Thank you Atty. Antonio Carpio for loving and defending our country, PHILIPPINES…GOD BLESS YOU WITH LONG LIFE …

What a fascinating long conversation segment between two intellectuals who are on the same page when it comes to the West Philippine Sea issues. Indeed a very compelling one!Thank you so much for the very enlightening historical background discussion about the WPS before UNCLOS. I hope people will have the time to listen to this conversation especially the students and even the older generation who side with China about our EEZ-WPS. Thank you so much Retired Senior Associate Justice Carpio and Professor Richard F Heydarian. I’ll never get tired listening to both of you, there’s always so much to learn. Mabuhay po kayo! Chapeau!!!❤🇵🇭💖!

That’s why we Filipinos have to be grateful that we had President Noynoy Aquino who gave the go ahead signal to sue China in UNCLOS.

Salamat at Mabuhay Kayo Justice Antonio Carpio!

Mabuhay ka Justice Carpio! A living hero of the Philippines!

Thanks justice Carpio.why not you run for public office in Senate or executive much better to us.❤

ENLIGHTENING! THANKS MR HEYDARIAN, JUSTICE CARPIO. MORE ON THIS SUBJECT , PLEASE...

Mabuhay ka justice Carpio! SALUTE.

DUTERTE MUST BE TRIED FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION

JUSTICE CARPIO FOR PRESIDENT! Will vote for you if you run

Di tayo magkakproblema sana sa ating karagatan kung ang US military bases ay hindi pinaalis ng mga senador na ito. - Jovito Salonga: - Juan Ponce Enrile - Agapito Aquino - Joseph Estrada - Teofisto Guingona Jr. - Sotero Laurel - Orlando Mercado - Ernesto Maceda - Aquilino Pimentel Jr. - Victor Ziga - Rene Saguisag - Wigberto Tañada:

Justice Carpio should run for Senate or be appointed to a cabinet position

Thank you fmr SCJ for always be the advocate of the WPS , an expert on this field!🙏 🙏🙏Richard you’re one of a kind like justice Carpio , thank you and you’re always appreciated just to let you know ! 💜🙏 Support to your advocacies at all times ! ✊💪💜🥰🙏

Salamat sa "Magnificent 12 na mga Senador na nagpaalis ng US Bases dito satin sa Pilipinas. Dahil sa kanila magkaroon ng lakas ng loob ang Comminist China na pumasok sa ating teritoryo at angkinin ito.

Justice Carpio we needed you in the Senate,,please Run for the Senate 🎉!!!

Malaking tulong ang America sa Subic nuon kaso pina alis sa panahon ni Erap, nicki coseteng. Nawala tuloy ang ilang isla natin at di makapangisda ng ayos mga nakatira dyan

This is sad. We must be better. We deserve to be better. Realities requires us to be better. Otherwise, we will fail as a nation.

Wow! Short but full of information ( inside information, as well), all Filipinos should see and share this video. Mabuhay ka former Justice Carpio sa iyong tulong at pagmamahal sa bansang Pilipinas.

I was in college when the Phil Senate kicked-out the US military bases from the country. I remember that most of the students were all ecstatic at that time, not knowing that the Phil. made a blunder in deciding to remove the bases without preparing / planning for it.

I blame it all to the Phil Senate in 1992 when they rejected the stay of US bases in the Phils. & our sealine territory was left without a navy guarding it & China took advantage of the situation & it only started to build small metal hut then until they built an artificial island.

Dapat lahat Ng tatakbong politiko sa Pilipinas ay kailangan ipag tango l ang ating bansa.kung handi nila mapaipagtangol pwede silang tangalin sa kanilang position.pati ang Kanilang Pilipino cetezenship.

Thank you Atty Antonio Carpio sa maayos na paliwanag. God bless you always po❤

Keep up the good work Judge.

No more Duterte-like president after PFRM, or else former associate justice efforts will be in vain

Very informative... thank u JC for the efforts and concerned to our Country. Mabuhay po kyu!

THANKS SIR AND THANK YOU TO FORMER JUSTICE ANTONIO CARPIO, MABUHAY PO SAINYO SND GOD BLESS

China has one goal and one mind. unlike Philiplines too many mind with different goals

Ex-president Duterte was elected beyond his competence. He should have stayed as Mayor of Davao!!!

Salamat po Justice

Perfect conversation, very comprehensive and informative. Thank you so much gentlemen.

Justice carpio kailangan ka ng Pilipinas

Yan yung effect ng anti US bases, those who voted against this bases at the senate did you all debated on this reprecussion which are our reality now - Senate & President Ramos major error

Justice Carpio the living Hero

Thank you sir Associate Justice Atty. Antonio Carpio for fighting what is for Filipino people in our territory.

informative. thank you

The US should not have left the Subic and Clack Airbase in the first place. Now we need them back to help the Philippines to stand against china's territorial expansion.

The sadly truth is that PH past administration didn't only prepared but they also help china. And now, Filipinos most specially our fishermen are suffering from their mistakes.

Salamat po at may mga kagaya nyong nagmamalasakit sa ating bansa, kasama po kayo sa aming panalangin para sa nagkakaisang mahal natin na bansang Pilipinas God bless the Philippines

In the late 80s and 90s, the Philippine government was engrossed in internal power struggles, neglecting crucial defense preparations. While the decision to end US presence was deemed necessary, the failure to fortify our self-defense force left us vulnerable. Meanwhile, neighboring nations like South Korea, Malaysia, and Singapore were diligently fortifying their economies and defenses, setting the stage for stark contrasts in regional power dynamics. As a consequence, my generation inherits the responsibility of defending our borders and charting a long-term solution to a problem that could have been prevented with foresight and strategic planning. Beijing's calculated efforts to shift the global balance of power, exemplified by their formidable navy, stand as a stark reminder of the importance of forward-thinking governance. Evidently, this wasn't a priority for the leadership in Malacañang over the span of nearly five decades. Remember we lost Sabah already. Had our leaders from the late 80s to the present prioritized long-term national goals and fortified our motherland, we wouldn't face the risk of being labeled the "Sick Man of Asia." It's imperative that we learn from past oversights and actively work towards securing a strong and resilient future for our country.

Long live FCJ Antonio Carpio.God bless you Sir 🙏❤️

The US should also have prepared for this eventuality, even as they left the bases. After all they also have an interest in keeping the freedom of navigation in the south China sea. The fault is not only ours.

Bakit hindi matatapang ang mga government officials in the past over the Philippine sovereignty and interest

very informative discussion. thank you

Praying for my country--Philippines! in Jesus name. Amen.

It’s very sad, but we have to admit that this present situation is because of our stupidity and of course the entrenched corruption in our government and society in general 😢

Salamat po CJ A. CARPIO dahil sa pakikipag laban sa WPS at di mo pinabayaan ang karapatan ng pinas sa iba dyan na ginustong mawala ang US sa usaping pag tulong at nakita natin ang resulta kaya gising tayo sa katotohanan na kailangan natin ang US

Now I understand when God said, "In this world you will have tribulations..." Because of these troublemaker countries, so these are still happening. But we must not lose hope. God is the most powerful and above all. I am so grateful that God placed me in the Philippines, a God-fearing country. God teaches us to submit to the authority. The Philippines practices submission of the International Law since we are part or member of the UN. God bless the Philippines and its allied countries. 🙏

This is the true story! Where did it start about this issue of the WPS! Sa mga nag blame kung sino ang may kasalan now! All keyboard warriors here! You should watch this! Educate yourself! This is where it Starts & happened!

Dami kong natutunan dito. Thank you for this interview. It is very sad that most of our national leaders did not have any vision of future-proofing, such as this concern. This is now a decades-old problem. Hay. Kelan kaya Pilipinas? Ang hirap mong mahalin.

When you gonna air the next episode? Thanks

The decision before was like...... aaaa basta paalisinna yang mga Americano bahala na si batman ..

I salute you then and now , Justice Carpio , The true Philippine Pariotl

Mabuhay si Justice Carpio. He is our modern hero, our national treasure.

Philippines must allow allied countries and internationalmedia to escort Filipino fisherfolks and supply convoys.... it's too long being defensive....be offensive by allowing allied countries to escort us

Clark and Subic now own by Politicians.

Pls. Sir justice carpio.. tumakbo po kaung senator.. kelangan ka ng bansa..

Now is again the time to think ahead and recover the lost time and opportunity the ph had.. Please formulate plan now for the next 5-10-20-50 and 100 years!!!

please, run in senate justice carpio

Monster Catamaran type PCG fleet should be built for WPS base patrol,strong stability and long stay in the area.

SO PHILIPPINES 'HOPE' 'HOPE' 'HOPE' BUT BUT BUT THE 'TORMENTS PROLONG' "PREPARED" AND "STRONG"

If no energy security, then forget EVs, AI, Data Centers, and even Foreign Investors. Simulan na ang drilling sa WPS.

Sorry Justice Carpio, di ko matapos panoorin. Nakakadismaya ang kabobohan ng mga politiko natin dito sa bansa. 😢😢😢

Atty. Carpio for PRESIDENT!!! Please run for the Philippines 🇵🇭

Kaya need natin Presidential parliamentary form na. Para kahit pabago-bago president tuloy tuloy ang long-term planning, action at execution. Sa atin pag bago presidente, refresh din lahat. Walang pag-unlad, walang unified direction. Ang hawak ng president Defense, Police, National security and acts as figure of the Republic. Ang PM ang head ng Executive/ministries.

Vote for government officials, leaders who really loves Philippines more than bribery

Pa LEASE sana ng gov't ang mga malalawak na assets sa NCR sa mga conglomerates para gawing business districts mala BGC at ng kumita ang govt sa LEASE, Taxes, donation, etc. ng malaki like NAIA complex since magkaka new airport na naman sa Bulacan eventually, Camp Aguinaldo at Crame since di naman sila sobrang kailangang nasa loob ng Metro Manila, BSP building in Manila since ililipat na naman sila sa Clark, UP Diliman Campus ilipat na lang sa labas ng M.M., etc. At tiyak yung malaking pondo na maco-consolidate sa Leasing at taxes eventually e malaking pera ipang modernize ng AFP sa Navy at Air Force especially para mapabilis since oras at time ang kalaban na natin. Let's be realistic this time sa ayaw man at gusto natin darating ang WAR dapat handa tayo, di na makukuha sa diplomacy ang China, buong buo yung plano nila sa loob kunin ang Taiwan sooner at pati na ang WPS. At tiyak pag nangyari yun ano ang kasunod? Gawawa na naman sila ng bagong dash line kasama ang buong mainland ng Pinas at kailan na nila tayong sakupin... Dahil sa mata ng mga Chinese sagabal ang posisyon ng bansa natin sa kanilang imperial ambition, the only way to fully dominate the region is to integrate the PH eventually. Try nyo baliktarin ang mapa, from China towards the region, naka bara ang Pinas sa kanilang daanan going to the Pacific. Haha

Thank Justice Carpio for exposing Philippines idiocy😂

Why not appoint Justice Carpio as DFA Sec?

The Philippine Government and it's officials are entirely to blame. All the politicians were concerned only about power a their personal interest. Now it is too late to stop them without the help of the USA. I don't know what will happen this late in the game. We are entirely under the mercy of the United States or China.

Former Justice Carpio makes a lot of sense. I agree with him that the loss of bases was an opportunity that China saw immediately to move in and grab WPS. Now that US came back, we are buying time while our allies are getting ready to defend our seas and valid claims to the WPS. Hopefully it won't be too late by the time US is ready.

Thanks for continuing to deal and emphasize phil terrotorial bounderies under UNCOS.

Pinaalis ang mga American Bases hindi naman pala kayang ipagtanggol ang ating mga isla at shoals. Sana nagpalakas muna ng pwersa bago tinapos ang mga defense agreements. Mahina ang foresight ng ating mga nakaraang leader hanggang politika lang talaga ang alam.

👍

We are prepared.. Maybe some of our politician and soldiers in the past ay nabayaran.

You can listen to LKY and Kishore Mahbubani from Singapore.

I agree, Duterte's term as president was the worst of times. He "loved Xi Jin Ping".

WPS is the Philippines responsibility to protect. If you can’t protect it then someone else will.

Yung hirap at pagod ni JAC...sinusugan ni PNOY..binalewala ni prrrd. PBBM is now mending like we came from war.

Aaaah… the great Monday quarterbacks..

We Filipinos have one fatal flow- we expect others behave as we behave ( do unto others)...we expected China to behave but they did not ..now they threatened us! But we love china that their bullying/brazen land grab has awakened our nationalism. Now the whole world is helping us: economically, militaryly, socially. Go Phils. Thank you Richard, Justice Carpio.

We should cooperate with the International Criminal Court in it’s investigation of the Duterte drug war‼️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

Yang NBN-ZTE Deal under GMA pa. Nasa Congress na naman si Arroyo.

Just an observation coming from an ordinary filipino citizen, you gentlemen said "we were fooled".....thats the problem with too much politics, iur legislators were distracted. They didnt see tge whole picture. Now we are paying the price becoz China was able to mobilize and the game took a more difficult turn.

After Marcos Sr.. the next leaders are weak on WPS. You can only blame the past admin for not preparing for anything

Pls allow the guest to make and compose his own premises to your questions… let him talk more…

JOIN NA LANG TAYO SA U.S.A TO SOLVE OUR PROBLEM,

Salute to our late President Aquino. Also salute to PBBM and their advisers.

Khng hind sanai pinaalis nina coseting ang base ng amerika, wla sanang ganyang problema...

根据自然界写的法规，接壤多国的海洋，多国拥有一小块海洋。而不是某一国独吞整个海洋。例如太平洋，它接壤多国，多国就各各拥有一小块太平洋。南海也接壤多国，南海各国当然各自拥有一小块南海，中国自然也只能拥有一小块南海。

Fidel Ramos was playing "footsies" with PLA generals which was a base weakness in foreign policy vis-a-vis the PRC. After which the geographical survey of the archipelagic boundaries of the country was undertaken with much funfare, which is the second sign of weakness that emboldened China to conduct survey on the edges and boundaries of the country. Then, they occupied the reefs on ostentatious pretenses.

Hindi pwede yan

Richard please summarize the intros of your questions… you’re hugging the conversation too much… sometimes!!!

I like Duterte but he has to protect the constitution and WPS amd sovereignty.

Oʻoʻ

The Philippines was not prepared because the politician are very busy politicking and saw the Americans as overdue colonial master that has been overstaying likewise politicians during that time wants to get a big chunk of the budget (cdf) and all of the budget went to bigtime projects all of w/c has Kickbacks likewise majority of generals are corrupt like Maj.General Garcia etc....

we slept on our rights during the time of dutz, and dutz literally gave the WPS away. that old man dutz, so incompetent!

There is no saving PH , even in the comment section, we fight each other while the others conquer our land.

You have the guts to kick out the Disunited States???

System failed

Hindi nga po pŕepare kasi mahina ang depense ng pinas dahil sa kapabayaan ng namumuno..tas ngayun sasabihin yan..