Choosing A New PLANER / THICKNESSER

Рет қаралды 33,072

Күн бұрын

Which planer / thicknesser? I am upgrading my trusty Elektra Beckum HC260 combination planer / thicknesser (or "jointer / planer" if you're in the USA) and looking at the available options within my budget.
0:00 Why I'm Upgrading
1:36 My Requirements
3:19 Available Options
6:51 Additional Options!
8:09 Conclusion
Links:
How I Sharpen And Set Planer Knives: • How To Sharpen & Set P...
My LumberJack TS1800 Table Saw Review • LUMBERJACK TS1800 TABL...
LumberJack 5% discount code RAGNBONE at checkout www.lumberjacktools.co.uk as an affiliate I may earn from qualifying purchases
HUGE THANKS to Ben ‪@HewAndAwe‬ Paul ‪@BrookesWood‬ John ‪@JohnMcGrathManInShed‬ and Stew ‪@BischBaschBosch‬ for allowing me to use their visuals - taken from the following videos:
Hew & Awe - Helical Head Cutter Problems • You might wanna watch ...
BrookesWood Builds Review of LumberJack PT305
John McGrath's Review of Charnwood W583 • Charnwood 10x8 Review....
Bisch Basch Bosch Review of iTech 260S • ITECH 260S Spiral Plan...
The machines I am considering are:
LumberJack PT305
Charnwood W583
Hammer A2-26
Record Power PT107
Record Power PT107HB
Axminster AW2260S
Charnwood PT10S
iTech 260SS
Record Power PT310
🔴My channel is supported by Milwaukee🔴
Check out their full range here: uk.milwaukeetool.eu/?...
#woodworking #planer #thicknesser
Thanks for watching! Please subscribe, click like if you like, and hit the bell icon for future video notifications
🔨 MY TOOLS 🔨
For links to the tools I use, plus some of my favourite consumables, finishes and more see links below. As an Amazon associate I may earn from qualifying purchases
UK affiliate store: www.amazon.co.uk/shop/ragnbon...
US affiliate store: www.amazon.com/shop/ragnboneb...
🤝 HELP SUPPORT THE CHANNEL 🤝
Support with KZfaq channel membership: / @ragnbonebrown
Support with Patreon: / ragnbonebrown
Support with PayPal paypal.me/ragnbonebrown
Shop With Amazon using my affiliate link: geni.us/iWD3K
💰 SHOP 💰
Etsy: www.etsy.com/uk/shop/KeithBro...
teespring.com/stores/rag-n-bo...
🎧 WORKSHOP BANTER PODCAST 🎧
/ workshopbanter
Also available on Spotify, Apple, Google and most other podcast platforms
🔗 LINKS: 🔗
Website: www.ragnbonebrown.com
Facebook: / ragnbonebrown
Instagram: @ragnbonebrown
Twitter: / ragnbonebrown
Email: ragnbonebrown@gmail.com
Second KZfaq Channel (non woodwork videos): / keefykeef

Пікірлер: 415

@renecruz2842 9 ай бұрын

Saving a few hundred pounds for a lifetime tool doesn't make sense to me. If this is what you really want then get the most with your budget and get the electrical work done. It hurts in the short time but you will love your situation for the long term. Go big!

@chillyspoon 9 ай бұрын

Totally agree, spend the few quid on the electrics and the best machine, and have the tool for life banked!

@pauldevlin84 9 ай бұрын

100%. you definately dont want buyers remorse with a liftime purchase, trust me 😂

@paulrowley71 9 ай бұрын

I was just about to post the same. Defo agree. 👍🏼

@davetay44 9 ай бұрын

This

@pgtips4240 8 ай бұрын

This is the right advice imho.

@johnmyers8895 9 ай бұрын

I think its worth considering a 16amp extension lead combined with a 16amp splitter. Both readily available. I think you are very unlikely to ever use the machines at the same time and therefore unlikely to cause problems with your supply. Its a cheap altrnative that i have used with three machines in my one-man workshop.

@TheErador 9 ай бұрын

That's exactly what I came here to comment. You can always tack the extension tidily to the wall so it can't be under foot too and leave a bit of slack at the splitter (they look like guns lol) end so you can switch one leg over to another tool if needed without hassle, 16A ceeforms can be sticky to pull out and you don't want to yank your cable off the wall at the same time lol my vote on the machine would therefore be the record power 310(?) was it where it was all green except power and price

@edwardmckenna7829 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, upgrade the supply to 16 amp outlet. Be cheeky and ask Artisan Electrics, Cambridge. Let them make a video and do a deal on the installation. 😊

@detroutspinners9933 9 ай бұрын

I dunno, I feel like David Savery is the collab we all need to see

@mattknights274 9 ай бұрын

@@detroutspinners9933 Get Nick Bundy in on it as well , all 3 for one 16a socket 😂

@caveweta 9 ай бұрын

Option 3 all day. Upgrade the electrics, you’ll never regret the extra grunt.

@thepeginator2556 9 ай бұрын

This.

@DeafMaker 9 ай бұрын

You said your looking for a forever planer, so at the price you're paying for the machines you're probably better off getting a 16amp, which will serve you better in the long term. Also an extra 16amp will give you more options in future should you decide to move things around. Maybe add several 16amp sockets around the workshop to give yourself more options for the future.

@lendevonuk5479 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, as this is a once in a lifetime purchase…..’buy nice so you don’t have to buy twice.’ Also, this machine is as pivotal in any workshop as is a rise/fall saw bench! I would go the extra mile and have a 16amp ring main installed (if your supply has the capacity) so that you don’t face power restrictions again!

@mikeg7746 9 ай бұрын

The the greater the number cutting edges, the greater the power required so if you are restricted to a standard socket you are limiting the number of cutting edges.

@revbobuk 9 ай бұрын

Just to note that 16A sockets should not be installed in a ring main, as the plugs are unfused. They should have their own 16A spur straight from the consumer unit, with a type C breaker to cope with the extra start up current.

@yorkshireworkshop3605 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith the dust hood needs to go inside the machine under the cutter block and you raise the table to trap this in place. I have the same machine and have little to no chips when surface planing. Give it a try before you let it go, the hood has a recess with goes around the bar which runs Under the table. Hope that makes sense 👍🏼

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

I wish someone told me this 9 years ago 🤣 thanks

@yorkshireworkshop3605 9 ай бұрын

😂 no worries it makes hell of a difference

@woodworkingandepoxy643 9 ай бұрын

Man you're killing it lately. A new baby and you can afford to upgrade some expensive tools. You're a motivation seeing where you started on KZfaq and where you are now. It's mine blowing how rewarding this can be..I hope nothing but continued growth for you and the Mrs and the baby.

@tomcordey5692 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I was in a similar position at the start of the year, took me months of going back and forth in my mind. I settled for the Charnwood spiral. The 16a topic isn’t one to worry about, it’s simple enough with a decent breaker. The machine is stunning to use and never stops amazing me at the quality and accuracy.

@casteliero 9 ай бұрын

I got myself PT107 just last week. Been using it a bit now and have been satisfied so far. And that double lifting bed hasn’t really been painful to use. It’s quite fast. Just couple levers and that’s it. Time wise you don’t lose anything.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you that's useful 👌

@Foxx6699 9 ай бұрын

I had the 230v PT310 with spiral cutter before I upgraded to a AD941. Great semi-profesional planer/jointer. Highly recommend for higher-end garage/shed and semi-professional setups.

@KGDIY 9 ай бұрын

Get a sparky in for half a day to put you another 16A socket in and this opens up your options! I’m my opinion, the itech and Felder are the more industrial machines and will be the better quality. The Axminster “workshop” series should be called the “shed” series as their aimed at hobbyists. Looking forward to seeing what you decide on as I will be upgrading soon too!

@Kosteriffic 9 ай бұрын

Keith, I’ve been there. In the end I went with the Hammer A3-26 silent power. It’s a stretch in your budget but worth it. The switch from regular knives to carbide inserts is a big relief! Good luck 👍

@divest6527 8 ай бұрын

I just bought my first house with half a garage, and I want to use salvaged wood to build my own furniture. This video has been very helpful for me to understand what to look for when buying a planer/thicknesser. Look forward to seeing more!

@davidcolin6519 4 ай бұрын

I think that the advantages of a spiral cutter have been very undersold in this video. Not only do they produce better results (as stated in the video), but the noise levels in operation a far, far lower.

@philstevens9914 9 ай бұрын

I have the Felder 16" and love it. Based on this I would have to say the Hammer would be the one in this list (as it is a Felder product) I'd really look at.

@Labrador-Woodworking 9 ай бұрын

I have the axminster planer and found it to be a fanstastic machine so far i have planed full width oak and ash on it both curly and straight grain and the finish has been fantastic, on curly grain the finish vs straight knives is night and day. For me the less cutters is a bonus as they are fairly pricey to replace. However you can get 4 rotatations and then sharpen them once for another 4. I havent really encountered any cons yet as its a far superior machine to my previous 😊

@tbwoodwork5529 9 ай бұрын

Hey Keith, I just upgraded from the metabo version of your old machine to the Axminster ap260spt and I can only say it’s been worth every penny. I’m not saying splash out on that machine but that personally I’m so glad I didn’t compromise and end up spending time and stress dealing with a cheaper model. Maybe even hold off a few months and keep putting some penny’s aside. Good luck mate 👍👍

@scottskelton1991 9 ай бұрын

I run a charnwood W590 and upgraded it to a 72 cutter helical head, more than happy with how it performs. I got it when it was much lower priced at around £1400 though. It's still available at around £1900-2100, as is the new variant with the spiral head by default (PT12s) the 12" well worth it and the table lift / switch over is a breeze. Quiet too with good extraction

@df9177 9 ай бұрын

I'd go with the Record Power 310. Have had one for about 2 yrs and is a great machine, easy to use and transfer between both options is simple and quick and have never had any issues with snipe. The extra width and length of the table makes a big difference compared to the 107, you'll be glad if you decide to go for the bigger version. Have never had a problem with the 310, it's a solid bit of kit with an easily adjusted accurate fence and it's also easy to clean too. Probably the best machine in my workshop as never have to adjust it and is always accurate. They did make a 230v version couple years ago, not sure if the still do but I know that they have just brought out the 310 with the spiral head option.

@ianfinch1522 9 ай бұрын

I would definitely upgrade the planer to the 16amp range as it’s a long term investment. I’ve had a hammer planer and spindle moulder and they were very well made coming from felder.

@Parafinn1970 9 ай бұрын

Without hesitation - get the sparky in and install a 16a socket - it didn't cost me much when I did it and I've never looked back, and I run 2 X 16amp machines (P/T & Table saw) from the 1 socket with a cable splitter. Getting this opens up your options and I believe will serve you better for longer - remember: Buy Once/Cry Once ;)

@Toograced 9 ай бұрын

Keith, as I have heard you mention many times, Buy once, Cry once. If this is going to be a forever tool, don't skimp out now. You seem to be growing tremendously in your skills and abilities. Definitely invest in yourself and your business and get the best machine regardless of power options. I happen to know the Hammer is about the best you can get for a small workshop. I myself would love one and probably will got one someday, but my business doesn't make excuse for it, it would just be a passion purchase. Hope that was helpful. Keep doing your thing. Absolutely love it.

@hb4519 9 ай бұрын

I have the itech. I use a 16a caravan type lead to attach it to a 13a socket. It hasn't tripped or blown a fuse in the 3 years I've owned it.

@Mrlaughy99 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I was in the same boat last year I had narrowed it down to Holzprofi and Hammer. I have now fully decided on Hammer I haven't purchased it yet but their autumn sale event has really tempted me at €2390 for the A3-31 P/T it's the lowest price in a long time. Don't buy something you'll regret if there is a negative such as removing the fence or low power you'll be annoyed at yourself self in the future for not going for the better option

@davidcalder8912 9 ай бұрын

I've got the Axminster one, and it's great. Even got a discount to £1399. Accurate, simple to use, and a great finish. It is bloody heavy though! Took 4 of us to move it into the shed!!

@Kosh42EFG 9 ай бұрын

I bought ex-display and had to get in in my car. On its side. Four of us to get it in, only me and the neighbour at home to get it out. Damn near had to strip everything off it bar the motor. Still almost killed myself despite heavy usage of levers and ramps to slide it on. But for £1,100 I was not leaving it...

@Brough_builds 9 ай бұрын

I've got this and it's fantastic in my opinion and even with the fewer cutters it leaves a lovely finish

@wonkycutsworkshop 9 ай бұрын

I was a bit concerned about the lack of knives on the axminster but I read a few customer feedbacks and all seem to be positive. It's still the one I'm saving up for... 😊

@michaelbausachverstandiger5172 Ай бұрын

i got the pt107 with a 4 helix and its absolutely WONDERFUL! The optional wheels do the job very well!

@rossquiney8887 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith. Based on the wattages that you have shown all of them would run on a 13A plug with ease.13A plugs are designed to run at 3000watts Tripping issues would not specifically be from the planner but maybe the circuit being overloaded. If your sockets are wired from a 32A ring main then you’re be fine. I would invest in the planner that you want based on the tool only and not the electrical issue that isn’t really there. Love the channel. Keep up the great work. 🎉🎉

@alieverett5895 9 ай бұрын

I’ve got the axminster spiral job-get a 16 amp supply it’s got to be worth it ! Best tool I’ve brought -I had the elektra for 15 years before

@c.a.g.1977 9 ай бұрын

Love these videos and your approach on chosing the right option for you! Have you considered buying two separate dedicated machines, instead of a combination?

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thanks! I don't really want two machines taking up space 👍

@andycutlergfd1 8 ай бұрын

Hi Keith - I have the Axminster - best machine I have bought - love it - 24 cutters are absolutely fine

@richarddalton7085 9 ай бұрын

Option 3 for me Keith. You said yourself you want to make a forever tool purchase. I think the 16amp options are the best.

@mark_loveless 9 ай бұрын

The Record Power PT 107HB with the quantity 44 seems like it checks enough boxes to be worth the budget. Personally I cannot say enough good things about helical head cutters in general - I've never had a problem with them and my experience has been extremely low maintenance, much lower than knives.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you Mark that's really helpful. Yeah I have been leaning towards the Record Power options for sure, even though the HB option with 44 is quite expensive.

@johnwaddell4479 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I went through a similar process a couple of years back and ended up going for the Hammer A3-41 3ph spiral cutter (originally single phase A3-31 but got some covid grant money so upgraded). Yes, it was way more than I wanted to spend but it’s my favourite machine. I would get 16A version with spiral, much quieter, easier blade setup, and smoother finish. Plus, the cutter blades last forever and take seconds to rotate/replace. Option, speak to Felder Sales Rep, not HQ, and see if there are any used machines. Heard sometimes very good deals.

@MA.Joinery 9 ай бұрын

Been debating the record power one myself and since finding out about the helical head coming out seems like that’s the one even with having to lift both beds.

@ScouseAndy71 9 ай бұрын

I still like these style equipment videos even though I'm not in the market for such. 👍 To your logic behind trying to narrow down the obe you want! 😀👍

@davelowe1977 9 ай бұрын

I bet the 16a machines will be fine with a soft start device on 13a. None of them have too high a power rating.

@warrenusher3175 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, Have you looked at any of the Jet planer thicknesses? Would be interested in your opinion on this brand.

@maililistaalterego 9 ай бұрын

I just got a thickness planer with a "helical" head and carbide cutters. I'm not regretting going with that at all, the cut quality is awesome. I've only used big industrial machines with knives before. I did consider buying a floor standing jointer/planer instead of a "lunchbox" thicknesser, still not sure I made the right call. From the choices you listed, I'd pick one of the big machines with a helical head and get the electrical outlet installed.

@Cameron2874 9 ай бұрын

Definitely get electrical work done as gives you more options not only for this but future work. Spend a little extra now to make life easier in the future. Having had budget planners in the past and straight knives I would highly recommend spiral cutter heads for the less tear out, smooth cut but mostly the lack of noise. My extractor is noisier than my thickness planner. The single bed lift is something that once you use it would never go back as makes using the machine a joy instead of a pain. I got the hammer A3 410 spiral cutter and like it for the extra width. Regardless of the size I looked endlessly like yourself and the hammer was great value for what you get and solid. Hope this bit of input helps in your decision

@tpaulfelder1 9 ай бұрын

I have a Felder combination machine which has the easy change planer head.Its a doddle to use. Two different spec blades are available and both are double edged . The chip collection is excellent.Height adjustment for the thicknesser in manual is very slow to use but I jury rigged a method of of adjustment by a power drill

@tom314 9 ай бұрын

I've got the axminster AP260SPT ~3.5 years ago, back when it was a 2 bed machine and much much cheaper. Spiral blades are wonderful, they're seemingly (nearly) indestructible still working well even after sectioning a screw. I've rotated the tips once so far, I too was worried about it but the night before I soaked them in penetrating oil, used my impact driver and they all came out without the slightest issue. The PT is accurate, reasonably quiet and I'm very happy with it. In usage the 2 beds is annoying but the worst bit is the fact you have to wind down the thicknesser table to the bottom to allow access for the dust hood, if any of them have got over that go for that one. The removal of the fence is also annoying, it's quick but as always you have to reset it to square. So if it were me, I'd go for one where you don't have to move the thicknesser bed during swap over, then a spiral block and finally one where you can leave the fence attached. One side note, a lot state they need a 16A socket but don't actually, I think it's that their big brother versions do need 16A and they've just fitted the baby one in the series with 16A . A 2kW motor should be fine on 13A. You can easily buy the adapters, the worst that happens is it blows the fuse in the 13A plug, I have them on my planer thicknesser and my bandsaw and never had a problem. I have also used the adapters in a commercial laboratory setting and everyone (H&S etc etc.) were fine with them.

@RobHimself86 9 ай бұрын

I have exactly the same model. In planer mode, you have to wind the thicknesser bed down, and the extractor hood sits right inside, right underneath the cutter head. You will see how the U-shaped notch in the hood fits. Wind the thicknesser bed up a few mill to secure it.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

I wish someone told me this 9 years ago 🤣 thanks

@muggerjm 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, will you be using the table saw and PT at the same time? If not run a 16A extension cable from the saw socket to the PT.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

it's very unlikely I would run them at the same time. It's a good idea, but I don't really want the hassle of trailing cables, and I know it sounds really lazy but I don't want to be plugging and unplugging things either! Cheers

@someamir2287 9 ай бұрын

I would probably go for one of the newer record power options. first of all, I have a couple of their tools and they work great + the service they give is incredible. my bandsaw is second hand and they were happy to help me re-wire it when I found the previous owner messed up the wiring somehow. Many people are advising to opt for the 16amp options which isn't a bad idea but will be limiting if/when you have to rearrange your shop.

@andrewmazurkiewicz105 9 ай бұрын

Go for anything with a spiral shear cutter. I put a shellix cutter in my ancient.emco b50 10''' planer and the difference was night and day. I use a lot of flamed/birdseye hard maple and the carbide cutters eat through it,and it's quieter and uses less power. You don't need a zillion cutters for it to work. The sanding saved because of the fine finish is more than worth the price, just make sure it's a proper shear cut! Cheers. Andrew

@williammoore4101 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith. I don't have a recommendation on any of those planer/thicknessers, but it might be worth a shot to see if there are any woodworkers in your vicinity with one of those machines to see about trying one out. I definitely feel better about a purchase if I can get my hands on one prior to purchase. As always, great content! I hope your dream machine comes true!

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you! That's a great idea

@Kosh42EFG 9 ай бұрын

I have the Axminster. Got it ex-display in the Basingstoke closing sale with closing discount on top of it. Works a treat for me, but setting the tables is a right pain in the butt. But hopefully a one and done job.

@keggyification 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, The Axminster machine is a great unit and I was lucky enough to have a 1 on 1 demo a couple of weeks ago when I visited the Axminster branch new show room. The 24 blade helical head produces a beautiful finish on both soft and Hard wood. I was shown the device cutting a mixture of woods including Walnut, Elm, Poplar, Oak, Pine, Douglas fir and Red Cedar. I would be surprised if the 48 cutter heads would show any better finish if I'm honest. It was also surprisingly quiet whilst operating compared to my old DeWalt DW733. The product advisor Stuart also mentioned a possible soon to be announced, new addition to the range that would fill the gap between DIY and Pro users and whilst this wouldn't match what your looking for it confirms that the development team at Axminister are always looking to advance and improve the current products and are looking for the next best thing for all levels of users. I'd give them another call and ask for a review machine again and I don't think you'll be disappointed if you can get your hands on one.

@JohnMadeit 9 ай бұрын

I wouldn't let the electric supply be an issue as you already have a 16amp supply in the workshop. Can you run a 16amp extension cable to the planer from your table saw socket?

@Martin-hy5ye 9 ай бұрын

I've got an older Axminster craft machine which is very similar to the Charnwood and Record machine. It has 3 knives and has performed great for several years. The big downside to having the 2 tables to open is the space they take up when in thicknessing mode as they open at an angle and the cutter guard further adds to chaos. The single lift design that Axminster and others have since introduced looks much improved as it hinges straight back and appears that you can leave the fence fitted as well. Good luck with the decision!

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you, great feedback

@mattknights274 9 ай бұрын

I recently bought a charnwood PT12S, spiral head, with the single lift table, it was expensive but like you I'm not changing it for a long time. It was a toss up between the record pt310 and the charnwood. I went with the charnwood for 2 reasons, 1 the noise levels on a spiral cutter block is significantly less than straight knives and 2 with a spiral block there is no messing about when changing cutters. The 16a power supply for me was not an issue as I'd need to upgrade either way. 100% go with a 16a machine. Buy once, cry once. 👍

@joeleonetti8976 9 ай бұрын

For many years, I held off on upgrading electrical. Finally, I was "forced" to do it. What a relief. Was expensive but I have moving forward much more flexibility. I'd suggest you "bit the bullet" and upgrade your electrical. I'd be inclined to save a bit more and go towards the higher price point. It's what I did for my forever bandsaw and dust collection system. A different thought, have you considered getting separate planer and jointers? The Dewalt 735 table top planer or newer Oliver appear to be solid choices for thicknessers. Not sure if this opens up options on the jointer. Good luck.

@mwjoinery 9 ай бұрын

Has anyone had any experience with an axminster professional AP260SPT planer thicknesser? Thinking of getting one ordered

@Psychlist1972 9 ай бұрын

That Axminster helical cutter block is very similar to the ones Felder/Hammer uses when you get the Silent Power helical head option, even on their most expensive machines, although the Felder/Hammer cutters are closer together to the point of touching side to side. But if they perform similarly, then they are quite good. If you're not used to a helical cutterhead, vs just a carbide insert head, then they can look a bit sparse.

@cuebj 9 ай бұрын

The clue was at the start... 'forever planer'. Go 16A and best quality-capacity balance without delux options like helical heads. Then upgrade to very good helical heads if the extra use warrants it when you can afford. You may find the greater quality of cut from such a machine means you never need helical. 16A will mean it's nor straining so likely to last. As a recycled timber specialist, planer-thicknesser is a key part of your workflow. You need rapid set up. Similar with bicycles and many other heavy use machinery

@buddythompson5284 9 ай бұрын

It's a forever tool, so don't cheap out. Upgrade the electrics and stick with the "bigger is better" concept (which includes more power!). Go with the highest capacity Record Power PT310. It offers everything you want at a price point that should allow for the electric work and still be at your upper budget limit. It's only downside is the knives vs. spiral cutter head, which you said wasn't a big consideration and you'll always have the option to upgrade to a spiral head in the future. Believe me, after a few months you won't miss the extra expense and you'll forever be glad that you got the extra capacity, higher power, and easy to convert choice.

@PeterOConnl 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, the dust extraction when in planet mode was wrong. The dust hood goes under the top table and rests on the thicknesser table. Youd then wind it up and secure the dust hood in place.

@neilarmour4497 9 ай бұрын

I have the Metabo machine and I agree with all your complaints. The dust extractr shroud is secured to the machine using a screw in holder through both

@frederickwood9116 9 ай бұрын

Get the 16 amp upgrade and broaden your options in many ways. If price is more of an issue then it’s likely the one of the record options with the helical cutter coming soon. My choice ( not knowing more than your video in data) is the pt107

@bigpete4227 9 ай бұрын

Just got the itech saw and I’m very pleased with it. Would be interested to see the itech planer.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Bisch Basch Bosch has a great review of it on his channel

@bigpete4227 9 ай бұрын

@@RagnBoneBrown I’m on it.

@MCsCreations 9 ай бұрын

That's a tough call, Keith... But I would save a bit more money and go for the better one, I guess. Either way, looking forward to see what you decide! 😊 Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊

@jmakes3745 9 ай бұрын

As others have said I think a planer/ thicknesser is a tool it’s defiantly worth spending more on. I’d recommend getting one with a helical head - they do take longer to change but in my experience they also last longer and not getting tear out on difficult bits of grain is a huge huge plus

@thistleman5 9 ай бұрын

Spiral head every time. I am fortunate to have a Felder machine with their silent power head. The cutters last for ages and are very simple to rotate as long as you do your regular maintenance of removing resin build up and ensuring the retaining screws are correctly torqued whenever you tighten them. I appreciate that budget has to be a limiting factor but within reason I would look at the cost of ownership over the anticipated life of the machine rather than just the upfront purchase price. Final point - getting the right machine first time will cost a lot less in the long run than an further upgrade in a few years time and remember a decent machine will pay for itself in the quality, speed and safety of its output

@haydenharris5506 9 ай бұрын

Go 16amp with a single lift bed. I went with a Jet JPT-260 a few years ago, and never had a single regret because it is perfect for my workshop and work volume (which is very similar to yours). Hope this helps. Hayden

@grahamalexander7230 9 ай бұрын

I have a really old Metabo 310mm planer thicknesser which I changed the cutter block to helical cutter (at an outrageous cost) but the improvement in abilities was well worth it. I would not go with any motor less than 2000watts if you want to plane full width hardwoods esp recycled timbers which are inherently harder. So my money would be the hammer and get the electrics fixed to 16amp, at some point in the future have a play with a helical cutter but no less than 40 heads.....

@federicom2801 9 ай бұрын

Regarding the minimalistic spiral block. I own a Bernardo AD260S with the same block as the Aminster. It works absolutely fine, the finish is good and a big plus is that the cutters are encased in the block instead of been lifted. This makes it impossible to mess with cutters installation, with the lifted cutters spirals you risk to misalign it while changing/rotating it. Look at SCM or Felder spiral blocks, they have the same encased cutters as the Axminster

@samrix5793 9 ай бұрын

Go for the itech, I've got the axminster ap310spt and run this on a 16a to 3 pin adapter and runs fine. Either way, the spiral block is quieter, makes smaller shavings so easier on dust collection and gives less snipe

@paulmorton5542 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I am in the states and my situation is a little different, I have a Grizzly 15" planer and an 8" Jointer - not a combo. The jointer has a spiral head and the quality of cut is far superior to the straight blades on the planer. I recently planed some hickory and just about destroyed the straight blades. The jointer head has been going for 13 years and I have only had to rotate the carbides once in that time. It handled the hickory without any issues.

@JohnMellor-nd8bs 9 ай бұрын

From years of having, my dad who was an engineer always said to buy the best you can afford look at what the 16A supply would cost and factor in the cost to keep to your 2K budget or bite the bullet and go over if you intend to keep it long term

@southgsx 3 ай бұрын

I'm looking to upgrade my planer thicknesser. Can I ask Why did you go for the itech over the charmwood? Aren't they the same just rebadged?

@RagnBoneBrown 3 ай бұрын

Explained here... kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ot2jmpNy2NCYdmQ.html

@grahamsmith874 9 ай бұрын

I would put it on hold and save up more money to get the one you really want, rather than settling for something you may regret

@slow96ss 9 ай бұрын

Totally go with the upgraded electric, you won't regret it! You did say this was a forever machine, get the one you want to use the most with the biggest muscles.

@thetalkingdonkey07 9 ай бұрын

I bought the Axminster 2260s last winter to replace an old Record Power. The Axy is superior in every way, reasonable chip collection, MUCH quieter and superb cut quality. Customers service from Axminster has also been faultless. I'm in Fakenham, you'd be very welcome to try it...

@crashkg 9 ай бұрын

You'll never regret upgrading the electric no matter what tool you use. When I upgraded my electric I added one extra 220V outlet 40AMP that I had no immediate use for. I debated spending the extra money. Now, of course, I use it every day and I would have had to add it later at a much greater expense.

@chris_hertford 9 ай бұрын

How close is your fuse box to the tool location? A short run should be that expensive to have installed? A new 16a supply opens many options and will be there for any future tools.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

But it also restricts the layout of the workshop.... 👍

@andyc972 9 ай бұрын

An interesting dilemma Keith, I don't envy you having to make a decision on something you're hoping to use regularly and hopefully for ever that inevitably costs a great deal ! That being said, my gut reaction would be to go with the single bed lift options as for the difference between £1700 to £2000 you'll kick yourself later if you don't invest now ! I'm shocked by how much machine tools seem to have gone up in recent years, I haven't looked at buying a planer for some time but it's changed significantly. Had you considered separate machines for the two functions, or is this an absolute no go regarding space and or budget, this would be my preferred option !

@m0aze611 9 ай бұрын

I think the general census is to upgrade your electrics. This gives you more options. I’ve spent too much money on compromises in the past which has ended up costing me more in the long run. I should have bought a Festool Domino years ago but didn’t. Now at my age it’s a little too late. Good luck with your purchase. Mike

@awantamta 9 ай бұрын

Happy shopping

@allthegear-noidea1264 9 ай бұрын

I took a good 15-18 months deciding this. It was around the time that Covid hit as well and in the end the prices went up and my dilly dallying around cost me about £800. I’m a woodworker above all else (although still have a huge amount to learn) and not great on the whole maintenance replacing parts thing. So partly because of this I wanted as low maintenance a machine as possible. I also decided I would be better buying something that could last for life. I went for the JET in the end with the helical head. I know it’s above your ceiling price wise but there are features I have found to be invaluable. First, it has a “single” bed rather than the butterfly style. I read a huge amount of reviews and a common complaint about the butterfly tables was maintaining co planar between in feed and out feed sides. I really wanted to avoid all that faff. Secondly the helical head, I chose it as I had a separate thicknesser that I’d previously converted from flat blades to helical and the difference in cut quality was distinct. The biggest differences though were (a) the noise levels - noticeably less, and (b) the helical creates smaller chips compared to the “stringy” chips created from blades and this really helped dust extraction. So these things convinced me to dig deeper for something I was going to be more satisfied with. In your place, I think I’d still prioritise these things over the power supply which would take me to the Charnwood PT10S (that Axminster cutting looks a bit ‘cheap’ to me). Anyway sorry for the essay and hope some part of it was helpful - Billy. PS the Jet is an amazing machine if you’d be prepared to stretch for it and runs on a normal power supply 😬

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you! I agree the charnwood looks a good option for me. Is there anything that the Jet does that the others on my list do not?

@allthegear-noidea1264 9 ай бұрын

@@RagnBoneBrown so I bought the jpt 310 hh in the end, the hh being helical head. It’s monophase so running on a normal 230V plug (I’m in France and I didn’t need any modifications to my shop for it…there is also a 400V triphasic version. Anyway it was about €3.5k but the jpt 260 is the slightly smaller one and it’s much cheaper (at least in France). When I check now it’s about €2400 or about £2100. I assumed there was an hh version of this but I can’t find one. So essentially for you, you’d be paying more but for flat knives, although on a normal power supply. You can add a digital height meter for the thicknesser part but it’s an extra. The build quality of the one I have is top quality and I’m over the moon with it. The 310mm cutter head has 56 cutters and it cuts so so cleanly. I’m sure the Charnwood is quality also for the money you’re paying (I think 44 cutters for a 260mm head would be plenty) so it’s probably not worth it for the Jet, if I’m being honest. I really struggle to get access to the UK brands in France so my options are usually limited. I waffled on a bit there again but the short answer to your question is probably “no, it doesn’t really do anything differently”. Also, Peter Parfit from New Brit Workshop has a couple of reviews for the Jet machines on his channel (260 and 310hh) if you’re interested and not seen them.

@TheNaturalWorkshop 9 ай бұрын

Just my 2C, I love the LJPT305 and have run 100s if not 1000s of meters of material through it but I fully understand the concerns with the motor issue. It's worth remembering that although the hood change isn't as smooth as the bed lift, it takes all of around 20 seconds to do and is simple enough. The other thing is that you don't need extraction hooked up to the LJ due to the internal fan and extraction set-up. As for the others, I've pretty much given up on Record and Charnwood due to the appalling after-sales and lack of spares. Same thing for the Itech, I was about to buy a sanding machine from them and they didn't keep spares in stock, told me it would be 6 weeks to get spares shipped from Canada, they may have sorted that but that's worth bearing in mind. Same thing with the CNCs, their sales team talked nonsense and had no idea what they were selling. Thinking about the Axminster, its sold with the helical cutter head so maybe the lower power motor works fine because of the lower amount of wattage needed with the smaller cutters? Axminster tools are always a great option, we have a bunch of them. If you're looking at upgrading to a 16A supply, I would go all in and get the Felder. They are by far the nicest, smoothest and most well-made bits of kit I have ever used and wouldn't think twice about dropping that money on any of their bits of kit. Have fun buying, good luck!

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you mate

@catchepicair 9 ай бұрын

I'm with John's comment below, the PT310 seems to offer you to most versatility. If you cite the faff of transition from planer to thicknesser and setting up dust extraction on some machines then you have to factor in the faff of manipulating stock to get a desired width to avoid glue ups due to width/height restrictions. If its a forever machine then that for me the PT310 is the winner with a 16A extension/splitter. You've got the means and knowhow to sharpen blades. Helix cutters come into their own for noise reduction and if you plan on putting a lot of reclaimed stuff with lots of potential for imbedded metal.

@CaptainofmyShed 5 ай бұрын

Hi Keith. I’m just starting the Axminster Planer review video and I wonder if you would mind me putting a link to this video as a source of info for people looking for other options to compare the Axminster to? I’d like to mention it in the video and point people to a link in the description.

@RagnBoneBrown 5 ай бұрын

Hi, yes that's fine. Look forward to seeing your video

@audiorackcompany4468 9 ай бұрын

You could y split the 16a feed after the outlet to give you a 16a tail to each machine. You can get solid plastic or wired y splits - they are very common in the events industry. It would work out much cheaper than an extra breaker as you could just order what you need online.

@stuartwilliams5385 9 ай бұрын

I have the PT305. Switching from p to t is no big deal. A slow-blow fuse has addressed the fuse-blowing issues.

@BischBaschBosch 9 ай бұрын

Can't believe you did us like that Keith!! 😂 On tenterhooks over here! Worth taking your time over though buddy.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Haha! Cheers Stew and thanks again for letting me use your footage

@pbarnfield 9 ай бұрын

16A Option 3 I'd say, and probably go with the Hammer unit as it sounds decent.

@BradshawJoinery 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith. My input would be very strongly.... Get a carbide insert cutter block As much power as you can even if needs 16a supply

@philvarois 9 ай бұрын

I had the same issues choosing a new machine and i choose the jet JPT310 which i must say is Great. using it for almost a year and a half, i enjoy it. when you find the rignt settings it's performing and you only have to sharpen the knives.......infortunately i'm in france and don't know if you can fint a us model of this. i had to wait also to have the money.

@rkerr4059 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I went through the same process earlier in the year! If operating noise levels are a concern go for a helical/spiral cutter head. Like everyone else I'd have to agree on upping to 16AMP now and eliminate power as a limiting factor in your decision making process. Bigger motor better for this type of machine, especially when the one motor powers both the cutter head and feed rollers. I bought the Charnwood PTS10 earlier in the year as noise was my biggest concern and can highly recommend it as its so quiet in operation and easy to use. Really easy to flip between modes and crucially the fence flips with the tables which makes changing modes less of a chore. I have a 1HP extractor and it copes easily (with a huge chip separator metal drum). BTW, I went from a Triton lunchbox thicknesser which was an absolute screamer but it had a 317m cutter block so I was concerned about losing some capacity on the width of cut but in reality that's not be a problem for me, but I'm glad I didn't scrimp on the capacity and went with the 10" machine rather than the 8" I was thinking of to save some money. Finally, don't overlook the digital counter for the bed height; I didn't realise I needed it until I had it!

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you!

@rkerr4059 9 ай бұрын

@@RagnBoneBrown you're welcome. Looking forward to seeing what you go for! Also meant to say that when I was doing my research I was advised to go with cast iron tables over cast aluminium. I know at least the LJ has cast ally tables as it was on my list as well.

@jamesbrockington2220 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith. I have a PT (Holzprofi DR310 - available in France, not the UK) which comes fitted with a spiral cutter block but only has 30 carbide cutters. I live in the tropics and work with dense tropical hardwoods all the time. I’ve never had a problem with the quality of finish. I wouldn’t worry about it. My machine has a 3kW motor though; 1.5kW seems maybe a little underpowered. Good luck with the choice. BTW, no love for the Minimax FS30 Genius? Looks like a solid little machine to me. Worth checking out.

@derekrobertson1548 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, I had the lumberjack planer thicknesser and had so many issues with it. Spoke to lumberjack a few times and they could not resolve the issues and gave a full refund. Customer service from them was amazing but the thicknesser planer was a nightmare not sure if I was just unlucky. I ended up going for the Hammer A3 31 from felder (helical head) and I love it but it does require a type c 16 amp breaker to be installed. Hope this is of some help.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thanks. What issues did you have with the LJ?

@derekrobertson1548 9 ай бұрын

@@RagnBoneBrown the feed rollers for the thicknesser only worked intermittently, the cast iron bed for the planer was not flat and if the machine was not hooked up to a dust extractor the dust port would jam up with chips even although the bag was empty and I was only taking shallow passes each time. The last issue was not a big deal as was only going to use the bag for a couple of days until the ducting was sorted to accommodate the machine. But when the wood got jammed in the thicknesser it made a mess of the piece I was working on. The lumberjack is extremely noisy compared to the Hammer not sure if this would be an issue for yourself. I don't know if the issues were a one off and if not they may have been rectified by now as lumberjack wanted the machine back to figure out what was going on and offered a full refund or replacement, as I said there customer service was top notch and could not have been more helpful. Good luck in your decision. Looking forward to seeing what you go for. Having used both straight knifes and spiral head the upgrade is definitely worth it, even if you have to hold off for a bit to increase your budget.

@chrisl187 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, i have the record power pt260 which looks similar. You probably won’t care now, but I think you’ve been using the dust extraction wrong in planer mode. The duct sits on the thicknessing bed on mine, you lower it, put in the duct and then raise the bed to clamp it in place. It goes in from the opposite side you have it at the moment

@ton2528 9 ай бұрын

Yes, Keith is using it in the wrong way. I have the pt260 and the extraction of the chips is fine.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

I wish someone told me this 9 years ago 🤣 thanks

@paulbanks8583 9 ай бұрын

I'd say upgrade your electric outlet so you have another 16amp outlet. And go for the one that ticks all your boxes. I have a Former RD30 and was also sold under the record power brand, which I've had for nearly 30 years now is strong but when it does give up ill be replacing it with a helical head type and with lift up beds as finding a home for the table when you convert it is always a problem.

9 ай бұрын

Another vote for uograding the electrics, and then see what machine comes up on top. Personally I would go for record power because I like the brand very much. Good luck with your choice!

@norakasa 9 ай бұрын

Absolutely would do the extra electrical work! You'll love yoursrlf in the future for it!

@seantellnotail 9 ай бұрын

Hi Keith, speaking as an American, i may just be unfamiliar with whats available in the UK, but could you purchase a 13in lunchbox thicknesser and a separate planer (jointer)? Again not sure whats available but i think you could get the 13in thicknesser and atleast an 8 inch planer for under your budget.

@RagnBoneBrown 9 ай бұрын

Thank you! I think a combination machine would be best for my needs, but I will have a look at the options for separate machines. Cheers!

@howlinmad4208 9 ай бұрын

I have the Itech, it is great. My only regret is not buying the 300 mm one, next time😊

@alindorindicu3732 9 ай бұрын

I've bought the DR310 from Holzprofi, with hellical cutters shaft, for 2700€, in March 2022. It's probably not selling in the UK. I don't see one alike in your list. It has the same plane opening tables. It's very practical. I've waited 5 months for delivery from China. It probably runs on 16A. I live in a new house with standard electricity. All the house is probably wired on 16A. It doesn't make sense to use electrical installations from anoter age, when it can upgraded without much work, like in a shop. I mainly work oak for my own furniture. It's a good tool for an amateur. You should buy the best one you can now that you need one!