yeah they shouldnt have cut starboy being a humanoid romantic interest damn

Magnifico❌ Starboy✅

​@@HyouVizer Sorry to disappoint you, but Starboy was his Saba Sabino, not his love interest.

THATS WHAT IM SAYING 😭

​@@victormeneses7934That was only one interpretation. The initial plan was that they were a couple.

*cough* frozen love is an open door *cough*

​@@SleepyWhistles beat me to it 😅

Not much but sometimes!

Yeaaaah, until you get to know that this song was supposed to be for Asha and the Starboy

@@SleepyWhistles it was a hidden villain, not revealed until the climax

I’ve been a fan of Chris Pine since Star Trek

Beautiful voice 🌉

I just imagine Jack Frost is the one singing together whom ever I wanna ship him with 🥰😍

I've been a fan of Chris Pine since Into The Woods and then another movie he starred in with Lindsay Lohan " Just My Luck "( I Think That Was The Name of It) 🤔

I was just thinking that!!! Why did they have to make the voice of Jack a VILLAIN in this movie?!?

Desculpa mas você sabe que uma canção de amor mesmo povo trocando algumas letras da pra te sentir

Yh

if only they have had a father-and-daughter relationship, this would've fit great

@@Dragonstorm2000it would’ve been cool if he turned out to be her real father because that way Asha would be a literal Disney princess.

Oh, I like the first one better

As long as you don't have anxiety and self-doubt like I do, you can.

Right? There's something so calming about this song. A perfect lullaby for children!

OMG I'm so glad so many ppl thought the same thing I did abt this song

A lot of people have said that this is supposed to be a romantic love song, because that is what most Disney movies have, but I didn't get that vibe here. I agree that if I were to sing this song it would be to my children, it does have a very sweet and soothing rhythm to it.

This song has become the lullaby my husband and I sing every night to our little one ♥ It is special to us because somehow the scene reminds us also (with all the blue bubbles) the two ones we had lost before birth and that remains in our hearts.

Because they're not singing about each other they're singing about their hearts deepest wish

It’s because it was originally a duet between Asha and star’s old version of a mute star boy (who would’ve probably been singing in the head) who was Asha’s love interest. So it was originally a love song

100th liker

Also the fact that almost as soon as I assume they say that lyric, ASHA leaves the kings side to chase her grandfather's wish

@@progamer69243hi my name lsabella 🤗💕 i wish Hannah Montana

@@lewismoreton4856 Also, the king was also distracted by the wish and did not realize the fact that he was singing while leaving Asha's feelings behind. It's sad, but I like this kind of relationship😭

yeah one is selfish, the other (king) loves everyone

Indeed :-)

Word 👌🏻

Agreed. ❤

💀

I love it so much, added it to my wedding playlist right away. I expected the rest of the movie to be just as amazing but it was all downhill after this song

Yes!!! There are so many nods to Disney movies throughout. It’s like a modern day Disney “when you wish upon a star” origin story ❤

@@silviadiaz1248I don’t understand why people thought it was bad. The wishing star has been in serval movies but it never had a movie of its own. And making a movie of the heart of Disney is not easy.

​@@alexisclinton717 well the concept for this film is arguably better, this song used to be a love song between the Starboy and Asha. The song sounds like a love song, it doesn't fit as well as the original concept

YES EXACTLY ❤

100’years of pedos too

THISSSS

It's not her father's (I think it's a grandfather), her father died when she was a kid. But yeah.

Asha is the villain in this story.

Exactly! She literally pushes past all the wishes and makes a mess just to admire her grandfathers wish. She's incredibly selfish.

You can see it when Asha runs to hold her grandfather's wish and "destroys" the order with the wishes that were forming a circle when the view turn to top view

Probably bc its the only song from the original version and even then its clear as day that this was supposed to be a love song and makes it very out of place in the movie

Same. I watched the movie yesterday and I know ALL the lyrics

@@jimthedog2604 by live song do you mean something a celebrity would release on an album? Because modern pop doesn't sound like this at all. It was perfect for a movie

⁠@@DevilNeverKnowshe meant “love” song, meaning that it was suppose to be a love duet between Asha and Starboy which got scrapped. Still feeling disappointed that this move could’ve shown more potentials and Disney dropped the ball on that.

@@eronjacobbuenaflor1127 I honestly think starboy as a love interest would have ruined the movie, I like the story we got. I just wish Asha wasn't so "quirky"

starboy is Asha's deceased grandfather please stop spreading the romance thing, it's weird

@@Alex-mh5mu What are you talking about??? Saba, her 100 year old grandfather, is alive in the movie. He’s one of the first side characters we see from the very beginning and his 100 year birthday is made a point in the first 2 minutes. The romance plot was scrapped in pre-production and Star’s original design can be seen in concept art. You can also find a demo version of “At All Costs” on KZfaq, where the lyrics are changed ever so slightly to resemble a love song between Asha and Star.

@@sydm5237 sweetie it's in the artbook there are pics online, the grandpa passed away and became starboy which is her spiritual guide in the concept art, it was scrapped because they decided to keep him alive instead

@@Alex-mh5mu That was another previous idea, in that version saba died years ago before the star came around

@@Dragonstorm2000 yes and there are pics of his face being the shapeshifting star so it's gross to promote it as her lover

Seriously so true. This was one of the scenes while watching that gave me goosebumps and chills.

Love Wish!!!!❤️✨

The context feels out of place, though

HUMAN

@@Alexander-wv3tb It was meant to be a love song that's why it's so out of place, they scraped a lot of the old plot where Star was meant to be a Starboy who fell in love with Asha and this was going to be their song

His voice in this song makes me melt. ❤😊

@@emilyglass5313 Same.

Especially that beginning segment, utter chills!

@@emilyglass5313 I totally agree! Swoon ....

Also the fact that Love Is an Open Door doesn't sound romantic at all while this one does

Where did you read that this inspired love is an open door

the villain being Asha of course

@@Alex-mh5muno it ain’t Also how long has this been in production?! Frozen was like 9 years ago

@@gamingriley5851 Yea it is

me too i love this song

i literally did cry... reminded me of my grandmother when asha looked at her sabas wish...hit home

☠️

So close. Magnifico only cared about the wishes becasue controlling how they got granted gave him power and adoration. Asha never ask for every wish to be granted. Just for people to have their wished BACK so they can pursue them of their own free will.

How is she selfish? Do 18 - 100 see how many years she's been waiting I'm not hating if u think that but macnifico was sorta rude anyway he kept wishes for years qnd years and never granted them

I want her goneeee 😭😭😭 give us King Magnifico back Disney

@@Alex-mh5mu what? U hate asha?

Because, not only does he not grant EVERY wish. He doesn’t grant nearly *ALL*wishes, even if there not dangerous for Rosas but he *NEVER* gives them back either, he also shows signs of Narcissism and completely overreacts when his kingdom gets suspicious of him, and when he sees some harmless “amateur”magic he chooses to open the book he swore he would never open because he knew the consequences, Asha acknowledges that some wishes may be dangerous “some might be dangerous but we can stop them”and the king also says “I DECIDE WHAT EVERYONE DESERVES!”A king only decides what’s best for his kingdom, not what they deserve human wise or wish wise. He seems like a good king and yes, maybe for the first part of the movie he’s truly genuine about that, but someone can change that quick believe it or not.

@@Angel.-dust3620 nah

He's always been a villain. The treasure is in realising them from the beginning of the story.

I know. Honestly Asha with her "You should grant everyone's wish" is more like a villain. The moral of the story should change to "you can make your wish true" or "try hard to make your wish true" instead of "you can just sit here and wait and your wish will come true without any work on its own".

​@@vikaziza1506anyone who says asha is the villain either hates women or watched the movie with their eyes closed. she *literally* suggests for him to return the wishes he won't grant so that his people can work to make their dreams come true themselves, but he refuses and insists that *he* gets to decide what they deserve. i don't know how you got "sit there and do nothing" from her words.

Hooo

I know! I would have liked to see more of him, he has a very interesting background and motivations, and as a writer it breaks my mind that they didn't do it! The fact that he didn't have desires for power but because they give him a feeling of fulfillment is very intriguing, it makes me wonder if he even had desires at all and that's why he wanted to have other people's wishes for him, because he no longer had any after he lost almost everything he loved. Also his relationship with Asha, which could have been the means to explore that past or really give it a selfish or more malevolent side to justify the ending.

This is the king not her dad….

@@1111e4 hmm they could be talking abt the small scene where she holds his wish lovingly?

@@dhruviart ohhhhhh that makes sense Ty

@@1111e4Saba is her grandfather, not dad.

Technically this was originally sang by Starboy instead of the king. And Starboy was revealed to be her grandfather but younger (her grandfather was originally dead-)

I would like to listen this song at my future baby, i listen this song all days

It was suppose to be a love duet between Asha and Starboy which got scrapped. Still feeling disappointed that this move could’ve shown more potentials and Disney dropped the ball on that. Romance is one of the central core themes in Disney animation and it’s one of the main reasons that made Disney…. well Disney in the first place.

Absolutely 100 percent

The songs always go hard for no reason

Apart from some good songs, the story and characters were pretty bad and written poorly

And This Wish " reprise"

Yup! We have to wait. Until then,

I can’t stop listening to “This is the Thanks I Get”… it’s too catchy!

Same! It's taking so long for the official vids to release!

RHIKR

Same when I saw it in theaters, I thought it was a beautiful movie

Most people didn't hate on the movie just to hate. It was just a bad movie 😂. Apart from this one good song, the story and characters were really bad. Generic, boring, and made no sense. People these days think that any negative constructive criticism is hate or toxic when it's not.

Tasha princess born ages ago Disney tales baugher women

In it

And don’t get my started on how Magnifico looks at the wishes 🥹

When we all realised it...yes. Yes we all had that immediate fangirl heart attack!

You should hear him in the movie Into the woods. He was pretty good there. But his voice in this song just makes me melt.

@@emilyglass5313 oh definitely! While that movie was definitely a low point for Disney, casting Chris Pine was a highlight!

​@Alphawolf2017 Yyyyyeah. Not its best movie. I grew up with the stage play , and having Disney cut out a lot of the darker elements in Act 2, that just didn't sit right with me.

@@emilyglass5313 I know! I personally prefer the stage production, yet Disney made...an attempt 10 years ago...I won't say it was good...just...it was attempt...although I did rather like Johnny Depp as the Big Bad Wolf.

That's not true. They sang "And love you as one does I will protect you at all costs". It sounds more like a lullaby than a love song

It was still Asha and Magnifico singing, but Asha was singing to Starboy and Magnifico was singing to Amaya. It would have been nice to see given how the lyrics would make more sense in that context.

@@ozvuchkibilla It actually was. They changed it to just have this scene with Asha and Magnifico singing to the wishes but intended it to sound like a lullaby or love song or whatever suits you when taken out of context. One of the things they envisioned was playing the song at a wedding.

Me Too :,-)

To me it’s like they were trying to find something to hate about him & use it to make him a villain. But I genuinely think he was just a victim from losing everything when he was a child & then built himself back up when he built his own kingdom & got a wife that he genuinely loved & wanted to protect her & his people. The problem is that everyone in the kingdom was so greedy & selfish that they wanted him to grant everyone’s wishes & they took him for granted. They thought they could use him as their personal sorcerer but he didn’t want to grant everyone their wishes because of that. He’s a king first of all, he doesn’t have to be fair. He didn’t have to be a caring & kind king but he wanted to be loving & caring to his people & wanted to protect their wishes. It’s like when he doesn’t grant someone their wish they suddenly have a personal vendetta against him. That’s part of life. You can’t get everything your way & you can’t get everything your way. For some people he’s probably doing them a favor in keeping their wishes bc they’re not always realistic & sometimes they’re not good wishes to grant

@@kimberlybellard6972 You guys get it, finally!!

Indefinitely :-)

Magnifico didn't really care about the wishes though, apart from how they served to stroke his own ego. They were a symbol of his control over his subjects. And the minute his control was challenged, he couldn't handle it and went off the deep end.

??? She was looking at and loving all the wishes she saw for most of the song. Of course when she sees her grandpa's she's gonna run to it. Y'all r so weird and misogynistic honestly

@@supremeoverlorde2109 He constantly talks about protecting the wishes equally, protecting his people and making sure the past tragedy could not repeat, on that so did he create a country where people happily moved to and the entire deal was in the open, sure when Asha turned traitor and started stealing from him he thought the treat was larger then it was and it started going downward but this stress of protection an entire kingdom from the old tragedy was getting to him, he needed a vacation 😆

@@jinkieez Only one buzzword? Why not use racist and nazi too while your at it 🤣 ,the entire story started because of Ashas greed, she wanted to steal her family's wishes from him and spends a lot of brain gymnastics to justify her theft, so she is not only a traitor and a thief, she is also the cause for everything bad happening in the movie 😆

@jinkieez Only one buzzword? Why not use more or did the YT censors hold you back? 😆 ,the funny thing is the entire story starts moving from Ashas greed, she wanted the working for the king perks before even getting the job so when she was told no she immediately decided to steal her parents wishes and did all the mental gymnastics needed to justify her theft, so shes not only a traitor and a thief, she is also the cause of all bad things that happens in the movie 😆

You're not alone. But then when you look at it, his past hurt and loss he experienced fueled what he did to keep others from experiencing the hurt and loss he experienced. He was doing a bad thing with good intentions. She because of that, he lost himself along the way and forgot why he did what he did in the first place.

Asha is my favorite disney villain

And this is why I tend to be on the villains side. In the end he was relatable.

It was meant to be a love song duet between Asha and Starboy.

I thought I was the only one. I really liked him in the beginning. he just lost sight of the reason he build the kingdom in the first place. a victim of his past.

I wish I had seen the storyboard to show what this song would be like with Asha, star boy

@@VitorFerreiraSodre I am sure the storyboard looked awesome

I saw it in the theater on my 23rd birthday, and I loved it too. It's one of my personal favorite movies of 2023.

True, apart from the fact that the wish spheres turn a slightly purple tone when they are around her. Although from what I know, supposedly in the extra material of, (If I remember correctly) the novelized version of the film indicates that Magnífico partly keeps them there because he belives he can find a certain feeling of fulfillment in having them (?

​@@janusthekitten9692I Feel like if Asha wasn't tempting him and if Magnifico got therapy he would be less overprotective Let me remind you, Magnifico literally lost both his mom and dad, So it's probably the major reason he was so overprotective and acted too quickly, Magnifico was never a villain, he was being used by the people around him

I still wish we had seen the love song version still 😢

Oh c’mon! I would’ve loved seeing that!

No! Originally Asha's Grandfather was going to die, then he was going to come back as Star Boy.

@@EzraSkywalkerFett Nah thats completely wrong the Star Boy was a love interest for Asha so her singing this song with her Grandpa would be weird 😅

@@waverider9920 No! What I mentioned was revealed by the producers in an interview! Wish I would never have a romance! Because they are already past this stage.

Noticed that too. It’s a beautiful song but kinda doesn’t fit their relationship

They want to do the same thing, but one lost the reason why (and themselves) along the way.

It sounds weird in the video. Sounds like they are saying each other but they are singing to the wishes (?? It sounds REALLY weird. You can tell this was a love song

It's still a love song.

@@user-ej4th4pq9k It was suppose to be a love duet between Asha and Starboy which got scrapped. Still feeling disappointed that this move could’ve shown more potentials and Disney dropped the ball on that. Romance is one of the central core themes in Disney animation and it’s one of the main reasons that made Disney…. well Disney in the first place.

Me to

Me too it's my favorite song with " It's not my king "

It was originally supposed to be a romance song with asha and the star but as a humanesque boy.

@@MellowSoupman that would be so cool! and then Star boy and Asha could be floating with the wishes around them 😭😭😭

Man, the deleted scenes are so much better than the final product 😭

Well, I don't see anyone trying to do anything to make it a reality, so... Also, no money excuses. There have been independent content creators who go far with few resources. If so many fans support the idea, let them all get together (or at least a bunch who can add what is necessary to give it quality) and do something.

@@Hilario-von-Fledermausburg1973 I've been trying to do so I did a fan art and some illustrations for a possible story book.

The demo version is way better talking about romance rather than wishes

We were so robbed ....

@@Hilario-von-Fledermausburg1973there’s tons of animatics of them singing it instead of

At least I find it a slight improvement from Strange World over a year ago. I was a little worried how this one was going to turn out. But I came home relieved of what I got.

I genuinely believe king magnifico had good intentions, he did originally and he has a good point, a wish cant be ambiguous, he’s traumatized and it’s protective, this song.

He didn’t know the wishes had power

You are 100% right but many people don't seem to get this movie... It became a box office bomb :( It is still one of the best Disney movies of the last twenty years!

Honestly, this movie didn't need a villain, it's so cruel to have a character with so many unresolved things end up punished like this, considering that characters like Elsa left her kingdom behind without stopping to think about how her people and sister would deal with the matter, in addition to refusing to return even after knowing how serious the winter situation was and that at the same time Magnífico does not have a redemption or a better development to become cruel is the result of little interest in character development and wanting to please the absurd demand of a villain that is bad only for the sake of being bad.

Same here

I got emotional too

I definitely cried. 😢

someone hasn’t heard i see the light i don’t think

Disagree it is i see the light

@@thatguydylan_4879 It's not that good, even "Love is a Open Door" is a waaaay better than that.

but the context is very different,

Unpopular opinion, but I think I like “If I Never Knew You” more than “Colors of the Wind”.

😭

They ARE singing to their 'loves', though. Magnifico loves his people (yes he actually DOES, but Asha kinda ruined it) and Asha loves her Grandfather. He is singing to the wishes of his people, she is singing it 'to' her granddad.

​@@artisannoteworthyFeel like he's also singing to his power and control he has over the wishes.

Of course, because love and devotion belong to romance. How disgusting are the people who comment on these kinds of things, because you can even love an idea, a movement and also a group of people whom you seek to protect, literally that should be the goal and feeling that every ruler should have for their people.

Hoped the quote made sense. Can u think of anything in wish that 8s similar to the quote?

Is not 8s

❤️🙏 God bless

Oh my goodness, so true, I think of it so much differently now.

this was also my interpretation

Especially "what's pain when I look at you" 🥹✝️

God is imaginary