Nah Shanks might not look the part but he did nail Shanks as a character

Shanks actor dude, he really played it well!

People dont understand that Shanks even in anime isn’t supposed to come out as a badass person, he is shown as a normal guy and people underestimate him. If we go with that context then I feel Shanks looks the part to me.

Bruh Sanji 10/10 Mihawk 10/10 Buggy 15/10

One piece fans when they found out the live action doesnt have a wide neck, 2 meters tall, huge ass chest--

Shanks’s and Arlong’s performances were actually so good.

Mihawk just looks perfect for the role definitely 10/10

Bugga was genuinely goated best acting

The actor portrayed shanks well , no complaints from my side 😊

Bro gave shanks 4 and mihawk 9 when hes 10, mihawks actor played him really well

When you only judge the book by its cover

Bro was being a little racist at the end 💀💀💀

shanks actor can’t control how he looks, but he nailed the vibe itself. he doesn’t look the part but the feel is there. that is shanks.

Long nose would be look weird in live action

The actor for Mihawk is the one that out of everyone looks the most like the anime version

The portrayal of Shanks and Arlong were perfect to be honest which is really helping with how they look.

Shanks looks fine wdym??

We have to consider this was made before the show's release. But I think now we can all agree live action Shanks was perfect.

Shanks had such high expectations from the anime I don't think anybody could've matched them. This guy did a really good job though.

You do realize Eiichiro Oda met and approved the cast, and worked directly with netflix to make sure its as perfect as it can be. So if you doubt the cast your doubting Oda

Mihawk not being a 10/10 is wild, same with 5/10 for Gol D. Roger, his actor was perfect imo, and him not looking completely healthy like he did in the anime wouldn't make much sense since hes a pirate whos hes literally dying

Who ever got Ryan Gosling to play Shanks needs a raise

Makino played by Vin Diesel is 10/10.

Damn, talk about absolutely not even seeing a single minute of anime Zoro... He's just as goofy as Luffy in the manga and anime...

The guy who played Shanks did a amazing job

I give buggy 100000000000/10, I just love scary villains

Wtf!!! Arlong's character was probably one of the best along with Buggy's. They captured the character's essence and especially the voices so damn well. This comparison is the worst. You would not expect them to literally look like the anime characters. There's going to be some human element. My suggestion: Rewatch OP😮‍💨

Let me try and see you make a perfect live action Arlong lmaooo

What have they done? They adapted a fictitious character to real live acton adaptation

Just watched one piece and shanks is the most nailed one in my opinion, he looked bad in that shot we’ve seen but in the actual show he was just as good and as kind and as sexy as the anime shanks, my favourite character in the entire anime and became my favourite one from the show Well done oda!

The only issue I have is that they made Garp too serious. From the beginning, Garp was presented as this silly, lax, laid-back man who's relation to Luffy made complete sense

How dare you not give Sanji 10/10! The man’s amazing..also Shanks actor is amazing too. The man knows how to act

Nigga you cant just bring characters from manga or anime directly into live action. Whatever has been done is nearly perfect. Especially shanks, as he was just a goofy looking, bamboo like, skinny ass man at the starting of the series. And arlong is a proper live action fishman.

I liked Shanks. I didn't care at all for the looks because he portrayed Shank's energy so well in the live action.

Garp actor nailed it , literally the best anime to live action transformation. And sanji is also 10/10

Nah, OPLA Shanks portrayed Debut/Young Shanks very well. Y'all just nitpicking comparing him to Yonko/Current Shanks.

Luffy 10/10 Nami 10/10 Zoro 10/10 Usopp 10/10 Sanji 10/10 Shanks 10/10 Buggy 10/10 Mihawk 10/10 Garp 10/10 Gol D. Roger 10/10 Arlong 10/10 Oda hand picked these actors so your opinion isnt valid.

Nah personally I think shanks is 10/10

Shanks has a broad nose square chin and a kind smile beyond what was asthetic plus brought the character. I've seen mixed before the acting, but he looked the part imo.

Mihawk cast is 100/10 Absolutely nailed it

there are leaks of shanks looking great in the show

Some people disliking Rodger just cause his mustache ain’t bigger I’m calling it, you know how much hair you gotta grow to GET THERE!?

The actor got shanks personality right as hell though ngl

Appearance doesn't matter if the actors can portray the characters, and EVERYONE in this remake were spot on. As for Usops nose, I don't mind it not being in this because the actors doesn't need it (also, would be hella distracting and much more of a pain).

"I CAN STILL TAKE YOU, WITH ONE ARM TIED BEHIND MY BACK" ~ *SHANKS*

Gold roger actor really nail it, it's like looking jack Sparrow,and i love it,for shank he just look like early shank,he just need a little bit buff and perfect for yonkou shanks.

Shanks and Roger, look like a real pirate would look like in real world, dirty, messy hair, they look great

For my opinion the character portrayal hits the sweet spot for me. They made them look realistic but kept them closely accurate to the manga. I actually like that they chose not to have Usopp's pointy nose and Sanji's curly eyebrows. It'd look a bit off in the live adaptation.

What?! Mihawk is definitely 10/10. He nailed that character too.

Arlong was dope! Great live action adaptation and his theme was a bop

Ok I understand. But at the same time, you can’t really have people look exactly like the anime, without them looking exactly like the anime. What’s that means is that you can’t always expect a perfect 100% when going from cartoon to live action

They worked well can't expect them to be perfect

Take notes Disney and marvel studios, this is how you do good CGI except for James Gunn he's already good at it

Shanks looks great and the actor played wonderful the role

Bro, Shanks is a straight up 11. Did his part with perfection

Shanks looked more kindhearted while anime shank is more badass IM MAJOR OP FAN I PREFER the live actor his acting looks perfect for shanks

Shanks looks fantastic!

Roger looks terrible because he was on death’s door.

Arlong I actually liked, cause it's a hard one to represent in real world, and they did a good job

I thought Shanks actor portrayed the character really well. Buggy should have been 10/10, Sanji also should have been 10/10

Shanks and Roger are good

Shanks and Arlong despite appearance played their roles phenomenally. Arlong surprised me bc you could really feel the hatred he has for humans regarding how they treat fish men

buggy is definitely a 10/10 for me, he played the role so damn well imo

The One Reason shanks Is A 11/10 Live Action Shanks: Fraud, Anime Shanks:Fraud, Manga Shanks: Fraud

Yall expecting pirates to be handsome and what not lol their pirates and gold d roger was in prison for a while before getting executed and he was sick yall want him to look sexy

Shanks actor did sooooop great

If y’all don’t like the characters then stick to the original and stop complaining … for me all of them were soooo good

I’m sorry but Roger with 5/10 is criminal

You used the trailer picture as reference… in the show he looks amazing and accurate, while also portraying Shanks very accurately. He’s a 9/10.

Am I the only one who thinks Shanks looks like Ryan Gosling🤔

Can we all agree that he does look like Shanks but it's the hat that doesn't look good on him. When you see him in the end without the hat he looks perfect

This whole adaptation was like a spectacle to behold. I loved every second of it.

Wdym ryan gosling nailed his role

Oda did hand pick them so he knew what he was doing

Just like what Emily said: "Shanks is a daddy!"

If you know, initially in one piece anime shanks was also look like rookie and not interesting. But from marineford he was chad So casting of shanks - 7/10

Bro shanks is literally me

For me. Luffy 8/10 Nami 9/10 Zoro 10/10 Usop 9/10 Sanji 10/10 Shanks 6/10 Buggy 8/10

One Piece anime fans ignoring the fact that Oda chose the cast, level 100

Nah nothing looks as bad as ben beckmen. It looks like they got a homeless person to act as hom

im so exited for it

Shanks is not a real person, you cannot find anyone that looks exactly like him

Alvida, Kuro, Gin, even Don Krieg were spot on.

You think Shanks is off but that Luffy and Usopp are accurate? Lmao. Usopp looks Filipino in the anime. Luffy isn't supposed to sound like he should be wearing a sombrero.

I would give the Luffy actor a 5/10. While he kinda looks like Luffy, his acting hasn’t really embodied Luffy. He over-acted too much. Also, Shanks and Arlong deserve 10/10; the actors did a phenomenal job, same with the rest of the cast.

The actor for Arlong was great he had a presence about him but maybe they could of done the make up and costume design better with him make him bigger and more menacing but actor was great.

If Usopp had a long nose in the live action he wouldn’t be taken seriously, same with Sanji with the curly eyebrows thing.

For me zoro 8/10 he face look cute just like group in bts.. Not like anime fierce

they all look like dollor store rip offs hahahahaahahahaa

This is probably one of THE best casting for any series in a longggg time

Arlong is literally the best character in the live action

I actually like all of the live action characters. They are more realistic and not too cartoony. 😊❤

Shanks does look like a real pirate, and Arlong (alongside the other fishmen) also looks like a men with fish mutation, rather than a small kaiju. I know the manga designs are supposed to be unrealistic and fanciful, but giving the context of the live action, I think they did a good job. Also, the actors made a good job

All characters were spot on imho. Acting performance trumps 1 for 1 visual match imho

Shanks and Arlong looked great, and played them very well. What are you even chatting? 😂

Perfect one is ZEFF they literally made a lookalike casting for that character

Can we talk about Zeff? The actor looks exactly how I'd imagine him. I can't wait to see the cast for the next season.

Bruh shanks in start story is a fun guy but later on in sure they will make him more versatile

I think even if Shanks and Arlong don’t look entirely accurate to the manga, they easily had some of the strongest performances in the show. Also, it’s impossible to not make Arlong look badass, so I still really like the art direction they took for his design. His nose looks toothy like an actual sawshark, it’s great

mihawk is 10/10 shank is 10/10 these both character that ive been waiting for is spot on tbh