Yes, the version of Dirrty from this day was also the best

Shanta Jordan yeah me too...Brings back some good memories.. I'd love to go back to the late 90s-early2000s..

Well they didn’t have cameras, otherwise you would see them There Use your common sense

@@sinhueherrera8984 Are you stupid or something? I obviously know that they didn't have phones during those times. I'm talking about the audiences before compared to now Use your common sense.

God I’m sick of this bullshit over used crap. People want their fucking memories get used to it!

@@melissacorrigan9238 STFU if you want to enjoy the concert that way then do you, but that doesn't mean you have to comment on how i want to enjoy the concert.

yeah i agree . she hit some of the high notes , but not all of them

True.

yes, she has always a hard time singing this song, it's always a hot mess

Lies

There is another one from 2010 where she also hit the E5’s. Also close to studio version

ummm no iss abt her father

It’s actually about her former manager

And at 3.43

yaz hahaha

Can they be wrong if they are hers...

Actually didn't even notice

It’s the pre chorus

Her best vocal wise was Back to Basics era

Shit she's beautiful as hell right now and her vocals have only improved.

Back 2 basics rules

@@eduardoalmeida943 iconic how I saw this comment five years later and was about to say Back To Basics was the best but I already said it years ago lmao

Hasta en concierto a aire libre.

What is that supposed to mean?

She did great wym !

韶安 that doesnt better than her recent performances...its pop rock so its way better when she growls, even the studio version is like that....

That growl is sexy as hell the fuck you mean?

+Wilford Kelly It's unfortunate, Xtina didn't have proper vocal training for the majority of her career, and always used her larynx to support her notes/create the raspy/growl effect.

A whole lot of "backseat vocalists" on here, eh? Throwing terms like "support" around, LOL. You think you can tell whether she's supporting a note seeing her from the chin up and hearing a tiny short note covered up by backing tracks? "Used her larynx to support her notes"... pardon me, what? Where do you suppose her voice is coming from if not her larynx? IDK, man. She's doing a particular pop-rock style here that necessarily sacrifices perfect technique/accuracy for flavour. She's excellent at it. That's why she has a career.

@@jd3563 Hey, I'm a really big fan of hers since I remember. But you can tell she's not supporting or where she places her larynx by the way she sounds. She's incredible talented and amazing, but her raspy/growler voice has made her had really bad times.

Not more serious? She was on top of her game here. She’s singing and moving around... she’s clearly out of breath and I don’t blame her. The song is beyond difficult to be moving around and I think she did a pretty damn good job.

Um - all she would do is practice and do vocal lessons. It’s a shame singing isn’t easy. At least she tried to hit them and that’s better than not hitting them at all because she’s the real deal on that stage.

Mitch Krause - actually this was the start of that singing style of her.

@@VenNavarra yeah, but when she started singing growl of the style is from the song called come on over.

Yesss

she often lipsynced or used a loud playback during performances of her first album. mostly genie in a bottle