And the worst thing is that (if you've seen V app lives from exo memebers, you may know this) Sehun's kinda afraid of singing, he doesn't like his voice (like when in his solo broadcast he was listen to unfair I think, and he kinda wanted to sing but at the same time he looked afraid)... I think some artist from SM or even the vocal trainers have said to him that his voice is not good, but for me, like Chanyeol, he can sing so good wven when a deep voice.

I think that's, as you stated, because the vocal trainers think he doesn't have much potential in terms of singing. However, if you really looked closely, during the time when he sang Sing for you in the V app broadcast, Channie broke into this huge smile as soon as Sehun started singing. It's because he's proud of how far he's come, and it's because he KNOWS Sehun can sing as well as Jongin or anyone else, for that matter, especially considering how little time he gets to sing or rap. I think maybe he's afraid of singing because of the rejection and criticism he got for his rapping when on Sketchbook; the baby's grown insecure ;u;

+Mahnoor Amjad but tbh i think that chanyeol was smiling/smirking because of the fans who were dead silent but when sehun started singing they applauded him haha (:

+Mahnoor Amjad I think Chanyeol smiled because only in Sehun's part, the fans were crazily screaming all over the place xD

+Mahnoor Amjad He looked like trying to controle himseld not to laugh as he always do, so loudly and with a huge smile...

Omg i just realised that after seeing your comment hahahaa

lmao I thought they are sitting on a elegant or park style chair hahaha

JiSoo's Only Wife omg jisoo~~ such a baeeee lol

+Sewmai hagao ikr!😍😍😍

Omg they are!!!

Graz Gratz how did you know? Wow. Seriously, how did you know it was fit for rock? And they listened to you!

@@rawanhadi66 his voice fits everything in my opinion

Graz are you some kind of saint? I'm speechless. SM is gonna release kim chen's solo soon 😯😂

Don't forget to streaming Chen debut Solo. And it's a Ballad song not a rock song.. hahaha

Yes, Chen has a solo now! So beautiful but sad song makes me cry ~

*Xiumin

danielle Gathings I wonder if they sing this for Kris Luhan and Tao... :"(

they teach idols to express themselves like that during emotional songs, exo always does a great job 👌🔥

In the music video Basketball=Luhan Fighting=Tao Galaxy=Kris

OMG YAS

jongdae is the bes(≧∇≦)/t

Amazing voice and very very handsome!!!! Love Chen chen~~~~

yeeeeees please! i love Chen 😻💕

+Coomet did you see his adam's apple vibrating at 2:43... i'm dying....

frantastique omg yes! i'm Chanyeol biased but Jongdae is like my child sounds awkward, but he's too precious for me ;^;.

Same

+Amanda S. You're not alone with that

yep haha

+Amanda S. He definitely needs to sing more!

+Amanda S. i feel you :)

hii! I'm sorry but wheres lay? I'm new and im confused 😯. Btw I agree whit you 😁

+mmayah He had a drama to film in China

Have you heard Sehun live?

No hate

+JzlPlys he said he's working on it

i know when he started singing i screamed

+Malaya Cody he's so cute >w< i didn't notice him at first when I started to listen to them but now I can't take my eyes off him

+Diana Pach its so hard to keep a bias with him in the same group

Me toooo I'm chanyeol biased but I screamed louder at Sehun's part

It's angelic.

he is always handsome

+Munaaa B. But today particularly xD I'm Chen biased, but I think sometimes they style him very very bad~

+Jie Gao .. i'm chen biased too..haha yeah i Know what you mean

Chen becomes everyday handsomer 😊💕🔝

Totally agree😁 Chen is so handsome today😍

yup daebak ♡♥ i love them

Sara Elouazani they are my fav chen is my bias

+Muneerah Alhasawi mine is baek ~

+Muneerah Alhasawi CHEN IS AMAZING ^^ SO HAPPY HES BEING RECOGNIZED MORE

He deserves all the love

it really does, that really got me

Yeah Chanyeol in the beginning actually. His eyes were watery there 😞

I swear I saw D.O shed a tear 😣

+Makayla Dunbar omg yes. d.o is around 2:20

sehun trash omg he did not my bby

Ikr

i thought not many noticed it. so clean!

what run

@@kledi3817 when he says “the way”

@@Musical.Princess that’s not a run, it was mic interference

Same thiughts

Same!!

+Hana Byun im crying legit

yaaaah 😢😢😢😢💕

+Hana Byun like per usual ♥♥

Not the only one

me too

Here!!!

in dying here every single time...

same

I'm not Sehun biased but my ovaries exploded

love shot!

@@lindseyarriate5608 he has the most angelic voice.

+黃子于 Yeah he looks and sounds great! ;o;

Same here..

+aiz_a _ Plus his personality is cute >.

la bruja LMAO 😂😂 I CANT UNSEE IT

la bruja i love exo and i do love cakes, too. 🍰 It's everything nice in this video

Same x))

lol

Totally agree his voice is soo emotionaly beautiful 😘❤️

agree :)

I agree 😘

+HPTSML he has a hot deep voice.

i hope kia sound very good

sorry by mistake i wrote this i mean i hope and kai sounds very good

It's been exactly a year since this live but I can't stop listening to it plussss kyungsoo's and baekhyun's voices are so soothing shit

so perfect

ikr

+minato namikaze Gets me everytime!!

+xxkickedfruitcakexx ╮(╯_╰)╭生无可恋

+minato namikaze I KNOWWWW SM DID THE THING

+minato namikaze MY HEART EXPLODED

Annyeong Baekhyun cause when you're sad you eat cakes 👍👍

Annyeong Baekhyun its winter special which is usually Christmas special songs n Christmas is realted to cakes... dats it😉😉

very drama hahaha i misss

omg. Sehun's voice is good and warm, normal sehun voice is deep bass ? But anyway, sehun's voice is great

Xiumin sempre foi um bom cantor

Chen,Baekhyun and D.o are amazing singers.

+Trang Ly Bui Inkigayo's sound system is better! It does better justice to their voices ^^

+VL (YBlvr) and their voices are also more stable ^^ i hope someone will make a mr removed for this performance

agree, they are so cute and lovely guys, this song is calm and sweet i like👌😘

You can say that again!!! So perfect!!!

And he has such a great voice (even if is deep, still being so good to hear)

+Nathalie Fortman rapping sure made him stable. ;)

+Nathalie Fortman Singing live? Are you kidding me? You guys just can't hear or see the difference betweeen singing live and lip sync? It's pre-recorded...

+AVenka22 idk if your an exo-l or not, but we know its live because, suho sings lays part, and d.o added an ad-lib near the end of the song. Also when kai sings, suho is harmonizing with him, they don't do that on the track version. But if you still don't believe its live, then just wait for the mr removed and you'll be surprised :)

they sung live, but prerecorded the stage because they needed to catch a flight to their concert

He's like " I'm so done with this shit"

😂😂😂

shawolshawol he looked like he was ready to cry 😭😭😭😭😭 awwwww I wanna hug him and yes I agree with u 🤗❤️❤️

hahahaha true but its hard to think of any other haircut for him

he did many hair cut from debut. you can check their video from debut era. i dont say he like short haircut, but i think he look more mature here with that haircut. D.O dont like people saying he is cute, that why i think he don keep his hair long or color anymore.

Haha so true! I swear, the hair stylist especially likes to give him wet/damp hair!

ahhahahaha ikr? 😂 he looks stunning anyway ^^

looooooooool your comment

+Pammie Poo yeah he does🤗

+Natalie Gyan Lool

mintsuga Because he is in rapper line and if you watch the MR Removed, you will see that our Sehun's voice is not suitable for the song

mr removed videos don't mean anything lmao

abbie is cool Agree.

I laughed to hard at that

Chi Mai Nguyễn wtf .. whats wrong with you

Fun fact: the term for that is called vibrato

@@sab7608 hehe 😄

I am dead! Play moonlight at my funeral😭💜

this is why i said baekhyun has the most beautiful n perfect vibrato in exo. also his falsettos😍

omg yesss jongdae's low register gives me life

I too love his low notes more.

Yaaas :'(

+D R E A M E R omg Someone sees it finally... That made me really sad cos I was like kris!! And then I realised it was suho.... Broke my heart.

Omoo the sameee :( If kris and luhan and tao was here everything gonna be perfect 💔 So sad how things end up

+D R E A M E R yh... Omg I wanna cry lol

+Army_L!! Me too lol!!

Ikr? ㅠㅠ today he is beautiful

yasss he so amazing

+Ever Christmas Pshhh. He's singing for Chen and Luhan.

Renzil Estrella wtf HAHA that 'smay'

Suho to Kris

lay we love u just be happy and careful , we miss you oppa Don't press yourself 😢

What did you think about Chen here? He was really feeling it ~~ I think this is his best performance out of all ( and yes visually stunning omg). Xiumin really did a good job too. Baek as always, emotionally the best

Didi J​ I wrote about them all at length over at the other thread (Val's link), but I'll briefly recap. Not only has JongDae never looked better, but he has never sounded better - this is certainly the best he's sung this song. Main vocalists took it to another level with this one. Kyungsoo was stunning, absolutely stunning in every way. Baek is Baek - life. Xiu's improvement is note-worthy, but his breathing is still iffy to me and he needs to grow in confidence. Suho was gorgeous, Chanyeol was extra gorgeous (best he's sounded as well and that little head-shake he doe gets me every time). Kai gave another solid performance, can't fault him (love this hair on him too). Sehun's line, I really can't say...I'll have to listen a few more times to all SFY SeLines in order to determine it. On the whole, best SFY stage to date. 

i think the music was too loud compared to their mics' on the Music Core perf >

byun bobohu No, for me he is the best singer in Kpop 😘

lol

Same😍😍

Kyungsoo to.

Same thinking