No video

China Returns to Mao | 5 Minute Videos

  Рет қаралды 523,854

PragerU

PragerU

Күн бұрын

In the decades following the death of Mao Zedong, China enjoyed relative economic freedom and unprecedented growth. But under Xi Jinping, Mao-like government control has made a comeback, weakening China’s economy. Helen Raleigh explains how socialism is once again failing China.
See the rest: l.prageru.com/...
Script:
Socialism is failing China.
It wouldn’t be the first time.
After the Chinese Communist Party (the CCP) took over the country in 1949, party leader Mao Zedong set out to create a socialist paradise. He forced farmers to sell their produce at fixed prices, nationalized industries, and abolished private property.
Things went from bad to very much worse.
Between 1958 and 1962, China experienced the worst famine in human history. Estimates range as high as 50 million dead.
Throughout Mao’s reign, many more were exiled, jailed, or killed.
After Mao died in 1976 signs of a free market began appearing around the country. Some brave farmers sold a portion of their produce at market prices. In the cities, black markets emerged: haircuts, shoe repairs, and other services were bartered for food.
Instead of cracking down as Mao would have done, his successor Deng Xiaoping realized that for the CCP to survive it had to adapt; it had to allow the Chinese people a measure of freedom.
The free market is like a grapevine; it thrives wherever it’s given a little room to grow. Farm yields quickly doubled and tripled. Urban shops sprang up everywhere. The more freedom the party granted its citizens, the more the nation prospered. Within three decades, China transformed itself from an impoverished nation to the world’s second-largest economy. In that time, 800 million Chinese lifted themselves out of poverty.
One of them was Jack Ma.
Born in 1964, Ma, like most Chinese, grew up poor. He became an English teacher in 1988, making $12 a month. During a trip to the U.S. in 1995, Ma used the Internet for the first time and recognized its potential. Upon returning to China, he founded an e-commerce company called “Alibaba,” providing an online marketplace for small businesses and bargain-hunting consumers to trade directly with one another.
Alibaba became a huge success. Its $150 billion initial public offering in 2014 was the largest in the history of the New York Stock Exchange. Ma became the richest person in China, with an estimated worth of $25 billion.
Stories like Ma’s were repeated a thousand times over. Capital poured in from around the globe. The nation’s economy grew by 9% or more per year.
To most, it was a thundering endorsement of the power of the free market.
But that’s not how China’s new leader, Xi Jinping, saw it.
It wasn’t entrepreneurs like Jack Ma who deserved the credit for the Chinese miracle, it was socialism and the CCP. For Xi the path to more prosperity was not more freedom, but more government control.
So, Xi slowly and deliberately forced China back toward the socialist economic model envisioned by Mao. Deeply suspicious of entrepreneurs and their independent ways, Xi decided to show everyone who was in charge.
📲 Download the FREE PragerU app: prageru.onelin...
Follow PragerU on social media!
Instagram ➡️ ( / prageru )
Twitter ➡️ ( / prageru )
Facebook ➡️ ( / prageru )

Пікірлер: 699
@mustang607
@mustang607 Ай бұрын
"Socialism never fails to fail."
@drzman6901
@drzman6901 Ай бұрын
That one got to me too. The contemporary socialists in the U.S. often admit that socialism has failed everywhere it has been tried, but that is because it was implemented incorrectly. Trust us to implement a version that will succeed, they say. Ms. Raleigh speaks the truth when she said that "Socialism never fails to fail." It does so because it goes against the grain of human behavior. Socialism will always fail.
@wdd3141
@wdd3141 Ай бұрын
Free market capitalism, for all its flaws and limitations, is self-adjusting, self-correcting. Socialism, on the other hand, apparently needs to be applied in a strict, precise way in order to function in a sustainable way, and even then, there are innumerable ways in which it can falter and fail. I submit that socialism is an INFERIOR system of economics and social organization. Chinese Communism is a vampire feeding off the lifeblood of capitalists abroad. Let's stop feeding it and expose it to the light of day!
@johnkim4548
@johnkim4548 Ай бұрын
Socialism always fail.
@drapas7467
@drapas7467 Ай бұрын
What a lovely quote, Best Regards from Communist of Vietcong in South China !
@ForGlory
@ForGlory Ай бұрын
That would be a good thing if it weren't for all the souls it eats before it dies, getting fatter and grosser until it is an undead behemoth that eats the world, at which point everything is dead and it doesn't matter if Socialism dies, last of all, ironically. There is a hapless but well-intentioned fool born every minute, and since everyday Americans stopped telling their children campfire stories about the Socialism monster, Socialism always has a supply of fresh meat. And no wonder! Now that 99% of people are so corrupt they would rather support the perversion whereby marriage and gender were "redefined" than stand up and Fight for Principle, everyone got lazy and self absorbed, and therefore gullible and indulgent, so they're ripe for consumption!
@charlesferdinand422
@charlesferdinand422 Ай бұрын
To state a few facts: Capitalism and the United States WON the Cold War while the Soviet Union disintegrated under its own weight without a single shot being fired; Socialism is the obsolete ideology that failed miserably in Zimbabwe, Venezuela, Grenada, Vietnam, North Korea, East Germany, Yugoslavia, Libya, Sri Lanka, Chile, Hungary, Nicaragua, Poland, El Salvador, Mozambique, Romania, Honduras, Mongolia, Bolivia, Afghanistan, Angola, China (which has been Capitalist in everything but name since the economic reforms of 1964 by Deng Xiaoping), Russia (of course), and everywhere else it has been tried. Capitalism continues to be the best and only option while Socialism continues to be the worst, the most failed and most lethal after having caused at least 120 million deaths in less than 90 years which would translate in more than 1 million deaths per year. BTW, how come reds keep bitching about American "imperialism" but never mention Chinese imperialism in Vietnam or North Korea? Or Soviet imperialism in Afghanistan, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Hungary, East Germany or Yugoslavia? Or Cuban imperialism in Angola, Mozambique, Grenada, Nicaragua or Venezuela? Or Yugoslav imperialism in Albania? And let's finish with the Socialist prayer: If it's a Socialist atrocity, it never happened If it happened, it wasn't that bad If it was that bad, they deserved it If they didn't deserve it, mistakes might have been made If mistakes were made, that wasn't real socialism.
Ай бұрын
Real socialism is libertarian socialism/anarchism. State "socialism" just like (state) capitalism is responsible for billions of deaths. Absurd to say that Cuba is imperialist, Cuba helped liberate Africa from capitalist imperialism. Nelson Mandela praised Castro and the Cubans. You can be critical about so called Communist states, but it doesn't mean they were the worst and countries such as China did not progress since 1949. It's fanatical to say capitalism is the best and only option, a system that is built on hierarchy and inequality.
@ulikemykungfu3995
@ulikemykungfu3995 Ай бұрын
It’s an ever changing inequality in capitalism. I have gone from broke to well off in only a few years. In Venezuela people are eating dogs to survive. In socialism everyone is equally crushed under the state.
@stoneymcneal2458
@stoneymcneal2458 Ай бұрын
Well said!
@drakke125Channel
@drakke125Channel Ай бұрын
Hierarchy IS needed, the ideal of equality is a fantasy everyone hopes for but fails and falls short on because of human corruption.
@DrillPreacher
@DrillPreacher Ай бұрын
“But that’s because real socialism has never been tried” 😢
@Spencerianism
@Spencerianism Ай бұрын
Yet the new generations are always willing to embrace socialism as the answer to thier problem of laziness
@geemac7267
@geemac7267 Ай бұрын
Laziness always has an element of "I don't have anything, so I don't want anyone else to either". Which could be socialism's honest slogan.
@jimdandy849
@jimdandy849 Ай бұрын
And public schools are pushing socialism in the classroom.
@micheleh5269
@micheleh5269 Ай бұрын
Virtue signal
@lawrencehalpin6611
@lawrencehalpin6611 Ай бұрын
Funny and true. It does work until they are out of every one ell's money.
Ай бұрын
So all those peasants, workers, and slaves who made a social revolution to overthrow the capitalists, landlords, and masters were lazy? You have got to be kidding.
@ZZZ2573
@ZZZ2573 Ай бұрын
PragerU is the type of "education" that sounds profound until it starts talking about things that you know about
@scillyautomatic
@scillyautomatic Ай бұрын
I feel bad for the youngest generation who did not receive a solid education on US Civics, History and the disasters of communism.
@PANZERFAUST90
@PANZERFAUST90 Ай бұрын
Yeah, the public education system in the US is deliberately awful.
@adorabledeplorable5105
@adorabledeplorable5105 Ай бұрын
Maybe it’s because our education system has been compromised.
@sodazman
@sodazman Ай бұрын
Except China isn't actually communist. It's only communist by party name.
@micheleh5269
@micheleh5269 Ай бұрын
And world history
Ай бұрын
What is communism in your opinion?
@halnicholas3791
@halnicholas3791 Ай бұрын
I’m in China now, in several cities for two months. Massive variety of consumer goods at very affordable prices (anything you can get in US available here), tons of expensive cars (every brand imaginable), great energy and innovation. Not really seeing an economic failure here. But I might be wrong.
@kwamesmith3214
@kwamesmith3214 Ай бұрын
The real problem or question is that you are in China right now… 🤔🤔🧐🧐
@freethinker810
@freethinker810 Ай бұрын
@@kwamesmith3214 whats the problem?
@kwamesmith3214
@kwamesmith3214 Ай бұрын
@@freethinker810 Reminds me of a metawoke joke/anecdote I told… The People’s Republic is the Republic of the Party and Ocean People… but not decent Chinese People… A decent Chinese person isn’t allowed to break thru the Firewall to come onto KZfaq but Ocean People(foreigners) are allowed. In fact I might’ve been one of the few foreigners who also weren’t allowed to break thru the Firewall. The Republic of the Party and Ocean People reluctantly let me bypass the firewall because their intelligence agency eventually realized I removed them in most timelines (I had several diseases when I was in China, lead by cancer, and no I wasn’t privileged to get medical care, so the Grim Reaper offered them Ghost of Christmas Future). Finally I was able to bypass the firewall to find crude but possibly effective methods to perform self surgery, operated on myself, removed cysts, tumors, ulcers, etc, and maybe survive. So I already saw their graves. They probably also saw their own graves as my experience was a shared coma.
@aurigalin6327
@aurigalin6327 Ай бұрын
Every year the United States spends half a billion dollars to propagate the theory of China's collapse, a claim that has been going on since 1990. In 2000 the United States said that China would collapse in 2010, and in 2010 it said that China would collapse in 2020, and the United States' crazy political propaganda floods the entire Internet. If socialism will collapse, why has China survived to this day? If democracy will work, why did Athens fall?
@aurigalin6327
@aurigalin6327 Ай бұрын
@@kwamesmith3214 I also use KZfaq in China ,So the real question is why do Americans who don't speak Chinese, don't have passports, and haven't left their city or country think they know everything about China?
@nicholasemjohnson47
@nicholasemjohnson47 Ай бұрын
Returns? I didn't know it left.
@drakke125Channel
@drakke125Channel Ай бұрын
Many people grew away from Mao, but went back to Mao because their lives were silently being forced back to the old days. Many youths do not or may not understand the corruption of the CCP because they did not experience it. Like Japan, China hides a lot of atrocities from government tyranny. My family experienced such tyranny from both the CCP and their radical citizens, much like the ANTIFA and BLM and extremist liberal leftist Democrat voters in the US today.
@user-dn5rf8ql2b
@user-dn5rf8ql2b Ай бұрын
国有经济的占比和管制程度还是有起伏的😂 从劳工权益的角度看,中国没有工会劳动法形同摆设,远比西方资本主义国家不保护劳工权益而似乎比西方资本主义国家更“自由市场”,因而在很多民营行业形成了不小的竞争力 但从企业主的角度看,中国又从不承认他们有法定不可侵犯的财产权(不是单指税收,而是指可能被随意行政罚没)导致外逃和缺乏长期经营的动力 大量资源行业被国企行政垄断,所有土地被政府垄断也造成企业除了人力外的成本高企
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
​@@drakke125Channel China 'socialism with Chinese characteristics' is improving the livelihoods of Chinese people. when 'free' capitalistic market does not have guardrails' it is no better than communism.US is a plutocracy- a 'crony-capitalism' that allows corporations to control your 'democracy' which means you have no democracy. you complain about 'Xi's' 'dictatorship but your US system is no better. controlled by oligarchs that you call philanthropists. . you are hypocritical to criticize another country when yours is no better!! And you have NO knowledge of how the CPC system works. Instead you spread fear of 'communism' instead of going through an actual analysis of how the CPC governs. It is not perfect, it may be terrible, but the US system is no better!!
@renequinonez2614
@renequinonez2614 Ай бұрын
Would be nice a PragerUn en español, Latin America need this education.
@Octovisuals
@Octovisuals Ай бұрын
Indeed, and very much. I vote for this.
@changuito10
@changuito10 Ай бұрын
Agree. In the meantime, people can first turn on the "Captions" in english, and then find the option of auto-translate. A list with all the languages pops up and one can select the language of choice.
@democraticrepublicofsprout7263
@democraticrepublicofsprout7263 27 күн бұрын
It won't happen. PragerU would never talk about things like the Banana Wars, the Filibuster Wars or the numerous coups and dictatorships the US backed.
@markmunroe-hz8rf
@markmunroe-hz8rf Ай бұрын
This iscwhat happens when one is far too blind to ideology instead of the broader picture.
@BlckJack123
@BlckJack123 Ай бұрын
The reality is that China never really left Mao.
@yootoobvyooer
@yootoobvyooer Ай бұрын
Yup. Mao picture is still on their currency and tinanmen square. Funny how a billion+ ppl can idolize a guy who killed more of their people than anyone in history.
@selohcin
@selohcin Ай бұрын
Nonsense. China left Mao behind in 1979 when they started doing business with other countries, and even back then private businesses were springing up.
@sir_dreadlord_on_blitz7042
@sir_dreadlord_on_blitz7042 Ай бұрын
In a documentary i watched about xi it Said: "when xi opens His mouth, mao speaks."
@hoperules8874
@hoperules8874 Ай бұрын
😱
@kodeedog4660
@kodeedog4660 Ай бұрын
must have been a Falun Gong documentary.
@sir_dreadlord_on_blitz7042
@sir_dreadlord_on_blitz7042 Ай бұрын
@@kodeedog4660 it was an Arte documentary
@Aidann72
@Aidann72 Ай бұрын
Not even close, Xi and Mao are worlds apart
@Billilv
@Billilv Ай бұрын
@@Aidann72 They may have met each other.
@bosse641
@bosse641 Ай бұрын
What a world we live in. Fallen indeed.
@michaelklein9276
@michaelklein9276 Ай бұрын
@bosse641 yeah, it would be way better if women couldn't vote.
@mustang607
@mustang607 Ай бұрын
From: Woke: A culture war against Europe: "The only difference between equity and socialism is the type of property that they redistribute, the type of shares. They're going to redistribute social and cultural capital in addition to economic and material capital, and so this is my thesis when we say, "What is woke?" Woke is Maoism with American characteristics. If I might borrow from Mao himself who said that his philosophy was Marxism-Leninism with Chinese characteristics. Which means Woke is Marxism and that's a very provocative statement." -James Lindsay
@sodazman
@sodazman Ай бұрын
China actually bans so called "Woke" media and ideologies in their country. They banned K-Pop, LGBT material in all their shows and movies.
@DoubleplusUngoodthinkful
@DoubleplusUngoodthinkful Ай бұрын
Xi: "You didn't build that!"
@RaGinGnonSToP
@RaGinGnonSToP Ай бұрын
That's right! Jews did! They're the best!
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
Prove it i
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
​@@RaGinGnonSToP😂😂😂😂 Israel biggest exporter is China . Israel buys everything from China sooooo
@anng.4542
@anng.4542 Ай бұрын
Although I am relieved to hear that Jack Ma is alive, even if in hiding.
@horridohobbies
@horridohobbies Ай бұрын
China's famine in 1958-1962 was also largely due to US sanctions on China that prevented food imports. Conveniently, you didn't mention this. It also coincided with an historically severe drought. I suppose you'll blame Mao for the drought, as well.
@gdprsn
@gdprsn Ай бұрын
perfect example are the two Koreas .
@kodeedog4660
@kodeedog4660 Ай бұрын
not a fair comparison. if North did not have sanctions and then you compared, then you could evaluate more fairly.
@Octovisuals
@Octovisuals Ай бұрын
Also the Soviet Union and virtually every country where communism or socialism has been imposed in, without a single exception.
@yootoobvyooer
@yootoobvyooer Ай бұрын
​@@kodeedog4660so you think no country can prosper without US help? How very USA USA of you.
@kodeedog4660
@kodeedog4660 Ай бұрын
@@yootoobvyooer listen closely... the example was the two Koreas. no one talking about 'no country'. But US dollar hegemony and vassal states are very apparent. US is the self proclaimed 'greatest democracy' on the planet... you have two criminals in Binden and Trump for president!? please do some reading / listening.
@ColdWarII
@ColdWarII Ай бұрын
@@kodeedog4660 No one obstructs North Korea to choose an open policy
@72dew
@72dew Ай бұрын
Im a pretty die-hard libertarian, but I've travelled to China and it's paradigm-shattering how efficient and advanced the Chinese are. Due to the massive cultural differences between the Chinese and Anglo societies, "socialism" doesnt mean the same thing in English. Chinese socialism (not USSR socialism) is having critical upstream industries such as energy, weapons, fiance, infrastructure etc. nationalized. And have those crown corps act as economic stabilizers. While it's easy to point to their govt for "bullying" industry giants, they're laughing at our govt for being owned by industry giants. As much as I'm a libertarian for Canadian politics, i cant ignore the fact that had China practiced western liberal democracy, they would've been another India.
@amimi-ricky
@amimi-ricky Ай бұрын
A very rational point of view. The more likely fact is: if China implements Western liberal democracy, China will be inferior to India. China's total population will reach 1.8 billion or more, the country will become unstable or even divided, and the world will not receive the dividends of China's development.
@user-rz2hy6rs2y
@user-rz2hy6rs2y Ай бұрын
讲的不错👍
@graemeroberts7367
@graemeroberts7367 Ай бұрын
@@72dew 😂 you really are the most easily led commie in the world eh
@jacksmith-mu3ee
@jacksmith-mu3ee Ай бұрын
​@@graemeroberts7367 prove it . Waiting
@jasonjean2901
@jasonjean2901 Ай бұрын
This entire narrative falls apart pretty quickly when the fact that China's economic growth is well over 5% right now. Hard to claim an "economic collapse" when the world's second-largest economy is growing at 5%. Now compare this to the U.S., which is going $2 Trillion into debt every year for 2-3% growth. Which one looks like an economic collapse?
@Bay0Wulf
@Bay0Wulf Ай бұрын
“Well over 5%…” LOL … FOMALOL!!!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
​@@Bay0Wulf I don't see a counter
@sbkarajan
@sbkarajan 21 күн бұрын
@@Bay0Wulf China goes to the poorest countries in the world and builds roads, bridges, hospitals, power stations, ports. But what did the US do in Vietnam, Cambodia, Afghanistan, Somalia, Nigeria, on and on?
@sbkarajan
@sbkarajan 21 күн бұрын
@@Bay0Wulf The problem with GDP is, I have been to China and Mexico. They ain't the same GDP per capita of $13,000. Not even close, even remotely. So, how the F GDP is calculated? Even the US, GDP per capita is $80,000???? Meaning AVERAGE household of 4 earns like $80k x 4 = $320k? Total bull.
@Bay0Wulf
@Bay0Wulf 20 күн бұрын
@@sbkarajan Well, I suppose you could say we didn’t do anything … comparatively … however, the USA didn’t build a bunch of stuff and screw the countries to the wall and literally take over their stuff and crush them financially. The Chinese are definitely NOT doing anything out of the goodness of tgeir hearts. You ought to look at the cost of doing business with China.
@skyliner467
@skyliner467 Ай бұрын
China is not really a communust, but genuine fascist state.
@johnju-s9y
@johnju-s9y Ай бұрын
Exactly! But PragerU won't recognize it. PragerU calls Venezuela socialist while it actually isn't. ---Trotsky(just joking)
@louisbabycos106
@louisbabycos106 Ай бұрын
They are so communist they are fascist. They are so fascist they are communist. They are communazis.
@alpine1600s
@alpine1600s Ай бұрын
Fascism, like monarchy and republics can have good foundations and moral directives. Socialism and Communism are evil to the core. They are dehumanizing and silence the individual.
@bosse641
@bosse641 Ай бұрын
Exactly. Two ways on the Left, both Statist. Communism or Fascism. None of it good.
@XGamin1
@XGamin1 Ай бұрын
How so? Are you talking about right now, before, or in both instances?
@sbkarajan
@sbkarajan 21 күн бұрын
China goes to the poorest countries in the world and builds roads, bridges, hospitals, power stations, ports. But what did the US do in Vietnam, Cambodia, Afghanistan, Somalia, Nigeria, on and on?
@Bronzo87
@Bronzo87 Ай бұрын
I disagree, the quality of life in china for the regular citizens is still better the the USA today
@Billilv
@Billilv Ай бұрын
But the westerns value freedom and democracy more, don't they ? Like the freedom for drugs, cult, and guns.
@naive985
@naive985 Ай бұрын
不知道你反对的理由是什么,but as a Chinese, I think my life is so terrible. Especially in Political life.By the way, Maybe you are right, You can visit China in your future time, China has visa exemption in these day, As a saying in China that"耳听为虚,眼见为实",也谢谢你这么支持China.
@clairde
@clairde Ай бұрын
If Socialism is failing itself and Capitalism is winning, Why capitalism keeps saying socialism is failing?
@mikecanton9147
@mikecanton9147 Ай бұрын
Preach on. No socialist/ communist practices in America. Thank you very much 🇺🇸
@KatyYoder-cq1kc
@KatyYoder-cq1kc Ай бұрын
That would take a complete act of God and miraculousness. God has departed from the US
@HollyDutton-wz8fe
@HollyDutton-wz8fe Ай бұрын
No unjust or irrational exploitation of labor either.
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Preach Jesus was socialist😂😂
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
​@@HollyDutton-wz8fe😂😂😂😂good joke
@btlim4316
@btlim4316 Ай бұрын
My country indonesia is a capitalistic country. How come we still got massacred with half a million deaths in 1965?
@selohcin
@selohcin Ай бұрын
That's a great question.
@yiqingwang1437
@yiqingwang1437 Ай бұрын
Isalm is as bad as socialism /communism
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
​@@yiqingwang1437now is islam ??? 😂😂😂😂 So no longer communism ? Ok usa had 100 million native Americans . Where are they ?
@Marsbati
@Marsbati Ай бұрын
She is just saying BS, a speaker for the western mainstream media. That’s the conclusion!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Agreed
@saintorlamb
@saintorlamb Ай бұрын
This lady FAILED as soon as she said CCP instead of CPC 😏😏😏
@HoustonRacewayKid
@HoustonRacewayKid Ай бұрын
The US is facing a totally opposite problem, Capitalism is becoming the “Dictatorship” of business - ie. Monopoly control. It’s bad for all small businesses, and more terrible for the people that own and operate these business with employees now demanding a “living wage” which is far greater than what can be provided. Cost of living is high, thanks to some certain factors. Nobody without skilled labor or doctorate degree at some level nearby can afford to purchase a home, unless they’ve spent years of savings to do so today.
@jpcmt1721
@jpcmt1721 Ай бұрын
America has no private property. As long as there's eminent domain and property tax, we are serfs.
@yootoobvyooer
@yootoobvyooer Ай бұрын
Lol. You seem to think death and taxes are things you can avoid.
@Capital-Science
@Capital-Science Ай бұрын
The property being taxed uses public utilities.
@selohcin
@selohcin Ай бұрын
@@yootoobvyooer You know the early Americans didn't pay property taxes, right? They also didn't have an income tax!
@yiqingwang1437
@yiqingwang1437 Ай бұрын
​@Capital-Science like what? Do you know the so called public universities benefit rich people? So is social security program?
@yootoobvyooer
@yootoobvyooer Ай бұрын
@@selohcin you know the constitution did not restrict taxes of any kind. This is what founders wanted, tax as much as your representatives voted for.
@tech-mediasvc
@tech-mediasvc Ай бұрын
Sound familiar? “If you’ve got a business - you didn’t build that. Somebody else made that happen.” -Barack Obama
@scillyautomatic
@scillyautomatic Ай бұрын
I remember that one! I think I screamed some bad works at the TV when I first heard it.
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
​@@scillyautomatic source ? Proof ? China created everything . U are using a chinese phone .
@septembersurprise5178
@septembersurprise5178 Ай бұрын
"Isn't it odd that we should take a spasm, every now and then, and go spinning back into the dark ages once more, after having put in a world of time and money and work toiling up into the high lights of modern progress?" - Mark Twain Nothing new under the sun, just our turn in the barrel!
@KatyYoder-cq1kc
@KatyYoder-cq1kc Ай бұрын
While other countries progress, the US is paid to have chaos and double mindedness
@Emppu_T.
@Emppu_T. Ай бұрын
Great little videos
@steveguti6452
@steveguti6452 Ай бұрын
Urgent emergency please join me in prayer for all those affected families children animals massive life threatening Situations hurricane beryl they desperately need your prayers please pray for them God bless you all...
@richa.s9912
@richa.s9912 Ай бұрын
Beryl allergies pills ?
@richa.s9912
@richa.s9912 Ай бұрын
Yes I will pray 🙏🏼 for Texas and Louisiana and Arkansas and Missouri and Oklahoma and Kansas.
@hoperules8874
@hoperules8874 Ай бұрын
Deng Shaouping-best economic help to China-and they still sent him to re-education camp...😢
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
China 'socialism with Chinese characteristics' is improving the livelihoods of Chinese people. when 'free' capitalistic market does not have guardrails' it is no better than communism.US is a plutocracy- a 'crony-capitalism' that allows corporations to control your 'democracy' which means you have no democracy. you complain about 'Xi's' 'dictatorship but your US system is no better. controlled by oligarchs that you call philanthropists. . you are hypocritical to criticize another country when yours is no better!! And you have NO knowledge of how the CPC system works. Instead you spread fear of 'communism' instead of going through an actual analysis of how the CPC governs. It is not perfect, it may be terrible, but the US system is no better!!
@dweedlemiggs4177
@dweedlemiggs4177 Ай бұрын
The economic relaxation was not openness to free markets, it was to dominate global manufacturing before dropping the authoritarian hammer
@rollingage5590
@rollingage5590 Ай бұрын
My grandfather's family was originally a well-off family in the Sichuan area. Atfer the communists took power, family property was looted and most elders died of disease or starvation.My grandpa's eldest brother eventually starved to death to feed his young siblings.For survival, his second brother joined a geo exploration team to Guizhou.This brother also suffered many times of famine, but he survived by picking fruit in the mountains( compared with the steep mountains of Sichuan, the Guizhou mountains are much smaller).My grandpa and his younger sisters stayed in Sichuan, survived by collecting crabs and river shrimps and trading them for other food nearby Chengdu.
@Night-forever-g4s
@Night-forever-g4s 15 күн бұрын
地主好死😂你的财产被没收了,贫农的好日子才来了😅
@firefly4326
@firefly4326 Ай бұрын
Misleading news. 1958 famine was due to WW2
@papabear90
@papabear90 Ай бұрын
A lot of westerners here making comments while their countries are in steep decline lol. You're worried about the wrong things.
@saiga12forme88
@saiga12forme88 Ай бұрын
Good video, not sure why all the dislikes.
@nihlus9589
@nihlus9589 Ай бұрын
this is the weirdest case of dislike bombing I have ever seen, there is hardly any misinterpretation in the video to justify this
@angrybull
@angrybull Ай бұрын
@@nihlus9589 CCP bots
@thatchacre5763
@thatchacre5763 Ай бұрын
@@nihlus9589 Though I have no evidence, I suspect it is the work of CCP's internet water army. Do you know that CCP has been mobilizing tons of prison inmates to fight the disinformation war allover the internet for the party? They were just following orders issued by their political commissars.Who wouldn't want a parole?
@Dennis-nc3vw
@Dennis-nc3vw Ай бұрын
If they're too cowardly to argue in the comments, their opinions should be ignored. I almost approve of youtube hiding dislikes. Downvotes are the tool of cowards who can't argue.
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
​@@nihlus9589prove it Socialism succeeded so much that usa sanctioned china many times . Hmmm so why is usa in recession while china is rising ?
@steveguti6452
@steveguti6452 Ай бұрын
Jesus Christ died for our Sins according to the scriptures and that he was Buried and he rose Again the third day praise God praying for everyone Everyday God bless You all
@secretbassrigs
@secretbassrigs Ай бұрын
And God says to vote Republican across the board
@richa.s9912
@richa.s9912 Ай бұрын
Yes God comes first then later Republican and Americans Christian people and Our America needs saving from dictator Eugenics Party leaders millionaire and billionaires Demoncratic Party's Satan Worshipper lovers who doesn't want to believe in America and God's LAWS of 10 commandments and Common sense TRUTH rules and Jesus Christ and Prayers and Bibles and Pledge to the America flag.
@boethius9173
@boethius9173 Ай бұрын
The USA is getting terrible, too.
@samfisher4566
@samfisher4566 28 күн бұрын
The quote that resumes socialism: “Socialism never fails to fail”
@JonySmith-bb4gx
@JonySmith-bb4gx 25 күн бұрын
When will it fail ? Prager never tell the truth
@catotheyounger2689
@catotheyounger2689 Ай бұрын
China has never been a free country, and it's likely to stay that way. One if the big reasons why communism failed in China is because it was an agricultural economy trying to apply an ideology intended for an industrialized economy. Today, businesses in China are allowed to operate so as long as they further the interests of the government.
@SHARKVADERS
@SHARKVADERS Ай бұрын
PRAGERU!!!!!
@mamc1986
@mamc1986 Ай бұрын
Uh oh! I guess we better run?
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
​@@mamc1986 Prageru is famous for misinformation and racism . China economy is suffering at 5% growth despite sanctions and trade barriers levied against china Usa economy is robust at 0.9% growth 😂😂😂😂 China 0 wars Usa constant wars . China best nation
@ermytanio7111
@ermytanio7111 Ай бұрын
Jack Ma: Chinese banking was so complex Xi: the earth king has invited you to lake laugai
@MrElliotc02
@MrElliotc02 Ай бұрын
Excellent presentation...
@ugochukwuinnocentebere2703
@ugochukwuinnocentebere2703 Ай бұрын
Good comparison and I think my best video in this channel 😅
@eurospec
@eurospec Ай бұрын
True...but China's economy was not growing sustainably before Xi either. The "socialism with Chinese characteristics" was plagued with graft and a massive debt bubble was already forming. Xi has definitely aggravated the situation and has popped that bubble while simultaneously lowering the prospects of growing out of it by kneecapping the free market and retrenching to State Owned Enterprises
@magnaman80
@magnaman80 Ай бұрын
Having lived there at the peak of the good years - and the fall - I was glad to experience a new culture and explore the world by my job there. Also, glad to be long gone out of that country!
@seanrodgers1839
@seanrodgers1839 Ай бұрын
China isn't really socialist, it's more fascist. Where are all of the social services for the people?
@mohamedabarkan7734
@mohamedabarkan7734 Ай бұрын
And the aliens are real lol
@Night-forever-g4s
@Night-forever-g4s 15 күн бұрын
在哪里?你真是可悲,不了解中国的话就不要信口开河。 中国的几乎所有大学,一年学费只需要700美元,包括住宿费,中国人的医疗保险可以报销绝大多数疾病,中国如今的饥饿率是发展中国家里最低的几个,有些国家,比如马来西亚,GDP和中国接近,但是饥饿率远远高于中国,你不相信的话可以自己去查联合国的数据
@stuh4932
@stuh4932 Ай бұрын
Great video
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Cia bot 👆
@samholden5735
@samholden5735 Ай бұрын
Excellent video
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Prove it😂
@user-so2lf5hq7g
@user-so2lf5hq7g 26 күн бұрын
You are right. No one dare to stop him. Lots of Chinese know what he is doing and don’t like it, but yet they have done nothing to stop him.
@JonySmith-bb4gx
@JonySmith-bb4gx 25 күн бұрын
Prove it . Be more jealous
@valorzinski7423
@valorzinski7423 Ай бұрын
A shift in economic and industrial planning was needed even if it meant lower growth since the existence of China is more important than slightly higher growth and better living conditions Geopolitical tensions with America made the move necessary
@craigslistseller9354
@craigslistseller9354 Ай бұрын
中國萬歲!!! 中国万岁!!! Long Live China!!! 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 Long Live the CPC!!! 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳 🇨🇳
@onlinerando-xfr9kd44
@onlinerando-xfr9kd44 Ай бұрын
Is PragerU deleting comments?
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Prageru is famous for misinformation China economy is suffering at 5% growth despite sanctions and trade barriers levied against china Usa economy is robust at 0.9% growth 😂😂😂😂 China 0 wars Usa constant wars . China best nation
@craigslistseller9354
@craigslistseller9354 Ай бұрын
"Israel and Taiwan are bases of operation for Imperialism by the United States in Asia. They created Israel for the Arabs and Taiwan for us. They both have the same objective." - Mao Zedong 毛澤東 (1965)
@jhljhl6964
@jhljhl6964 Ай бұрын
Mao created Hell on Earth. ..
@SancLunatic
@SancLunatic Ай бұрын
Chinese Socialism. Its like Capitalism except there is only one conglomerate corporation and zero competition.
@steveguti6452
@steveguti6452 Ай бұрын
I would appreciate it Deeply if anyone could pray for me im very sick suffering with chronic pain from long time illness please pray for me praying for everyone Everyday God bless you all
@secretbassrigs
@secretbassrigs Ай бұрын
The Communist Party is doing the opposite right now.
@richa.s9912
@richa.s9912 Ай бұрын
Yes I will be praying for you 🙏🏼🇺🇲✝️🛐
@baikeiast5255
@baikeiast5255 Ай бұрын
No😅😅😅😅😅
@userwest626
@userwest626 Ай бұрын
who made those videos?
@aurigalin6327
@aurigalin6327 Ай бұрын
It was produced by the US funded anti-China media, she was obviously born in China in the 80's when China was trashy and her English was so bad she was reading from a script completely. Those Chinese born in the 70's and 80's went to the US and did what they do every day, make a living off of anti-China content.
@lisasaims3007
@lisasaims3007 Ай бұрын
You are simply brilliant thank you for clarification I pray for the Chinese people 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
@crit_cannon1090
@crit_cannon1090 Ай бұрын
if you have someone whom has lived through a terrible system, why not believe them? why are we running toward it?
@KatyYoder-cq1kc
@KatyYoder-cq1kc Ай бұрын
Follow the money trail.
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
​@@KatyYoder-cq1kcsource ?
@horridohobbies
@horridohobbies Ай бұрын
China has a hybrid economy that blends central planning with free markets. It is NOT purely based on free markets. It is this hybrid economy that is the key to China's spectacular growth.
@basiclawprof
@basiclawprof Ай бұрын
Listen to this woman
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
That's not a woman . That's a puppet
@seangriffin2053
@seangriffin2053 Ай бұрын
I had never heard of Jack Ma's story until now. I feel sorry for what was done to him. He would definitely have a happier story here.
@mahendrakrisnamurti9599
@mahendrakrisnamurti9599 24 күн бұрын
I think I like where this is going. Jack Ma introduced the 9-9-6 working system. They want people to work from 9 AM to 9 PM for six days straight. Knowing how successful Jack Ma and his Alibaba were, many businesses were trying to implement this to their own workplace. Not only that, in my country there's a sense of fear that the mainland chinese would dominate our own soil. The local businesses were worried. It happened to some countries in Africa. Even in Australia, there are so many lands owned by mainland chinese and this is not right... This is literally colonialism all over again. It is sad to see China regressing. But I am also grateful to see China stumbled
@Mao11622
@Mao11622 Ай бұрын
Some channels are so good I would hit the "like" before even watching it. This channel is one where I hit the "dislike" button and leave, it's pure propaganda.
@merlinwizard1000
@merlinwizard1000 Ай бұрын
1st, 5 July 2024
@danjohnson887
@danjohnson887 Ай бұрын
Nope! July 5th, join the American team
@shawngilliland243
@shawngilliland243 Ай бұрын
Very educational video, Miss Raleigh. Good for Jack Ma, using the evilnet for good. No doubt Xi knew where Jack Ma was.
@craigslistseller9354
@craigslistseller9354 Ай бұрын
Mao Tse-tung = 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍
@Vincitorerose
@Vincitorerose Ай бұрын
Thank you for this! I stumbled upon NTD and it helped open my eyes to what's happening to China and the great people. God save them all ❤
@user-rz2hy6rs2y
@user-rz2hy6rs2y Ай бұрын
…… 我们很好 上帝要帮助的人太多了 我们就不麻烦上帝了
@BB-vh8cj
@BB-vh8cj Ай бұрын
Gweilo detected
@jacksmith-mu3ee
@jacksmith-mu3ee Ай бұрын
Pino bot😂😂😂
@horridohobbies
@horridohobbies Ай бұрын
China's economic growth was expected to slow down. No economy can grow at high rates indefinitely. Once the economy grows large enough and mature enough, slowdown is inevitable. Funny how you didn't learn this in Economics 101. Nevertheless, China is expected to grow 5.0% this year and 4.5% next year. Compare this to USA's 2.6% this year and 1.9% next year. The British and EU economies are expected to do even worse than USA. [Source: IMF.] So what on earth are you going on about? Socialism has NOT failed. It is capitalism that is failing - just look at the economic and social chaos in America.
@saisirvous7363
@saisirvous7363 Ай бұрын
This is a pure anti China propaganda. You see when she show the map. Even that Chinese map is an Indian version which illegally occupied several Chinese territories
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Agreed
@jeanthony4003
@jeanthony4003 Ай бұрын
Thank you for your short video. I wish I could share it with my daughter, but she's over in the deep end of the socialist democrats. She's one of those... too smart.
@sotecluxan4221
@sotecluxan4221 Ай бұрын
USA, too. At least for the last ~50yrs.
@user-hs7yd4eb4y
@user-hs7yd4eb4y Ай бұрын
Jack Ma is a rich kid, when he was young he could go outside to study, and his father has a very close relationship with CCP leader Chen Yun.
@Billilv
@Billilv Ай бұрын
Don't speak out the truth, it's bad for a "story".
@user-hs7yd4eb4y
@user-hs7yd4eb4y 27 күн бұрын
@@Billilv but good life need the truth
@Redmi-xu1yo
@Redmi-xu1yo Ай бұрын
Chinese power 💪👏 no1 in the world 🌎
@Aidann72
@Aidann72 Ай бұрын
The idea that Xi Jinping wants to return to the Maoist model for China is simply false. Yes he has been terrible for the economy but Xi was chosen to his position because he wouldn’t return down the path of Mao, his political opponent at the time was a Maoist. So I don’t think it is fair to characterize Xi as taking China back to the economy of Mao because he isn’t. No Chinese leader would dare do that, they would not be able to rise in the party with that strategy. Xi Jinping is more of a believer in centrally planned development economics (as seen with the Belt and Roads initiative). The only reason he is harsh to criticism (which I disagree with) is because he is very conscious of national security compared to his predecessors. However, even though he is shit with the economy right now he definitely is nothing close to what Mao was.
@dontaskmewhy100
@dontaskmewhy100 Ай бұрын
Disagree. It surpassed and better than Mao. It's CPC, not CCP. Propaganda channel
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
They are jealous of china
@Bay0Wulf
@Bay0Wulf 20 күн бұрын
Most commenters here make the mistake of trying to compare the “Numbers” with those they are familiar with which is not suitable. There are 1.425 Billion Chinese / There are 0.340 Billion US Citizens (4.2 for every 1) There is an Estimated 175 Million “Young Adults” in China (More than 50% of USAs Total Population) To say “Youth Unemployment” in China is at 21% means 35 Million are Jobless To say “Youth Unemployment” in USA is at 8.9% means 4 Million are Jobless If you wish to compare USA to China … 4M x 4.2 = 16.8M You have to consider the numbers to make a reasonable comparison and then, you have to recognize that every one of those is a Person with all the needs, wants, desires and consumption rates of a Person. 35M Unemployed People is More than 10% of the Total Population of the USA.
@changuito10
@changuito10 Ай бұрын
"After the fall of communism, everybody in the world agreed that socialism was a failure. Everybody in the world, more or less, agreed that capitalism was a success. And every capitalist country in the world apparently deduced from that what the West needed was more socialism." Milton Friedman
@user-ub7kg5fo9v
@user-ub7kg5fo9v Ай бұрын
Great summary of the mess that prevails here in China . So sad 😢
@burrru007
@burrru007 Ай бұрын
Socialism is obviously a very bad thing. The only question is which countries are more socialistic now? I would argue that China is less socialistic than France, US or Germany. And therefore more successful.
@butchlester1
@butchlester1 Ай бұрын
Thank you / great info 👍👍👍🙏
@Milton_Friedmanite
@Milton_Friedmanite Ай бұрын
Didn’t Ma say something absolutely crazy during his Musk interview?
@Count1jt
@Count1jt Ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing
@ForGlory
@ForGlory Ай бұрын
This video doesn't help. As a KZfaq video, it will only be watched by those who are either... a) already well aware of the existential threat that is Marxism but who aren't willing to do anything meaningful about it so they watch the video to make themselves feel virtuous b) an exceedingly few who are exposed to it, but who, influenced by 99% of people, ultimately do nothing about it and forget Ever since 99% of people became so corrupt they would rather support the perversion whereby marriage and gender were "redefined" than stand up and Fight for Principle, everyone got lazy and self absorbed, but in plain English it means that no one will act in meaningful ways, even given compelling info. This video doesn't help because it's a KZfaq video. But if it were MANDATORY in ALL schools and workplaces, then, maybe then...!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Source ? Proof ? Prageru is famous for misinformation and racism . China economy is suffering at 5% growth despite sanctions and trade barriers levied against china Usa economy is robust at 0.9% growth 😂😂😂😂 China 0 wars Usa constant wars . China best nation
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
This video is debunked already . Prager u is known as a joke . If u uses prager as source you ll be laughed at😂😂😂
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Ok lets see A) proof ? Show proof B) prageru is well known propaganda. They are a joke on the internet . Also I see 0 proof from u
@pantarkan7
@pantarkan7 Ай бұрын
Yet, despite the fact that the world is still waiting for the first time marxism/socialism/communism produces anything but death and economic downturn, "highly educated" people keep telling us we need to accept it as the only reasonable way forward. Forward toward what, is never really explained... but there are a lot of historical references available that indicate the "what" is not something people really want to experience.
@yitzharos
@yitzharos Ай бұрын
SerpentZA has great journalism on CCP.
@disabledmechanic5316
@disabledmechanic5316 Ай бұрын
the guy who spouts anti-china propaganda slop? lol
@kwamesmith3214
@kwamesmith3214 Ай бұрын
@@disabledmechanic5316he reminds me of my own joke The People’s Republic is the Republic of the Party and Ocean People😂😂… but that joke is too metawoke/periwoke 😅😅
@aurigalin6327
@aurigalin6327 Ай бұрын
@@disabledmechanic5316 That white south african guy and another american wingman were passbro from the earliest days of china. when they said on youtube that chinese girls are easy to have sex with and they only like white guys. And these two white guys were criticized by almost all Chinese people when they told other passbro how to tell which ones are just graduated high school girls. So they lost their jobs, had no skills, no money, and relied on donations from white Americans who wanted to come on sex trips to China, so they started riding their motorcycles to the most backward villages and filming those villagers attempting to prove that all of China is villages, that all of those cities are CCP false propaganda, and that the Chinese people are living in an extremely repressive society, etc., and used it to retaliate against the Chinese for criticizing them.
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Serpentza is a con . His cfo is arrested
@caseclosed9342
@caseclosed9342 Ай бұрын
“China’s gonna eat out lunch, c’mon man!”
@freesk8
@freesk8 Ай бұрын
Wonderful video! Thank you so much! :)
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Bot 😂😂😂
@freesk8
@freesk8 Ай бұрын
@@zacksmith5644 Not a bot. A man who has run for office 6 times as a way of defending marriage equality.
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
@@freesk8 nope a bot . Prageru said anything and u accepted it without question. Prageru is famous for misinformation and racism . China economy is suffering at 5% growth despite sanctions and trade barriers levied against china Usa economy is robust at 0.9% growth 😂😂😂😂 China 0 wars Usa constant wars . China best nation
@raphaelrae8186
@raphaelrae8186 Ай бұрын
Socialism never fails because it's specially crafted to do all those horrors.
@zacksmith5963
@zacksmith5963 Ай бұрын
Ok prove it . Socialism succeeded so much that usa sanctioned china many times . Hmmm so why is usa in recession while china is rising ?
@demaszstyo9644
@demaszstyo9644 Ай бұрын
It's not a lie. She is a legitimate Chinese from the accent alone 😂
@davidxyj
@davidxyj Ай бұрын
Socialism & Communism are 2 sides of the same coin period!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Both defeated hitler Only natsees hate communists . Which make u ........😂
@horridohobbies
@horridohobbies Ай бұрын
China is *_already_* the world's largest economy by purchasing power parity (PPP). PPP is a better measure of a nation's economic strength.
@bub0niccommie3
@bub0niccommie3 Ай бұрын
incredible how you got every information wrong. where did you get your information from? where did you study? surely you'd know everything you're saying is just flat out false. you're just being dishonest.
@old-gamer-01
@old-gamer-01 Ай бұрын
GOOD CONTENT! KEEP LET PEOPLE KNOW!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
Source ????
@old-gamer-01
@old-gamer-01 Ай бұрын
@@zacksmith5644 DNA!
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
@@old-gamer-01 I asked for source . There is no news outlet or source called DNA on this matter . So try again
@old-gamer-01
@old-gamer-01 Ай бұрын
@@zacksmith5644 good I see you start to do your research lil commy.
@zacksmith5644
@zacksmith5644 Ай бұрын
@@old-gamer-01 I did . I asked u to prove it . If u Cant prove it u lied and got caught
@danjohnson887
@danjohnson887 Ай бұрын
Wibbilty wobbilty Mao mao mao mao mao...
@richa.s9912
@richa.s9912 Ай бұрын
LOL 😂😂 yes sounds like Hawaiian music 🎵🎶
@IsaacParent
@IsaacParent Ай бұрын
"Government as a solution, is always the problem". - Anonymous
Three Chinas | The Economics of China Episode 1
17:56
New Economic Thinking
Рет қаралды 37 М.
КАКУЮ ДВЕРЬ ВЫБРАТЬ? 😂 #Shorts
00:45
НУБАСТЕР
Рет қаралды 3,2 МЛН
The Giant sleep in the town 👹🛏️🏡
00:24
Construction Site
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН
Идеально повторил? Хотите вторую часть?
00:13
⚡️КАН АНДРЕЙ⚡️
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Why didn't Communism Collapse in China as in other countries?
11:06
Knowledgia
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
Why Russia's Biggest Threat is Actually China
36:21
RealLifeLore
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Piers Morgan debates UK leader of Islamic Extremist group Hizb ut-Tahrir
19:38
Sky News Australia
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН
Israel-Hamas War 2023 Summarized | Animated History
18:54
The Armchair Historian
Рет қаралды 550 М.
The Taiwan Trap
14:23
Search Party
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
КАКУЮ ДВЕРЬ ВЫБРАТЬ? 😂 #Shorts
00:45
НУБАСТЕР
Рет қаралды 3,2 МЛН