Charlotte Tilbury use to work for Tom Ford that is why you see a lot of similarities in product packaging (especially their eyeshadow quad).

I love cream eyeshadow just so much! My only problem with this series is that you make me want to buy every product you show us 😄

Charlotte Tilbury worked for Tom Ford. She was the creative mind behind the TF beauty line before she created her own brand. That’s why you will find a lot of similarities between the two (and also why Tom Ford beauty has gone downhill somewhat in more recent years, IMO). I never tried either product because, despite having the world’s driest skin, I have the oiliest eyelids... and I have heard from people that the CT ETM doesn’t wear well. I just kind of assumed that the TF would be super duper similar and also not worth my time. I feel like I tend to hear more about the TF cream/powder duos than these cream singles, but I don’t have any of those either.

I have almost all of the CT Eyes to Mesmerize because I love them so much. They're so freaking easy to blend!

Charlotte tilbury cream eyeshadows have been on my wish list for such a long time. I put on marie antoinette once at Sephora. And maybe five to six people asked me that day what I was wearing. Such a different color from that classic browny goldy champagne shades. Thank you. Great video:)

Bought the TF Platinum based on your videos. It doesn’t do much for my coloring. Gave it to my 86 year old mom and she loves it! She’s gone all ‘ one and done.’

I’ve never tried the Tom Ford but have wanted to. Platinum’s gorgeous. Love that wet look! Great info and comparison. Super helpful, per usual:) Can’t wait to see what’s next. Thanks, chickadee🍃🌸

I agree with you about the lighter versus the darker colors. I’ve had all four and don’t care for the lighter. Mona Lisa and Platinum are great. I also love the naked bronze from Tom Ford as well as Spice.

Really enjoying your cream eyeshadow series. Cream eyeshadow really changed the game for me! I haven’t tried either of these two products yet, but they are on my wishlist. Bette from CT looks lovely for an everyday brown. Sphinx from TF looks absolutely beautiful and unique. I may try that one in the spring!

My fave pot cream eyeshadows so far have been the maybelline colour tattoo ones 😱 they are super cheap but the colour selection isn’t the best!

You save me a lot of money ! Iove how detailed you are with reviews

Yes!! You got my attn here with cream shadows!! I’m 59 and want to start wearing more cream shadows on my lids bc they do t smudge and I love a little shimmer and shine on my lids!! So yes more cream shadows!!!! New subby!! 😀

Wow, such a detailed and useful review! I have Opale and I was thinking about getting Platinum but after seeing that perfect sheen on your lids I am definetly getting it. Just the right balance between matte and sparkly, it has such a beautiful glowing sheen, I absolutely adore it! Thanks for the great review! :)

You made my buy the Platinum shade by Tom Ford. 🙈 I love your reviews ❤️

Charlotte mainly seems to use Jean as the inner corner highlight with the other shades. You’d prob enjoy it more if used for that☺️

I have quite a few Caviar Sticks, a few Bobbi Brown sticks, and a couple of Charlotte Tilbury but I definitely want to try Tom Ford.

I am loviiiing this series! It’s like you’re reading my mind, Amanda! Ahahhaaha. Thank you.❤️ EDIT: I know it’s a bit early but i’m sooooo looking forward to watching your final thoughts on this series and hear your pick for the best cream shadow. Xoxo

Thank you for the everyday suggestion. This is what I was looking for :)

Another wonderful review! I’ve been able to purchase products based on your videos with fantastic results 😘

Agree /you....in my opinion, the formula of the Tom Ford cream eyeshadows is superior to the CT. The CT cream shadows crease significantly more on my eyelids but I will admit her shade options ARE beautiful.

Platinum is on back order everywhere🥺 but I found it at Neiman Marcus it will be shipped in another month.. (I'm excited to try this) I went ahead and bought Opal from Sephora.. Thank you for your recommendations

I have the Charlotte Tilbury in rose gold and really enjoy it! I especially wore it a ton during spring and summer. I’ve honestly never been drawn to the Tom Ford cream eyeshadows though. I have a few of the TF quads and I may purchase the contour and highlight cream duo but for some reason I’m not in love with the cream eyeshadows?

2:22, 2:32, 4:18 👍, 5:05, 6:52 Tom Ford "platinum"💛💛💛, CT Mona Lisa 💛

Would love to know what you have on your eyes at the start of the video, it’s beautiful!

Great comparison! Have you ever seen a shadow like these in light pink with a pearl shift? Been looking for ages haha

We just got CT at the Nordstrom near me. Haven’t tried anything tom ford but that color looks amazing

I love your eyebrows! Perfectly bushy and beautiful - Lisa Eldridge would be proud :)

If I use glitter primer I never have issues with creasing when it comes to cream shadows no matter how cheap or expensive

Thank you i loved this so informative.

Could you compare Natasha Denona Chroma Crystal Top Coat with HOURGLASS Scattered Light Glitter Eyeshadow? Or at least review either one of them? I'd be very grateful :)

Yes most waited comparison 😍

very in depth review. thank you.

Hi Amanda. Do you think Tom Ford Platinum would also suit medium skin tones as an everyday glossy lid look? Or would it pull cool toned and/or make the taupe more apparent upon wear than the brown?

Also just got Platinum with a coupon. Now I'm all set for eye shadow until next year! 😂

Your top looks really nice! Would you mind sharing where it's from? Textured white and cream clothes are my thing haha x

Which are shinier?

Girl, where are your earrings from? LOVE them!

Does anyone know what the Charlotte Tilbury Mona Lisa colour is in the UK? Is it Amber Gold?

subscription worth kind of review!

What is on your eye?

To me it seems like the lighter cream eyeshadow shades in general are more problematic.... I notice this across brands, whereas the more medium and deeper shades tend to be the best quality.

Charlotte used to work for Tom Ford

I just purchased CT Marie Antoinette. It creases terribly on me. I’ve tried priming and concealer underneath. Any other suggestions?

I think CT Marie Antoinette is comparable to TF platinum!!

But what is on your eyes 👀?

You really are like a female sheldon cooper

I will never understand why Americans pronounce Charlotte's surname "tilBERRY" XD It's TILbury, people!

Charlotte Tilbury is cruelty free and less expensive whereas Tom Ford tests on animals and still charges more. Go figure.

It's "Tilbury" not "TilbARRY".