Her technique nasal need gone but have potential

she can hit the notes and maintain stability but she sounds like she has a cold all the time.

@@irenraug part of that's her vocal color though, her tone has always sounded pretty nasal

her voice is very nasally

She def has great stability, but she has a long way to develop technique like Liz’s

It's just funny to me. As people pointed out, Gaeul said that idols should focus on singing rather than dancing, yet here wew are. I do think we should wait for other performers for the final judgment. This might just be because it's the first performance and thus the one that will likely have the most views and attentiom

@@multifan6679 she never said that, the clip is taken out of context. she was talking to the MC of the talk show she was on because he was trying to sing and dance.

yeah.. i think something is wrong with this video or their mics lol. She wasnt singing that loud, and you can hear Leeseo just as clear. Yujin is great dont get me wrong. But I can always hear Rei and Liz in these. Unless the other members mics were turned way down? Not sure why they’d do that for their main vocalist tho. Idk something is weird. Yujin do be slaying though.

@@irenraug It’s not that complicated, they just didn’t sing or didn’t sing loud enough to be heard. There are 3 members you can hear pretty loudly here whenever they sang and whenever they didn’t.

@@irenraugif you can't hear them singing some parts of the song then that means they're not singing those parts, simple as that lol

@@irenraugI think they didn’t sing I mean it’s okay they sang during all of HEYA promotions it’s completely fine to lip sync a few times but also Accendio has a lot of low notes probably why they only sang the chorus

She always sings live, i have been telling everyone that she is one of the best vocalists of Ive but no one believes me 🙄

she's already a true vocalist

I very agree on this.

they train during years but they can not be stable on low? The choreography isn't even dance heavy, so they have no excuse

@@Kefa_spirit girl go somewhere, they literally proved how good their stability is with the heya stages. shut up.

they sang live, the backtrack was js loud and it has low notes that cant be heard too much bc ure singing w the backtrack.

The manager here doesn't let you hear the bass sound very well 😭 Ives's skill is great

아뇨... 걍 립싱크죠

ㄹㅇ

@@user-wm4sp6tc3e뉴진스는 아예 안들림ㅋㅋㅋ 그게 진짜 립싱크 아님?

And Leeseo

@@hallooos7585 exactly

The liz glazing is crazy

Wonyoung improved A LOT.

If you paid attention to more than this one single stage you'd know Wonyoung has improved. Funny how all her live performances from Baddie, Off the Record, Either Way, I Am, Kitsch, and so on and so forth are magically ignored when you solo stans come across just one performance to focus your hate on like you did with Strawberry Moon

Rei improved too, and don't try to say that she avoided her high note like she is just being nice to interact with dives.

이분 저번부터 유독 아이브 엠알제거만 개많이 뭉개놔서 욕많이 먹었어요 아니면 음이 낮은부분이 많아서 소리가 작아서 같이 지워진걸 수도 있구요 분명 저도 음방볼땐 더 라이브 잘들렸는데 이영상만보고 욕하는 사람들 있을까봐 좀 걱정이네요 ㅠㅠㅠ

Now go to watch aespa's one

@@gsuznhdndn7996 Which song are you talking about? Also this song in particular is supposed to sound hypnotizing and enchanting which is not easy to achieve while dancing. The belty parts are in the pre-chorus which were sung. If this were a concert they would sing it all using chest but this is a music show.

@@RK99KR their last song supernova at the same channel go and watch Mr removed

@@gsuznhdndn7996 aespas was precorded. aespas ACTUAL live performance vocals in MR removed videos are so different from their music show ones + they are added flaws in the pre recordings. Aespas sings very good, and when they sing live its IMPRESSIVE, but I hope we can distinguish live and pre-recorded so our expectations for groups are not unrealistic!!

Can we have the same energy with newjeans as well? I am beging you cause I am getting tired of eyplaining that. The same goes to lower notes, really belting/screaming is honestly the easiest to do when dancing, while lower notes and soft notes are the most difficult. Even more so when you are moving your upper body

앞은 다 저음파트라 지워짐

ㄹㅇ 이분 저번부터 계속그럼 하이브 관계자신가

Btw Yujin's pre chorus and leeseo's High notes were very probably live

ummm leeseo is definately rapping on her rap part. but what i noticed here, their backtrack is too loud. but i realised that leeseo it is rappint. or maybe is the fanchant???

@@dymsummm there are parts where they're singing live and also where they aren't, so I'll say like partly live and partly pre recorded, but I'm sure the other stages would be completely live that's how the pattern works for most of the groups

걍 립싱크맞는데 억빨ㅋㅋ

@@user-uc4bl7jc3i뭐라냐 진짜 에휴..

@@user-pf2yp4rp4z 하이라이트부분만 부른거 안들림?

본방보면 대략 맞긴함 부르는멤들은 뚫고나와서..

@@user-le5dc7zu8u 그래도 앵콜이 제일 확실하니 그거보고 판단해야할듯 해야부터 못믿겠음 ㅋㅋ

@@user-le5dc7zu8u 그춐ㅋㅋㅋ 근데 해야 엠카 엠알제거보면 괜찮게해서 이 영상을 확실히 믿지는 못하겠어요 ㅋㅋ 앵콜해서 보여주는게 확실하니깜 ㅎ 셉틴 이기기 힘들죠..

그렇다기엔 또 잘부르는애들은 잘부르는디

애초에 춤추면서 노래하는걸 앵콜처럼 서서부르는거랑 동일시 하면 안돼요 직접 해보세요

ㄹㅇ 그리고 음이 낮아서 고음보다 소리기 작으니까 같이 지워버린듯

I don't think it was edited, it's just that we could barely hear them so I think it must have been hard to isolate their voices. Except for Yujin, Liz and some of Leeso's parts cause they were singing higher so louder

ikr they do it all the time

It does seem to be correct based on the actual performance though? The parts you can hear here are EXACTLY the parts that you can hear in their actual life performances as well, but go on I guess. Keep living in your delusional world

@@multifan6679 I promise you, it's not that deep.

전부터 이지리스닝 올려질려고 진성고음 코노 성대 차력쇼 ㅇㅈㄹ하면서 깐 팬덤인데 그런갑다 하셈

idk. but in leeseo rap part, she is clearly rapping. i can hear double voice in the original perf. and also here... sligthly... so my conclusions is... the backtrack is tooo loud/fanchant is too loud.

이서 쭉 부르는데 이 채널에서 잘못 지운 거임 누가봐도 쭉 부르고 있잖음..

@@user-pf2yp4rp4z 그런거죠?? ㅠㅠ 제 귀가 늙어서 잘못들은줄 알았어요 ㅠㅠ 라이브에 도전하는 이서 너무 이쁩니다

it's not really because of that, it's because it's hard to sing low register notes live while also dancing. i'm sure they can do it well while they're not moving

How is it expected for her to lipsync when she's sung hundreds of live stages, including as recently as two weeks ago with Heya? And literally all the members lip-synced to various parts of this particular stage. Just because they don't sing live once doesn't mean they won't sing live again 🙄

All of them took vocal lessons, it's clearly obvious leeseo has improved

facts...if there is sound going tru that mic..it can be heard on this mr removed..simple as that.

Jiahahaha 🤣🤣 I know you toxic right?!! Btw you can see Mr remove æspa tòó and hear the difference🤣

if it makes you sleep well at night..

They both can sing live well let's not compare, aespa doesn't sing live bcuz of SM

正直明らかにライブで歌ってた部分(heyaのステージの時も)ももわもわしちゃってるんでこういうmr除去動画は完璧には信じない方が良いと思います

maybe the song isn't in a comfortable range for them

Mm but I think Liz leeseo and Yujin did pretty well. Still hope they’ll sing live though

For first day promotions most groups dont sing live

@@iamcycy1426yeah i also hope, i hope they will sing tomorrow at music bank

⁠@@safasathar1019 they were singing on first day promotions heya so

Why are you only focused on her when literally all the members lip-synced the chorus?

Leeseo? Lmao

Except IVE can and has sung live. Or do you want to pretend all their hundreds of live stages before this single performance don't exist? Literally two weeks prior and you can hear them all singing live in Heya. Not to mention they've done a whole international tour of nothing but live performances. It's delusional the way you pretend a single performance means they suddenly can't sing anymore. They're not like your faves

@@Yamainthejar oh I like IVE dw about it, I just think it’s hypocritical. And not, they didn’t do as you said “a tour of nothing but live performances” in fact, IVE barely sings live and it’s mostly pre recorded, and when it’s live is basically just Yujin and Leeseo and sometimes Liz, and they scream more than singing ngl.

@@annatroncoso7085 Hypocritical is LSFM stans dissing IVE while coming up with every excuse in the book for their own faves despite it being categorically proven that IVE does more live stages than LSFM ever has. The fact that you're continuing to lie and claim they rarely do live performances when even just three days prior this channel has posted live renditions of Heya tells me everything I need to know. There was an entire tally done showing how little LSFM sang live and how much more IVE sang live compared to several other 4th gen groups.

@@Yamainthejar Im just saying both groups sing bad lmao, don’t get too offended, I don’t even Stan them girl go support your faves instead of wasting your time here like😭

@@annatroncoso7085 I do support my faves. Unlike you that wastes time lying about the fact that IVE can't sing instead of spending time telling your faves to improve. You can pretend to yourself all you want, it doesn't change the reality that IVE can and does sing. The way you keep acting like one stage disproves that is truly delusional

lagu ini nadanya ke rendahan buat ive, lagu nada rendah tuh lebih susah ditampilin daripada nada yang tinggi. di lagu ini aja nada tinggi nya masih di nyanyiin kok

mungkin ini khusus fokus dancenya aja kali. liat selanjutnya lagi aja nanti, masih gak nanyi gak mereka (IVE)

@@ChikYeyo iyah, lagian kita juga tau kok kemampuan live mereka bagus

yap kita tunggu aja semoga next semua nyanyi dengan baik​@@ChikYeyo

Bukan kembali ga pede bambang, mereka udh menunjukkan vocal mereka d era I Am & Heya kmrin lagian Accendio lanjutan dr promosi Heya mau take rest dlu mungkin mereka

해야는 듣지도않고 자추

리즈도 초반 저음부분은 안 들림...저음부분들이 대체적으로 안들림 지워진건지 안부른건진 몰?루

이서도 하는데....?

​@@user-bc4fm7sp2d근데 유진 저음파트는 라이브하는거 들리는데..?

​@@user-le5dc7zu8u 그니까 내말은 처음 리즈 목소린 안 들린다고 라이브하는 멤이 굳이 저음 안부르고 고음 부르고 하겠냐고 조금이라도 부르지. 애초에 이서랑 유진이 안 들린다고 안했음. 걔들은 아이브 멤중에 성량 크니까 들릴 수도 있지

"pratiquement jamais" 🤡🤡🤡 She sang live very clearly just two weeks ago during Heya. She also sang live during Baddie, Off the Record, Either Way, I Am, Kitsch, Love Dive, After Like, all the way back to Eleven era stages. They've been singing live for their whole international tour. How is that "practically never"? You haters love to jump on any single moment to shade Wonyoung when she's already proved she can and does sing live. If you actually listened to IVE you'd be well aware of that. Even Aespa lip-syncs some of their stages but IVE does it once and suddenly it means they "practically never" sing live? Get lost