Charlie's and Sabrina's voices surprisingly compliment each other and work very well alongside Dan and shay. Great collaboration!!

Their voices blend so well together! The contrast fits beautifully. I'm so glad this duet happened.

Sabrinas voice is so angelic, this song and melody compliments it so much. She’s such an extraordinary artist so hearing her here is so beautiful

So glad Sabrina was included in singing this song. She kills it every time!! Everyone here has such strong vocals

The way all FOUR of their voices blend beautifully together is insane. This is definitely the superior version of this song 🔥🔥

I did NOT expect all 3 parties to be involved here! I love that you, Sabrina, AND Dan & Shay are in one song. Genius and we must promote this too. Thank youuuu! This is a star-studded masterpiece, Charlie!

Sabrina's vocals really added a layer of intimacy and reliability/closeness to the record! All of your voices combining together is pure bliss! 🙌🏽🎉

Sabrina’s voice combined with Charlie and Dan and Shay’s voices makes the song even more complete

Fact: Sabrina and Charlie vocals are very perfect 🥰

Dan, Sabrina, and Charlie all singing the third chorus: just plain shivers.

LYRİCS ❤️ Thought, the day you disappeared that it was over Didn't even hear you leavin' Saw you with someone and thought that it was closure But you still tell me that you need me Baby, why? Tell me why can't you just make up your mind? Quit messin' with my head You can't say you hate me Then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works No, that's not how this works You can't walk away Then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works No, that's not how this works, no No, no, no, no, ooh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works, no That's not how this works, oh Stop reminding me of when we said forever I know exactly what you're doing When you say you need to drop off all my sweaters It's just one of your excuses Baby, why? Tell me why can't you just make up your mind? Quit messin' with my head You can't say you hate me Then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works No, that's not how this works You can't walk away Then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works (that's not how this works) No, that's not how this works, no (that's not how this works) Don't say that you're in love with me (Say that you're in love) 'Cause I know it's not what you mean You can't say you hate me Then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works No, that's not how this works (works, baby) You can't walk away Then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works No, that's not how this works (oh) No, no, no, no, ooh, no, no, no (hey) Baby, that's not how this works, no (works) That's not how this works, oh No, no, no, no, ooh, no, no, no (ooh, oh oh) Baby, that's not how this works

3 things: 1- this is just perfection 2- this need to have a live/acoustic version 3- i've never been so happier with a feat before, you guys need to do more stuf cause you match really well together! ❤

The feeling we get when Sabrina's vocal hits... 😊 This song is so relatable, I don't know why it's kept in the darkness for so long... Puth should release these kinds of songs... 🥺🥺🥺🥺 My second favourite after "smells like me"

OKAY THIS SONG WILL BE ON REPEAT FOR HOURS FOR ME. OMGGGG THEIR VOICES FIT SO WELL 😭😭😭😭

I listen to this version like thousand times. Sabrina's voice is so soothing. This type of song suits her well.

This is a type of collaboration I'd love to see on award shows, or live in general. Such talented musicians in their own ways

Sabrina's so talented!!! She needs more recognition

Sab slayed so hard and her voice fits this song so well omg. She deserves so much more recognition.

Sabrina's voice is adding that extra zing to an already beautiful song...nice work by all four of them....❤

sabrina’s voice sounds so relaxed in this song and it’s beautiful

I remember when Sabrina covered Charlie's song Attention she sang it so well when she was on Disney and now she collaborated with Charlie puth himself. This proves that dreams can come true and that life can change so fast

Charlie and Sabrina's voice sounds compliment each other very well❤️❤️❤️. love this song❤️❤️

Sabrina's Version 💜😇

Charlie puth is a master at picking the right people to collab with at the right time with the right song

Sabrina's version is equally good. This song is going to be extremely popular in the upcoming years!!

This one is better than the other one

This is what I desperately NEEDED from this song, Sabrina’s voice 🤍

Sabrina's voice melted my ear... Her voice blends perfectly with Charlie Puth

Her voice is so beautiful.

This song is criminally short😩😩. We need atleast an hr of this!!!

all 4 voices mend so well together. such a beautiful song

I knew a version with Sabrina would drop eventually. And it’s even better than I pictured it! Thanks Charlie! 😊❤

man these harmonies are crazy and loving this perfect pitch

The melody of this song is enjoyable

Wow, all their voices sound so good together. Great job Charlie. Plus, I just discover Sabrina as a singer here.Probably a new fan.

Their voices go so well together omg

What a special musician 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶

Sabrina's voice is very beautiful. gives that unique tone in the song, I needed to hear it :D

LYRICS Thought, the day you disappeared, that it was over Didn't even hear you leavin' Saw you with someone and thought that it was closure But you still tell me that you need me Baby, why? Tell me, why can't you just make up your mind? Quit messin' with my head You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no, that's not how this works You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no No, no, no, no, oh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works, no, that's not how this works, oh Stop reminding me of when we said forever I know exactly what you're doin' When you say: You need to drop off all my sweaters It's just one of your еxcuses Baby, why? Tell me, why can't you just makе up your mind? Quit messin' with my head You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no, that's not how this works You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no Don't say that you're in love with me (say that you're in love) 'Cause I know it's not what you mean You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no, that's not how this works You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no No, no, no, no, oh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works, no, that's not how this works, oh No, no, no, no, oh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works

I was hoping she’d be on the track after seeing her in the vids, it’s perfect omg

La voz de Sabrina es muy hermosa. El da ese tono único en la canción, necesitaba escucharla 💜💜✨

Love this version so much, Sabrina's voice fits in so well

Sabrina's voice and Charlie's blend so well ❤️🙈 love this version

Definitivamente la voz de Sabrina le da otro toque ♥️

The Harmonization at the end! Bro in the actual fk?! THAT WAS HELLA FIRE 🔥😭 We can all agree that all version rocks!

perfect duo❤

Their voices compliment each other so well it blends in perfectly 😭💗

So real man.. Just wanted to say thank you for the cool little things you taught me. I'm a disabled vet and was going thru a hard time and took it upon myself to take my music further and to make it more like therapy... and that meant singing. I learned a lot from you and I put up my new jam "Leaking" which is the first song I ever sang on(lyric video on here). I used some harmony techniques you taught me in the first verse. I would love it if you could give it a listen. Much love my man.

This song better gets nominations and awards this year!!! I'm happy with Sabrina's advancing recognition and progress 📈💅🏻✨😭

today marks the 8th anniversary of Sab's Eyes Wide Open album&another gorgeous song is released on the exact same day. unbelievably proud of her✨️

Loved this version the best! Sabrina's voice adds a delicate touch.

Charlie Puth, Sabrina Carpenter, Dan+Shay did great job 👏. This version is much better than original version.

Like this version better 👏👍❤️. Sabrina’s voice matches and blends In perfectly with CP! Also this version includes all parties, with Dan&Shay, 👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥

oh my god absolutely perfect

This version is amazing! All their voices sound great together and hopefully they will perform this live together

Beautiful ! Her voice should have been added in the original

Amazing song! Sabrina really adds another unique piece to this amazing tune!

First of all thanks to jk when he is live he introduced this song now I am addict ❤❤❤ Charlie voice is so smooth when he sing that's not how is works

Your voices compliment each other so well this was definitely a win in my book

Pero que arte acaban de entregarnos, la voz de Sabrina es como si los mismos angeles cantarán

I know it's a sad song, but I'm loving the vibe.

I miss old charlie puth

Lovely Lyrics: [Verse 1: Charlie Puth] Thought the day you disappeared that it was over Didn't even hear you leavin' Saw you with someone and thought that it was closure But you still tell me that you need me [Pre-Chorus: Charlie Puth] Baby, why, tell me, why Can't you just make up your mind? Quit messin' with my head [Chorus: Charlie Puth] You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no That's not how this works You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no That's not how this works, no [Post-Chorus: Charlie Puth] No, no, no, no Oh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works, no That's not how this works, oh [Verse 2: Dan + Shay] Stop remindin' me of when we said "forever" I know exactly what you're doin' When you say, You need to drop off all my sweaters It's just one of your еxcuses [Pre-Chorus: Dan + Shay, Charlie Puth] Baby, why, tell me, why Can't you just makе up your mind? Quit messin' with my head [Chorus: Dan + Shay, Charlie Puth] You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no That's not how this works You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no (That's not how this works) That's not how this works, no (Not how this works) [Bridge: Dan + Shay, Charlie Puth] Don't say that you're in love with me Cause I know it's not what you mean [Chorus: Dan + Shay, Charlie Puth] You can't say you hate me, then call me when you're hurt Baby, you know that's not how this works, no That's not how this works (Works baby, no) You can't walk away, then come back to what we were Baby, you know that's not how this works, no That's not how this works (Not how this works) [Post-Chorus: Charlie Puth, Dan + Shay] Oh woah, no, no, no, no (Hey) Oh, no, no, no, no (Oh) Baby, that's not how this works, no (That's not how this works) That's not how this works, oh (Not how this works; oh) [Outro: Charlie Puth] No, no, no, no (Ooh, oh, oh) Oh, no, no, no, no Baby, that's not how this works

I basically just listen to this version and the original version together and you can hear both differences between the second verse and the ending chorus, they are both really good and I would listen again over and over on repeat for both songs

La voz de Sabrina es hermosa, cómo la de un ángel

Why why and why this song fits our situation? Pufff man

Sabrina is everything she’s such a great actress AND singer 🥹🥹 I’m glad she’s getting the recognition she deserves

I just turned the two versions of the song, carpenter and dean at the exact same time, surprisingly too much stereo but quite interesting.

I didn’t know there would be a Sabrina’s version ! That’s such a great surprise 🥹

Charlie keeps surprising us with better and better! I love it!

I’m so glad Charlie listened to his fans, and added Sabrina Carpenter to the song instead of just making her his love interest in the video. The both of them together makes one hell of a duet.

sabrina’s voice >>>> !!! they sound so good together

This version is a better one than the first version . I personally love it more

La voz d Sabrina me encanta ❤

All of their voices complement each other so well omg i love this !!!

THIS VERSION IS A THOUSAND TIMES BETTER, THEIR VOICES TOGETHER IS WHAT THE SONG NEEDED ♡

They’re both super talented ❤

Love u charli❤

I'm in love with this beautiful song. The vocals are so perfect. there are so many emotions... Charlie never disappoints and it's such a pleasure to listen to his wonders.

Only 2.1M views?! This is better than the previous one.

I think I wanted them to collab for a LONGASS time, and here we are! Thanks you guys!

Their voice together is heaven

This duo makes me cry 🥹🥹

As a long time fan of sabrina carpenter, I'm so happy that she's getting the recognition she deserves

I actually prefer this one than the official.

I Love This So Much🥰

the mix of their voices sent my ears to paradise goshh

i hv literally listened to this a thousand times back to back

Their voices blended so well.... Loved the song 💚✨

This version is the best

Essa versão tá ainda melhor! Sabrina e Dan + Shay que perfeição! Hit #01 certeza

Is it me or whaaaat...charlie's and sabrina's voices are magical ✨️ 😍

i lowkey wish dan and shay werent in this one. he just kinda comes out of nowhere towards the end lmao

That's perfect, their voice match so much

This version is lit...Its so amazing to see how their voices compliment each other.

this was so good i'm so glad Sabrina was included!!

Idola sangat2 sempurna.

The harmony is amazing! I didn’t think the song could get any better but it did!

One of Charlie's best collabs for sure. Sabrina's version almost has a different umph to it, love it as well!

Ouhh my God, this song are bringing me to heaven