under 10:00 and I rest my case...

Chuck has some good points but compared upper middle class w to lower class b unfair argument the upper middle b have the same understanding as the w. He also left out the way the system designed help for b women they had to put the men out in order to receive gov benefits this was after integration of women inside workforce that took a lot of the jobs b men. Also the prison policy of the 80-90s

Personally i hate them both arguing black problems smh both are missing key facts here and both fail to realize how both of their stances align with each other. This game of wanting to win the argument rather than conversing to understand is tiresome and doesnt do nothing for the communities you call yourself debating for.

Uh no I would have to disagree with on him on that.

I kind of like her , she might not be correct in all pointers. But Charlie did dodge some of the questions.

Dumsybrown don’t promote victimization. Be the solution not the problem.

It’s always the people who think they are so smart sound so dumb

If you give a man a fish you feed him for a day. If you teach him how to fish you help him feed himself for the remainder of his life.

FUCKING DUUHH!!!! SUCH LAWS LIKE YOU LISTED WERE REMOVED!!!!